News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Shivetya on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:33PM (#19948601)
Chicago is in the hole for nearly thirty billion dollars. They have been floating the idea of a ten billion dollar bond with the debt structured in a way which lets current politicians escape the fallout from its payment and not having to raise property taxes. The state of Illinois is not well off either with debts estimated at the low of one hundred thirty billion to two hundred fifty billion. An Illinois proposal just to fix state pensions would result in a forty four percent property tax increase for thirty years.

Chicago has a narrower group of people to draw from so besides tourist and sin taxes they have to go after any product consumed by residents of the city and that includes digital.

Why is this all happening, because there is a well hidden largess in government employee payroll and worse in their pension system. Illinois alone is estimated to have over twenty three thousand retirees pulling down one hundred thousand dollars a year or more. A lot of this is from the higher end positions in city and county governments but you can find police and fire there too.

People complain about the disparity in corporate executive level pay to employee should also take a look at the disparity between the same in state and city governments let alone the disparity in retirement to even every day workers in the state. A 100k retirement not counting full benefits is equivalent to nearly forty eight dollars an hour.

So expect more digital taxes in your future.

PS: the Chicago debt is only for pensions, they are down tens of billions more in deferred maintenance and similar debts.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rrrrreeeee on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:56PM (#19948735)
Do the employees and employers not pay into a separate fund that cannot be touched? I fail to see how it's the fault of the pensioners. It's absolutely archaic if the future taxpayers have to pay for a retirees pension. In Canada we have pension funds that are separately funded entities that are payed into over an employee's career.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sct202 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:45PM (#19949625)
In Illinois and Chicago, the government has been playing games like declaring pension holidays where the contributions shift to the future. The unions control a large base of voters and haven't objected, even though this basically endangers their retirements. There's going to be a point where the funds will literally run out of money, and I doubt that there will be enough things to tax in a year to make up the difference that should have been paid in over decades.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 19, 2019 @11:00AM (#19953606)
What boggles my mind is that bond rating agencies rate Illinois debt at any rating that allows continued borrowing when it is so obvious how bad and deep the financial hole is.

Disclaimer: actively seeking ways to short Illinois/Chicago.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:17PM (#19954612)
They are rating the chances of default. The bond purchasers will be paid, one way or another. Privatize the parking meters (like Chicago already did), the roads, the water utilities, etc. It's the people who live there that will pay for the deficit via increased taxes and fewer services.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:20PM (#19954909)
So why are property values not reflecting this? Irrational market?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Monday May 20, 2019 @06:53AM (#19959082)
They are. From all the data I can see, property values for almost all areas in the Northeast and Rust Belt in general are declining (in real terms), except for certain few rich areas in and around the big cities that the richer populace is “escaping to”. I’m writing from mobile, but compare the Fed’s analysis for home prices by state.

Even Buffett says he’s looking at state finances when deciding investment options, and if he’s saying it, surely other organizations are too. It will be a gradual accelerating decline though (barring effects of natural disasters), since people don’t just up and move.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by toomuchtodo on Monday May 20, 2019 @12:51PM (#19962320)
Check out downtown Chicago and the western suburbs. Prices are not going down. If anything, they’re more inflated than ever.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Monday May 20, 2019 @02:32PM (#19963532)
I specifically conditioned out that situation:

>except for certain few rich areas in and around the big cities that the richer populace is “escaping to”

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by toomuchtodo on Monday May 20, 2019 @06:13PM (#19965828)
Sorry I didn't pick up on that. The areas I refer to in the Chicago western suburbs aren't particularly rich (Aurora, IL, for example).
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by cdfky on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:24PM (#19954927)
All markets are irrational. It will take time
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by cljs-js-eval on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:40PM (#19949610)
It's archaic and should be changed, but the way the system works in the U.S. is pretty well known to its citizens, which makes it at least partially the fault of the pensioners. I live in Chicago and every retired schoolteacher and police officer I meet knows full well that they're making an exceptional amount of money in retirement. It's usually part of why they took the job.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sokoloff on Saturday May 18, 2019 @05:52PM (#19949934)
IMO, it's no more the pensioners' fault than any other voter. If they're a resident eligible to vote, it's partly their fault. It's not their fault for accepting a job offer with certain terms broadly available.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by roenxi on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:34PM (#19950835)
On the one hand, yes. On the other hand...

(1) Pension decisions play out potentially over ~30-40 years.

(2) If we accept that the cause is some official made a bad decision, it is almost certain that pension issues will be ongoing. There is potentially a 40 year window for idiots to get in and screw the whole system up.

So in a sense, some large group of people need to be responsible. Not because it is fair, but because if that isn't how we treat the situation it isn't likely to get fixed for the next round of pension crises. The pensioners were most invested in the success of the enterprise. They are most responsible for its failure.

This isn't a nice position to hold, but the alternatives are a very nebulous concepts of blame and lumping the cost of fixing all the mistakes on the one group of people who we know weren't responsible - people who are currently entering or in the workforce and can pay taxes.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by behringer on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:44AM (#19951664)
So you're saying the pensioners are the reason for our failed system? I've never been more swayed by an argument in my life.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by unchocked on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:24AM (#19951780)
They’re saying it’s most reasonable to hold the pensioners responsible, but that’s a subtle difference and you weren’t reading closely anyhow.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jonathankoren on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:50AM (#19952054)
Except that’s not how responsibility works. They may be the beneficiaries of a broken system, but they aren’t necessarily — and certainly not solely — the ones that broke it.

