Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite...
by mastazi on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:40PM
(#19041484)
In my opinion, it depends on GP's level of English language proficiency. If it is at least average, then he did make the claim.
AFAIK "... or B" is a common idiomatic expression used to convey, in a sarcastic tone, the fact that the speaker disagrees with A, and considers B to be true.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite...
by yesenadam on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:48PM
(#19041527)
Sure, but saying (or sarcastically hinting) that you believe B (that you 'consider B to be true') is still a different thing from saying ('claiming') that actually B.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite...
by mastazi on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @09:29PM
(#19041779)
Oh OK I see what you mean, yes I agree with you then.
Re:Facebook shares shoot up after strong Q4 earnings despite...
by randomsearch on Thursday January 31, 2019 @03:26PM
(#19048460)
Thanks Mastazi, for pointing that out. I did make the mistake of intending what I wrote to be literal rather than implying something. My bad. But I see what you mean.
"..or B"
"You claimed B!"
It seemed to me that he 'claimed' (if you want to use that term) that "A or B". I'm not sure what "A" was exactly, but he pretty clearly didnt just assert "B". Although sure, he did cast aspersions (or something), but he's hardly alone in doing that about his target. It would be novel to hear someone claim Zuckerberg is truthful, or say anything nice about the guy. The word "claim" was the problem here, I think. He may have suggested the possibility that Zuckerberg was lying, but claim that he was?! By what definition? "It's day..or night" "You claimed it's night!"