News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by wbronitsky on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:08PM (#19101099)
No, eating more fruit and vegetables is correlated with improved mental wellbeing. In fact, the study, even though it was longitudinal, did not dissect if increasing the amount of fruits and vegetables eaten across a lifespan causes increased happiness even though they could have! The headline, and TFA, are like saying having more TVs per capita causes fewer babies to die. They are both obviously correlative, and clearly not causational.

If the UK is anything like the US, there are some obvious confounding factors, with the most obvious being that poor people cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables, and that poor people are actively persecuted in our society. Hence you get studies that output the above headline.

This isn't really news people.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by neetdeth on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:37PM (#19101349)
This study was peer reviewed, and neither the researchers nor the reviewers are drooling morons as you seem to imply. From the article:

"Based on prior research, we included a rich set of commonly observed predictors of well-being as control variables (see Dolan et al., 2008 for a review of this literature). These include socio-demographic variables such as age, household income, gender, relationship status, number of children and education. Such controls are important as it is possible that fruit and vegetable consumption would co-vary with, for example, income – someone becoming richer and as a result enjoying higher well-being scores and changing their food related behaviours. We also controlled for the presence of long-standing health conditions as well as health and lifestyle related behaviours such as walking frequency and smoking behaviour – again potential confounders that could bias any estimates of the relationship between fruit and vegetable consumption and well-being."

While I do think a lot of research in the social sciences is of questionable value, there's no need to shoot from the hip just for the snarky HN comment.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by ppod on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:04PM (#19101570)
It's in the summary too:

>They took account of many potential confounding factors, including age, income, marital status, number of children, employment status, smoking status, exercise levels (measured by days each week on which they walked for at least 10 minutes at a time) and whether they had a longstanding health condition.

>The study has limitations, however. The most important is that this type of observational study can't tell us whether the fruit and veg consumption actually causes improved mental wellbeing.

While the longitudinal design and the adjustment for potential confounding factors helps to make the results more robust, there may be something else unaccounted for at play here. The possibility that people who feel happier are more likely to choose healthier food, for example, cannot be ruled out.

Its a responsible and cautious summary.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by tapanjk on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:35PM (#19101804)
Is it fair to assume that one cannot just eat more of something without changing anything else? If yes, eating more fruit and veg can be accomplished by eating less of something else and/or increasing caloric requirement through increased physical activity. It would be very interesting to find out what that is, because that could be turned into actionable recommendation about how to eat more fruit and veg.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by oliwarner on Thursday February 07, 2019 @03:41AM (#19103903)
It could just be focussing on cooking. Less junk food. Taking longer meals. Spending more time on the toilet. Better bowel health.

A litany of secondary factors. But they're all direct effects of eating more veg. That's more than correlation.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mkumm6 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:06PM (#19101588)
It doesn't really matter if it's peer-reviewed or how many variables they controlled for. It's still an observational study and not a randomized controlled trial.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:28PM (#19101768)
Observational studies are not completely devoid of value. They are in many cases the only way we can practically learn about certain aspects of our world.

Randomized controlled trials are better, of course.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by sridca on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:14PM (#19102028)
Nutrition epidemiology studies are not scientific experiments; they are wildly inaccurate, questionnaire-based guesses (hypotheses) about the possible connections between foods and diseases. This approach has been widely criticized as scientifically invalid [see here(1) and here(2)], yet continues to be used by influential researchers at prestigious institutions.

Even if you think epidemiological methods are sound, at best they can only generate hypotheses that then need to be tested in clinical trials. Instead, these hypotheses are often prematurely trumpeted to the public as implicit fact in the form of media headlines, dietary guidelines, and well-placed commission reports like this one.

Tragically, more than 80%(3) of these guesses are later proved wrong in clinical trials. With a failure rate this high, nutrition epidemiologists would be better off flipping a coin to decide which foods cause human disease.

(1) https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnut.2018.00105... (2) https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2698337 (3) https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1740-...

Ref: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/diagnosis-diet/20190...

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mikekchar on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:35PM (#19102126)
Although, potentially interesting: Self reported mental well being is correlated with self reported belief of eating more fruits and vegetables. Though a much weaker claim than the headline, I think this is still useful information. Without looking at the study, you can't rule out that there was something about the surveys that caused this correlation, but if there wasn't, it certainly would be interesting to try to find out why this correlation exists.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mkumm6 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:58PM (#19102249)
John Ioannidis, the guy behind "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False" has recently gone after nutrition research. Turns out that nutritional studies are basically devoid of value. After decades of nutrition research we know almost nothing about how to eat healthy.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by hackits on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:02AM (#19103129)
That's a very bold statement to make.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by tiew9Vii on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:03PM (#19101567)
I never get the argument it’s more expensive to eat fruit and veg, I find it far cheaper.

