News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by swombat on Thursday November 18, 2010 @10:58AM (#1918150)
Is this the kind of problem that a politician like ron paul can fix though? Thanks in great part to Reddit, Ron Paul is largely associated with crackpot ultra-libertarian Ayn Rand type movements, so anyone in the know would probably dismiss anything he does out of hand as "just a stunt move". Certainly, that's my first impression for his introduction of a bill with no political support and, as far as I understand the US legal system, zero chance of actually getting anywhere.

Now, if someone with some political credibility introduced a bill with support from other members of the House and Senate, that'd be worth pointing out. But as it is, this is no more "serious" than a good sketch on the Daily Show, is it?

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by astine on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:18AM (#1918230)
Paul's reputation for submitting legislation that gets ignored by congress is much older than Reddit. For better or worse, Ron Paul has always represented an agenda that is unpopular in congress and he has always voted with that agenda in mind. He is not prone to compromise.

He's actually gotten into a much stronger position of late than he has been in past.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by tzs on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:02PM (#1918410)
> Thanks in great part to Reddit, Ron Paul is largely associated with crackpot ultra-libertarian Ayn Rand type movements, so anyone in the know would probably dismiss anything he does out of hand as "just a stunt move".

You greatly overestimate the power of Reddit. You also misread Reddit--he's most associated with just plain crackpots there than with ultra-libertarians. Ultra-libertarians are for reduced government everywhere--Ron Paul doesn't seem to mind government, as long as it is not Federal government.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by ryandvm on Thursday November 18, 2010 @01:18PM (#1918706)
> Ron Paul doesn't seem to mind government, as long as it is not Federal government.

Indeed. And with a number of U.S. states having economies larger than most countries, this is not such a illogical ideal.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by grandalf on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:14AM (#1918208)
I think that in spite of Ron Paul having been marginalized, he still has a lot of credibility among people who irrationally didn't vote for him b/c they prefer to vote for a candidate who they believe has a chance of winning.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by maxharris on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:50AM (#1918358)
> ultra-libertarian Ayn Rand type

It is a mistake to conflate Ayn Rand with libertarians: http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/libertarians.html

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by alanh on Thursday November 18, 2010 @03:56PM (#1919209)
The strongest libertarians I’ve met in my own personal live seem to be fans of objectivism.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by DanielBMarkham on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:09AM (#1918186)
I don't know. I'm hugely aware of how Ron Paul got stereotyped in the last election, and I think he's not the guy to fix it.

But we're not at the point of fixing it yet, I don't think (unless TSA comes to their senses. One can always hope). More likely is that you will see politicians who are considered outside the mainstream begin to pound the podium over this. In time, I expect it to become more mainstream. A month maybe? A year? As hot as folks are, it might happen very quickly.

The big problem here is that the answer requires putting people in charge at the local airport who are allowed to make mistakes. I hate what's happened to airport security, but I'd happily do the naked body scan and group grope -- as long as it was done on an ad-hoc basis. Maybe once out of every thousand flights or something. There's a bit of a quagmire about the way politics works, especially involving areas of risk and fear, which I won't go into here. Let's just say that yes, Ron Paul is not the guy, but things could change, and change quickly. But the overall problem of how to solve airport security is just going to stick around. Even if the grownups show up and set TSA straight, the only thing they're going to learn is how to use fear to sell even more equipment that intrudes on every passenger. Just in a different way.

They need to find the terrorist, not the weapon. The plane can be full of weapons, and as long as nobody wishes any harm to be done, it's as safe as a plane without weapons at all. Such a simple concept, yet I think it's going to be a bridge too far for policy-makers. (of course a plane can't be full of nervous people carrying nitro-glycerin and hand grenades, but you get my point)

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by pyre on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:22AM (#1918252)
You're not necessarily looking for the terrorist, though. You might also be looking for the guy who might have too much to drink, get into an argument with his seat neighbor, then reach into his bag for his glock. Or the guy that's just mentally unstable.

Granted, these are one-off cases, but I can't think of a good reason for people to have guns, or (large) hunting knives in their carry-on luggage. And truthfully, if people want to pack guns in their checked luggage, from a safety perspective, it's probably better to have them declare it and put it into some sort of 'safe' container. Lord knows there will be people with ammunition that is waiting to misfire inside the luggage storage compartment of the plane.

(Not that I'm defending the TSA's actions for the past 9 years or anything...)

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by Qz on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:26PM (#1918517)
You might also be looking for the guy who might have too much to drink, get into an argument with his seat neighbor, then reach into his bag for his glock.