Just phase them out and switch to 401ks. It’s absurd that such a large portion of government budgets are retirement accounts.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by toomuchtodo on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:06PM (#19954552)
The problem when you say “just phase them out” is what to do with the trillions in outstanding obligations. For example, pension benefits are protected by the Illinois state constitution. You can imagine the process you’d need to construct and execute to fix pensions in Illinois, Cook County, and Chicago’s cases.

The unwinding is the terribly difficult part because the can keeps getting kicked down the road due to a combination of greed and incompetence. You need back pressure from financial markets to inhibit borrowing for what can never be paid back. Then the hard conversations are forced.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jonathankoren on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:17PM (#19955886)
There's a finite time that benefits are paid out. At most, it's the maximum lifetime of the retired worker or their spouse. At some point, the workers and their spouses will be dead. They're beneficiaries do not, nor have they ever gotten a pension.

You simply stop giving new workers pensions, and you offer buyouts to the existing workers. None of this is fast, nor did I say it was. Even if you did it today, we're talking probably at least another 50 years before the last pension is paid out. Meanwhile, You're still dealing with the problems of running a pension plan, but at least you're on a path to divest from them.

This strategy is basically what every old company with pensions is doing. The problem here, is that governments don't do it, in large part due to the unions. I don't blame the unions for insisting on pensions, they're a good deal if you've got one But the fact is they're unsustainable. Unlike a company, the government is never going to go out of business, it's just going to become a retirement plan with a police force.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by x0x0 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:35PM (#19950343)
I tend to agree, but there's a limit. Accepting a job where the payout promised requires an almost 50% property tax raise? You can't possibly claim surprise when those promises are reneged on.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sokoloff on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:42PM (#19950372)
The current pensioners didn’t recently accept their job. They accepted it decades ago and it’s on the municipality to manage the funding.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by 9935c101ab17a66 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:34AM (#19951451)
A lot of the people paying these taxes never agreed to the other end of the bargain either? I mean, you can argue that this is an integral part of the social contract, but if everyone leaves Chicago because property taxes increase astronomically there won't be any tax payers to lecture about how they have to hold up their end of the one-sided bargain. And then the whole thing collapses anyway?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sokoloff on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:54AM (#19953068)
When you move to or live in a city, you sign on to the things the city did/does. That you didn't personally agree to build a new library or hire Sally Jane as a Police Dispatcher is irrelevant.

I think people are leaving Chicago over solvency/funding outlook issues. I have two barely wealthy (single digit millions, almost surely) friends in Chicago who are moving to Arizona and Texas because they worry they're among the juiciest targets to be squeezed in the upcoming years.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by x0x0 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:51PM (#19950423)
this so-called pension crisis has been clear for well over a decade, bare minimum. It was heavily discussed circa 2000.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by conanbatt on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:12PM (#19950739)
And apparently on the tax payer to eat it up.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by cljs-js-eval on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:54AM (#19953282)
I view it in the same terms as an elected official who willfully courts lobbyists or something else legal, but still distasteful. Members of those pension classes have known forever that their pension amounts would bleed the city dry, but they went along with it anyway. It's technically not their fault, but only in a dry legal sense. They knew they were leaving the rest of us in a bad state.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sgregnt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @10:50AM (#19953555)
That's how socialism works: you spend someone's else money.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by codedokode on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:12PM (#19954874)
That's how any government works I think.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by stochastastic on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:15PM (#19948847)
In the US a “pension” typically means a fixed benefit regardless of investment performance. Many pension sponsors reduced contributions to their plans when markets were up and have had large shortfalls when markets have gone down, which has contributed to the “pension funding crisis”.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rrrrreeeee on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:23PM (#19948899)
In Canada, pensions contributions are never ever adjusted depending on market performance. Instead, payouts are typically indexed to inflation. When markets are down, funds usually have a shortfall, so they cut the inflation indexing. When markets are up and the pension fund is overfunded, they restore the inflation adjustment. This slightly harms the pensioners, but not by much to have a critical effect on their well-being.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by chrismeller on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:31PM (#19949274)
This is a reasonable approach, but means you don’t really ever have any idea how much you’ll have when you retire. Honestly that’s probably the only approach that will ever work longer term, but it’s not an easy thing to sell or plan for.

The US Postal System has essentially this exact problem every year - they aren’t making enough to cover their pension obligations so they keep raising stamp prices (and let’s not get started on the absurdly short-term solution of “forever” stamps). Since they’re a government agency but independent and unable to accept funding from any other method it’s a great example of the problem.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rrrrreeeee on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:39PM (#19949320)
You have an idea of the minimum you will get. Your pension will never go down, just that you don't know whether your pension will go up.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by asah on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:12AM (#19953125)
inflation means that your pension goes down by default.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by wbl on Saturday May 18, 2019 @10:32PM (#19951068)
They also are obligated to cover all future obligations today, which is pretty unrealistic.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by opo on Saturday May 18, 2019 @11:53PM (#19951331)
The real issue for the postal service is that the law was changed so that the USPS would start funding their retirement health care costs since they are promised to the workers and the projected costs had exploded:

>...Although retiree health benefits are often unfunded or poorly funded, two considerations suggested the Service’s retiree health care obligations should be funded: they are as firm a commitment as the Service’s pensions, and they had become enormous (about $75 billion by 2006). In 2003, the presidential commission suggested establishing a reserve fund for these obligations, and the Postal Service itself sent Congress a proposal for creating such a fund.