Sure go to your local supermarket it’s way overpriced and expensive. Go to your local green grocer or market and by seasonal produce, it’s cheap, really cheap. Even the stores like Aldi and Lidl are pretty cheap if you are short on time to go shopping round your local green grocery / market.

Where fruit and vegetables are expensive is time, you have to prepare a meal vs putting a ready meal in the microwave for a few minutes.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by fourmii on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:08PM (#19101605)
Not sure where you're from, but in the US, a fast food meal is far cheaper than buying produce from grocery stores. That is if you can find a nearby grocery store to begin with:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_desert

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by nicoburns on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:58PM (#19101941)
In the UK it tends to work out more or less even price wise. So it's a mostly a convenience vs health thing (ignoring taste preferences).
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by nradov on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:26AM (#19103213)
Canned vegetables can be just as healthy as fresh, and common items like green beans and peas are super cheap.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by yesenadam on Thursday February 07, 2019 @03:11AM (#19103800)
Does "just as healthy" include PCBs from the cans? Google "pcb canned food".
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by Jommi on Thursday February 07, 2019 @03:10PM (#19108098)
How are you not thinking about differences between cities and countries?
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by bellerose on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:01PM (#19101546)
I agree & speculate that mental wellbeing has everything to do with finances. Including if a person develops a mental illness; of course there will be cases where the person is financially well off. Approximately 75% of suicides occur in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) where rates of poverty are high. sources: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5454768/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3431736/ https://www.cdc.gov/vitalsigns/suicide/index.html
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by chrisco255 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:39PM (#19101362)
Fruits and veggies are among the cheapest items in any grocery store in the United States. And we provide food stamps to poor people for this very reason.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by munk-a on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:54PM (#19101485)
Home cooked fruits and veggies end up getting a lot more expensive when you factor in frequency of shopping needed to maintain a stock and time required to cook. I applaud everyone who manages to cook every day and I strive to do so, but both of the people in my relationship work full time and waste about three hours a day commuting, round it up to about twelve hours a day lost to work - cooking and then collapsing after that is un-affordable without getting lost in a spiral of depression.

We cook and eat well on the weekends, we try to reserve food for the week and I continue to be amazed by people worse off than us that are working as much as we are _and_ a part time job on top of it.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by tom_ on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:17PM (#19101684)
Just eat fruit raw! It's not exactly difficult to find fruit that requires no significant preparation, needing nothing more than a quick rinse under tap/removal of skin (according to taste), if even that, before you can put it in your mouth and eat it. I particularly like apples and tomatoes, but there are other similarly straightforward fruit options. Bananas and oranges seem to be popular.

Pick the right type of fruit, and you'll be done in less than 1 minute. You probably just spent more time than that writing a post about how you don't have time to eat fruit! - just think how much better your life would be had you spent that minute eating a banana.

(Many types of vegetables do require cooking, but, again, you have options: bell peppers, onions, spring onions, most types of lettuce...)

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by tzs on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:18PM (#19101693)
Frozen vegetables can help a lot with that, especially the miracle that is microwave "steam in bag" frozen vegetables.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by imwally on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:21PM (#19102378)
This. Around 50% of my veg and fruit intake comes from frozen organic bags. They're cheaper, last longer, and quicker to make. My go-to lazy meals involve throwing frozen rice, broccoli or kale, and beans in a glass bowl and heating it up in the microwave.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @10:51PM (#19102854)
Those "steam in bag" vegetables are convenient, but way expensive considering you can just get a plastic microwave steamer for $10.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by nicoburns on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:02PM (#19101963)
> and waste about three hours a day commuting

Jesus. 3 hours! That sounds awful. I'm unhappy when my commute is more than 20 mins each way.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by zhte415 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:48PM (#19102201)
Cooking shouldn't require so much time, at least not needing to collapse. I have a similar commute time. Morning cooking time is 10-20 minutes, evening about the same.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by flukus on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @10:02PM (#19102621)
> Home cooked fruits and veggies end up getting a lot more expensive when you factor in frequency of shopping needed to maintain a stock and time required to cook.

What sort of meals are you comparing? To cook a steak, sausages, bacon and eggs and things like that can take more time than cutting up some vegies and making a basic salad. A lot of veggies like beans and lentins can be stored dried, their shelf life is infinitely longer than meat and bread.

