News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @11:51AM (#19502143)
Why is it important to accommodate people who might want to move to an area? Does everyone have the right to live anywhere they want to live without having to pay the necessary price to be there? For example, does everyone have a right to expect a residence on a Hawaii beachfront? And if not, why is it reasonable to portray a city as somehow lacking because it serves existing constituents above new ones?
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by skybrian on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:22PM (#19502541)
It's like saying some cars are more responsible for a traffic jam than others, or some people on the subway contribute to it being crowded more than others. Everyone takes up space. The people who live somewhere contribute to the housing problem just like people who move in, in proportion to the amount of space they take up.

Choosing a subclass of people to scapegoat doesn't solve a structural problem.

It's also useful to think about who is doing things to make things better or worse. Moving in makes things worse, moving away makes things better. Building more housing helps, removing housing makes things worse.

So far that seems to make sense, but here's the counterintuitive part: in any given year, choosing not to move away is as bad as moving in. You're taking up space someone else could use.

(But normally we don't beat ourselves up too much for taking up space.)

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by burlesona on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:04PM (#19502298)
It’s exclusionary and merely the local version of nationalism. If you don’t want anyone to move to an area raise taxes and stop allowing new business etc. - ie, actually discourage new growth.

But no place does that. They actively encourage new growth, just not new housing, which has the effect of systematically displacing lower income people, and eventually the middle class too. Long term it ends up hurting the original people it was supposed to benefit - ie. all the Californians crying about how their kids can’t stay in state when it’s the discriminatory policies they supported that created that situation.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:37PM (#19503497)
I have to be honest, the linking of 'nationalism' to this discussion looks like hyperbole to me. Those who want to prevent housing growth or higher-density are not thinking "I don't want people of type X living here". They are most often thinking about what they personally want for themselves - the quality of life they want, the neighborhood character they desire, the breathing room/space they desire, the amount of traffic they want to deal with, and so on.

> If you don’t want anyone to move to an area raise taxes and stop allowing new business etc. - ie, actually discourage new growth.

Personal responsibility is still a thing. If someone can't afford to live in some area, or they don't like what they're getting out of it in terms of wages or expenses, they shouldn't move there.

> They actively encourage new growth, just not new housing

If people continue to move there, they are signaling they are OK with low wages or high expenses or any other drawbacks associated with that choice. If they are not OK with those things, they shouldn't move there.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by kelnos on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:08PM (#19506038)
No, they are signaling that, in a world that does not have limitless options and alternatives, this one option is at least marginally better than other available options. It doesn't mean the option is good, or even sustainable, just that it's not the worst one.

I, for one, would like to raise the bar a bit and give more people actually good options.

Anyone who suggests that a "best option" that involves commuting 3 hours every day is actually a good option is not someone I want in charge of public policy.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by kd0amg on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @09:44PM (#19508335)
I have to be honest, the linking of 'nationalism' to this discussion looks like hyperbole to me.

I have seen a lot of people in my area assert that my political will should be subordinate to theirs because I came from somewhere else. Last place I lived, the notion that a particular demographic I fall into should be kept out of the general housing market when possible due to pricing others out was not just a fringe idea but part of several (ultimately successful) city council candidates' platforms. Perhaps people in your area are less nutty about outsiders.