>Prior to 2006, the Service simply paid retirees’ health benefit premiums when they came due. The Service put aside no money when it promised the future benefits. Paying benefits when they come due rather than funding them in advance is known as the pay-as-you-go or unfunded approach.

>Early this century, Congress, the Administration, the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO), and a bipartisan presidential commission expressed concern about the lack of funding. Although retiree health benefits are often unfunded or poorly funded, two considerations suggested the Service’s retiree health care obligations should be funded: they are as firm a commitment as the Service’s pensions, and they had become enormous (about $75 billion by 2006). In 2003, the presidential commission suggested establishing a reserve fund for these obligations, and the Postal Service itself sent Congress a proposal for creating such a fund.

>In 2002-2003, it was discovered that the Service was contributing far more than necessary to fully fund its pensions, and Congress allowed the Service to contribute less. Congress decided the pension “savings” could help patch the retiree health benefit underfunding. In 2006, as part of the Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act (PAEA), the Postal Service Retirement Health Benefits Fund (RHBF) was established. Most of the Service’s contributions to the new fund could be paid using the pension “savings.” PAEA was bipartisan legislation with broad support.

https://taxfoundation.org/primer-postal-service-retiree-heal...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by hvs on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:22AM (#19951599)
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by ComputerGuru on Sunday May 19, 2019 @08:58AM (#19953078)
I don't understand how they ruled officers don't have to pay back that money. It was clearly stolen from taxpayers.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:01PM (#19948761)
How do you ensure the funds are invested properly, and not in a nephew's real estate development project? How do you ensure the correct assumptions are used in calculating how much to contribute into the fund in the first place? You can adjust mortality tables and investment return assumptions to make the benefits seem cheaper than they are. The government can even choose to forego making their understated contribution if they vote themselves to forego it! (which many governments frequently have)

People's eyes glaze over when talking about their own 401k, what chance is there for voters to get into the nitty gritty about multiple government agencies' pension liabilities and investments at the city/county/state/federal level?

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rrrrreeeee on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:14PM (#19948839)
The employer isn't liable for the pension at all. Neither is the employee. All they do is pay into the fund. Instead, there is an entirely separate legal entity (the pension fund) that controls and distributes the assets. The fund releases reports regularly on the health of the fund. The contribution calculations are usually included in those reports. The investments by pension funds are usually in long term infrastructure assets like highway 407 in Ontario, or various property management companies such as Cadillac-Fairview. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontario_Teachers%27_Pension_... the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan is probably one of the best examples of a well run pension fund. All public employees in Ontario, as well as federal employees are all part of a union, whether it be OMERS, PSAC, CUPE, caisse or otherwise. These unions protect the employees from the 4 year swings of governments and instead look after the long term health of employees.

I suggest you research the laws surrounding pensions in Canada. Answering the questions properly here is too lengthy, but they could probably be answered by 30 minutes of research. Pensions are incredibly powerful for looking after retirees. In fact, Canada has a federal pension plan called CPP which pays out to all Canadians based upon their contributions over their lifetime. Pensions are not the enemy my friend, it's elected representatives who look out for their short term interests instead of the health of their electorate.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:51PM (#19949051)
That is not how taxpayer funded pensions in US work. What you describe is the equivalent of the employee purchasing an annuity from an insurance company. What the US has is a politician today offering benefits 30 years from now, which may or may not be funded with contributions and investment returns from a pension fund, but at the end of the day the employee always has a lien on the tax revenue if pension funds are short.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by refurb on Saturday May 18, 2019 @05:25PM (#19949805)
The same problem exists in Canada as well.

https://www.cfib-fcei.ca/en/research-economic-analysis/canad...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by dusbajd on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:26PM (#19948913)
“How do you ensure the funds are invested properly”

Look up the Ontario public teachers pension plan, OTPP. It has its own quite extensive wiki page.

Spoiler: it has more assets than the entire state of PA public pension fund (by a factor of 6, if I recall)

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by intended on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:18AM (#19951404)
Pension funds are a force on the stock market and have been for aeons.

Getting a fund to work is not hard, and given the massive economic growth that america has seen in the past 30 years alone, even the most conservative fund would be doing impressively well.

All of these things are easy.

The only thing which I have heard and seen which is a problem is people/politicians coming in and breaking the compact made with emoloyees 10, 15 years down the line.

At that point the fund gets drawn down and you can easily get a scenario like today.

The spenders are no longer in office and the obligations are coming Due.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jijji on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:03AM (#19951362)
i've noticed a lot of banks/hedge funds will invest in property tax certificates with a typical return of 18%, and then pay out a lower interest rate back to the customer... its alot safer to do it that way than to invest in randomly performing stocks or mutual funds.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by kristianc on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:58PM (#19949417)
> In Canada we have pension funds that are separately funded entities that are payed into over an employee's career.

