News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bredren on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:16PM (#19137850)
>"I recall the phrase, 'It's a six-hour, daylong celebration of football, and you're not the right person to celebrate football,'" Costas says.

The odd thing was if you watched the Superbowl the culture of the event had obviously changed. You rarely saw cheerleaders, unless in the background of a play. None of the commercials offered up exploitation of women at least nothing on the scale of GoDaddy and Paris Hilton had in the past.

Budweiser's main hook throughout was that they did not use high fructose corn syrup in their ingredients! That's a long way from the bro-y bikini image beer companies have made the Superbowl to be about for so long.

So when I read that this was a celebration of the culture of Football, what is that now? Is it this more progressive, more healthy sport EXCEPT when it comes to brain trauma?

I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football at this point and has true global appeal. Football and the Superbowl seem like so many boomer institutions where this old guard is doing everything to slow down the bleeding for as long as possible.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by simmanian on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:35PM (#19138045)
>I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football

I cannot disagree more. NFL is the biggest sports league in the entire world by revenue by far, even though it's only played within the United States! More and more people are playing video games, but eSports is still a very niche market. You certainly don't see people talking about a DOTA championship match as much as people talking about the Superbowl game on social media. eSports still has a long way to go in terms of general acceptance and social influence.

edit: changed "sports" to "sports league" after seeing some feedback

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bilbo0s on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:42PM (#19138106)
Well, the original commenter overstated the importance of eSports, but you're overstating the appeal of American Football.

The global sports are probably soccer, and basketball, in that order. And even those are only because they are the cheapest to play. Just need a ball and a goal. I think this appeal is reflected in global revenue, and certainly in participation, outside of US. I'm pretty sure it's soccer by far.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by masonic on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @06:05AM (#19142559)

  you're overstating the appeal of American Football
He didn't refer to "appeal" on an aesthetic level. He wrote of revenue.

NFL in-person attendance is spiraling downward. Don't look at published attendance figures based on "tickets issued"; look at video of actual butts in the stands.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by simmanian on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:44PM (#19138129)
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-nfl-made-13-billion-la...

This article says otherwise, but who knows, maybe it's wrong.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by wfleming on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:07PM (#19138365)
That article states that globally Soccer makes more money than the NFL. Just adding up the 5 Soccer leagues listed in the top 10 there, they total more than the NFL. And there are a bunch of soccer leagues globally that aren't in the top 10. So while the NFL does have a commanding lead as the largest sports league globally, American Football is indeed behind Soccer globally as a sport.

Another way of thinking about why that is is that the NFL is effectively a monopoly. They are the only game in town for a sport which is only popular in one country (the USA). Soccer is, globally, a much more popular sport than American Football, but it's not controlled by a single league (FIFA is a governing body (a terribly corrupt one, but that's a separate conversation), not a league).

If you look at it per-capita, the NFL also seems a bit less impressive, and their revenue might be more a result of the fact that the USA is both rich and fairly large than any strong indicator of global popularity. Taking population estimates from Wikipedia, the NFL made roughly $39.76/person in the USA, and the Premier League made roughly $80.30/person in the UK. (And that methodology is arguably a bit generous to the the NFL, since the Premier League is technically only in England, but I'm including the rest of the UK since they also do watch a lot of Soccer AFAIK.)

To me the enormous revenues of the NFL is a stronger indicator of why monopolies are harmful than of any special virtues of the NFL or American Football.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by shoulderfake on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:50PM (#19138703)
Also, nobody outside of USA actually likes American football as a sport. There is no global appeal to the sport.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jacobr1 on Monday February 11, 2019 @06:21PM (#19139517)
Let us not forget Canada!
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by masonic on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @06:08AM (#19142569)
"I don't even know what street Canada is on."

-- Al Capone

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by babesh on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:39PM (#19139155)
Mostly true but you should then take college football revenue in the US into account.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by wfleming on Monday February 11, 2019 @10:20PM (#19140714)
Interesting point but I'm not sure I agree. There are other professional soccer leagues in the UK aside from the Premier League as well. It's not entirely apples-to-apples because the wider market structures are different between the US & UK, but I do think comparing the dominant player in each market is useful & instructive.