If someone can't afford to live in some area…

Yes, those who can't afford the rent can live elsewhere, so rent control is not needed.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by mochomocha on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:11PM (#19502394)
In San Francisco the return on land is so much higher than the return on work. There's no scenario under which this leads to a healthy society. NIMBY excesses created a modern feudalism. Why would the new hard-working generation subsidize the previous one and suffer taxes order of magnitude higher than the previous one (through property tax for example)? This is like a Ponzi scheme. There's nothing fair nor sustainable with this model. That's when in a properly working society you would have the State or Government take over and override the local policies to implement what's good for the greater good. Not what's good for the SF boomer wanting to sell his shack for 2M and retire in Florida. A couple of billionaires in Atherton should have no say on Caltrain improvements that could benefit millions of working people at the expense of a couple of trees in their backyards.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:18PM (#19502492)
I realized this when my landlord came home with a brand new Mercedes SL one day, and I was still taking the N to work despite having a 6 figure tech salary. I was basically subsidizing his car payment. I worked at a 6 person startup that received a few million in funding, and between our personal rents and the rent of our office, probably around 40% of that investor money went into the pockets of landlords. If our startup was somewhere cheaper, yeah we wouldn't have raised $X million, but we wouldn't have needed that much just to exist.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by nradov on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @03:06PM (#19504750)
Peter Thiel: Majority of capital poured into SV startups goes to 'urban slumlords'

https://www.sfgate.com/expensive-san-francisco/article/peter...

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by rootusrootus on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @02:01PM (#19503889)
Sounds like the solution is to become a landlord ;-)
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by asdff on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:03PM (#19506000)
Right after I get approved for my small loan of one million dollars to buy a 2br bungalow that will turn to dust the next earthquake.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:41PM (#19503578)
> There's nothing fair nor sustainable with this model.

This is an opinion and not fact - it's how it looks from your perspective. The line between what is a smart investment and unfair feudalism is pretty gray, and I am betting people decide how to frame the situation based on how it personally affects them. That is, I am betting everyone is acting in a self-serving manner.

> Not what's good for the SF boomer wanting to sell his shack for 2M and retire in Florida.

This statement comes off as ageist. Why is it wrong for the SF boomer to want to make a gain off their investment and retire elsewhere? This is a core mechanism of every modern society.

> A couple of billionaires in Atherton should have no say on Caltrain improvements that could benefit millions of working people at the expense of a couple of trees in their backyards.

You are cherry-picking. It isn't just a "couple of billionaires in Atherton". But even if it were, why can't they choose to defend their quality of life? Why does everyone have to live in the bay area? This all comes off as people feeling entitled to live in a highly-desirable region, but on terms that suit them.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by bduerst on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:41PM (#19502770)
>Why is it important to accommodate people who might want to move to an area?

It's not just people moving into an area, it's moving within an area.

Rent control creates an market where existing renters are inhibited from moving even into the building next to their current residence. It prevents free movement in/out and within the market.

This also makes it so landlords want to evict/churn renters as much as possible, so they are incentivized to become slum lords. Landords invest as little as possible into the property because as soon as a renter moves in, that renter is never going to leave and the landlord sees diminishing returns over time.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:45PM (#19503642)
OK here's a better alternative. Instead of rent control on a per-unit basis, cities could provide subsidies to long-term low-income residents that reduce their personal expenditure on rent. The subsidies would be paid for through taxes, thus amortizing the subsidy across the local tax base instead of impacting an individual landlord or unit.

But let me note that this must be done only for long-term residents (that is, those who have been there for years). For example, if someone moved to SF within the last 5 years, they should have known what the price of living there is. This is one of the most desirable cities, and it makes sense that it would be expensive and that not everyone would get to live there. Those moving there in recent years therefore, simply made an irresponsible personal choice and must yield to the consequences, rather than being subsidized at others' expense.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by bduerst on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @03:56PM (#19505288)
This already happens with income-subsidized housing. The added long-term requirement is absurd for the same reasons that locking people into long-term rentals is bad for rent control. You don't want to inhibit movement in the market.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by ebog on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:02PM (#19502266)
People should be able to move easily because it's good for all of us. The less friction there is in the labor market, the better off the economy is. It's also very good for the sellers of labor who now have better ability to move to where their services are most wanted or negotiate better rates.

It's not super unreasonable for a city to try to protect its current residents but when an entire country of cities are all protecting their own residents that country is much worse off.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by bzbarsky on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:24PM (#19502559)
> Why is it important to accommodate people who might want to move to an area?

Just to be clear, "move to an area" includes "move out of their parents' house and live on their own".