Speaking for the UK, ‘national insurance’ is a direct transfer from young to old.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by ThrustVectoring on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:25PM (#19948911)
Pay-as-you-go versus fully funded makes little difference. If you fix retiree membership and consumption, it's the difference between workers paying an extra $X/month in student loan repayments etc versus an extra $X/month in taxes.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by gfodor on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:38PM (#19948626)
Pulling or cutting the pensions of retired public service workers (many of whom who risked their lives to protect the public) would, beyond the ethical questions, eliminate the credibility of the city's promises to those who sign up for such jobs and hence would likely greatly reduce the quantity and quality of recruits.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:01PM (#19948764)
The whole idea of policemen “risking their lives” is not statistically accurate. Only 144 policemen died in the line of duty in the entire United States last year (https://www.npr.org/2018/12/27/680410169/more-police-officer...)

The Chicago police department isn’t exactly what most people would call “quality”.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by aswanson on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:05PM (#19948797)
It's not even in the top 10 most dangerous occupations: https://www.ajc.com/news/world/these-are-the-deadliest-jobs-...
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sa46 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:37AM (#19952215)
Full list of occupations ranked by fatal injuries per 100k workers. The referenced article isn't that useful because it doesn't provide any numbers to do an absolute comparison.

                                           Fatal injuries per
  Rank  Job                                100k workers
  ====  ===============================    =================
  1.    Fishers                            100.0
  2.    Logging workers                     87.3
  3.    Aircraft pilots                     51.3
  4.    Roofers                             45.2
  5.    Refuse material collectors          34.9
  6.    Steel workers                       33.3
  7.    Truck drivers                       26.9
  8.    Farmers, ranchers                   24.0
  9.    Groundskeeping workers              21.0
  10.   Electrical power-line installers    18.6
  11.   Misc agricultural workers           17.7
  12.   Construction workers                17.4
  13.   Helpers, construction trades        17.3
  14.   Maintenance and repair workers      16.6
  15.   Grounds maintenance workers         15.9
  16.   Construction laborers               14.3
  17.   Mechanics                           13.1
  18.   Police                              12.9
  19.   Construction equipment operators    11.8
  20.   Mining machine operators            11.7
  21.   Taxi drivers                        10.5
  22.   Athletes                             9.5
  23.   Painters                             8.9
  24.   Firefighters                         8.9
  25.   Electricians                         8.4
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sl1ck731 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:46AM (#19952243)
Why is aircraft pilots so high? I'm assuming it isn't just commercial airline pilots?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jcranmer on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:41AM (#19953227)
The airline pilots who are flying from NYC to LA have a fairly safe job. It's the bush pilots flying between remote places in Alaska who are driving up the statistics; basically all of the fatal air crashes in the US are in Alaska.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rjsw on Sunday May 19, 2019 @07:20AM (#19952734)
Probably includes helicopters.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by gfodor on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:43PM (#19955706)
The danger involved for fire and police is highly dependent upon geography and role/rank.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by throwawaymath on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:04PM (#19949456)
It strikes me as a bit disingenuous to say it's not even in the top 10 when it's number 18, according to that list. At that point we're talking about a difference of degree, not category. If anything your citation supports the idea that police officers endanger their lives.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:17PM (#19949508)
It would be disingenuous if he said “it wasn’t in the top 10” when it was #11. #18 is nowhere near the top 10.

Even a garbage collector is three times more likely to die on the job than a police officer.

https://qz.com/410585/garbage-collectors-are-more-likely-to-...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by throwawaymath on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:40PM (#19949608)
18 is quite close to 10, in an absolute sense. The context of that citation is a claim that it's statistically inaccurate to say police officers risk their lives. That claim is demonstrably not borne out by statistics. Out of the universe of available professional work, being a police officer is #18 in risk. It's a rather small consolation that they're not eight jobs higher up the chain in terms of risk, considering there is essentially no chance of e.g. my monitor killing me as I sit at my desk.

A valid takeaway from the cited list is that being a police officer isn't literally the most dangerous thing you can do for work. An invalid takeaway is that being a police officer isn't dangerous.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by GreaterFool on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:26PM (#19950061)
How close 18 is to 10 in absolute sense has zero meaning. So does saying "10 most dangerous jobs" without quoting actual numbers. What if job 11 is 100x more safe than job 10? What if job 18 is 100000x more safe than job 10?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by gfodor on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:51PM (#19955742)
Being a police officer in a suburb where there is no crime does not belong in the same analysis as being a police officer in a crime filled area. Being a parking compliance officer and an undercover drug enforcement agent also have wildly different risk exposure. To compare these various jobs similarly from a risk assessment point of view by bucketing them under "police officers" is ridiculous.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by aswanson on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:56PM (#19956096)
Being a nurse or care technician in a hospital is more dangerous than being a cop in terms of being physically assaulted. They are often females on 1-to-1 assignment with mentally ill men that often attempt to attack & rape them.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by gfodor on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:05PM (#19956737)
I'm not sure if you just intended to reply to someone else, or just ignored the words I wrote completely. Comparing these professions on a global basis is dumb. Nurses who work in environments where they are exposed to convicts or the mentally ill are at a higher risk of assault than those who work in pediactrics. Comparing risk-laden professions by just putting everyone into a gigantic bucket by a job title in order to say "which job is more dangerous" defies a basic understanding of what people in these fields actually experience depending on where their job is, their position, and their role (disclosure: son of a firefighter, brother in law of a cop, husband to a physician)
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by aswanson on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:26PM (#19956832)
The point is, you can render specifity to the point of uselessness. Of course there are specific situations & circumstances where a given occupation is more risk prone than another, but global averages are where public perception & policy are set & laws are made. Such is life.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by throwawaymath on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:41PM (#19949328)
Why do you consider the idea that police officers risk their lives to be statistically inaccurate? According to the United States Department of Justice, there are approximately 1,100,000 police officers in the entire country[1]. If 144 police officers died last year, a given police officer has (assuming uniformity) slightly greater than a 0.01% chance of dying each year. In other words one out of every 10,000 officers is killed.