> I applaud everyone who manages to cook every day and I strive to do so

It sounds like your comparing cooking to takeaway/frozen rather than comparing cooking veggies to other food.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by gregcrv on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:02PM (#19102270)
But most of them live in food deserts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_desert

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by barry-cotter on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:21PM (#19102380)
http://www.nber.org/papers/w24094

The Geography of Poverty and Nutrition: Food Deserts and Food Choices Across the United States Allcott, Diamond, and Dubé:

We study the causes of “nutritional inequality”: why the wealthy tend to eat more healthfully than the poor in the U.S. Using two event study designs exploiting entry of new supermarkets and households’ moves to healthier neighborhoods, we reject that neighborhood environments have economically meaningful effects on healthy eating. Using a structural demand model, we find that exposing low-income households to the same food availability and prices experienced by high-income households would reduce nutritional inequality by only 9%, while the remaining 91% is driven by differences in demand. In turn, these income-related demand differences are partially explained by education, nutrition knowledge, and regional preferences. These findings contrast with discussions of nutritional inequality that emphasize supply-side issues such as food deserts.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mancerayder on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:43PM (#19101857)
By what measure, though? What does "cheaper" mean here in terms of unit to unit comparison?

For those interested in protein, or feeling full, chicken is one of the cheapest things you can possibly buy. In NYC, fresh vegetables, and (god forbid) organic, is one of the most expensive things you can buy. In my experience, buying ingredients for a full salad with relatively fresh ingredients is almost as expensive as going to a moderately priced restaurant. It's crazy.

If what I said sounds wishy-washy, it's because no one's defined what a unit of animal product versus a unit of fruit and vegetables is, when doing this price comparison.

It might just be because the weather here doesn't give us Mediterranean-like weather conditions and a lot of stuff has to come from places like Mexico and California (it seems from what the local grocery stores are stocking).

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mikekchar on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:16PM (#19102348)
I live in Japan. Here's a comparison between NYC and Tokyo: https://www.expatistan.com/cost-of-living/comparison/tokyo/n... Click on the plus on the left hand side of food. You can see that Tokyo has dramatically higher fruit and veg prices, especially compared with restaurants, etc (and even compared to chicken). However, it's still dead cheap to buy fruit and veggies. It's certainly one of the cheapest things on my budget. I definitely pay more for my cell phone contract than my fruit and veg!

Your contention that it costs almost as much to buy ingredients for a salad as going to a moderately priced restaurant, don't make sense to me. Even a "basic lunch in the business district" costs $16. That's pretty close to my entire weekly budget for fruit and veg. According to this site you could by a kg of tomatoes, a kg of apples and a kg of potatoes for $12. That's a hell of a lot of food.

When I first moved to Japan I cooked vegan meals at home. Since I got married, I eat a small amount of meat and fish with my wife (I still like vegan cooking). First, I should point out that I didn't eat dramatically more fresh fruit and veg as a vegan -- definitely more beans and grains, and probably a bit more veg. Fruit stayed about the same. My budget for food (which I track pretty closely) has almost exactly doubled per person since adopting more animal products. I spend about $2500 per year per person on groceries now, while I spent about $1300 per year per person on a vegan diet.

One thing that might stand out is the really, really small values there. Food is cheap compared to about every other expense as long as you are cooking for yourself. If you find yourself trying to cut back on your grocery budget, I will suggest that for most people there are almost always better ways to save that money.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by greeneggs on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:36AM (#19103264)
> Even a "basic lunch in the business district" costs $16. That's pretty close to my entire weekly budget for fruit and veg. According to this site you could by a kg of tomatoes, a kg of apples and a kg of potatoes for $12. That's a hell of a lot of food.

I'm not sure what I'm missing. That's only 1466 calories according to Google, mostly from the potatoes—which are not particularly healthy. For $12, it is not much food. An average man eating 2500 calories per day would be spending $143 per week with this diet (of potatoes!). How do you get it to $16/week, including fruits?

For me, at least, fruits and vegetables are the most expensive part of my diet. And I can't afford to buy organic or shop at the farmer's market. It's worth it for me, but I don't pretend it is cheap.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by bluedino on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:48PM (#19101886)
>> In NYC, fresh vegetables, and (god forbid) organic, is one of the most expensive things you can buy

What isn’t expensive in NYC?

