News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by billfruit on Thursday April 11, 2019 @12:40AM (#19631198)
Why I do I see the problems of harassment and of lack of representation being conflated here.

While harrasement is deplorable and needs to be tackled, I think it is wrong to insinuate that it is a major cause for lack of participation by women in Wikipedia.

It is a voluntary effort, and besides editors do not have to declare their names or gender in Wikipedia. Editors need not even have accounts. So the numbers the article cites are likely to be unreliable.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by sgillen on Thursday April 11, 2019 @01:07AM (#19631305)
I’m not sure why you are being downvoted. I do not have any reason to believe men are any more resilient to harassment than women are.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by bluescrn on Thursday April 11, 2019 @04:00AM (#19632004)
Men are in some ways stuck in their historical gender role, expected to be tough and ‘have a thick skin’.

There’s certainly vast amounts of abuse and harassment hurled at men online - politicians in particular. Right now, the US president probably receives more online hate than anyone else in history...

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by FuckOffNeemo on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:41AM (#19633787)
You had me going with a convincing argument till you finished your second sentence.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:10AM (#19634068)
I'm not going to wade into the gender roles debate but who "receives" the most online hate Depends on your definition of "receives" The most polarizing US president since the internet no doubt has the most shit talked about him on the internet (I'm sure someone more polarizing will come along eventually though). I don't think he sees much of it. It's not like world leaders fill their free time by browsing /r/politics.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by JimiofEden on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:18AM (#19634145)
I mean, it doesn't sound completely wrong to me so far in history.

Regardless of whether or not that hate is deserved is another matter.

But thinking back as to who else receives as much hate: A few other thoughts are Hitler, maybe W Bush back before modern social media took over. There was definitely the whole Shkreli thing, but I don't think that ever reached the average joe as much as the others have.

[dead]
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by adrianN on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:44AM (#19631739)
I claim the opposite with an equal amount of supporting data! I even make my factoid more believable than yours by calling to mind the viciousness of harassment among teenage girls and I point out that they are avid users of social media.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by coding123 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:37AM (#19634334)
I'm gonna wager a third option with ALL chips in that it's not the gender that's at issue but the gender roles that is at issue and is to blame for the harassment.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by bubblewrap on Thursday April 11, 2019 @03:12AM (#19631838)
There have been studies showing most harassers of women are actually other women. I think it was for Twitter, and perhaps comments on The Guardian website, not sure about the details.

I don't know the total numbers for harassment in general. For example if more men than women would use a particular social network, men would likely be more often harassers. In total numbers, not proportions. But I am not sure you would win your bet.

I'm pretty sure men are more often the target of harassment than women. Would take that bet.

Edit: can't find the exact articles anymore (thanks for nothing, liberal Google), but here is for example one mentioning 50% of harassment women receive on Twitter is from other women: https://www.businessinsider.de/half-of-the-sexist-harassment...

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by okcando on Saturday April 13, 2019 @02:08AM (#19651362)
I heard on I think Malcolm Gladwell's podcast (and he's hardly infallible and this is second hand so grains of salt and all that) that women tend to harass other women more often when they are underrepresented or subordinated in the group.

The context was a diversity hiring push that put a few women in otherwise primarily male offices across the country and saw disappointing results. The idea was that when women (or any minority group) are outnumbered, they will try to defy expectations and stand out by adopting the social habits of the majority and will compete with each other for ratification.

And that makes some amount of sense to me, like when a gay man reassures us that he's conservative and subtle and a good dinner guest and not like those oversexed deviants that march in the parades. He's forsaking others in his minority group to get in the club.

But it's a thin line. I don't mean to take the position that anything bad that women do is always the fault of men. It's just hard to suss out something this complicated.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by schwurb on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:04AM (#19632268)
What does the effect of harassment on males have to do with whether males are more likely to be harassers?
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by kristianc on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:36AM (#19634315)
> While harrasement is deplorable and needs to be tackled, I think it is wrong to insinuate that it is a major cause for lack of participation by women in Wikipedia.

I'd say that if someone left photos of genitals on my userpage, that would be a pretty strong disincentive for me to participate.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by scarejunba on Thursday April 11, 2019 @02:30AM (#19631685)
I have an anecdote to share which has (perhaps unfairly) biased my beliefs regarding underrepresented people on Wikipedia.

On /r/twoxchromosomes, a profile of a somewhat accomplished (more like John Aaron, less like Alan Turing) woman was posted. In the comments were some six to ten people lamenting that she didn't have a Wikipedia page.

I thought perhaps it had been put up for RFDs or something the way they complained about how a man in the same position would have a page. Anyway, so I waited a day to see if they'd do anything and they didn't.

The woman in question did deserve a Wikipedia page so I made one, described her story, and added citations. Within the week, various bots had made it pretty. I was then able to go request a picture for her Wikipedia page. I just checked and the page looks pretty good. Lots of people have contributed.