Assuming surviving one year does not impact the likelihood of dying the next year, over a 20 year career a police officer then has a 0.26% chance of dying in the line of duty. We can expect that slightly greater than two out of every 1,000 officers will die prior to retirement.

___________________

1. https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/nsleed.pdf

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:47PM (#19949360)
From another post, that doesn’t rank being a police in the top 15 most dangerous occupations.

https://www.ajc.com/news/world/these-are-the-deadliest-jobs-...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by throwawaymath on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:03PM (#19949447)
Okay, but it is listed in the top 20. What you're citing doesn't seem to support your thesis; in fact, it appears to refute it. With that in mind, and considering the foregoing back of the napkin math I presented, I'm still not following how police officers don't endanger their lives.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:23PM (#19949541)
About a third less than garbage collectors....

https://qz.com/410585/garbage-collectors-are-more-likely-to-...

Does that mean we should pay garbage collectors more in hazard pay than police?

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by throwawaymath on Saturday May 18, 2019 @04:36PM (#19949594)
Statistically speaking, yes, if your compensation model pays commensurate with risk. But I'm not sure I see how that's relevant to the discussion at hand.

You started by saying that the claim that police officers risk their lives is statistically inaccurate, with a citation. I countered that citation with one of my own and a calculation showing they do risk their lives. Now you are talking about garbage collectors and their exposure to risk being greater than that of police officers.

That doesn't really counter my point about police officers' lives being exposed to risk, because I never made a claim that police officers are exposed to more risk than garbage collectors. Likewise I'm not forwarding a normative point about whether or not people should be paid commensurate with the amount of risk they encounter in their professional work. I am making the narrow, positive point which is that, objectively speaking, police officers are exposed to risk (and this is borne out by statistics).

I'm not in a position to make a normative claim about whether or not (or how much, in an absolute sense) we should compensate people more for risking their lives. I'm not sure if you were expecting me to say that garbage collectors shouldn't be paid more than police officers in hazard pay. But if we are assuming a system that pays commensurate with risk, then I'm happy to agree it would be internally consistent to pay garbage collectors more than police officers in hazard pay, sure.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Ntrails on Saturday May 18, 2019 @05:57PM (#19949954)
To say someone "does not risk their life" is meaningless really. What OP probably means is "not risking their lives to an exceptional degree". Born out by a comparison to jobs that might otherwise be classed as lower risk
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Spooky23 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:36PM (#19950845)
No. Garbagemen should have life and disability insurance.

Police and fire employees tend to live shorter lives due to specific conditions related their occupation. It’s apples and oranges.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jonathankoren on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:33PM (#19955972)
When killed in duty, it's most often due to a traffic accident. [0] Garbage men die when their own truck runs over them.[1] Additionally, trash collectors get a lot more repetitive stress injuries. The cause of death for garbage men is just as intrinsic, to their job. It's just that the sanitation workers' union isn't as politically popular.

As for firefighters, it's literally no more deadly than being a painter (8.9 fatal injuries per 100k). They're both climbing tall ladders with one hand. It may not be romantic to say that, but that's the actuarial science.

[0] https://qz.com/410585/garbage-collectors-are-more-likely-to-...

[1] https://consumer.healthday.com/encyclopedia/work-and-health-...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Spooky23 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @07:11PM (#19956171)
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:21AM (#19952532)
According to another post, the study attributed much of the difference to shift work and bad eating habits that may result from shift work. This also isn’t unique to police work among blue collar workers.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Spooky23 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:32PM (#19950827)
Police and Fire work is hard on employees, reducing their overall life expectancy materially.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4734369/

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jonathankoren on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:00AM (#19952092)
From the paper:

>A recent study suggested that overweight and obesity were more prevalent among law enforcement personnel than the general population (Ramey, Downing, & Franke, 2009) and lack of regular physical exercise is one of the occupational risk factors contributing to the higher prevalence of elevated blood pressure, metabolic syndrome, and CVD among emergency responders such as police officers (Kales, Tsismenakis, Zhang, & Soteriades, 2009).

Lay off the donuts.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by enraged_camel on Saturday May 18, 2019 @10:27PM (#19951042)
You can say the same about a lot of professions, particularly blue-collar.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rat9988 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:01PM (#19949109)
Only 144? I guess it's a matter of perception, but I'm pretty sure way less software developers died for their job.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:06PM (#19949140)
From a sibling comment, it is the 18th most dangerous job.

Also from the article.

Leading causes included heart attacks and strokes, which caused 18 deaths. And 15 officers died due to cancers that the NLEOMF says were "related to search and recovery efforts after the attack on the World Trade Centers on September 11, 2001."

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lr4444lr on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:52PM (#19949057)
What about injuries, and the fact that they are forced to retire once their physical fitness wanes?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by scarface74 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:05PM (#19949128)
Here are numbers from the CDC:

https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/updates/upd-2-12-18.html

But as far as retiring when your fitness wanes. How is that any different than any other job that requires manual labor?