There are 310 million people in the USA who don’t live in NYC

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by iflint on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:44PM (#19101408)
This needs to be said more often. Money is not the problem, the time needed to shop and cook as well as the discipline necessary to consistently do so are the largest factors.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by themarkn on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:06PM (#19101590)
Money is still the biggest problem if you are poor. It blocks out all the others. You spend all your time thinking about staying ahead of financial ruin. Calling time and discipline the largest factors, to me, misses the point entirely. You can’t have time if you juggle multiple employers and have kids and are still scraping by. You can’t have “discipline” or willpower or whatever about this stuff if there are 20 more important things you don’t even get done thinking about before you fall asleep from exhaustion at the end of the day. Who’s doing organized meal prep when they have to decide whether to pay the water or the gas bill this month or take out a payday loan or what to do?

Sorry for the rant, if that tone is coming through. But no, the problem is not that poor people aren’t trying hard enough, which is what these kinds of responses seem to boil down too. The problem is people without wealth are exposed to way too much risk and hardship to ever have a chance (or even enough resources and time) to act strategically the way people. Everything is tactical, everything is about just staying upright.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by iflint on Friday February 08, 2019 @11:24AM (#19115713)
Yes the tone is coming through, where did I say that poor people aren't trying hard enough? When you work long hours for low pay or have a family, time and discipline are difficult, I am not belittling the effort it takes.

Money is a huge problem if you are poor. My point is just that you can substitute frozen vegetables for whatever you are eating and it can be the same exact price. It does take more time to make, and is less convenient than unhealthy options. This is what I mean by time and discipline.

There are comments about vegetables having a high cost per calorie, but this misses the important point that many unhealthy, poor people are obese in the US. By swapping a meal at McDonalds or packaged snacks at the convenient store for some pasta with frozen vegetables, you may not be getting the same calorie/dollar value. But getting enough calories is not the issue for most poor Americans, getting enough vegetables is.

I'm not talking about fancy meal prep either. Roast some broccoli in the oven, boil some noodles. Add salt, pepper, butter. Done. Don't like broccoli? Swap it for something else.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by desc on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:18PM (#19101694)
I don't see how this conflicts, exactly. Time is indeed a major factor, but money is not orthogonal: below a certain level of income (which depends on the person's circumstances) it impacts the amount of available time too, with cascading effects.

It doesn't matter how much food (discipline) you've got if your water supply (time, money) is dry for a month.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mikekchar on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:44PM (#19102489)
I've lived on incredibly small amounts of money before. At one time in my life (when I was young and travelling) I couldn't afford meat and became vegetarian. Throughout my life I've spent periods where I've chosen to spend incredibly small amounts of money (though out of choice rather than necessity). I'm talking the equivalent of less than $1K per month.

I think the biggest thing you need is to have the skill to understand where the time/money tradeoff pays off. If you have a low paycheck, it doesn't make any sense to work overtime and then not have time to cook a meal. If you have a family, you might be talking about making $20 and spending all of it at Mac D's. These kinds of things add up as well. If you need a car to maintain a hectic schedule, it can easily end up costing you as much as your entire food budget.

These things are super hard and I think people, whether poor or rich, get it wrong all the time. Prioritisation is also super hard. It's easy to get in your head "Oh, I should have a least X" and so you go out and get X, even though you don't actually need it. Then you get stuck in an inefficient part of the curve for all of the other things that you do need.

In that way, the stigma of poverty is often worse than the poverty itself. If you accept your poverty and cooly make the right choices all the time, then you can live on very, very low levels of money. You can even do so very comfortably and be happy. But if you fight against it, loose heart and try to be "like everyone else", then it's this terrible downward spiral that you can't get out of.

And it's kind of stupid because you can work out the math a million times over and say that people should be able to live on $X or make time for Y, but nobody teaches people how to be poor and happy. We collectively send the message that poor is bad and that only through increased money will your life get any better.

I honestly wish we taught more life skills in high school. Most of the academic stuff people ignore and forget anyway. I'm happy I know about ionic bonding, how titration of acid works, etc, etc because I have used it to make beer and cheese. But it's just not relevant to the vast majority of people on the planet. How we get away without teaching basic skills like managing a budget, shopping, finding a place to live that you can afford, finding and doing well at a job, etc, etc, etc I just don't understand.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by kiba on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:48PM (#19101440)
Some tricks and tips off the top of my head:

* Sous vide: It's very easy to learn and make for juicy and delicious food easy.

* Meal prep. Rather than cooking everyday of the week, spend two hours or so prepping meals for the rest of the week so that you don't have to cook.

That said, the problem is that such knowledge isn't that widespread, although it's widely available on youtube university.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by toomanybeersies on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:05PM (#19101576)
Are you suggesting poor people go out and invest in sous vide equipment? That's not to mention the running cost of vacuum sealer bags.