> because it serves existing constituents above new ones

Because the "new ones" are the kids of the "existing ones", in many cases, if not most. As in, they are also existing constituents.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:48PM (#19503691)
> Because the "new ones" are the kids of the "existing ones", in many cases, if not most.

Do you have a source for this? Personally I don't buy it.

But just for a second, let's assume that's the case. Would you be OK with limiting rent subsidies to just those who either have provably been residents for multiple years (let's say 5+ years) or have long-time roots (e.g. family)? I don't think any city owes expansion and housing supply and a re-architecture to accommodate just anyone who wants to move there.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by bzbarsky on Thursday March 28, 2019 @12:05AM (#19509143)
> Do you have a source for this?

Non-anecdotal? Not at the moment, sorry. I'd have to go dig. But anecdotally, most of the people I hear complaining about rents (not in SV, various places on the East Coast) are complaining about it being impossible to stay near aging relatives.

> Would you be OK with limiting rent subsidies to just those who either have provably been residents for multiple years (let's say 5+ years) or have long-time roots (e.g. family)?

I personally? It really depends on the form the "rent subsidies" take and how they're financed. I do think that thinking of "build more housing if there's more demand" as a "rent subsidy" is a bit odd, if that's the sort of thing we're talking about here.

> I don't think any city owes expansion and housing supply and a re-architecture to accommodate just anyone who wants to move there.

Now we're talking about the moral and ethical dimension of things, right? Opinions on this differ widely; I personally do not have strong opinions that would apply in a blanket way, and would prefer to analyze specific cases (i.e. specific cities) on a case-by-case basis.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by rcpt on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:29PM (#19502622)
> Why is it important to accommodate people who might want to move to an area?

Because walling off cities has awful consequences for national GDP

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/06/opinion/housing-regulatio...

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by kelnos on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:04PM (#19506009)
Not everyone has a right to a specific house of arbitrary size in a specific location. Sure.

But it's also a bit hypocritical to encourage and incentivize building tons of new office space, and then be surprised when the people who are to fill that office space would like to live within a reasonable commute distance of that office, and then deny them that opportunity, because "it will change the character of the neighborhood", or, "it will reduce my home value".

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by dredmorbius on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:13PM (#19502425)
Your, or more generally, the present population's children, are among those who will seek to establish new households.

Whilst unlimited population growth is impossible, stagnant communities and regions tend to slide into decline. Those regions most amenable to and rewarding of new activity tend to grow.

California occupied this position, globally, for much of the period from ~1930 - 2000, and particularly from ~1950-1975 or so. It does so far less now, with housing costs being a major factor.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by ModernMech on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:00PM (#19502245)
Maybe not, but would you agree it's important to keep families together? If my children turn 18 and want to move out of the house but stay in the region to be close to family, they might not have many options when rent is $3000 per month and minimum wage is $7.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by Solvitieg on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:01PM (#19502257)
It's not just people moving to the area.

Also consider existing renters who need to move, or people who become renting-age.

I will need to move out of the city if I lose my place. I'm paying $1000 below market value.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @02:02PM (#19503920)
[Apologies - copying a comment I made elsewhere, but it is relevant to the point you made]

Here's a better alternative to rent control. Instead of rent control on a per-unit basis, cities could provide subsidies to long-term low-income residents that reduce their personal expenditure on rent. The subsidies would be paid for through taxes, thus amortizing the subsidy across the local tax base instead of impacting an individual landlord or unit.