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lr4444lr on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:29PM (#19950312)
You're correct, it's not different. A lot of those jobs (construction, plumbing / steam-fitting, railworkers, auto plant workers) are unionized too.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by cannonedhamster on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:38AM (#19951467)
Why does the fact that they are unionized matter? The police union is one of the strongest unions in the country and they will even protect obviously bad apples from prosecution. On the one hand, it's good to see unions protect their members, on the other police don't really need more protection from prosecution than they inherently receive just for being officers. It's pretty hard to prosecute an officer even when is obvious to most of society that they've done something wrong that any other person would get some form of punishment for simply because it's in the DA's best interest to not screw with the police, who they require assistance from regularly.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Hydraulix989 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:55PM (#19950181)
Have you spoken to any police officers lately about their jobs? My next-door neighbor in my hometown was a state policeman who had guns and knives pulled on him several times in his career (during ordinary traffic stops, no less). If you're a cop working in a high-crime area, you're going to be dealing with the worst of society on a daily basis. I'm very thankful that my computer can't sporadically decide to physically attack me while I'm at work.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by cannonedhamster on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:46AM (#19951496)
We pay soldiers who literally go into war zones less than what we pay officers typically. I'm if the opinion that we should pay soldiers more and gurantee lifetime healthcare for soldiers, but at this time it does put the actual risk into perspective. Healthcare workers are also routinely put into danger, as are security guards, and really any position that deals with the public on a regular basis. I'm not sure police officers really have a strong argument about being more dangerous because of several occasions of violence or risk of harm, obviously it's a non-trivial risk, but they typically should have body armor and training to minimize the risk that others may not have access to.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Hydraulix989 on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:40AM (#19967808)
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by outside1234 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:42PM (#19948651)
Just pay them market rate and give them 401ks like everyone else - what am I missing? Why do we keep doing this to ourselves with government jobs?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:53PM (#19948715)
> Why do we keep doing this to ourselves with government jobs?

Because the politician who agrees to the largess will be long gone before the bill comes due.

Not sure how to fix this, but generally I think some sort of additional checks and balances should be required whenever government takes on huge future liabilities.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:57PM (#19948744)
Easy to fix, ban long term compensation agreements. If a union wants an annuity, they can go buy it from an insurance company. No need to negotiate anything other than cash salaries. Unfortunately, not enough taxpayers vote to offset the government workers voting themselves benefits as a bloc.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by malandrew on Sunday May 19, 2019 @02:42PM (#19954737)
And sadly every time we grow the size of government by assigning more responsibilities to government, the larger that voting bloc grows. In states favoring big government, this can only end badly. Although they can always raise taxes to address shortfalls, this has limits as it eventually drives those paying the most taxes to low-tax states.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by BurningFrog on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:01PM (#19948765)
> Why do we keep doing this to ourselves with government jobs?

Time horizon arbitrage.

The elected politicians care about things looking good the next 4 years. The employee unions care about the life long outcome for their members.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lostphilosopher on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:59PM (#19948750)
Doing this requires spending money now. You can get away with funding pensions with IOUs much longer than you can do it with a salary or 401k. Further the benefits of solving this kick in long after you are out of office, assuming no one breaks your system before then.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by seizethecheese on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:41PM (#19948995)
Public employee unions.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:11AM (#19951572)
Public employees don't have a market rate...wat
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by chrisco255 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:55PM (#19948724)
A lot of states do this. Florida Retirement System for public employees is mostly paid for through managed assets.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 19, 2019 @07:48AM (#19952830)
> Pulling or cutting the pensions of retired public service workers (many of whom who risked their lives to protect the public) would, beyond the ethical questions, eliminate the credibility of the city's promises

Well, yes. It would be a default. But more money has been spent than is there and there are only three pools to draw from: taxpayers, services and creditors. (Creditors include both pensioners and bond holders.) At this point, multiple pools have to be hosed. It’s just a matter of when and to what degree, with the hosing being less extreme the earlier it’s dealt with.

In all likelihood, the city will go bankrupt and have creditors cut services in federal bankruptcy proceedings, thereby imperilling the city’s long-term tax base. State, being unable to go bankrupt, will probably hose creditors more.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by dev_dull on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:15PM (#19949193)
They were promised something by the city that couldn’t be delivered to them. There’s no other way out.

Is there a difference in Silicon Valley workers being promised future stock if they just forgo their paycheck for a little while longer? The Difference of courses that taxpayers don’t foot the difference.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rocqua on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:49PM (#19950155)
Differences between silicon valley stock and city pensions are

1) stock options are a known volatile thing rather than a government backed guarantee.