I think your point is totally fair though in that my description of NFL as a monopoly isn't as comprehensive as I expected. From what I can find, CFL revenues are about $213M , and US college football is $3.4 billion. CFL is pretty close to being a rounding error compared to the NFL, but college football is a definitely a significant presence. I think I'd say a market where one entrant commands almost 80% of the revenue is pretty close to being a functional monopoly, but not entirely, so I should have accounted for that.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by NFLisFixed on Monday February 11, 2019 @07:25PM (#19139887)
And the CFL as well.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by saberience on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:02PM (#19138312)
There's a massive difference between revenue and viewership. Also, these figures are a bit weird since they are just based on the "NFL" company, which is pretty much the ONLY provider of American Football in the world, this says a lot in itself. There is obviously much more money spent on Cricket and Soccer than on American Football totally.

Check out this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-watched_televisio...

NFL doesn't come anywhere near the amount of viewers for soccer or even cricket OR badminton.

BILLIONS of people watch the World Cup and Olympics, the super bowl attracts about 115M. The soccer world cup had 3.5 BILLION.

Do you really think more people spend money on the NFL than the total world spend on soccer?

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by masonic on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @06:14AM (#19142593)

  BILLIONS of people watch the World Cup and Olympics, the super bowl attracts about 115M
The Super Bowl is one event. World Cup is dozens of events. The Olympics are hundreds of events.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bilbo0s on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:54PM (#19138231)
I don't know man?

I think this is just saying which league has the most revenue. I'd find it very difficult to believe that the number of people who played American Football professionally and recreationally was anywhere even close to the number of people who played soccer on this planet last year. I'd be pretty confident betting that the number of people who play basketball on this planet dwarfs the number of people who play American Football. (And the number of people with an interest in soccer or basketball on this planet definitely dwarfs the number of people interested in American Football.)

Maybe American Football can make a lot of money because it is in a rich market? Not really sure. But you can't really argue soccer and basketball as the global sports. It's not even close.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:20PM (#19138465)
Add up all the “Association football” from here and it’s huge. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_professional_sports_....

Soccer is a much larger sport by revenue globally. It’s simply split into different nations + an international competition. The US is a single market so if you split things by country it tends to win.

PS: The World Cup is based on the best national teams vs using each individual team. Much like the US men’s basketball team at the Olympics vs NBA.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by simmanian on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:56PM (#19138252)
Yeah, I was talking about specific leagues, not sports entirely. My original post was misleading.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by detaro on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:47PM (#19138155)
Tbh, when you said "biggest sports" I didn't think you were looking for "league with most revenue", might explain some of the reactions.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jimmy1 on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:51PM (#19138200)
Yeah I am not sure about the NFL being the biggest in the world, but I got a bit of a laugh out of eSports being more relevant. People forget eSports is decades old now at this point, and the pinnacle of the eSports world is Korea where it has just now caught up to even challenge traditional sports such as Soccer. In America, there is still a way's to go.

"Activate (www.activate.com) projects that in the United States eSports will have more viewers than every professional sports league but the NFL by 2021" and will need to more than double viewership to topple the NFL.

And if you consider "traditional sports" holistically like they are treating "eSports" it is more fair to consider NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, MLS viewership together, of which have large non-overlapping segments, then the gap becomes more of a chasm.

Riot released viewership total for the Worlds finals a couple months ago, and viewership in NA was significantly down than the previous year. In fact in almost every eSport viewership figure, if you discount Chinese and Korean viewership, the rest is almost insignificant -- an MLB playoff game attracts more viewers. I will say we are in the twilight years of the NFL, but what is more likely is that another physical sport topples the NFL throne rather than an eSport.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by hinkley on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:50PM (#19138711)
Unannotated numbers and trends don't tell you much when you're talking about this sort of demographic. I'd have to see a cumulative flow diagram showing breakdown by age range over time to have a shot at having an intelligent conversation about this.

Products that are associated with a certain age group by dint of biology (eg, bifocals) will constantly see an influx of new customers, so you just have to project population distributions.

I don't think people 'find football' when they get older. It was a thing when they were a kid, maybe they have watched the whole time, or maybe in a fit of nostalgia they're back. If the latter is a phenomenon, then high school and college football are your gateway to keeping the numbers up (and haven't they, or at least colleges, imposed tougher concussion guidelines?), otherwise the fanbase may be shrinking even though the graph says things are looking up.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jimmy1 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:03AM (#19144605)
> I'd have to see a cumulative flow diagram showing breakdown by age range over time to have a shot at having an intelligent conversation about this

You have a very high standard for having intelligent conversations, then. Sometimes the data you ask is not easily obtainable, behind paywalls, or just not presented uniformly. How about some good old fashioned "good faith"? Let's assume that both parties in this argument are indifferent to being right, but trying to sort out to find the truth of the matter, and they aren't pulling numbers out of their ass, how does that sound?

