News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by isostatic on Sunday March 03, 2019 @08:56AM (#19294436)
Soyuz takes people to the space station every few months, has done for years.

Why is this specific mission new?

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by ncallaway on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:08AM (#19294752)
The commercial crew missions by both Boeing and SpaceX are new and interesting for a number of reasons:

- This will be one of the first vehicles developed by a private entity to launch people into space, rather than a nation. That represents a huge step "down" the ladder of who has access to space. First, it's only nations. Later, it's large companies and entities. Down the line a little bit medium-sized companies will have access to space and wealthy individuals. Then we'll get down to small companies and fairly well-off individuals. Finally, we'll reach a point where everyone can afford to make trips to or through space. This is a huge first step on the ladder.

- The first stage of this vehicle was a booster that autonomously landed itself on a drone-ship, allowing it to be recovered and refurbished quickly and cheaply. Re-use of this first stage has the potential to drastically lower the cost to get humans (and stuff) into space. SpaceX has already pretty radically altered the launch provider scene by causing all players to lower costs across the board. And they can do that while maintaining very healthy margins if they get re-use right. Eventually, as other competitors (like Blue Origin) enter the market with re-usable launchers the price will fall further toward the new marginal cost, which is drastically lower.

Both of these things have the power to be the first steps into a world where there's a radically expanded access to space for people and companies. All this is happening at the same time that there are a number of other exciting developments in the space industry (NASA planning to start the Lunar Gateway; SpaceX thinking about how to plan to colonize mars; Bigelow planning to launch commercial space stations; Blue Origin about to enter the scene with a very exciting new launch vehicle), it feels (to me, anyway) like we're on the cusp of another big leap forward.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by baxtr on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:26AM (#19294851)
Isn't your first point the natural development of things? As example: Which tank or fighter jet is NOT produced by a private entity today?
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by ncallaway on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:05AM (#19295091)
I think it is the natural development of things!

Just because something is a natural development doesn't mean we don't get to be excited when it happens.

I think airplanes becoming a mode of mass transit were a natural development. It probably seemed like a pretty exciting development as that transition was happening.

Similarly, once you have computers it seems natural to develop a global interconnected network of them. I was pretty excited when that was taking off!

Also, just because the ordering is natural doesn't mean the timing is natural. We've expected these kinds of developments to happen in space for a long time. But we didn't know when they would happen. It was thought that this change might happen in the 70's or 80's. Others thought it might be as far off as 2040 or 2050.

The fact that we're seeing some real tangible evidence of progress _now_ is super exciting.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by isostatic on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:16PM (#19295519)
It's a step, but not a first step - it's the second step along the nations/large/medium/small/people road

Nor have they actually put anyone in space.

The first stage landing is great, but again it's not new -- SpaceX have been doing this for a few years now. Last year's Falcon Heavy, especially the two rockets landing simultaneously on live tv, felt very futuristic. This isn't anywhere near as impressive as that from a "wow" perspective . The MaxQ abort test probably will be, especially if live-streamed.

Scientifically, in the last 10 years we've landed on comets, brought bits of asteroids back to earth, driven a rover on an asteroid, landed on the far side of the moon, explored rocks billions of miles away.

Any 'new commercial space age' started at least 7 years ago when spacex started being paid for these types of launches - a commercially developed rocket being used for commercial purposes, but companies have had access to space for decades - everytime I point a BGAN at the sky to get communications in the desert I'm using a private company's infrastructure.

If you're just talking about a new crewed space exploration age, SpaceX has immense promise, but that's all it is - promise. Once it is delivering people to orbit, which a 50 year old technology currently does, and hopefully progresses further, then that's great. But this is just another minor step on the road.

If America was still launching people to the ISS on Apollo, and a Chinese company did a test flight to the ISS using SpaceX technology, I very much doubt there would be as much excitement as there is for this launch.

If dearMoon puts private people round the moon, the first people to leave LEO for 50 years, I'll be ecstatic. But I'm also cautious -- SpaceX announced a crewed lunar flyby for launch in 2018.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by ncallaway on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:34PM (#19295962)
> It's a step, but not a first step - it's the second step along the nations/large/medium/small/people road

Cool! I agree, but did anyone claim it was the first step?

Magellan or Captain Cook weren't the first steps of their day, either. Nor were the Apollo missions first steps. The Mercury missions had come first!