Nothing I did was impossible for any of them to do. So why didn't they do it? Why instead did they write absolute reams of comments about the unfairness when they had the tools to fix it? Why are they so helpless?

On the Internet, no one knows you're a dog. You can be the change, quietly.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by Traster on Thursday April 11, 2019 @04:35AM (#19632125)
One thing I've noticed with wikipedia is that it has an insanely high barrier to entry. I will never create a wikipedia page for 1 reason: The first time I tried to edit a page was a nightmare. I was doing a degree, looked up some information, followed the source and it was very clear in the source that the equation on the page was wrong. I corrected the equation on the page. It was then reverted. I pointed out in the chat that the page was wrong and the source proved it. I was told the page was already based on the source and unless I could find a new citation to prove what I was claiming the page would stay as it is. So wikipedia is factually wrong on some basic engineering equation, and I walked away because I'm not going to wade through bureaucracy for some charitable change I was making.

Over the years I've found out that this is the standard experience for most first time wikipedia contributers. So whilst it may be easy for someone to create a page, that is not the experience for a first time user, and high barriers to entry are a great way of creating an exclusionary environment.

What you're describing is a problem not for the people in that thread. It' sa failure of wikipedia that it's created an environment where the average person doesn't feel able to contribute on a topic they know.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by gjm11 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:05AM (#19635193)
For what it's worth, I've never encountered the sort of "yow, my perfectly reasonable change just got reverted with extreme prejudice and other editors are immovable" problem at all. Maybe I've just been lucky?

(I do wonder whether maybe it's not so common, but when it happens it makes a big impression and so we hear more about those cases since their victims are understandably annoyed about it and want to tell everyone.)

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by jcadam on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:52AM (#19633340)
Yep, once tried to correct a Wikipedia page about an event I had direct knowledge of, only to have my change reverted. Whatever. Not going to get into a fight when I was only trying to contribute - enjoy being smugly wrong.

I'm also sitting on a few bug fixes for open source tools because some of the larger projects have made the process for contributing just way too obnoxious. (Sign our code of conduct, sign a contributor licensing agreement, submit your pull request along with a three page explanation (making sure to use the correct cover sheet) in X format, etc). That feels like work and I'm doing this for free -- like I'm supposed to feel honored that you're allowing me to submit an improvement to your code base. Meh, never mind - I'll keep the fix for myself.

I think that wikipedia and some of the more popular OSS projects have something in common: a clique of long-serving contributors erecting barriers to entry to keep newcomers out.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by JulianMorrison on Thursday April 11, 2019 @04:50AM (#19632200)
And where people whose knowledge is "the system" do feel able to "contribute" on a topic they don't know - but are sufficiently insistent about.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by antientropic on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:47AM (#19632903)
It's absurd to say that Wikipedia has an "insanely high barrier to entry". You click "Edit" and that's it - you don't even have to create an account. It's hard to imagine a lower barrier to entry. Of course, the flip side is that anybody can revert your change as well; your edit is not sacred. I mean, what alternative do you propose? That Wikipedia should never revert edits? Change into Everything2?
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by baud147258 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:34AM (#19633203)
That low barrier to entry is just for the more minor changes, like correcting a typo. For anything more complex, you'd have to successfully use their editor, find acceptable sources and correctly quote them.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by DanBC on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:41AM (#19633254)
Even seemingly minor changes can be fraught.

The discussion about whether to use –,— or - takes several hundred thousand words, and went all the way to ArbCom. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Arbitra...

For a while merely chosing a username was risky business. It's got a bit better now, but it's still weirdly complex process if someone disagrees with your choice of name.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by oriolid on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:26AM (#19633154)
Not auto-reverting fixes to obviously wrong content would be a good start. I had a similar experience with fixing a page where someone had confused kilograms and pounds.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by iagovar on Thursday April 11, 2019 @03:18AM (#19631865)
That's exactly my experience. I contributed to spanish Wikipedia several times. I don't really see the barrier. Yet I read about wikipedia and women again and again.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by Semkas on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:43AM (#19632474)
If a non-programmer critisised some part of Blender or some other large scale open source software project it would be weird to call them hypocritical for not just enacting the change themselves wouldnt it? Seems strange to pretend that there is no barrier to entry to contributing a page to an encyclopedia.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by swebs on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:11AM (#19632681)
>Seems strange to pretend that there is no barrier to entry to contributing a page to an encyclopedia.

No, there actually is no barrier to entry. You can go to any page right now, click "edit", and are greeted with a WYSIWYG editor. No programming or markup knowledge required. No registration needed either.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by tomgp on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:46AM (#19634429)
As discussed further up the thread (and as per the point of the article) the barriers to entry aren't technical but social.