More sensibly, time and money poor people should invest in a slow cooker. You can cook a huge variety of different cheap and easy meals with one. It also allows you to prep in the evening, then put it on to cook in the morning, so you have dinner ready to go the instant you get home.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by hirundo on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:18PM (#19101689)
Here's a sous vide cooker you can use with any pot for $45.

https://www.amazon.com/My-Sous-Vide-My-101-Immersion/dp/B071...

An ordinary ziploc type bag works fine for sous vide as long as you don't submerge the opening. I've used them for that many times. It's a bit awkward and takes a little more time, but no big deal.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by Shog9 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:27PM (#19101763)
$45 is a pricey slowcooker; the last two I bought were $10 and $30 respectively - the latter has a removable ceramic container. A quick check for what's in stock at the local WalMart shows only 2 out of the 13 available running more than $45. Even the fancy "wifi-enabled app-controlled" Black & Decker is only $38
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by justtopost on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:28PM (#19102090)
A suis vide is much different than a slow cooker. I use both quite a lot, and they seldom overlap. The temp control is crucial.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by kiba on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:34PM (#19101797)
I paid mine for like 70 bucks with the ongoing cost of ziplock bags.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by munk-a on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:56PM (#19101500)
Doing a big cook on the weekend is a good idea, but two hours or so is insufficient for a week if there are picky eaters involved. Processing the volume of veggies into food for a big meal like that will usually end up around two hours, but making multiple dishes in parallel adds a lot of time onto that, especially if you've got limited resources in terms of burners/cookware.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by sevensor on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:13PM (#19101651)
I always make sure to provide two meal options for the picky eaters in my house. (1) take it. (2) leave it. The extra prep is minimal, I assure you.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by munk-a on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:19PM (#19101698)
Great, I'll try selling those options to my spouse who is having issues with low iron right now and for which cooking an additional meal option for the week is not an option.

The "my way or the highway" approach is only really valid when children are involved so that advice is quite limited in terms of value.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by astura on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:04PM (#19102280)
May I suggest these to your spouse?

https://www.luckyvitamin.com/p-555407-luckyvitamin-easy-iron...

I have to take iron but I struggled for many years, most iron pills cause me lots of digestive distress. These ones don't, at all. I even can take them on an empty stomach. Pretty much a godsend.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by astura on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:00PM (#19102257)
That works for kids, not spouses. It also doesn't work for medically indicated diets. (If one of your kids has allergies, etc.)
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:14PM (#19102024)
My impression was that sous vide was generally for meats, not veggies?

I would think a pressure cooker might be a practical solution to the "no time to cook veggies" - I use mine to do things like steam a bag of prewashed and cut kale in under 5min.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by zhte415 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:58PM (#19102247)
Or just buy kale, chop and wash it yourself, add some garlic too, and stir fry the lot, under 2 minutes end-to-end.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by usaythat99 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:49PM (#19101447)
This feels like it’s making it a moral failing.

The effects of social discourse and corporate indoctrination are a thing.

A lot of people believe it’s a duty to support American companies by purchasing their packaged foods.

Advertising branches out of government propaganda research. It’s powerful stuff.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by buzzdenver on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:48PM (#19101437)
Fruits and veggies are among the most expensive items in any grocery store in the United States per calories, which is the metric that really counts.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by chrisco255 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:51PM (#19101461)
That's mainly because veggies have a low calorie count in general. No one's going to get a majority of their calories from fruits and veggies alone. That's pretty prohibitive for most people.

Note: I'm not counting potatoes, rice, and other carb-rich foods here as veggies.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by TallGuyShort on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:54PM (#19101482)
Oh - do people in the US typically have a hard time getting sufficient daily calories on a mostly non-fruit-and-veg diet?
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by buzzdenver on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:16PM (#19101679)
The overwhelming majority does not have a hard time getting sufficient daily calories, but fruits and veggies are still expensive enough that many people probably don't find it affordable to buy a lot of them.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mancerayder on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:46PM (#19101870)
It's almost disturbing how cheap some animal products are, in fact, like chicken. Eggs are a fantastic price for their nutritional content, as well.