Why can't we be exciting, and have that feeling of exploration for each step? Why should only the first step be exciting? I reject the notion and would argue that every step in pushing our boundaries further out is exciting.

> The first stage landing is great, but again it's not new -- SpaceX have been doing this for a few years now

I feel like you and I have different time-horizons for what counts as "the dawn of a new space age". When areoform said we were at that dawn I didn't take it to mean on this day we are at that dawn.

The dawn of a new age takes a while. This decade is the dawn of a new space age, not necessarily this specific day. At least, that's how I interpreted the comments.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by isostatic on Sunday March 03, 2019 @04:03PM (#19296845)
> Cool! I agree, but did anyone claim it was the first step?

Yes, the person I responded to said

"This is a huge first step on the ladder."

This is a tiny step. Come summer when there's actual people on board then yes, it's a significant step towards forward movement, having being going pretty much nowhere since the 70s.

I think the biggest step recently, beyond landings or space flight or even a lunar return mission, is the live streaming of launches on youtube. SpaceX feels more futuristic and accessible because they drive that engagement, something not seen since the days of Challenger in 86.

I disagree about the dawn. The dawn of the space age was October 4th 1957.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by ncallaway on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:54PM (#19297456)
> Yes, the person I responded to said

> "This is a huge first step on the ladder."

Ha! Fair enough! The person you responded to was me, and I did write that.

I guess "first step" was not actually an important part of my claim, so I didn't think about it as I was writing it.

I'd agree that I should have written "this is a huge next step on the ladder", and not claimed it as the first step.

> This is a tiny step. Come summer when there's actual people on board then yes, it's a significant step towards forward movement, having being going pretty much nowhere since the 70s.

Eh, I think of the launch today, the in-flight abort, and DM-2 as all part of the same step. Fair enough if you don't consider it "done" until DM-2. I probably won't consider the step "done" for a couple of years (when commercial crew is as routinized as commercial cargo and booster re-use), but I would definitely consider today a major milestone.

It's the first operational flight of the hardware!

> The dawn of the space age was October 4th 1957.

Sure, that's true. I mean, it's pretty semantic at this point, but areoform had originally written: "We're at the dawn of a new space age."

I was using that as my reference for being at dawn. I think it's pretty reasonable to say we're right at the cusp of an exciting decade of development in space, in a way that we haven't been for half a century.

I'm not going to stop being excited about that!

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by avmich on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:07PM (#19295796)
That's in a large part subjective. For some until we have truly groundbreaking physics with applications which allow doing something considered strictly impossible with previous science, it's not worthy of consideration. For others, just watching slowly unrolling results of decades of development - in electronics (hardware on board of Falcons), computers (organization of that hardware into bigger complex structures, software), organization of enterprises (venture capitalism able to support risky ventures, accumulation of wealth to individuals, ability to optimize for non-immediate or non-financial goals, cooperation with government), methods of material tuning (heat shield, tank bodies, engine) is demonstration enough of the progress being made.

We can easily, within few years forget how hard is a particular achievement. Remember how fast Apollo flights started to be considered boring. Or we may turn to those who work on complex problems as we speak, imagine how hard would it be for ourselves doing that and appreciate and honor actual work which leads to these demonstrations. The choice is definitely ours to make.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by Klathmon on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:28AM (#19294566)
It costs about $81 million USD per seat round-trip to go to ISS on Soyuz. SpaceX is doing the same for around $58 million per person (last I read). That alone is a HUGE deal. And that cost is expected to drop as SpaceX gets more comfortable with launching humans, whereas Soyuz has been raising prices.

Not to mention that it's increasing the number of countries and rocket designs that can send people to and from the ISS. Without alternate launch providers, if some flaw were to be found in Soyuz or political issues begin to get in the way of launches, then the US could find itself unable to get astronauts to and from the ISS safely.

Boeing is also in this race, and will be sending up humans to space in their Starliner soon as well, it's still up in the air which will get to the with humans on board ISS first.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by rayiner on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:47AM (#19294657)
A cost reduction of less than 50% for something that the Russians have been doing routinely with 1960s technology is akin to Magellan setting sail? I like SpaceX but man the spin is blinding.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by oldgradstudent on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:05AM (#19294743)
The cost reduction is relative to the price Russia charges, not compared to their costs.

Supposedly[1], it was $23 million in 2007. but Russia raised the prices since then. The cost of the Soyuz to the Russians could well be lower than SpaceX still.

https://web.archive.org/web/20090604111935/http://www.kommer...