An example not mentioned in the article (it's kind of tangential wrt the problems of wikipedias community) but worth noting; women are still disproportionally more likely undertake caring responsibilities outside of work and so may not have as much time as men to create and edit wikipedia pages.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by Semkas on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:14AM (#19633570)
The barrier to entry is the effort required to create a good and truthfull page.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by dangerface on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:03AM (#19633998)
Because people with two x chromosomes aren't capable of that?
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by fxbl0i on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:25AM (#19634225)
There are many more biographies of males than of females on Wikipedia. Whatever the reason for that might be is up to debate.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by gsich on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:35AM (#19634301)
Is this good or bad? Maybe because (assumption here) there are more "relevant" males throughout history?
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by fxbl0i on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:59AM (#19634582)
It is not good or bad, it is what it is. Unless biographies of females are actively being suppressed, it is simply irrelevant: they are not being created because nobody cares, literally.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by scarejunba on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:15PM (#19640270)
It's actually not that high. In the anecdote, the little page I created had two sources with citation formatting messed up and two paragraphs of text. A week later, bots had cleaned up the citation, another bot had added an infobox, and someone had added all the "Retrieved at" dates to the citations. I did so little.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by scarejunba on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:13PM (#19640255)
I did it. With a fresh account. Fresh page. They could just as well have done it.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by baud147258 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @03:53AM (#19631987)
It's a lot of work, you need good sources (better than reddit comment) and write the text; at least it's more work than just complaining on reddit/twitter. Another matter is that adding sources is complicated (at I found the process cumbersome last time I did it).
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by el_cujo on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:50AM (#19634476)
I agree that there is definitely a barrier to entry for making wikipedia articles, it definitely takes a little bit of time and effort. What bothers me is in a situation like the person you're replying to described, its hard to feel like the disgust/disappointment with the fact that this person didn't have an article is obviously overstated by the commenters. Yes, making a wikipedia article requires some effort, but not so much that if you cared at all about making one that you couldn't do it in an afternoon or two. Maybe it's an unfair assumption, but it just pushes me to further think that these people who complain about stuff on the internet don't actually care, they just want to win brownie points for appearing to care.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by baud147258 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:13PM (#19640641)
Also such a thread could be an easy springboard for a collective effort on such an article. One could create the article with an outline and share the link in such conversation, so that people could put their time where their mouth is.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by nvrx on Thursday April 11, 2019 @04:58AM (#19632240)
This is also true for open source projects. You can literally start a widely used project under a pseudonym (if you really feel the need). If it is good, it will be used.

It is easier to complain, especially if these days money can be made by complaining.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by gsich on Thursday April 11, 2019 @03:47AM (#19631963)
And even if the page on Wikipedia got deleted (relevance or content issues or whatever) you can at least say that you tried.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by Animats on Thursday April 11, 2019 @01:50AM (#19631498)
Don't ask, don't tell. Editors on Wikipedia can be anonymous.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by kristianc on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:34AM (#19634291)
Don't Ask Don't Tell sends out entirely the wrong signal to would-be editors. What it tells people is that Wikipedia - something whose sole purpose is to catalogue the world's knowledge - is an intolerant place that prioritises internal cohesion over diversity, fairness, and decency.

It was bad enough when the US military applied the policy to LGBT people. To say that Wikipedia (something that people do entirely in their free time and unpaid) should do the same for women is ludicrous.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by bjourne on Thursday April 11, 2019 @04:05AM (#19632013)
I'd call it being pseudonymous rather than anonymous. It doesn't always shield you from harassment. For example, I edited some articles relating to Sweden and the clever trolls on the site put 2 + 2 together and used that as an attack vector. I can only imagine what the insults would have been had I edited something more sensitive like about transgender issues or sexual fetishes or whatever.

I really think the site should have required real names for most editing. Pseudonymity brings out the worst in people.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by hombre_fatal on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:15AM (#19632322)
Facebook shows that people are perfectly capable of nasty things under their real names. Reading Facebook comments on popular videos and groups basically exposed pseudonymity=bad as a myth to my eyes.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by Tade0 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:55AM (#19633379)
Same here.

People are also not that different in person - it's just that some of them don't go out much so you're unlikely to meet them and their horrible personalities.

Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by bjourne on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:55AM (#19635914)
But there are degrees of hell. Facebook comments are usually not as nasty as Reddit comments which in turn are not as nasty as 4chan comments.
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by icebraining on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:21AM (#19632360)
How should Wikipedia require real names? And who would validate them?
Re:Wikipedia isn’t officially a social network, but the hara... by gsich on Thursday April 11, 2019 @03:44AM (#19631951)
>While harrasement is deplorable and needs to be tackled, I think it is wrong to insinuate that it is a major cause for lack of participation by women in Wikipedia.

This. You participate in Wikipedia because you want to. And like in many tech areas, women tend to not be interested in them.