The market where I am pushes you towards things that are not fruits and vegetables.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by chrisco255 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:45PM (#19101866)
It's plenty affordable to buy staples like broccoli, spinach, bananas, oranges, etc...what grocery stores are you shopping in?
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by buzzdenver on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:25PM (#19102405)
Affordable is a relative term. Think of it this way: at Sprouts where I usually shop, which is a middle-priced grocery chain here in Colorado, you can buy a pound of chicken breast for $2 on sale. You make some rice to go with it, which is at most 25 cents, plus some spices from your cabinet. So for $2.25 you can have a meal that'll satisfy you. Now to add vegetables, you can throw in a bell pepper ($1 on sale), and 4oz of spinach for $1.5 . So adding vegetables just made your meal twice as expensive and added practically no calories, so you can't save half of what you cooked as leftovers.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by TallGuyShort on Thursday February 07, 2019 @02:50PM (#19107924)
Your own comment agreed that calories aren't usually the critical problem, though. Fruit and vegetables are generally associated with good mental function because of the micro- / phyto-nutrient content. You can eat all the grain and meat you can afford and still be missing essential nutrients.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by toomanybeersies on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:06PM (#19101586)
Given that poor people are more likely to be obese, I don't think that getting their daily calorie intake is a serious issue.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by barry-cotter on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:12PM (#19102329)
> If the UK is anything like the US, there are some obvious confounding factors, with the most obvious being that poor people cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables, and that poor people are actively persecuted in our society.

In that case the U.K. is nothing like the US because frozen vegetables are cheap, convenient and easy to cook. If you don’t want to eat vegetables that’s fine but in Europe it’s not going to be because they’re unavailable. A vegetarian diet is cheaper than an omnivorous one.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by dana321 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:23PM (#19101724)
Eating fruit and raw vegetables for me does make me feel good and brings about a feel of wellbeing. Whether thats the sugar or the other nutrients that they bring i don't know.

Its not really news, i agree, but to a lot of people it is.

I agree that correlation is not causation in a lot of cases, but in this case its kind of true but it depends.. Raw is a lot better than cooked.

Its also the difference between real physical wellbeing from nutrients/sugars, and percieved psychological wellbeing from eating certain foods.

Apple pie might be more of a psychological wellbeing than raw apples which is more physiological, although cooking can bring out different types of nutrients in some cases.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by DanBC on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:39PM (#19101359)
The article says this.

> The difficulty is in knowing whether fruit and veg is actually the cause of their improved mental health. Researchers took account of factors such as people's age, income levels, marital and employment status and general health, and compared the same people's results over time. This approach helped to make the results more reliable. But we can't be sure that the results don't show, for example, that people eat more fruit and veg when they feel more cheerful, rather than the other way around.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by jSully24 on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:13AM (#19103170)
“...cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables”

Worse than “can not afford”, they do not have access to fruit and veggis to start with. Do a search on “food desert” or “poor access fruit”. It is not good.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by sonnyblarney on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:14PM (#19102026)
"with the most obvious being that poor people cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables"

This is simply not true.

In fact, the least expensive foods are fresh vegetables.

Aside from the homeless, most poor people have some means to cook as well, giving them access to an astonishing variety of meals.

Meat, milk, cheese, often expensive.

Fruit and veg is the cheapest thing in the store.

Processed/fast foods are more than likely the culprit in so many ways, it seems wherever you are in America, you're arms length from something massively processed, salty, fully of fats/sugars etc..

Same for Canada.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by miguelrochefort on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:44PM (#19102179)
I'm pretty sure fruits and vegetables (with some exceptions) are more expensive when you factor in calories and nutrients.

https://efficiencyiseverything.com/calorie-per-dollar-list/

https://efficiencyiseverything.com/applying-protein-per-doll...

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by sonnyblarney on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @11:13PM (#19102940)
Your data actually confirms my thesis.

But thanks for the data points, very helpful.

Fruits and Veg are super cheap.

A 10 lb bag of potatoes is $5 at Safeway in SF. That makes quite a number of 'servings' of McD's fries.

Avg ground beef price in US is $5.50/pound in 2018, 1.8 ounces in McD hamburger = 62 cents for the meat.

Wonderbread 20 pack of buns is $3 = 15 cents for the bun.

A slice of tomato, bit of lettuce = not much.

So the burger made at home is less than 90 cents.

The soda is surely less expensive, especially on sale.

So at least for 'fries, burger and coke' in the cheapest place, it's still cheaper to cook - and of course the 'expensive' part is the meat.

It's very inexpensive to buy and cook vegetables, and most fruits are cheap as well.

Meats etc. get a little tricky, but still cheaper than fast food.

I'm really surprised at the comments indicating otherwise, this is pretty easy to see for people that buy food, I didn't think this would be contentious.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by miguelrochefort on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:06AM (#19103149)
> Your data actually confirms my thesis.

I don't think it does.

Your thesis was:

> the least expensive foods are fresh vegetables

This is a vague claim. Are you looking at the price per

- unit?

- weight?

- volume?

- calorie?

A cup of milk is a lot more nutritious than a cup of lettuce. A dollar of sardines is a lot more nutritious than a dollar of apples.