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by Klathmon on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:58AM (#19294714)
I'm not saying it is, i'm just explaining what is new about this mission and why I'm excited for it.

I think people are making it larger than it is because doing something and commercializing something are completely different things.

The first flight in a plane was awesome, but not if we just stopped there. Currently SpaceX is somewhere along the line between the Wright Brothers and the Boeing 707. It may be "only price reductions", but once those price reductions hit a critical mass, it enables a whole world of possibilities. SpaceX is already talking about using their next rocket in a similar way to airlines now. Launching a bunch of people from one place into orbit, then landing in another place on the same planet for extremely fast flights across the world. They are talking about creating Moon and Mars bases. Those are things that won't ever happen if we keep spending hundreds of millions of dollars per launch, because the economics of it just won't ever work out.

They still aren't done, and it's no guarantee that they will be able to ever get prices down low enough, but at least they are trying, and making good headway toward it.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by mcv on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @09:11AM (#19310574)
Magellan was not remotely the first to set sail, nor was he the first to apply that technology.

Of course what SpaceX does is not the same thing as Magellan's trip around the Earth, but it's absolutely an important milestone. It reduces costs on something very expensive, it reuses rockets in a way that wasn't possible before (this is the part that makes it arguably more innovative than Magellan), and it finally gives the US its own capability to go to space again. It was a bit embarrassing how dependent the US had become on Russia since the Space Shuttle's retirement.

But the Soyuz was absolutely also a fantastic feat. It may be small, but it's been the world's primary workhorse for manned space travel to LEO. It's far more reliable than the Space Shuttle (2 lost crews vs none for the Soyus on far more flights, I believe). And the US has nothing remotely comparable. Until now.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by avmich on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:11PM (#19295829)
Hopefully Crew Dragon will not only provide alternative to Soyuz, but also allow bigger crews and payloads both to and from space, nicer atmospheric returns in terms of accelerations and ability to fly on a shorter notice - it takes 2 years to make a Soyuz today.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by Ankaios on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:40PM (#19295994)
The price per seat of $58 M was actually the average over SpaceX and Boeing seats (https://spacenews.com/nasa-boeing-spacex-share-more-details-...), not the price for a seat on Dragon. As far as I am aware, the prices that NASA is paying for seats from each provider are not public.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by iguy on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:59AM (#19294716)
Google thinks a shuttle launch cost at least $450 million, for comparison.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by rplnt on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:31PM (#19296645)
It's really not something you can compare. Space Shuttle was not a can for humans to reach LEO. It was a much more capable spacecraft with a significantly bigger (both in volume and weight) payload.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by isostatic on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:47PM (#19297989)
With an appropriate payload there were proposals for upto 80 people in the shuttle. At $450m to launch that would be $6m a seat.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by iguy on Monday March 04, 2019 @05:54AM (#19300293)
Indeed, clearly not a head-to-head comparison, I just wanted to find some figure for the shuttle's cost. It's not clear to me what the 450 includes.

I had not heard of this 80-person shuttle-bus, that sounds pretty crazy!

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by bluGill on Monday March 04, 2019 @10:00AM (#19301740)
It was in the plans back in the late 1970s/early 1980s. You can see it popular science of the past, along with a lot of other parts to the total shuttle system, very little of which was ever built. The basic idea is you can put lots of things in the cargo bay, parts to a space station (not the ISS, though the shuttle was used to build the ISS), a rocket to get from low earth orbit to something else, a bus for lots of people.

I wonder how much was a serious proposal, and how much was an artist allowed to daydream.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by jacobreg on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:50AM (#19295360)
I thought the going rate for falcon 9 reusable launches was $60 million a flight. With 7 astronauts shouldn't that work out to $8.5 million per astronaut? That's not accounting for the cost of the crew dragon, but I'd be surprised if that increases the cost by an order of magnitude
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by Klathmon on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:02PM (#19295432)
Well they had to do quite a lot to be able to get to the point where NASA approves of them launching humans, and those costs have to be gained back. Just look at this mission and the upcoming abort test and the years of work that has gone into getting that approval, it's not cheap!
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by jacobreg on Monday March 04, 2019 @12:58PM (#19303468)
Makes sense. Didn't NASA give them finding to develop the crew dragon though? Is that factored into the launch cost figures we see?
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by grey-area on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:21AM (#19294534)
Reusable rockets is new.

