News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by x220 on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:45PM (#19079918)
Would trust-busting do any good? The main reason no practical alternatives to Facebook exist is the network effect. The main reason that competitors to Google don't do well is that people will just use the search engine that returns the most relevant results (unless your internet connection is censored). The only practical solution is regulating ethical behavior of these incomprehensibly powerful corporations.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by stcredzero on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:02PM (#19080090)
The main reason no practical alternatives to Facebook exist is the network effect.

Doesn't it creep you out that one company has a monopoly on the social graph? When we busted up Ma Bell, we basically put into place standards for interoperation. What if we had a law mandating social graph companies open themselves up for interoperation once they reach some critical threshold of size? Basically, the idea is that once you're massive enough in social media, you don't get to hold onto your lead purely through the network effect. Staying at the top, just because you're at the top doesn't really promote the general welfare of society or motivate people to make better products.

The main reason that competitors to Google don't do well is that people will just use the search engine that returns the most relevant results (unless your internet connection is censored).

At home, I use Duck Duck Go. It gives good enough results but comes with a better reputation with regards to privacy.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by twblalock on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:50PM (#19080492)
> What if we had a law mandating social graph companies open themselves up for interoperation once they reach some critical threshold of size?

If we open up Facebook's data to other companies, what makes you think those companies are willing and capable of securing the data and respecting user privacy?

Facebook having all of that data is bad enough. Requiring Facebook to share it with other companies would not make that data more secure -- but it could definitely make it less secure.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:13PM (#19080692)
For one, where sharing of data is concerned, none of this is about forcing Facebook to give your data to some random third party that asks for it. It is about you as a user being able to demand from Facebook that they make your data (or some selection of it) accessible to some third party of your choice.

But also, and maybe more importantly, interoperation does not really necessarily require any sharing of data. Think the telephone network: All telephone network operators world wide do interoperate, which is why it doesn't matter where you are a customer, you still can call any other telephone on the planet. But that doesn't mean that those telcos somehow share data of their customers, apart from the particular calls that happen between customers of two different telcos.

Also, one way in which Facebook could be forced to share data would be for migration to a different service: If you think Facebook is abusing your data, you could move to a different provider, and Facebook would have to allow them to pull your data over and then delete it on their side--and all that without you losing contact with people who stay on Facebook thanks to enforced interoperability.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by stcredzero on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:28PM (#19080813)
But also, and maybe more importantly, interoperation does not really necessarily require any sharing of data.

DRM actually has a potential for societal good. We should make companies like Facebook subject to DRM around our data. DRM is subject to the same asymmetry as privacy. Privacy for individuals is a societal good, in contrast to governments and big public companies, which should be as transparent as possible. Likewise, DRM used by big companies and organizations against individuals is bad for individuals and societies. However, DRM used on behalf of individuals to protect them from big companies would be a societal good.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday February 04, 2019 @08:48PM (#19082467)
Well, except it doesn't, because it necessarily either doesn't work or it is centrally controlled.

What does help is simply encryption and decentralized services, no need for DRM.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by stcredzero on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @12:39PM (#19087486)
Well, except it doesn't, because it necessarily either doesn't work or it is centrally controlled.

Putting in another hoop for abusive corporations to jump through does have a function. There would be additional opportunities for whistleblowers to spot it happening, opening up the company to legal and regulatory action. Also, it wouldn't necessarily have to be centrally controlled. 3rd party companies could be hired to do the administration.

What does help is simply encryption and decentralized services, no need for DRM.

DRM could well be implemented as encryption and decentralized services.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @09:19PM (#19092128)
> Putting in another hoop for abusive corporations to jump through does have a function. There would be additional opportunities for whistleblowers to spot it happening, opening up the company to legal and regulatory action. Also, it wouldn't necessarily have to be centrally controlled. 3rd party companies could be hired to do the administration.

In which case DRM doesn't do anything, but regulation and whistleblowers do?

> DRM could well be implemented as encryption and decentralized services.

How would that work? You don't have control over your own machine, but everyone else does?!

DRM is the idea that your property has a function that controls what you can do with your property based on instructions from a third party ... who would that "decentralized third party"(?) be? And what would even be the point of that? I am not sure I even understand what kind of construction you have in mind that would qualify as DRM and also be useful for the end user in any way.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by davidcbc on Monday February 04, 2019 @05:55PM (#19081509)
How does your idea of interoperation work for the read flow? How do I see my friends posts on your Facebook competitor without their Facebook data being shared with that competitor?
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday February 04, 2019 @08:46PM (#19082452)
Obviously, you don't. The point is that it's your and their decision to make, not Facebook's or the competitor's.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by nopriorarrests on Monday February 04, 2019 @05:49PM (#19081458)
>It is about you as a user being able to demand from Facebook that they make your data (or some selection of it) accessible to some third party of your choice.