2) Missed Stock options are much easier to compensate for financially than a pension. If you miss stock options, you are still part of the wage pool. If you miss a pension that is much harder. After all, the point of a pension is to take care of people who are 'worn out'. Hence, there is much less of a fall-back system for missed pensions.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by moorhosj on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:45PM (#19949350)
Silicon Valley workers also don’t work for the taxpayers, so that would be another difference. Who would pay public employees if not taxpayers?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by SOLAR_FIELDS on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:40PM (#19948639)
The current proposed solution is just to cut back benefits on new job offers - though obviously if they cut back too much no one decent will want to work there.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by Phlarp on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:46PM (#19948674)
Because there is some glut of smart qualified people gunning for those public sector jobs?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by vkou on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:45AM (#19951492)
I've met plenty of idiots who worked in well-paid private sector jobs, and plenty of smart people who worked in government jobs.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by czbond on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:35PM (#19948957)
Not true - if it were, every minimum wage, overworked job would go unfilled.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by closeparen on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:12PM (#19949176)
Minimum wage overworked jobs have a hard time attracting people with alternatives.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 18, 2019 @01:48PM (#19948685)
I would think quality recruits are already avoiding Illinois in general due to the future share of tax revenues that will need to be diverted to pay for prior years' labor, meaning less resources for today and the future's quality of life.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by moorhosj on Saturday May 18, 2019 @03:47PM (#19949363)
On the flip side, Chicago pays their teachers, police and fire fighters pretty good annual salaries. I imagine that outweighs their analysis of future benefits as a share of tax revenue.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by prepend on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:24PM (#19948902)
I don’t think the fix is removing pensions from old people, but rather drastically reforming pensions for future retirees entering the workforce now.

Cutting pensions now would be like cutting someone’s salary and would likely lead to skilled people quitting.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by RhodesianHunter on Saturday May 18, 2019 @06:54PM (#19950178)
So cut compensation for current already underpaid employees to shore up retirement for the people who voted for the politicians who caused this?

That doesn't taste right to me.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by prepend on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:48AM (#19959441)
I don’t think reducing compensation for future employees through reduced pensions shores up retirement for current employees or pensioners. For that you have to raise taxes a lot, I think. My suggestion was to prevent even worse problems in the future.

I think the current folks are hosed because raising taxes on the middle and working class along with rich people is unpopular so I don’t think elected officials will want to do that. So they will probably chug along and then go bankrupt, hosing pensioners.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by patrick5415 on Saturday May 18, 2019 @09:10PM (#19950729)
The aarp is a powerful propaganda machine.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jonathankoren on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:16AM (#19952161)
You can’t cut the pension for the retired, or the soon to be retired. Instead you try buy outs and phase them out. New workers get 401ks. Old workers get pensions. Middle aged workers get a choice.

30 years later, the pension holders are dead, or your company is. Either way, it’s no longer a problem.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by prepend on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:50AM (#19959453)
The feds went through this back in the 80s when they switched from CSRA to FERS+thrift (basically a 401k). I think that helped but didn’t completely solve the problem. But at least they are more solvent than Chicago.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by wbl on Saturday May 18, 2019 @10:35PM (#19951082)
What about unvested obligations for current workers like 3٪ of highest pay going to 2٪ for all pay after now?
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by intended on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:11AM (#19951386)
How can you be in debt for pensions of all things.

Get employee. Put money in pension fund. Let fund grow. Wait 20 years earn interest and pay employee.

end.

What you are describing is gross mismanagement of funds, and blaming the rightful recipients of funds for the existing.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by strictnein on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:51AM (#19951694)
The pension systems have overestimated their annual returns for decades and planned for future returns that are completely out of whack with reality. This is a pretty well known issue.

So if you're putting money into a system, and you know it's not enough to cover your benefits, you're not exactly just a innocent victim here. You're benefitting from a system that you know is broken.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by chii on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:14AM (#19951913)
I have no horse in the race, but it feels like the pension system is promising money that would never exist. How come there's no oversight or some sort of check against this when it was established? Surely those who would rely on the pension would at least band together to create this committee.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by honkycat on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:06AM (#19952115)
Ex Chicagoan here. Basically corruption and incompetence took the actual money away

The money did exist. Workers pay into the pensions as part of their compensation package.

Chicago borrowed against the actual pension accounts and corruption/incompetence drained them. Then they did scoop and throw methods for two decades to avoid having the pensions land on their heads.

There is a ton or corruption in Chicago. I have a friend who works for Idot. They have a lot of workers on the payroll who are making 6 figures. My friend has never seen these people who are supposed to be his co-workers show up for work, and when he asked he was told "Don't bring it up. Over your head. We can't fire them."

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by intended on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:16AM (#19952164)
How can a pension fund overestimate success?

Firstly pension funds are conservative in their estimates, they aren’t growth funds.

And what precisely is anyone supposed to do? NOT put money into a fund ?

The only option other than a pension plan is to put it in a more risky fund. Which means your investment would be blown out post 2008.

AND that means your benefit from that job changes, making it less likely for you to join a government job -at all.

There’s a huge amount of discussion here that seems to have nothing to do with pension funds, but some bizarre form of fund which you should be blamed for partaking or being a dependent of through your job.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by kgwgk on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:33AM (#19952582)
> Firstly pension funds are conservative in their estimates,

Not really.

https://davidgcrane.org/?page_id=702

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by IanCal on Sunday May 19, 2019 @05:58AM (#19952455)
There's two common ways of doing pensions.

One is a fund you pay into and at the end you get whatever it's worth.

The other is a scheme you pay into which guarantees a set payout at the end. It's that which often causes problems, because the scheme has promised payouts that significantly exceed their investments if they have assumed greater growth than they get.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @01:08AM (#19951565)
Because pensions are guaranteed benefits. So if you put it on a bond, and the bond goes down, you need to draw more taxes to make the difference.

Pensions are partially the outcome of wishful result-oriented thinking ("workers should have pensions they can depend on, so make the promise first and then the solution will happen").

