News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by maccio92 on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:28PM (#19019243)
Why are we acting like a journo company laying off 1000 people is the end of the world? Are people not aware of how many other companies across many sectors have layoffs all the time? This isn't news. BuzzFeed sucks, their journalists were providing benefit to the business, so they pivoted. Can we move on?
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by yuy910616 on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:35PM (#19019309)
It's more than that. buzzfeed is essentially a type of media company, one that is suppose to 'survive' in the new landscape where aggregates like fb, and google dominates. to learn and understand why it is struggling has more implications not just to the long term viability of journalism, but also to how aggregators dominate and there fore, should be regulated, and what can company do in a age where controlling demand is much more important than controlling supply.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by porpoisely on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:41PM (#19020391)
One way they could have survived was by not cheerleading for CNN, NYTimes, Washingtonpost, etc when the big boys were demanding fb, google, etc censor content and instead drive traffic to "authoritative" sources ( AKA themselves ).

People forget that smaller media firms like Buzzfeed, Vox, Huffpo, etc all thrived under a neutral FB, Google, etc. Remember when these companies were supposed to be the "new media"? What changed?

Buzzfeed did this to themselves. They demanded that fb, google, etc censor and pick favorites and they chose the big boys over buzzfeed.

What buzzfeed didn't realize is that their competition isn't infowars, breitbart or foxnews. Nobody who read those sources would ever waste their time on buzzfeed. Their competition was the NYTimes, CNN, MSNBC, Washingtonpost, etc. Now that buzzfeed has successfully helped these large media companies get preferential treatment with FB, Google, etc, there is really no room for buzzfeed. The big boys took buzzfeed, vox, huffpo, etc's market share. I bet these large "authoritative" companies are seeing a rise in traffic and increasing ad revenue. I wonder where that increase is coming from? Infowar fans? Highly unlikely.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by malvosenior on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:00PM (#19022396)
This is a very astute take. Buzzfeed had its interests more aligned with Breitbart than the NYT all along. Yet they continued to attack not just Breitbart but everything within a political event horizon surrounding it.

There were arguments that Buzzfeed was attacking it's potential readers for political reasons to their own detriment. I think the meme "get woke, go broke" hints at this. The question is why did they and so many other new media outlets let ideology get in the way of their own success?

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by maccio92 on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:40PM (#19019346)
maybe people are finally sick of trashy clickbait tabloid articles?
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by ravenstine on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:15PM (#19019671)
Not only that, but we really don't need journalists in the traditional sense as much as we used to. It wasn't even that long ago that newspapers and TV were people's eyes and ears. Now anyone with a phone can record video of events as they happen, and anyone with a YouTube channel can report on the news and make political commentary for a mere fraction of the overhead that media firms operate on.

This isn't to say that there isn't value in traditional journalism, and I think the viability of member-supported radio is a testament to that. But the old guard of for-profit journalism is obsolete, and it's quickening its own death by going hog-wild with unverified sources, hit pieces, and lack of fact checking.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by reaperducer on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:38PM (#19019873)
we really don't need journalists in the traditional sense as much as we used to

Are you under the impression that government corruption and injustice are things of the past?

Now anyone with a phone can record video of events as they happen, and anyone with a YouTube channel can report on the news and make political commentary for a mere fraction of the overhead that media firms operate on.

Except that we live in a world of deepfakes, astroturfing, and a dozen other reasons not to trust what is posted on the internet by any random person.

And building on my comment above, Random Joe isn't going to spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars investigating illegal arms sales, contract fraud, or hundreds of other things that big journalism companies do routinely.

member-supported radio is a testament to that

Member-supported radio doesn't cover 1/1000th of what local newspapers do.

I think you may not understand the value of professional journalism, past and present, perhaps because you haven't been exposed to it, or its consequences.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by ravenstine on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:52PM (#19020018)
> Are you under the impression that government corruption and injustice are things of the past?

Oh, come now.

> Except that we live in a world of deepfakes, astroturfing, and a dozen other reasons not to trust what is posted on the internet by any random person.

And professional journalists are going to be immune to these things? A lot of the time, journalists actually repost what they see on Twitter and YouTube. I suppose that in an ideal world journalists would wise up in the face of deep fakes and trust their various sources a lot less, but caution != profit.

> And building on my comment above, Random Joe isn't going to spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars investigating illegal arms sales, contract fraud, or hundreds of other things that big journalism companies do routinely.

I don't agree that you need Big Journalism for that job to be done. Individuals in the press who are outside Big Journalism, as you put it, can do the same job independently and for a fraction of the cost.

> Member-supported radio doesn't cover 1/1000th of what local newspapers do.

Sure, local newspapers have an edge over public radio, but you can also use that same argument against Big Journalism, which despite its resources can't do the same job that local newspapers do.

> I think you may not understand the value of professional journalism, past and present, perhaps because you haven't been exposed to it, or its consequences.

That's not a fair assessment at all.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by achillesheels on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:37PM (#19022629)
I don’t comprehend the romance of journalism like the parent comment, especially in light of a Harvey Weinstein scandal which revealed he had a payroll of journalists. These are people that are profit motivated like any other human being, and will often kiss the ring rather than shine light upon it.