Rather than ditching in the sea, the rocket landed back on earth and could in theory take up another payload a few days later, which is much cheaper and more efficient. It opens up space to a lot of other uses.

Compared to the cost and use of the shuttle (nominally reusable but not so much in practice), or other disposable rockets, this is a large step forward in reliability and efficiency, which will enable things like travel to Mars at low cost (by refuelling in orbit with multiple reusable vehicle launches for one mission).

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by shirro on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:44PM (#19297977)
Soyuz is a remarkable vehicle and the people who make and fly it should be very proud. The DM-1 mission is significant for several reasons. A return of manned space launch capability for the USA which will bring a lot of national pride. The commercialisation aspect with SpaceX and Boeing not just building a NASA vehicle like SLS/Orion but providing a launch service which could help open up space exploration to more sustainable development. And the story of SpaceX themselves from improbable tech founder vision 17 years ago to industry disruption and market leadership today. This is clearly a very important milestone for them as they ultimately want to send people to the Moon and Mars.
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by InclinedPlane on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:08AM (#19295103)
Well, for one, the Soyuz can only carry a crew of 3, whereas Crew Dragon can potentially carry up to 7, and is designed specifically (for NASA's purposes) for carrying 4. This alone adds significant flexibility to the crew levels of the station. Since the end of the Shuttle era the ISS has been stuck at only 6 crew, precisely the number that can come up and return on 2 soyuz capsules. With the addition of Crew Dragon in the mix it'll be possible to support 7 crew members on the station with just 1 Dragon and 1 Soyuz capsule. The ISS requires a lot of maintenance and routine tasks, even adding one crew member would significantly increase the amount of science they're able to do on the station.

Also, increasing the diversity of crew transfer vehicles is very helpful. Right now there are 4 different varieties of cargo vehicles that visit the station (Progress, HTV, Cargo Dragon, and Cygnus). This diversity means that delays or periods of downtime with any one of the cargo delivery systems can be made up for via the others, as has happened in the past. The same resiliency has not existed for some time in regards to crew transfer vehicles. Given that there was a failure during an attempt to launch a Soyuz capsule last year which put a serious strain on the station (potentially putting it in jeopardy of being left uncrewed for some time) you can see that this is a serious issue.

Additionally, Crew Dragon is the first new crewed spacecraft to visit the station that was designed within the last decade, or, indeed that was designed this century. Soyuz is reliable but it has a great many constraints and shortcomings, many of which can't be alleviated without moving to a new design. It's refreshing to see that we as a species still have the capability to build new crewed vehicles with new capabilities and new designs rather than simply shuffling about as custodians of legacy vehicles designed and built by previous generations.

Even more excitingly, the Crew Dragon was launched by a vehicle which landed the first stage, and will have its first stage be reused on a future flight. The Soyuz rocket/capsule is a remarkably inexpensive way for crew to get to orbit, but those low costs are due mainly to sticking with an old design (all the R&D has long been amortized) and reliance on inexpensive Russian labor. Falcon 9 is already cost competitive with the Soyuz and has the potential to be even cheaper as Falcon 9 first stage reuse becomes more common. As reusable rockets become more common and familiar, and as their design improves with increasing use and follow-on generations (Blue Origin's New Glenn, SpaceX's BFR/Starship, etc.) costs will continue to fall and access to space will open up. Which will bring about a new space age where many more people visit orbit per year, space stations become much larger and more advanced, and our capabilities in spaceflight are in general much greater than they are today.

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by gdpgreg on Sunday March 03, 2019 @09:27AM (#19294562)
It's the first new crew vehicle launch from the US since the end of the space shuttle program in 2011. It's also in theory a lot cheaper than the Soyuz.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by jjuhl on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:50AM (#19294992)
Why are "figures to worship" (religious or not - preferably not) needed at all?
Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by warp_factor on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:58PM (#19296107)
Because spaceX Marketing and PR departments want you to feel this is new. There is also some American pride to be able to send people to space again without the need of the Russians.

All of this creates this overblown achievement feeling. This has been done 40 years ago!

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by adventured on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:03PM (#19296487)
> This has been done 40 years ago!

What private company was sending people into space on reusable rockets 40 years ago?

Re:SpaceX Crew Dragon Docks with International Space Station by grkvlt on Monday March 04, 2019 @08:14PM (#19307294)
Rockwell, I guess, at a stretch? Over 30 years ago they built the Space Shuttle...