What's the point of making _my_ data accessible? AFAIR under GDPR facebook already can provide you all your data in downloadable form, at least if you are in EU.

If we want to break Facebook network effect, you need much more.

I, being early adopter, move to new service, called Bookface, and now I want to talk with my friends, who are still using FB. So I ask Bookface to connect to FB and suck the latest updates about these 1000 people, because they are my friends. Hmmm...

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday February 04, 2019 @08:53PM (#19082486)
Well, of course, this would be about real-time access, which is not something covered by GDPR, which would be the basis for interoperability. So, you could move to Bookface, and then your friends would have the option to allow Bookface access to their data on your behalf, in so far as they want to allow you to access it, in just the same way they would allow another user on Facebook to access it.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by haberman on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:49PM (#19080482)
> What if we had a law mandating social graph companies open themselves up for interoperation once they reach some critical threshold of size?

To me that sounds like legally-mandated proliferation of sensitive user data. The Cambridge Analytica scandal is essentially a case of Facebook being too open with their data.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by ucaetano on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:07PM (#19080645)
> At home, I use Duck Duck Go. It gives good enough results but comes with a better reputation with regards to privacy.

The fact that you do so, with no additional effort needed, kinda breaks the entire trust/monopoly argument, doesn't it?

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by jedberg on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:21PM (#19080753)
Facebook bought Instagram because Instagram was beating them at the social network game. So it is possible to create a new social network and win. BUT the interoperability is key. I think if they just legislated that part of it, it would be a win for consumers.

Maybe we can get the EU to pass some data probability laws and force Facebook and Google to share...

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by scotty79 on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:57PM (#19080033)
> The main reason no practical alternatives to Facebook exist is the network effect.

You could just split Google in half into Goo and Gle and force them to publish protocols their services use so they can share the network. This could also allow smaller players to join the network.

At the beginning you could bounce people going to google.com at random to goo.com or gle.com until they start prefering one or the other for whatever reason and go there directly.

And who knows ... maybe at some point Gle could attract more users by being more precise and less intrusive with their ads.

Until there is one Google, there is one strategy that can be tried at one time. This harms progress.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by nopriorarrests on Monday February 04, 2019 @05:55PM (#19081505)
>Until there is one Google, there is one strategy that can be tried at one time. This harms progress.

I mean, have you seen the full list of google chat apps? You call it "one strategy that can be tried at one time"?

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by scotty79 on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @08:56AM (#19085259)
It's easy to halfassedly try dozens of things and fail at all of them if your existence doesn't depend on it.

If what google monopolist does to try new things was best or even sufficcient then planned economies would thrive.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by roguecoder on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:52PM (#19079990)
The main reason for that is because they have been allowed to build a walled garden. Interoperable protocols would allow other companies to innovate on an equal playing field. Indeed if we follow the Bell example, the networked platform could be forced to be separate from those who profit off of it.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by x220 on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:55PM (#19080016)
Can you name some successful interoperable protocols used by social networks that allow for meaningful innovation and updates? All I can think of is Agora* (which no one uses) and IRC (which hasn't added nontrivial features in a very, very long time).
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by eitland on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:43PM (#19080426)
Whatever protocol (Ostatus?) connects my write.as account with my mastodon account and everyone else seems to be enabling meaningful innovation now.

And between your examples there's also XMPP.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by daveid on Monday February 04, 2019 @05:16PM (#19081188)
It's ActivityPub, not OStatus!
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:17PM (#19080725)
Whatever protocol Facebook is using internally to interoperate between their thousands of servers, with some additional authentication and authorization layers put in?

I mean, not sure how sensible that would really be, but I think it's worth considering that Facebook is not some PHP script with a small local MySQL database behind it either, but rather a massive distributed system in itself, even if under the administrative control of a single entity.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by wmf on Monday February 04, 2019 @08:33PM (#19082394)
One would assume that Facebook's internal protocols are constantly upgraded to enable new features and those upgrades would be much slower if industry politics got in the way.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by feanaro on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:31PM (#19080838)
Yes, Matrix <https://matrix.org>.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by tracker1 on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:08PM (#19080126)
> The only practical solution is regulating ethical behavior of these incomprehensibly powerful corporations

Unfortunately, regulating ethics tends to lead us to exactly what is starting to happen... Even centrist and center-left commentators and journalists are starting to see some fallout from the gatekeepers of money/donations/subscriptions online. Most of it is far-right targeted, but there's some bleed and it may expand.