> I don't think people 'find football' when they get older.

I admit this is probably not the best metric, but a frequent viewer of /r/nfl and the various team based subreddits at least hints that the opposite is true: many people are finding football later in life.

Another thing left out of this conversation all together is the NFL's focus on expanding internationally -- particularly the UK and Mexico. Viewership in London especially continues to rise Y.O.Y, and the NFL has been floating the serious idea of a London based team for a few years now, and I fully expect that to happen within the next couple of years.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by elif on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:14PM (#19138425)
What's better: 15 million viewers 17 days a year or 300k viewers 365 days a year?

1 viewer who gets the channel anyway and has social pressure to watch, or 1 viewer who goes out of his way to pay to watch something on his own?

I think there is far more nuance to trendiness than the story told by a Nielson Rating System calculated decades ago.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jimmy1 on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:16PM (#19138439)
What eSport gets 300k viewers 365 days a year?
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by hinkley on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:54PM (#19138745)
Maybe apples and oranges. Only 2 football teams get 15 million viewers one Sunday a year and it's a good bet it won't be the same two next year. As a national advertiser that's a big deal but if you've been supporting that team all year it's not as big of a benefit to you, and if you've been supporting a team that didn't go then it's less than useless.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by nopriorarrests on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:40PM (#19139166)
For football, you have English Premier League games, La Liga games, Italian Premier League games, etc, etc...

And at least EPL is watched all across the Europe, from Spain to Russia. For multinational advertisers, football is a boon, esports is not in a same league (pun intended).

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by wolco on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:18PM (#19138938)
Does a youtube channel count? Eyeballs mean very little if youtube payrates are to be believed.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bredren on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:52PM (#19139282)
I think video games have a bigger tent and offer opportunity for notoriety and even celebrity to way more young people than American football. American football is one of the most exclusionary school sports that exists.

I don't have data on this, but it feels to me that young people, particularly boys, are more interested in playing minecraft or fortnite and watching streamer videos of either game than high school, college or professional football.

And it makes sense because it doesn't matter how big you are or whether you can hang in a locker room or what you look like or what gender you are--what matters is you can play a game well or with style.

There are also more opportunities around eSports for young people in that they bundle in cosplay, artwork and even creating training videos and blogs are wide open opportunities to participate at little to no cost and regardless of physical capability.

Revenue is not a forward indicator of relevance. If anything it shows what _was previously_ important because this year's bowl game was a 10-year low in ratings.[1] Meanwhile, Twitch has more viewership than CNN or MSNBC. [2]

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2019/feb/04/super-bowl-tv-... [2] https://venturebeat.com/2018/11/30/the-rise-of-esports-as-a-...

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by aetimmes on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:39PM (#19138067)
> NFL is the biggest sports in the entire world by revenue by far

Source on this? I can't imagine this being true compared to soccer.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by astura on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:42PM (#19138104)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_professional_sports_le...

NFL had €11,394 million (over eleven billion Euro) in revenue in 2017 whereas the Premier League had €5,340 million (over five billion Euro) in revenue for 2016–17.

MLB and the NBA also beat out the Premier League in revenue.

EDIT: OK, OK, I thought the GP was talking about sports LEAGUES not NFL vs sports as a whole. I read "sports league."

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by microtherion on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:51PM (#19138191)
The NFL is the biggest LEAGUE by revenue, but soccer is by far the bigger SPORT. Just add up the revenues from all the national leagues. To my knowledge, there is only one other professional league in the world (in Canada) that plays (more or less) the same sport as the NFL.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:29PM (#19138525)
NFL is also used as a shortcut for a sport as it’s got different rules than high school or college football, and the both share a name with Soccer.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:39PM (#19138605)
Rulesets aren't what bound a "sport".
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Monday February 11, 2019 @06:11PM (#19139436)
Define something else that does.

Now, you may call something very similar the same sport, but a 100m vs 400m sprints are really different races even with just one slightly different number.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Monday February 11, 2019 @08:43PM (#19140304)
You're confusing event with category.

NFL and NCAA Football are different events, but the same sport. 100m and 400m races are different events, same sport.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:32AM (#19141299)
You play chess and checkers on the same board but they are different games. The rules are extremely different between the NFL and NCAA.

People discuss the “NBA’s” 24 shot clock vs the NCAA’s more leisurely 35 seconds which among other things has a dramatic difference in how the two different games are played. Which was my original point, when the only people using a set of rules are in one org the names become interchangeable.