Has this ever happened?

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by pyre on Thursday November 18, 2010 @08:12PM (#1920012)
There are plenty of people that get drunk and have done things like assault airline personnel. It's not a leap to think that one of them might reach for a weapon at some point.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by Blunt on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:32PM (#1918541)
"Maybe once out of every thousand flights or something."

So what gives you or anyone else the right to play God? Have you missed the point about these scanners being a health concern as much as flying is?

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by jdp23 on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:30AM (#1918284)
fixing the problem will take bi-partisan agreement -- which (at least in my opinion) will only happen if the grassroots outrage continues to mount. in that context, a powerful speech on the floor of Congress adds flames to the fire not matter who makes it.

and don't underestimate Ron Paul's influence. the Tea Party movement (which has a lot of overlap with libertarians on a lot of issues) and a general "small government" attitude were big winners in November. and with the Republicans recapturing control of the House, Paul's seniority leaves him well-positioned.

for more about the general political situation for privacy-related issued in the upcoming congress, here's my notes from a Privacy Coalition call early this month: http://getfisaright.wordpress.com/2010/11/15/looking-forward...

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by pdx on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:06AM (#1918176)
To be clear, I think for many of us, this is not about "being naked in public". It's not that "those silly Americans with their unreasonable body taboos" What this is, is just another straw, although a fairly large one, that's being piled on the back of an increasingly cranky camel since 9-11. This straw could have been any other increase in the erosion of rights of US citizens.

I'm confused why you seem to be so hostile to a member of congress from another country speaking up about an issue. We have no elections for two years so I'm uncertain why his motives are suspect to you.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by swombat on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:16AM (#1918218)
My understanding of your legal system is that before a bill introduced in the House becomes law, it needs to:

- be amended and approved by the appropriate Representatives committee

- be passed by the House of Representatives

- be amended and approved by the appropriate Senate committee

- pass the "filibuster" gate

- be passed by the Senate

- have any amendments reconciled

- be signed into law by the president

See http://www.usconstitution.net/consttop_law.html for more details. Each of those steps are difficult and require a lot of politicking about, building consensus, getting public support from other politicians across both houses, and so on. Successful bills are usually announced with political support from leading figures right away, particularly when they touch on a controversial topic.

So, proposing a bill with no meaningful consensus-building or public support is effectively just a PR gesture. It is utterly and completely fucking pointless when you're known as a politician associated with crackpots. Except, of course, for the purpose of getting the aforementioned crackpots worked up that "something is happening". Hence my point:

Is Ron Paul just capitalising on yet another libertarian crackpot movement and actually hurting the very legitimate cause of telling the TSA to keep their grubby paws and scanners away from travellers' bodies?

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by jrockway on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:32AM (#1918292)
Is Ron Paul just capitalizing on yet another libertarian crackpot movement and actually hurting the very legitimate cause of telling the TSA to keep their grubby paws and scanners away from travelers' bodies?

Preventing the government from groping travelers is exactly what libertarianism is. In this case, most people seem to be behind his "libertarian crackpot movement", if only for the TSA.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by nerfhammer on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:25PM (#1918515)
Most people are in favor of the scanners.

source: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2010/11/15/politics/main70579...

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by jrockway on Thursday November 18, 2010 @01:31PM (#1918748)
Most people don't fly regularly. The people that are answering that survey are not really qualified to talk about the issue, as they don't know what the machines entail, what data they expose, and what the alternatives are.

Do this survey in a line of people queuing to go through one and watch the results change. Do the survey after some ex-con pats down their 6-year-old daughter and watch the results change even more.

News surveys are worthless for debating public policy. You could do a poll of whether the Earth is flat or round, but the fact that some people said it was flat doesn't make it so.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by nerfhammer on Thursday November 18, 2010 @03:31PM (#1919124)
The majority is so large I don't think it can be easily explained or wished away. Honestly I think you're cognitive-dissonancing here.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by mquander on Thursday November 18, 2010 @02:29PM (#1918953)
The people that are answering that survey are likely as not people who vote, which is all that counts when it comes to "debating" public policy. There is no procedural rule in Congress that says "And finally, qualified experts shall vote on each bill, after appropriate discussion."
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by sudonim on Thursday November 18, 2010 @01:38PM (#1918773)
The way the questions is asked makes the new procedures seem pretty similar to the x-rays people are used to.

If CBS wanted to poll effectively, they could show an image of the x-ray, or even better, show people an image of their own x-ray, and then ask them if they would be ok with that.