I'm not a fan of extremist points of view. I'm more opposed to censorship as I feel it's far more dangerous than letting idiots talk. When a handful of companies serve as the gatekeepers to the world, it's more important that censorship is minimized, even if they are "private" companies.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by CM30 on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:23PM (#19080763)
Given that much of this apparently comes down to the likes of Visa and Mastercard, perhaps these types of companies need breaking up or regulating. Maybe also large enough payment processors like PayPal.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by tracker1 on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:44PM (#19080924)
I'm not sure that they realistically can be broken up. I mean, a government based one could be created, but there's the matter of interoperation between countries. I think that keeping them out of ethics/censorship in terms of what they'll process payments for would be where to start. That should include transparency in terms of when government actors ask them to blacklist someone.

They're in a potentially tough position, however they have an unfair level of power. I'm not sure how they could reasonably be broken up.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by zjaffee on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:56PM (#19080026)
One could argue that the level of data this network effect allows businesses to collect allows them to create a trust around advertising, which is in some sense true.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by mtgx on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:41PM (#19080407)
Even so, Facebook itself would eventually die out, as people would get bored with "social media", or at least the type of social media that Facebook embodies. How do I know this? Because I'm already seeing the trend for it. The trend might not be huge right now but no big trend is. After all, solar panels have been on a rising trend since the 80's, but its nominal growth only started to be noticeable by 2010 or so.

The problem is that Facebook is allowed to buy out any potential Facebook-replacements, too, and thus be allowed as a company to continue its monopoly almost indefinitely. If Instagram is the "new Facebook" then Facebook shouldn't have been allowed to touch it. And if it already touched it, the government should split them up, as they did AT&T, for the public good. Same with WhatsApp.

My guess is Facebook wants to integrate the three now primarily because it wants to use the excuse that it "can't" neatly separate the platforms anymore and that users will rebel against the government if they attempt that. So if politicians plan to bust Facebook, they should do it soon.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by tivert on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:49PM (#19080484)
> Would trust-busting do any good? The main reason no practical alternatives to Facebook exist is the network effect. ... The only practical solution is regulating ethical behavior of these incomprehensibly powerful corporations.

While I think regulation definitely needs to be on the table to control the perverse incentives that would affect all Baby Facebook's, I don't think the network effect makes Facebook resistant to trust-busting. If a breakup mandates the successors to:

1) share the core IP (e.g. the Facebook brand and facebook.com, etc),

2) create and participate in an open federated social network protocol to blunt future network effects, and

3) divide Facebook's current userbase in a way that does not follow the contours of the social graph

...then I think the network effects will be muted enough to prevent the current monopoly situation from reoccurring.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by michaelchisari on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:50PM (#19080501)
4) Require the baby facebooks to coordinate an open standard federated social networking profile that is managed through a non-profit consortium.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by malka on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:47PM (#19079935)
if such things are meant to be monopolistic, then the state should manage it.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by stcredzero on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:06PM (#19080112)
if such things are meant to be monopolistic

I think there's a very important truth in this sentence!

then the state should manage it

Do states have such a good track record with Internet tech.? I'm thinking of Korea and their mandated shopping encryption ActiveX.

IoT security is another are where lots of bad things are happening and an argument for state management could be made. How about the control of all IoT things, like webcams and smart assistants, go through government infrastructure? That way, they can 1) enforce security practices and 2) actually implement Orwell's total surveillance state from 1984.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by Aunche on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:58PM (#19080050)
The difference is that you can't really manipulate the power grid to favor a political party. You can do that with Google or Facebook.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by davidcbc on Monday February 04, 2019 @06:00PM (#19081545)
Which state?
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by Zecar on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:50PM (#19079957)
You want the state in charge of managing communications between friends and family members?
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by Qwertystop on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:52PM (#19079983)
In the same way/to the same degree that the state manages the phone lines and the postal system, I suppose.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by gotocake on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:52PM (#19079995)
Yes, in the same way they had to bust Ma Bell for the same damned reasons we’re seeing again. Let the state be the dumb pipe or at least ensure that the pipes stay dumb. It’s not perfect, but it’s better than the alternative.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by roguecoder on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:54PM (#19080010)
Rather than private corporations who turn around and exploit private communications between friends and family members for maximum profit? Yes.