If you never compete it’s not clear how seemingly subtle rule changes have dramic impact. This changes not only game strategy but also things like how far people travel over the course of the game. 400m at a full sprint takes real endurance where 100m is mostly about acceleration.

Top athletes may have many skills that crossover to different sports, but these are very different games.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @02:17AM (#19141672)
This is a dumb conversation. Basketball is basketball if there's a smaller (womens) ball or larger (mens) ball.

Football is football if you touch one foot inbounds or two.

You're clearly trolling, please leave me alone.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:28AM (#19143250)
Calling something Dumb does not win an argument.

Is flag football still football becase it’s got a similar name?

Greco-Roman wrestling and freestyle wrestling are separated at the olimpics. Even though they share the “wrestling” tile and just have different rules.

Clearly, people have different full names for the different types of football becase they are different sports. Which need somewhat different training and different reflexes.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:45AM (#19143350)
This isn't an argument, you are wrong on the facts. The definition of the word, in English, isn't what you say it is. It is dumb to pretend otherwise, because you are not able to communicate with others who speak English if you do.

I left Reddit to avoid this kind of drivel, go back there if you want to continue to perpetrate it.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:37PM (#19145615)
If you really believe that is true, find some actual evidence beyond gut assertions to support it.

The difference between HN and Reddit is not just being polite, it’s about productive arguments backed up by evidence rather than simply relying on believing something to be true.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:49PM (#19145718)
This isn't an argument, you are factually incorrect. You are misrepresenting the definition of "sport", and to disprove that, all anyone has to do is look up the definition of the word "sport", or have had a conversation with anyone else about sports at any point in their lifetimes.

No one, and I mean literally no one, thinks of NCAA football and the NFL as two separate sports; they're both football, with different rules, a fact you already know but are refusing to acknowledge because you're trolling.

Your insistence on some kind of "evidence" for what the word "sport" means is just you trying to get me to do work that you yourself could do, because that's what trolls do -- they waste the time of others for their own amusement.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retric on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @03:53PM (#19147380)
If you actually look up sport you end up with something like:

“an activity involving physical exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others for entertainment.” The first thing google returns. Which does not support your argument. Saying some arbitrary dictionary is enough is not evendence when they don’t actually say what you want.

I could go off and find quotes relating to the NCAA vs professional sports saying thing a like ~”Rules define the game, different rules different games.” But doing so is a waste of time when they don’t counter an argument.

As you need to be specific before I can counter or there is no way to move forward. Specific examples like the overtime rules are never going to counter your vague and baseless assertions so it’s pointless for me to keep responding to someone either trolling or just rather confused.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @04:08PM (#19147505)
Willfully picking the inapplicable definition, then lying about the fact that it doesn't support what I've been saying is troll behavior, friend.

If you look at the wikipedia page for "Sport", you see all kinds of instances of the word "sport" being used in a way completely incompatible with your view. Please go away now.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by renjimen on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:46PM (#19138146)
The Premier League is one league in a country of fewer than 70 million people. Try adding up all the leagues across Europe for a fairer comparison. Then it's no contest - football (the one played with feet) takes it
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by astura on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:51PM (#19138196)
I thought the claim was the NFL was the "biggest" sports LEAGUE in the world not "biggest" sport - "NFL" isn't a sport, it's a sports league. The NFL isn't the only American football league and I even heard that Vince McMahon is thinking about reviving XFL;. EDIT: Vince McMahon is planning on reviving the XFL in 2020: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XFL_(2020)#Revival
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by wolco on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:24PM (#19138995)
College football is huge. Arena football is popular as well.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by aurelius12 on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:50PM (#19138182)
"Soccer" brings in more revenue American football, baseball, and basketball....combined.

This article's 5 years old, but still relevant: https://mic.com/articles/91009/soccer-s-global-dominance-of-...

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by simmanian on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:40PM (#19138080)
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by conception on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:41PM (#19138099)
It's not. ~NFL = ~Champions League.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by diminoten on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:29PM (#19138529)
Why are you measuring by revenue and not by viewership?
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:25PM (#19137936)
> Is it this more progressive, more healthy sport EXCEPT when it comes to brain trauma?

The problem, I believe, is that to have a concussion free football game is to not have football. You can redesign the helmets, you can try and catch em early, but unless the dynamics of the game change from two amazingly explosive 350 lbs men running into each other, concussion won't go away.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by deanCommie on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:29PM (#19137975)
Is that true? Do rugby and Australian Rules Football have the same problem?