But let me note that this must be done only for long-term residents (that is, those who have been there for years). For example, if someone moved to SF within the last 5 years, they should have known what the price of living there is. This is one of the most desirable cities, and it makes sense that it would be expensive and that not everyone would get to live there. Those moving there in recent years therefore, simply made an irresponsible personal choice and must yield to the consequences, rather than being subsidized at others' expense.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by pavon on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:29PM (#19502624)
If you are going to adopt a policy of stagnation in housing availability, you need to adopt a policy of stagnation across the board. You can't have incentives that encourage businesses to locate in your area and at the same time refuse to allow additional housing for the jobs that the business creates. You should prefer to send to universities out of state where they are more likely to find jobs out of state rather than expanding your local higher education options. You should help with relocation expenses for young people who don't get into college, since you don't have enough jobs for them locally. And you should hope that the current industries you have remain relevant, because it is hard to adapt and diversify without allowing growth.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by pmart123 on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:49PM (#19502877)
The circumstance isn't exclusive to just people wanting to move to a new city. Rent control increases moving friction, which could be due to changing life events such as having kids, being an empty nester, or wanting to move to a more convenient neighborhood in the city.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by landryraccoon on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @12:32PM (#19502662)
Do you want your local school to be able to hire teachers, or your local restaurant to be able to get help? Housing costs make everything where you live more expensive. Lowering housing costs makes everything else cheaper for you too.
Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:57PM (#19503827)
> Do you want your local school to be able to hire teachers, or your local restaurant to be able to get help?

Yes, and they would still be available. If wages/living conditions are not good enough for them and they move away, there would be an under-supply of their labor which would cause their wages to rise, which would self-correct the problem.

Right now, those same people are willing to work for less. This is a personal choice they are making. And I don't think it obligates lower residents to provide lower-cost housing or greater housing supply.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by asdff on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:09PM (#19506049)
In CA there is an under supply of both teachers and wages. The market will not correct even if wages/living conditions are 1:1. There are already people living paycheck to paycheck, unable to generate a dime of savings. There are people who are priced out of cost of living despite holding a job, and they opt to be homeless in an RV or car. Here is a great article about this new class of homeless in CA:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/los-angeles-hidden-homeless-pri...

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by Kalium on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:27PM (#19503332)
> Why is it important to accommodate people who might want to move to an area?

They're going to move there anyway. Making it more difficult and expensive won't stop them, as the example of SF shows. Accomodating them, then, is about mitigating the negative effects of immigration on residents and welcoming your new neighbors.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by throwawaysea on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:55PM (#19503791)
> They're going to move there anyway.

I don't think this is going to be true in the longer-term, and clearly SF has an exodus underway (https://www.sfgate.com/expensive-san-francisco/article/Bay-A...). People will (are?) realize that the benefits of SF are not worth the tradeoffs (if their circumstances are such that they can't make it there), and move elsewhere. They might (should?) make their way to many of the inexpensive cities away from the coasts that are more affordable, and the new residents moving into those cities will help make them vibrant cities.

At some point, the incumbent residents of SF or other communities may change their policies if what they desire is different. Or not.

But I don't think there is any lack of housing supply or jobs in the middle of the US. What is lacking is the exact housing people want, at the exact price point people desire, at the exact locations they want to live in, in the line of work they want to be in. Demanding such an exceptional situation is highly unreasonable. Making tradeoffs/compromises is a part of life, and no one is entitled to have the best on every dimension by default - that has to be earned.

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by Kalium on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @01:57PM (#19503818)
> I don't think this is going to be true in the longer-term, and clearly SF has an exodus underway (https://www.sfgate.com/expensive-san-francisco/article/Bay-A...)

You're right! SF has an exodus underway among certain groups. It may be possible that this might be distinct from an overall exodus and resulting shrinking population, however.

Is it possible that your perspective, while completely valid in every possible way, may not be as widely shared as you could hope for?

Re:If You Can’t Afford the Rent, It’s My Problem, Too by kelnos on Wednesday March 27, 2019 @05:16PM (#19506115)
This is the thing that always gets me. It has been hugely painful for hundreds of thousands of people living in the bay area, for 10-15+ years now. Sure, maybe in 20 years people will give up and prices will go down again. Maybe. But what a pyrrhic victory it will be for the long term landowners who got their way only through imposing hardship on others for 30+ years.

But I guess they just don't care. "I got mine; fuck you" seems to be an attitude prevalent around here.