Then if they say no, they would show them a video of the pat down (their other choice) being performed on the gender. And ask them if they would be cool with that.

If they said no to that, then ask them if they are cool with paying a 10,000 fine as the third option.

See how people survey given more complete facts.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by detst on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:32AM (#1918290)
> Is Ron Paul just capitalising on yet another libertarian crackpot movement and actually hurting the very legitimate cause of telling the TSA to keep their grubby paws and scanners away from travellers' bodies?

I would say it's people that call him a crackpot instead of looking at the merits of the argument that are hurting this legitimate cause. Watch the video. He's right; we expect the government to protect us and have become submissive to them. Not enough people care and it's sad.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by pyre on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:27AM (#1918276)

  > Is Ron Paul just capitalising on yet another libertarian crackpot
  > movement and actually hurting the very legitimate cause of telling
  > the TSA to keep their grubby paws and scanners away from travellers'
  > bodies?
He's probably not hurting it. People aren't going to all of the sudden enjoy being groped because Ron Paul said that groping was bad.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by ellyagg on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:23AM (#1918260)
While I mostly agree with you, I could really do without the repeated "libertarian crackpot" sideswipes.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by swombat on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:29AM (#1918278)
If you've ever spent any time on reddit/r/politics, it's pretty hard to call them anything else... but, fair enough, less sideswipes in the future.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by fogus on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:45AM (#1918341)
You'll live a very "interesting" life if you choose to filter your world view through the comments sections of Reddit.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by ynniv on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:47AM (#1918343)
Calling anyone a crackpot says more about you than them. Please keep it on reddit.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by yummyfajitas on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:50AM (#1918352)
Interesting - I guess this means reddit/politics is no longer full of "BUSHitler will bomb Iran by $NEXT_HOLIDAY", "Chimpeach the Chimperor" and "PROOF: new crazy youtube video shows FIRE doesn't melt STEEL and 9/11 was inside job"?
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by bmelton on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:34PM (#1918547)
As a Libertarian, I think I should at least attempt to exempt myself from what I consider 'Reddit Libertarians', which are really more 'Ultra-Libertarians' or 'Anarcho-Libertarians' than Libertarians proper.

Ron Paul is a good example of a Libertarian, though he often parties Republican, in that he wants to liberate power from the Federal government and relinquish it back to states, generally speaking.

From what I've seen, many Redditarians just want the government to give up all their power, and just not have it anymore, uhhhh, for great justice.

Edit: I really wanted to use the word "Redditarian" after I thought of it.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by pdx on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:34AM (#1918301)
Thank you for your interest in US government. I'm delighted to see a foreign citizen take so much interest.

I think you would agree that the likelihood of a filibuster on this issue is zero. I would suggest that the likelihood of a presidential veto on such a bill would also approach zero. As for the whole amendment crap, that is our public shame, that no bill can just be about what it was written about, but instead, must be saddled with miscellaneous additions on any number of unrelated matters. If I could change that aspect of our government, I would do so.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by protomyth on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:44AM (#1918335)
You left out the much more obstructive part of the system, committees.

I find it kinda funny how people have problem with the current use of the filibuster when it was used by the other party in the past. It is a tradition to protect the minority. Committee rules are much more damaging and used much more often then the filibuster has ever been used.

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by Psyonic on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:57AM (#1918390)
The filibuster is never actually used anymore, just threatened. That's good enough to get what you want. No one these days has the patience or balls to actually make someone go through with it.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by michael_dorfman on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:11AM (#1918194)
Dr. Paul is a respected member of that body.

Well, there's respected and respected.

How many co-sponsors does he have on that bill? I have to agree with the assessment that it has "zero chance of actually getting anywhere."

Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by knieveltech on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:24AM (#1918263)
So get out and PUSH. I've already contacted my representatives this morning.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by soldarnal on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:24AM (#1918264)
I was under the impression that last June (2009) the House voted 310-118 to add an amendment (the Chaffetz amendment) to a bill to ban the scanners as a primary means of screening, but that the Senate never voted on the bill. It seems to me that such a bill would have popular support - supposedly it was backed by both the ACLU and the NRA - but maybe I am understanding the politics wrong.
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by camiller on Thursday November 18, 2010 @11:44AM (#1918332)
The amendment may have enjoyed popular support, but did the bill? What bill was it attached to?
Re:Ron Paul: Airport Scanners: Enough is Enough by soldarnal on Thursday November 18, 2010 @12:01PM (#1918407)
The bill is HR 2200. It passed the House on 6/4/09 by a vote of 397-25. http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d111:HR02200:@@@R