The substantial difference is the lack of padding in those sports. They are still physical. There is still tackling. But human beings behave differently when they don't think they and the target of their tackle are wearing a suit of armor.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by QuotedForTruth on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:54PM (#19138234)
No the substantial difference is the huge difference in the rules of the games. American football stops 100 times a game and sets everyone up to match up with someone and hit them. Concussions dont just happen in tackles. They happen in blocking too (no blocking in rugby or aussie leages afaik). There are an order of magnitude more blocks than tackles in any play or game. Some of the football concussion studies have shown that many sub concussive hits is horrible for the brain too. [1] A football player expierences tens of thousands of these over their career.

Take the armor away and you'll just have people dying instead of getting concussions. Knees to the head arent uncommon and are certainly not intentional by the kneeer or kneed.

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/01/18/5783558...

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by retsibsi on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:04PM (#19138326)
> no blocking in rugby or aussie leages afaik

There's something analogous in Australian football (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shepherding_(Australian_rules_...). It's not supposed to involve head contact, but concussions and whiplash injuries do happen.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by retsibsi on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:42PM (#19138111)
> Is that true? Do rugby and Australian Rules Football have the same problem?

I don't think it's as bad, but the AFL does have a concussion problem. (A quick search didn't turn up any numbers, but here's a relevant article: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2018/mar/20/link-between-c... .)

Players don't go in head-first quite as much as they seem to in American football, but every player has to leave their head vulnerable in certain situations (bending down to pick up a contested ball; going back with the flight of the ball) and some are crazy-brave or even lead with the head deliberately to draw a free kick.

Rugby is probably a better game to use as a comparison, because it is much more similar to American football, with teams lining up and facing each other front-on. Apparently concussion is the most common injury in English rugby: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concussions_in_rugby_union

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:30PM (#19137982)
https://theconversation.com/rugby-players-more-likely-than-n...

Yes, concussions are still a huge problem.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by nerdponx on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:39PM (#19138069)
The question is, is it a worse problem than in American football?

The argument is similar in MMA vs boxing - yes, you are still getting punched in the face and there is no way around that. But with thin gloves and wider variety of ways to get knocked down or out, you are less likely to receive permanent brain damage.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by retsibsi on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:57PM (#19138269)
> The question is, is it a worse problem than in American football?

That's a relevant question, but the post that sparked this exchange talked about the impossibility of 'concussion free football', and said that 'concussion won't go away'. To the extent that rugby or Australian rules are useful comparisons here, they definitely cause enough concussions to support that point (and not just in a pedantic, >0 way -- it's a big problem in both sports).

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:30PM (#19138532)
> The question is, is it a worse problem than in American football?

Retsibsi makes a lot of excellent points, but also the only way we can find that out is if we have American Football players play the game unprotected and find out.

That comparison of MMA to boxing doesn't work either, as it's not a matter of protection that affects the injury rate, it's the fact that you can't grapple in boxing. Boxing forces the game to be about hitting each-other in the head until time out or knock out, MMA doesn't have that same restriction. And that plays into my "to have a concussion free football game is to not have football." point.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by scott_s on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:47PM (#19138684)
It's also important to remember that the dynamics of an MMA fight and a boxing fight are only part of the damage a fighter will take during their career. They will also endure many, many sub-concussive hits during sparring that will also contributed to brain damage.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by stochastic_monk on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @04:03AM (#19142085)
They used to play without padding. That’s why Johnny Unitas, one of the most revered American Football players, was so physically damaged after his career. From Wikipedia: “Toward the end of his life, Unitas brought media attention to the many permanent physical disabilities that he and his fellow players suffered during their careers before heavy padding and other safety features became popular. Unitas himself lost almost total use of his right hand, with the middle finger and thumb noticeably disfigured from being repeatedly broken during games.”

I feel like head trauma has become disproportionately more of long-term physical damage from the sport, but I can’t back that up.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by colordrops on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:30PM (#19138534)
We move to touch or flags. I played plenty of touch and flag football games without head trauma.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by cjaybo on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:00PM (#19138788)
It doesn't matter if it's playable if no one wants to watch the games. Do you think you would enjoy watching a game of touch, or flag football?
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:38PM (#19138589)
While that seems like a good answer, I can't see the NFL adopting that approach. Touch and flag football isn't really the same game, and wouldn't have the same draw as contact football.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by dexterdog on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:05PM (#19138826)
The NFL is moving closer to touch football every year.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:11PM (#19138868)
Well then based upon this (1), touch football won't help the concussion problem anyways. 1) https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nfl/2018/01/26/nfl-con...
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by dexterdog on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:20PM (#19138955)
How much of that is because of the concussion protocol?
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by craftyguy on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:52AM (#19144484)
[Citation needed]
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jedberg on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:30PM (#19137978)
Go back to leather helmets, and eject players for their first head contact. Wire up the caps with sensors. If the sensor goes off, you're out. The game would still be exciting without the head hits.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by brandonmenc on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:35PM (#19139120)
Players actually died all the time when we had leather helmets. This is not a solution.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @06:01PM (#19139360)
Yeah, there's a reasons that the safety was introduced.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:32PM (#19138000)
> If the sensor goes off, you're out.

