News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by randomsearch on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @06:54PM (#19040907)
Or... Zuckerberg is lying.

You certainly can’t treat anything he says as ground truth - you need independent figures.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by dang on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @09:07PM (#19041650)
Please don't take HN threads on flamewar tangents. There's plenty of opportunity to make substantive critiques on HN. This is not that.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by randomsearch on Thursday January 31, 2019 @03:23PM (#19048430)
Ack sorry, my bad. It wasn't meant to be, but I see I have misintentionally done just that.

What I meant to communnicate was "we shouldn't take these stats at face value and therefore assume the scandals have had no impact" but I made the mistake of phrasing it as if it were an assertion (not an interpretation I'm used to), being too pithy, and also using Zuckerberg's name rather than "social media"/"facebook".

I didn't mean it to be a tangent, just a genuine point that such statistics should be treated with healthy scepticism and therefore caution against concluding too much from them. Hopefully the last bit in the post at least indicates I was sincere. But totally my bad. Need to take more care.

I'm certainly often a contrarian, but never intentionally a troll.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by dang on Thursday January 31, 2019 @04:25PM (#19049022)
Thanks. Moderating HN has taught me that most of what looks like trolling is unintentional.

Most of us consider our comments to be individual statements; we don't think of them as roots of the next possible subthread. But that's actually what matters for discussion quality.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by randomsearch on Thursday January 31, 2019 @05:01PM (#19049358)
That's a really good point I'd never considered.

It's very cool that on HN people sensibly and helpfully debated what I'd intended to say. Means I learn.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by bitpush on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:12PM (#19041039)
You have every right to be less than impressed with the company and its business model(s), but dont make baseless claims.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by gammateam on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @09:08PM (#19041655)
Companies restate earnings all the time, years after traders already made a profit :)

It isnt a baseless claim to point out the infallability of a CEO or the broken incentive model to tout bad information or consciously lie

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by randomsearch on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:38PM (#19041177)
I didn’t claim he was lying. I said it was an alternative conclusion.

Perhaps to be more generous I should say “exaggerating” or “being selective.”

Clearly his interests are aligned with higher stats. Therefore, it makes sense to corroborate those stats with independent data.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by AndrewKemendo on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:22PM (#19041390)
Your alternative "poisoned the well"

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoning_the_well

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by deelowe on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:08PM (#19041318)
> "Or... Zuckerberg is lying."

> "I didn’t claim he was lying."

Sure seems like you did...

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by yesenadam on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:15PM (#19041354)
"A"

"..or B"

"You claimed B!"

It seemed to me that he 'claimed' (if you want to use that term) that "A or B". I'm not sure what "A" was exactly, but he pretty clearly didnt just assert "B". Although sure, he did cast aspersions (or something), but he's hardly alone in doing that about his target. It would be novel to hear someone claim Zuckerberg is truthful, or say anything nice about the guy. The word "claim" was the problem here, I think. He may have suggested the possibility that Zuckerberg was lying, but claim that he was?! By what definition? "It's day..or night" "You claimed it's night!"

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by mastazi on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:40PM (#19041484)
In my opinion, it depends on GP's level of English language proficiency. If it is at least average, then he did make the claim.

AFAIK "... or B" is a common idiomatic expression used to convey, in a sarcastic tone, the fact that the speaker disagrees with A, and considers B to be true.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by yesenadam on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:48PM (#19041527)
Sure, but saying (or sarcastically hinting) that you believe B (that you 'consider B to be true') is still a different thing from saying ('claiming') that actually B.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by mastazi on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @09:29PM (#19041779)
Oh OK I see what you mean, yes I agree with you then.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by randomsearch on Thursday January 31, 2019 @03:26PM (#19048460)
Thanks Mastazi, for pointing that out. I did make the mistake of intending what I wrote to be literal rather than implying something. My bad. But I see what you mean.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by johnfn on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:55PM (#19041256)
Your first sentence was “Or... Zuckerberg is lying.” That is a claim.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by randomsearch on Thursday January 31, 2019 @03:27PM (#19048473)
Wasn't intended as one, but I see from discussion above that's a common way to imply that the alternative is true. My mistake.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by dmos62 on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:25PM (#19041407)
The claim was that there's another explanation, not that there's only that other explanation. Why did everyone get their feathers in a bunch over Facebook's integrity?
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by pavlov on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:16PM (#19041057)
Actively lying about numbers in the prepared remarks of an earnings call...? Probably not (unless you think Facebook is actually a scam ten times bigger than Enron waiting to be exposed.)
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by dymk on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:04PM (#19040991)
You honestly think that Facebook is lying to investors about key metrics?

Do you know how much of a field day of litigation the SEC would have if that were true?

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by huac on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:07PM (#19041009)
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by kerng on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:25PM (#19041113)
It's not that it didn't happen in the past...
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by fromthestart on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:29PM (#19041130)
After everything that FB has already lied about, the repeated examples of dark patterns, shady practices, the "dumb fucks" quote, is it really far-fetched to think that Zuckerberg would lie about this too, if he thought he could get away with it?

Who's going to prove him wrong? Does anyone else have access to FB internal metrics? And what's the downside to lying? Worst case a slap on the wrist fine and a drop in stock price?

Zuck has repeatedly demonstrated himself to be the type of person who will absolutely take advantage of any situation without any kind of ethical qualms.

I'm not saying he's lying about this too, but it wouldn't surprise me in the least, SEC or no.

Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite... by circadiam on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:00PM (#19040954)
If only there were research apps to get those independent figures...oh wait.