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by intended on Sunday May 19, 2019 @04:21AM (#19952174)
What? How the heck is that a pension ??

That’s a bond. Why does that have anything to do with a pension ?

And who in his right mind plants a bond and links it to a pension ? How does that even work?

A bond is a loan. That means the firm or institution is taking a loan.

A pension is the opposite of that - it’s money taken from employee payments and added to a conservative fund with a time horizon of 20-30 years. This allows them to make long term plans which avoid the risks of high beta and risk stocks or deals.

So as your economy goes up, your fund goes up and you pay people off with the interest.

Something changed/went wrong, long before you got to the bond.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by anthuman on Sunday May 19, 2019 @07:05AM (#19952681)
What do you think "conservative fund" is? It is a fund of bonds. What do you think pensions are?

There is nothing more "conservative" in investing than bonds ( particularly treasury bonds ).

Nobody "plants" a bond and links it to a pension. A pension buys bonds, stocks, etfs, etc which hopefully grows in value or pays healthy interest.

The problem is if the pension doesn't do as well as expected or the ratio of workers to retirees gets too skewed and they can't meet their defined payouts.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by conanbatt on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:36AM (#19953212)
Funds for pensions are usually mix of stocks and bonds, but stocks are really bad for defined benefit contributions because in a downturn you will have to oversell. This is something that actually happened in 2008 and broke some pension funds in the U.S. So bonds would not have that issue (treasury bonds, low-risk bonds) so you have no volatility.

But even they will not produce enough for the benefits that are promised: as soon as someone outlives their contribution the fund might not be actuarially safe. It turns out it is exceedingly difficult to mitigate all risk in a retirement fund, and government makes the promise that if they fail, they will pass the bill to someone else.

Pension funds are truly evil.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by rhinoceraptor on Sunday May 19, 2019 @12:19AM (#19951409)
> Wait 20 years

That's the problem, politicians don't care about 20 years from now. They care about their next election.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by closeparen on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:15PM (#19948846)
$75k income, increasing at 1% a year, saving 15% each year, investing at 7% average returns over a 40 year career would give you $101k in retirement.

That doesn’t seem unreasonable.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by phonon on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:22PM (#19948896)
Err, who earns $75k a year for 40 years?

40 years ago that person probably started off below $15k/year.

(In 1979 average household income was $19,553) https://www.multpl.com/us-average-income/table/by-year

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by closeparen on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:28PM (#19948922)
The calculation includes inflation. $20k in 1979 is $70k today.

It’s also the classic tradeoff of government work: lower salary than you could get in the private market, but retirement equivalent to a higher salary than you could get. Compelling only if you are sufficiently long term oriented.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by phonon on Sunday May 19, 2019 @03:37PM (#19955027)
I ran a few scenarios--your numbers are not correct.

Start at age 20, making $15,000/y, increasing 5% per year. (Salary at retirement over $100k/y)

Assume annual savings rate of 15%

8% return

Retire at 60.

I get around a million dollars saved at age 60 (i.e. today). Not enough to buy an annuity that pays out over $100,000/y. Off by a factor of 2 or so, I think.

And starting salary 40 years ago was probably under 15k, 8% consistent compounded returns are really good, the other retirement benefits besides the pension etc.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by sseagull on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:33PM (#19948947)
Your calculations are a bit off, since even $75k * 0.15 * 40 = $450k (ie, not taking into account salary increases or returns).

Also, $75k is a lot more that most people make. From what I can find, that would be ~85th percentile of personal income, or around the 60th percentile of household income.

Edit: Some representative (although a bit outdated) sources:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_income_in_the_United_...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by closeparen on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:45PM (#19949013)
101k a year in income, more than $2m in total balance.

Chicago police officers make $65k within 18 months [0]. If $75k is a high estimate, it’s not by a ton. Government competes for professional/managerial/educated employees as well.

[0] https://www.chicagomag.com/Chicago-Magazine/The-312/August-2...

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by echelon on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:10PM (#19948822)
Could they raise more money by locally legalizing more "sins" and heavily taxing them? Something of a cross between Las Vegas and Colorado could pull in a lot of revenue.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:53PM (#19949062)
They already do, via video game gambling in bars:

https://www.bnd.com/news/local/article230192814.html

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by czbond on Saturday May 18, 2019 @02:37PM (#19948968)
I suspect they will. As a resident of Colorado, once the politicians realize they can MAKE money off it, rather than spending considerably more money ON it (eg: jails, etc)... the transition suddenly "makes sense".
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by thelasthuman on Saturday May 18, 2019 @07:30PM (#19950318)
It's so sad that undoing horrible laws and ineffective prohibitions must come down to dollars and cents, rather than the innate freedom we all should have.

Land of the fee, home of the slave.

Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by anbop on Saturday May 18, 2019 @11:56PM (#19951345)
Hopefully the Fed can inflate away >50% of real pension liabilities.
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by alpineidyll3 on Sunday May 19, 2019 @09:53AM (#19953279)
God I need to sell our apt. in Chicago...
Re:Chicago successfully taxes streaming services by jacquesm on Sunday May 19, 2019 @06:25AM (#19952549)
> So expect more digital taxes in your future.

This is not a problem that will be solved with taxes, it will be solved with a global reset, and those are usually accompanied by major wars. This is not a Chicago problem, an Illinois problem or even an American problem.