Ok, so this 350 lbs man has been hit in the head without protection and he's out. When does he come back? Is that it, career over? Cause I can guarantee you he now has a concussion.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by maxxxxx on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:38PM (#19138060)
The helmet doesn't really help much against concussion as far as I know. It's the same with big boxing gloves or headgear. You cut less or don't break your nose but you still can get knocked out. The boxing part is first hand experience.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Benjammer on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @12:37PM (#19154821)
It's because in almost all cases, all the damage comes from your brain sloshing around in the fluid inside your skull and ramming against the front of your skull when your skull suddenly stops moving, it doesn't have a lot to do with surface trauma to your skull from the impact itself or anything like that. Until we can wear a helmet that directly augments the connective tissues inside the skull, we won't be able to solve concussions with head protection outside the skull.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:45PM (#19138137)
Regardless of it being good protection, it's better than leather skullcap. Also, with boxing headgear you're fighting the gloves, which protect a fighters hands, but do nothing to soften the impact to the head.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jedberg on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:52PM (#19138211)
The point is with leather helmets you won't use your head as weapon because you won't feel as protected.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:02PM (#19138306)
Rugby is a game played without helmets and concussions are still a massive problem. Regardless of the usage of the head as a weapon it's still a game that features massive guys hitting each other at high rates of speed. Taking the helmet away has now meant that when the guy gets tackled from behind and lands face first in the dirt he's not worried about getting a concussion due to his broken neck.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by maxxxxx on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:38PM (#19138587)
In bare knuckle boxing they can’t hit full power because they have to worry about their hands.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:55PM (#19138751)
That's what I meant - any gains in protection via the helmet is negligible given that the gloves allow you to hit harder.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by JumpCrisscross on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:09PM (#19138380)
> this 350 lbs man has been hit in the head without protection and he's out

350 lb athletes are a product of the current rules. Penalize concussion-causing blows and I bet you’ll see players shrink to a healthier size.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:13PM (#19138416)
> 350 lb athletes are a product of the current rules. Penalize concussion-causing blows and I bet you’ll see players shrink to a healthier size.

So what changes first? What happens in the meantime until the players become a "healthier size"?

And why would the players change? Those 350 lbs athletes who move like sprinters would be extra lethal without protection. It's already been shown that the league wants performance before any regard for player safety, why would they back off on the big guys?

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jedberg on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:34PM (#19138025)
No I mean the hitter is out for the game. If you hit someone in the head, you're out for the game.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by cortesoft on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:43PM (#19138118)
How would a sensor know who initiated the contact? Most head contact is not directly intentional, it happens when you tackle someone at speed in traffic, and they hit someone else or the ground.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jedberg on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:53PM (#19138218)
Call by the refs.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by SketchySeaBeast on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:39PM (#19138071)
I don't see how that would help as it would just turn to strategy, you'd be aiming to foul out key players with concussions.

And what if you legitimately tackle a guy from behind and he hits the ground so hard his sensor goes off? You've still got a concussed player, but now you have to play the rules game.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by jedberg on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:55PM (#19138244)
> you'd be aiming to foul out key players with concussions.

I don't see players willingly getting concussions just to get other players out.

> And what if you legitimately tackle a guy from behind and he hits the ground so hard his sensor goes off? You've still got a concussed player, but now you have to play the rules game.

It would be up to the refs to call if it was intentional. The sensor is only there to help the ref make the call.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by kelnos on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:11PM (#19138872)
> I don't see players willingly getting concussions just to get other players out.

The current state of the NFL is proof that if you give someone enough money (and/or don't educate them enough), they'll risk serious brain injury to keep that money coming.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by lmkg on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:51PM (#19138199)

  > Budweiser's main hook throughout was that they did not 
  > use high fructose corn syrup in their ingredients!
In the interest of counter-acting deceptive marketing:

None of the named competitor beers use high-fructose corn syrup. They use regular corn syrup. Meanwhile, Budweiser does use high-fructose corn syrup in some of its products (but not Bud Lite specifically).