The state could abuse its power: companies do abuse their power, because to do otherwise would reduce shareholder profits.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by lumberjack on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:05PM (#19080101)
There are technological solutions that could maximize privacy but they are not in use because the private service provider needs to snoop in on your conversations to build a profile of your life. With a public service we could have a system engineered to maximize privacy. Not to mention real transparency and oversight that is no possible with private services.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by twblalock on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:08PM (#19080132)
With a public service we would have a system engineered poorly, like healthcare.gov. The government can't do that kind of thing well.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by Larrikin on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:37PM (#19082849)
Then state should do what they did to make healthcare.gov work on the second time through. The roll out sucked but it's perfectly fine now
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by fixermark on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:58PM (#19080045)
The state already has extremely heavy involvement in management of the telephone system. There is plenty of precedent for this being generally benevolent authority.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by x220 on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:57PM (#19080034)
I want the state to specify restrictions on how companies can use the data transmitted in private messages on social networks.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by x220 on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:54PM (#19080003)
The state already unofficially manages, manipulates, and spies on communication.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by joshAg on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:14PM (#19080173)
more than i want facebook or google to, yes.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by ticviking on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:59PM (#19080060)
If multiple competitors have to achieve interop to provide a similar experience that doesn't seem like a bad thing to me.
Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by naravara on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:58PM (#19080049)
>The main reason no practical alternatives to Facebook exist is the network effect.

You could have said the same about AT&T. When they broke it up, they split it into distinct entities. There is no reason we couldn't split it back up into Instagram, WhatsApp, and its other various apps. It also has tons of individual functions and features that are only bundled together because of path dependence. The Marketplace, the news feed, the home page, and the discussion forums/groups are all potentially distinct companies. You could still even have one company in charge of managing identity and authentication and make everything interoperable between the distinct branches.

Setting things up that way would make it look more like a federated platform and would take no small amount of work, both from the private companies and the government (to establish standards). But as things are now nobody has an incentive to design an internet that works like that.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by bilbo0s on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:00PM (#19080065)
>You could have said the same about AT&T...

No you couldn't have, you could use your telephone to call any other telephone on the planet. Even if AT&T did not own the wires.

THAT is the behavior we have to stop. Breaking up tech companies does nothing to solve that problem.

Silos need to be made illegal if you want to stop the tech companies. (And even if you make silos illegal, good luck keeping your social network from knowing what you are searching for on your search engine. That's another one of the fundamental problems not addressed by break ups. Privacy.)

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by naravara on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:36PM (#19080878)
>No you couldn't have, you could use your telephone to call any other telephone on the planet. Even if AT&T did not own the wires.

What? The telephone exchange (run by Bell) had to actually make the connection for you. If you were not paying them for phone service your calls weren't getting connected. And they owned the entire vertical stack for phone service, from producing the handsets to leasing/selling the phones to owning the wires and operating the exchanges.

There were numerous reasons why it was just not viable to have an alternative business to AT&T. They owned all the infrastructure and it would have been impossible for any upstart to compete because you just can't build rival infrastructure overnight, and nobody wants to have a second-rate phone service.

Breaking it up IS how they solved that problem, for a little while, until technology moved ahead of the regulations and began consolidating again.

>That's another one of the fundamental problems not addressed by break ups. Privacy.

Break ups don't address climate change either. What does any of this have to do with the price of tea in China?

Also, if your social network isn't the same business as your search engine, why would they be sharing data with each other? This objection of yours makes no sense.

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by bilbo0s on Monday February 04, 2019 @05:24PM (#19081242)
>What? The telephone exchange (run by Bell) had to actually make the connection for you....

Exactly, and Facebook will not make an open connection for you to another social network. Any connection is strictly limited to protect Facebook's sovereignty over you. It would be like At&T making a connection to Sumatra for you, but only if you confine your discussion to the size of pants you wear. No other information would be allowed to be discussed. If you tried to even say your name, AT&T would automatically mute those parts of the conversation.

You cannot openly connect to another social network and move your data wherever you please. If you switch without moving your data, you cannot openly talk back to your friends who may still be on the old social network. ie - these are SILOS. And that's the behavior we should be targeting. You could go through the AT&T network back in the 70's and talk to someone in Sumatra, or Paris on a completely different national network not provided by AT&T. If you want to openly connect with someone in Sumatra or Paris via social network today, you have to be on the same social network. These networks are not open. What we need are laws obliging them to be open.

Trust busting does not do that, all it does, at best, is give you multiple siloed social networks to choose from. (But it probably wouldn't even do that. It would likely just separate, say, youtube from google. Or separate instagram from facebook. We're still left with silos.)

Re:Trust-Busting as the Unsexy Answer to Google and Facebook by naravara on Monday February 04, 2019 @09:56PM (#19082720)
>Exactly, and Facebook will not make an open connection for you to another social network.

Yes. This is why I said you need to make it a condition of breaking the trust. To open the platform and create general standards for interoperability is part of the point. You're arbitrarily constraining the definition of a breakup to only refer to dividing up administrations, even though almost every instance of actual trust busting involves making all kinds of requirements about the conditions of subdividing operations to help make sure the same problems of consolidation and collusion don't repeat.