In most cases, fruits and vegetables are nutritionally more expensive than flour, potatoes, milk, eggs, meat, etc.

> So at least for 'fries, burger and coke' in the cheapest place, it's still cheaper to cook - and of course the 'expensive' part is the meat.

I have never claimed that fast food was cheaper than cooking at home.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by sonnyblarney on Thursday February 07, 2019 @11:08PM (#19111437)
"This is a vague claim. Are you looking at the price per"

It's not vague at all.

By basically any nutritional measure, Fruit and Veg are the best deal. Even on the basis of protein, which might sometimes be tricky on 'mostly F&V diet' - it's cheaper - see your own data points for the many Veg's that have a ton of protein, on a cheaper basis than many meats.

"A cup of milk is a lot more nutritious than a cup of lettuce." - but maybe not more than a larger serving of Spinach, which is considerably cheaper.

"I have never claimed that fast food was cheaper than cooking at home."

The theme of this branch of the thread is that 'poor people can't afford to eat healthy' due to things like cheaper fast food' etc. - which is rubbish.

There are claims made by the USDA [1] which are totally misrepresentative, to the point of a lie. They claim anyone living >1 mile from a 'large grocery store' is in a 'food desert' - and that the problem lies in tons of 'Quick-e-mart' type places with terrible foods. The problem with their thesis is that '1 mile' is not far to go for groceries, that (almost) everyone does have access to fresh food, and that it's substantially cheaper than the crap in Quick-e-mart. The data essentially validates that 'poor people' are making bad nutritional choices quite on their own, not due to some kind of 'systematic problem'. They are buying crap from Quick-e-mart on their own volition, for whatever reason, not because they are coerced into it due to cost.

The fact is that a decent diet is available for relatively low cost to anyone that has the means to cook.

I takes a little bit of thinking, but not that much, and yes, some food products which should be more accessible (and possibly healthy) such as some processed foods, meats, dairy etc. are not very accessible, but they are also not necessary for a healthy diet.

[1] http://americannutritionassociation.org/newsletter/usda-defi...

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by miguelrochefort on Friday February 08, 2019 @04:36AM (#19112725)
> see your own data points for the many Veg's that have a ton of protein, on a cheaper basis than many meats

Not really:

https://efficiencyiseverything.com/applying-protein-per-doll...

> but maybe not more than a larger serving of Spinach, which is considerably cheaper

While 100g of spinach almost has as much protein as 100g of milk, it's also 3 times more expensive.

> The theme of this branch of the thread is that 'poor people can't afford to eat healthy' due to things like cheaper fast food' etc. - which is rubbish.

I don't disagree with you.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by wbronitsky on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:23PM (#19175710)
You are assuming that time costs nothing, which is incredibly untrue. How would someone who has to hold down two jobs, and whose nearest grocery store is 45 minutes out of there way, realize the low cost of these things?
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by dageshi on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:17PM (#19101173)
> If the UK is anything like the US, there are some obvious confounding factors, with the most obvious being that poor people cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables, and that poor people are actively persecuted in our society.

I'd put convenience above cost in most cases, there are worse but more convenient foods easily available that store for longer, require less preparation and in terms of fat/sugar adjusted taste buds taste better.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by fratlas on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:25PM (#19101239)
Can't wait until someone creates healthy, long shelf life food that is cheap, and tastes OK. Would be a game changer.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by kovrik on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:37PM (#19101345)
From the top of my head: beans. Canned fish (mackerel, sardines). Oats. Nuts/nut butters (ok, these are not that cheap).
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by koolba on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:30PM (#19101272)
That exists. Oats!
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by gboudrias on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:33PM (#19101297)
He said tastes okay.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by twic on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:09PM (#19101610)
And lentils. You can cook lentils with water and salt and nothing else, and they come out edible and nice enough, if unexciting - but they serve as a fantastic canvas for adding small amounts of other long-lasting things (stock, oil, herbs, spices, cured meat) which add interest.

Which is why my no-deal Brexit survival stash is a couple of kilos of Puy lentils, a bottle of olive oil, and a box of stock cubes!