While the ads did not mention high-fructose corn syrup (they would not be stupid enough to make an actually false claim), I'm sure that implied association was intentional.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by nopriorarrests on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:52PM (#19138718)
>I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football

Come on?! I don't know about US, but good old football (not an american kind) is like 100x times more imporant in Europe than any eSport.

Yesterday Manchester City - Chelsea game ended up 6:0, and #MCICHE tag was trending on twitter worldwide (and it is only England Premier League, not even Soccer World Cup!)

Please wake me up once some eSport event will be a worldwide trending topic on twitter.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bredren on Monday February 11, 2019 @06:17PM (#19139477)
I was specifically talking about American Football but even still, you might not be sleeping too long.

Paris Saint-Germain is a co-owner of the 2nd place champion DOTA 2 team in 2018

PSG is the 11th most valuable football club in the world and worth 825m euros. They bought in April of this past yaer and obviously see Dota 2 as worth investing in now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSG.LGD

It's funny how hacker news is obsessed with finding the next big thing but when something comes along that might challenge traditional sports industry there is so much objection. This is not specific to this comment but replies I'm seeing throughout.

I find this especially odd in light of the fact that a Twitch founder was a venture parter at ycombinator.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by joshe on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:13PM (#19138406)
Here are the top sports leagues with revenue summed by sport (in Euros). Soccer is far ahead of football. [1]

Ice hockey is surprisingly lucrative.

    Sport                             "SUM of Revenue (€ mil)"

    Association football (soccer)     32,412
    American football                 11,394
    Baseball                          10,868
    Basketball                        6,658
    Ice hockey                        5,495
    Auto racing                       2,491
    Australian rules football         754
    Rugby union football              710.8
    Twenty20 cricket                  480
    Rugby league football             414
    Canadian football                 200
    Handball                          103
    Grand Total                       71,979
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_professional_sports_le...
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bliblah on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:35PM (#19139117)
>I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football at this point and has true global appeal.

To be fair, it is also much muuuuuch cheaper to go and watch a Live match of League/Overwatch/Dota. I went to TI8 and the tickets were $190 for the final 3 days; I even got a cosmetic that I was able to sell for $400 on the steam marketplace. Even comparing a Major LAN event to a Single match of any sport can be a magnitude of difference in terms of price.

Also like you mentioned, the global appeal is crazy strong. I saw so many people from China, South East Asia, South America, Europe and the Middle East at these LANs regardless of venue.

However I do think OWL represent the future which is overly stuffy, no fun allowed, corporate events that are just trying to appeal to advertisers and investors; which is kinda lame. Dota and fighting games still have grassroots feel despite having massive tournaments with hundreds of thousands of viewers.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bredren on Monday February 11, 2019 @10:31PM (#19140774)
You could see this in the announcement of the planned US-based LAN for the Midas custom game that came out today. The video is absolutely daffy. It reminds me of the old twitter video with the founders as scientists. Super low budget, but raw, real and emerging.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Zimahl on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:50PM (#19139258)
> I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football

Ironically, fantasy football is the biggest eSport by far.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bredren on Monday February 11, 2019 @06:13PM (#19139451)
This is possibly the most interesting reply. I hadn't thought of FF as an eSport but I can easily see how it can be packaged under that tent.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by matthoiland on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:24PM (#19138997)
Anecdotal, but the eSport Overwatch League is the first time I actually enjoyed watching a spectator sport. Every other sport feels like tribalism and favors a brand over strategy and skill. These kids playing these eSports are crazy brilliant strategists, making decision in milliseconds, and breaking down their plays after the fact is utterly fascinating. –36/M USA.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by throwaway5752 on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:25PM (#19137940)
This has nothing to do with the current or future popularity of the sport, it has everything to do with minimizing the overall tort liability to current and retired players.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by heedlessly3 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:55AM (#19145166)
>I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football at this point and has true global appeal. Football and the Superbowl seem like so many boomer institutions where this old guard is doing everything to slow down the bleeding for as long as possible.

This statement is completely out of touch with mainstream reality.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by brandonmenc on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:39PM (#19139154)
> I think eSports, particularly DOTA2's TI is far, far more relevant to young men than Football at this point

You're living in a bubble. Pretty much no one wants to watch people play video games.

