Key drivers of the economy, like housing, exist in their present form to due explicit and implicit subsidy. I think China is more like the US then we care to admit, except they think on a longer timescale.
If you add in the GDP component of the financial and defense industries, you are looking at a massive overhead of markets managed by implicit or explicit government enforcement (or lack of it) for the benefit of a small elite. This is similar to China, but the Chinese have strategic vision for their economy; in the US it is managed by random allocation of lobbyist dollars.
This is not true.
To construe 'finance' a just some arguably unnecessary or inefficient 'overhead' in the economy belies a basic lack understanding of what that industry actually does.
It's often opaque to outsiders, but banking is a real value creating part of the economy, and it's also right at the foundation of it.
Also, 'defence spending' is a normal part of every economy, and it has existential impact for all of us.
Consider for a moment that US forces keep most international waterways open for everyone to use, even economic rivals, and even military rivals (!) so long as there's no war. The Suez Canal, Panama Canal, and other critical areas would instantly be under the control of nefarious regional forces if there were a power vacuum.
Now, the US has an overt policy of controlling what interest rate is charged.
So the banking system is a free market in the sense that theoretically participants could choose to leave if they wanted to. However, there is also a very overt layer of government decision making and control. The government putting a finger on the scale in a very fundamental way.
Exactly how that compares to China is difficult to judge - whatever it is, I argue it isn't very capitalistic. Capitalists are supposed to go broke when they lose money and given how low interest rates are they are more likely to refinance themselves with a new loan. The damage that has been doing to wealth creation since the GFC in around '08 is profound.
It is hard to say how much worse China's approach is. It isn't as clear cut as China's Government vs 10,000s of Capitalists - in which case I'd favour capitalism by the numbers. The US government is hamstringing the ability of its own economy to organise around profitable ventures. Instead it is encouraging Ubers and Lyfts.
You say this as if China were innocent in manipulating banks to control their banking system. This is not true. [1]
>The US government is hamstringing the ability of its own economy to organise around profitable ventures. Instead it is encouraging Ubers and Lyfts.
I disagree with this. I believe the Ubers and Lyfts (and Teslas) are caused by investors wanting to get in on the ground floor of the next Apple. To support your argument, please explain how the US Government is preventing its own economy to organize around profitable ventures. You may use citations.
1. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/22/china-banks-record-lending-s...
My gosh man, healthcare is going to be 1/3 of the world's economy in 30 years anyhow, as we all get a little older.
Insurance is a financial product which we have a hard time thinking about in tangible terms, but it's generally very value creating.
And so is education, often. FYI US exports about $25B a year in Education to foreign students.
China is rocking hard because of the wake we're leaving.
I can ask the same thing about any other country. What is truly unique? Eben the nuclear bomb involved atomic theories that were developed in Europe.
Just look at the first one: papyrus was in use for nearly 5000 (five thousand!) years in Ancient Egypt and all over the Mediterranean before paper was conveniently invented by Cai Lun.
The term paper itself is actually derives from "papyrus".
It's really not any different with the rest of those claims.
Is it that paper is not an improvement over papyrus? This clearly does not stand.
Or that paper was not invented in China but in the classical world? This is contradicted by archaeological evidence.
Or that somehow the fact that the word paper is derived from papyrus in English means that it was invented by the west?
It really amounts to claiming to have invented the entire field of metalworking, when all that's invented is the casting process, whereas everyone was using forging techniques before then.
Disingenuous.
It's very difficult to see what you're actually trying to argue here. Chinese civilization generated a large number of important inventions, including (but obviously not limited to) the stirrup, paper, gunpowder, silk, the compass and paper money. It's about as silly to try to deny this contribution as it would be to deny the contribution of the Greeks to civilization.
I always find it funny/sad that Easterners in addition to suriving the crimes, have the extra task of educating the Western populations of the crimes committed in their names.
I expect you've noticed that every single country that is a victim of modern Chinese espionage was directly involved in destroying the chinese economy during the 19th to early 20th century.
US, UK, Japan, France, Germany, Russia (a few of the top offenders).
These nations can't simply commit a bunch of crimes, get rich, change the rules, then expect to be protected from past actions.
They do it all the time. When will the Chinese Communist Party pay for the famine which killed 2-6% of the population (lower bound is based on official government figures)? Probably never is when.