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by deevolution on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:37PM (#19101348)
With peanut butter, honey and other things, it's surprisingly tasty
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by osrec on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:45PM (#19101417)
Yes, but we need a variety of such foods.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by yesenadam on Thursday February 07, 2019 @03:25AM (#19103851)
I lived on $2 a day for a couple of years (although also relying for variety on friends taking me out to lunch once or twice a week) - mainly 500g pasta + jar of pasta sauce (which had some herbs/veges in it), which made 2 meals and cost under $2. Sometimes also home-made cereal made from e.g. shredded coconut, wheat germ, sugar - surprisingly yummy. After about 3 months I splurged on a jar of garlic - man, that pasta was amazing! :-)
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mikekchar on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:34PM (#19101313)
It occurs to me (in all seriousness) that dog food fits that bill pretty well. Presumably we could easily make human versions. I think that there is more to it than that. Food that is not particularly good for you often tastes better and isn't any more expensive. It's that competition that makes it difficult. We can make pretty healthy dog food because we control what they eat -- they don't get to choose.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by bluedino on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:52PM (#19101911)
There’s the urban legend of senior citizens buying dog food to eat because they get so litttle in retirement checks
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by justtopost on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:29PM (#19102096)
Not a ledgend. Many now famous people lived on dog food for years. Phillip K Dick comes to mind.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by onemoresoop on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:38PM (#19101351)
What makes you think dog food is healthy?
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by mikekchar on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:39AM (#19103275)
From having raised dogs :-) Dogs have similar dietary requirements to humans. If you look closely at the nutrient breakdown in the dog food, you can see that it provides a very good balanced nutrition -- or at least it hits what they are aiming for. People can quibble about whether or not there are healthier nutrient breakdowns, but it's not really that hard to change things around. There are actually studies showing life expectancies for dogs eating dog food vs eating food made at home and they are higher for those eating dog food. There is a variety of reasons for that. For example, dogs are generally smaller than humans and dietary imbalances often have consequences sooner. So it's not really the case that dog food is super food or anything like that. It's just generally reasonable nutrition. The reason I found out about this is that I once thought about cooking for my dogs (I was cooking for myself every day anyway) and my vet highly discouraged me from doing so. She put me on to those papers (It was almost 20 years ago now, so I'm afraid I don't have any useful links, unfortunately).

Dog food also tastes surprisingly good. I never fed my dogs anything that I didn't try first (which I suppose may be weird, but oh well). I can say that some dogs really like the taste of liver, but aside from that kind of thing, dog food is surprisingly good. Some of the wet canned food rivals prepared human meals in my opinion, though the price is a bit higher. I can't remember the brand, but I remember one "beef stew" which was insanely good. I would have happily had it as a meal.

It seems like soylent.com is still around. I think they are making meal replacement drinks. Not my cup of tea, but at $1.80 per meal, it's fairly cheap and convenient. Not sure about taste (I think I'd go for the dog food myself!) However, it is almost exactly the average price for meals I cook for myself, so I'm not sure it's a great deal price wise. The same is also probably true of dog food to be fair.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by toomanybeersies on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @07:08PM (#19101603)
Pre-cooked rice and curries fit the bill for me. Less than $5 per meal, 2 minutes to heat up, and tastes decent. Not terrible for you either.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by miguelrochefort on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:48PM (#19102202)
I'm pretty sure it's terrible for you.

What are the ingredients? How much do you get? $5 per meal is not cheap.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by Mikeb85 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @08:55PM (#19102232)
Dried grains and legumes already exist, and provide the majority of calories that humans consume.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by Lorenzo45 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:42PM (#19101391)
Like Soylent?
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by fratlas on Thursday February 07, 2019 @01:02AM (#19103372)
Similar, but solid and with some kind of taste
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by colordrops on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:45PM (#19101415)
Sardines.
Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by open-source-ux on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @06:51PM (#19101465)
"...people cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables"

Fruit and vegetables are cheap in the UK. To look at prices, just visit any UK supermarket's website (e.g. asda.com, tesco.com, sainsburys.com etc). Lidl and Aldi can be cheaper, but often the cheapest of all are small independent grocery stores.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by black-tea on Thursday February 07, 2019 @12:50AM (#19103326)
> poor people cannot afford to eat more fruit and vegetables,

Why is this statement so persistent? Vegetables are the cheapest food there is. Lentils have long been a staple of students. Poor people are poor because they are bad with money and make poor decisions. That is why they don't eat vegetables.

Re:Eating more fruit and vegetables 'improves mental wellbeing' by wbronitsky on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:24PM (#19175723)
Food deserts exist. This also assumes that time is free, which it is not. If someone has two jobs and lives in a food desert, buying and making their own food becomes a burden and very costly.

> Poor people are poor because they are bad with money and make poor decisions.

you seem like a hateful person. i dont understand how, faced with overwhelming evidence to the contrary, how you can hold this in your heart. I truly hope you don't believe this.

but seriously. you are discounting family wealth, education, racism, and just plain bad luck. your assertion is so hateful it would almost be comical if there weren't so many people pushing this hateful and destructive ideology