Actual physical competition will always be more interesting to the general public than nerds sitting in chairs pressing buttons to move pictures around on a screen.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by bredren on Monday February 11, 2019 @06:07PM (#19139406)
I am not saying analog sports is going away. And I think it is still a big thing and people will be drawn to it.

However, I think the way you described esports suggests you may have personal bias against competitive gaming. I watched both the Super Bowl and 2018 True Sight. Perhaps, it is you, sir, who are living in the bubble.

The fact is that people are watching nerds move pictures around on a screen at rates rivaling major cable networks: https://www.investors.com/news/technology/click/esports-chan...

45,000 people attended the 2015 League of Legends final in the same stadium used for the 2002 World Cup. 27 Million people watched it online.

https://venturebeat.com/2018/11/30/the-rise-of-esports-as-a-...

This thing is real.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by JohnJamesRambo on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:49PM (#19138701)
https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/28/us/super-bowl-male-cheerleade...

There were actually male cheerleaders in the Super Bowl this year.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by mcguire on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:36PM (#19138578)
If you ask a gamer about the portrayal of women in games, you will probably get a bad reaction.

If you ask a US Civil War re-enactor about the proportion of black people in the hobby, you will probably get a bad reaction.

If you ask a chess afficionado about...ok, I don't know what will set them off.

Some criticisms are off limits in every field.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by noir_lord on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:45PM (#19138668)
> If you ask a chess afficionado about...ok, I don't know what will set them off.

Ask them if they think women only Chess tournaments are a good idea.

That'll generally do it.

Source: Chess player.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by scrumbledober on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:21PM (#19138963)
> If you ask a chess afficionado about...ok, I don't know what will set them off.

the difference in ranking requirements for male grandmasters and female grandmasters

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by josefresco on Monday February 11, 2019 @03:43PM (#19138123)
The "spectacle" of the Super Bowl may be lost, but the NFL is far from "bleeding".

>Says Costas: "Look, the NFL isn't just the most important sports property, it's the single-most important property in all of American television. And it isn't even close."

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by porpoisely on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:28PM (#19138516)
I agree. The superbowl is a day long celebration of ads. Football is just a sideshow.

Now as for ads themselves, they've gone from selling products to social engineering and selling an agenda. Is this a result of monopolization of industries where megacorporations no longer are worried about competition? Is it just a result of media getting more and more extreme ideologically? Maybe both?

And it's not just ads. It's the entire media space. TV shows, movies, etc are more about ideology and agenda than art or even attracting an audience. Even award shows, best selling book lists, prizes, etc are more about agenda than anything else. Maybe it's always been that way to some degree, but lately, it's become so extreme that the average person can see it now.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by unclebucknasty on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:35PM (#19138567)
>Is this a result of monopolization of industries where megacorporations no longer are worried about competition? Is it just a result of media getting more and more extreme ideologically? Maybe both?

>more about agenda than anything else...it's become so extreme that the average person can see it now

I believe it's that companies will always do what they assess is required to sell more stuff. In this age of hyper-awareness, uber-politicization, and social-activism, it's likely the companies now believe that's what people want--for them to be engaged.

And, it's a somewhat rational conclusion. On the other end, you see boycotts, etc. when companies go against the beliefs of certain customer groups, or even when companies sponsor people who do. It's this idea that people want companies to do "good", or at least the customers' version of good. So, they are likely just tapping into that. It's where many people seem to be these days, so that's where companies are trying to meet them.

Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by sotojuan on Monday February 11, 2019 @04:44PM (#19138653)
Companies do stuff like that because they think or have proved that it sells. I've heard and read that people increasingly don't want just products any more. They want a brand, a story, etc. That might not work for beer or TVs but that won't stop Budweiser and Sony from trying.
Re:NBC took Bob Costas off the Super Bowl for speaking out a... by Retra on Monday February 11, 2019 @05:57PM (#19139325)
What happens when a marketer sends out a brand message which reaches theoretically maximal returns? Why, nothing. They come to work the next day and try to beat it.

Advertising isn't a job that's just "done" and people walk away satisfied. McDonalds isn't going to stop putting new things on their menu either. Capitalism doesn't really seem to work otherwise... If you produced the optimal product, you have to come back next year and produce an (almost-by-definition) less optimal product and sell it better than you did before.

Most companies do things because people are being paid at that company to do things. The assumption that they do things because they work better or are better should not be so easily believed or sold. I produce content for my employer because they pay me to produce content, not because I think I can produce content which is better than all other content. Just because people are running really hard doesn't mean they aren't going in circles.