Idealism often dies when people start owning larger personal responsibilities.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by nopriorarrests on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:37PM (#19020366)
Are you under the impression that government corruption and injustice are things of the past?

I'm under impression that government corruption and injustice has little to do with kim kardashian reaction gifs. Yes, I know about Buzzfeed News, see below.

I think you may not understand the value of professional journalism, past and present, perhaps because you haven't been exposed to it, or its consequences.

Yeah, no. I can give you one recent example of professional journalism. Series of articles by John Carreyrou about Theranos, which were later followed by "Bad Blood" book.

Buzzfeed had 1700 (!) employees, as of Dec 2017, according to wikipedia.

Had the whole buzzfeed, news included, produced anything remotely comparable?

Do not degrade professional journalism by comparing it with Buzzfeed.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by ameister14 on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:24PM (#19019727)
I actually think we need curation a great deal nowadays - there is definitely a market for it, if nothing else. The massive amount of chaff 'content' is hard to wade through. Your second paragraph is dead on, though.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by gnhrgkai on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:12PM (#19020172)
Curation is a solved problem: # of retweets/likes/upvotes.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by yabatopia on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:05PM (#19020580)
That's popularity tracking, not curation.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by gnhrgkai on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:16PM (#19020676)
It is curation of the most popular things, which in turn are the ones that matter to most people.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by jsgo on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @02:40PM (#19029209)
Maybe in the sense of articles it can be of benefit, but with video or images it can be bereft of context which can stray, intentionally or not, towards misinformation.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by droopyEyelids on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:47PM (#19019969)
To me, this reads like someone saying "You don't need graphs if you have the raw data"

Journalists, in their true form, turn data into information.

That is more important than ever in our context free world of video snippets and misleading quotes.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by ravenstine on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:55PM (#19020044)
I do agree that we need raw data. Sadly, we're not getting enough of it, and part of the cause is the speed of the news cycle; it's far more expedient for someone to write prose than spend the time gathering raw data, making sense of it, and distilling that data into graphs.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by jvagner on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:09PM (#19020160)
my latest theory is that people like participating in the news cycle more than they are inclined to consume it. click-bait and fake news lets people instantly rage / share, where as good journalism would be valuable to people who want to pause, comprehend and have an outlet that isn't just sharing, raging, etc.

which is probably why even big brand journalism hasn't really changed. the list of outlets that i block on twitter and apple news (the latest of which is forbes, for yet another installment in their "latest iPhone update has a NASTY SURPRISE" articles) grows weekly, but i can't get out of the clickbait content tsunami.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by ravenstine on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:22PM (#19020253)
> my latest theory is that people like participating in the news cycle more than they are inclined to consume it.

That's an interesting observation. It seems like how most people who watch sports have little to no interest in playing themselves, even recreationally, but they "join" a team because of the sense of participation they get. Not sure if that's the best analogy, but it's reminiscent for me.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by thrusong on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:33PM (#19020809)
In a world where everyone has a video camera in their pocket and AI can generate deep fakes, maybe we'll come full circle to where traditional gatekeepers are needed once again to verify the accuracy of the information out there.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Xamayon on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:49PM (#19019430)
I think this is a large part of it. At some point I stopped falling for clickbait titles, unnecessarily drawn out slide show style articles, etc. These days, the automatic response I have is to block sites which waste my time. If that kills off sites which peddle such crap, maybe the media landscape will improve...
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Xamayon on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:59PM (#19019508)
I do my best to, but the number of news sources which treat my time as important is dropping fast. It's all about the quick buck these days. hn is a great filter for tech stuff, which is a big part of why I'm here~
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by yuy910616 on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:52PM (#19019457)
do you instead pay for a good, reputable source of news?
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by mondo9000 on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:20PM (#19019701)
I tried the Wall Street Journal Online, since I think news about money is more real, but their website wasn't very good [1], I think there's still hope to get paying subscribers if the online reading experience is more pleasant.

1) Right now WSJ has three columns of text because they want consistency with their hardcopy, but it doesn't feel right for a laptop.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Varcht on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:24PM (#19019730)
Do you have any suggestions? Are there any reputable sources remaining? Not sure I could trust any single source ever again. Not enough to pay for it anyways.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by swebs on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:43PM (#19019919)
Associated Press, Reuters, Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Varcht on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:51PM (#19020475)
AP has had a lot of "opinion..." in it's feeds over the last couple years. I used to be a big fan of their uncurated "Raw Feed" but they decided that was not something they wanted to expose any longer.

The others are ok sources but still too much opinion mixed in for my money. Can't somebody just give us the facts?

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by pbalau on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:50PM (#19020947)
> Bloomberg

What happened with that story about the magic Chinese spying chip, found only on SuperMicro motherboards sold to Apple? Did they prove it true? Did they retract it?

There is a point about this, if I can't trust them with things I have an idea about, how can I trust them with things totally foreign to me?

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by yuy910616 on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:37PM (#19019855)
axios, economist, and this very article you're reading. i also read bill bishop's newsletter, very good as well
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by ytNumbers on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:44PM (#19019935)
Some of the journalists who used to work for companies like Buzzfeed have joined the YouTube cottage industry of reporting as an independent journalist. Unlike 90% of the mainstream news media, these individual journalists are not owned and controlled by six billionaires. They make their living via the tiny percentage of their audience that is willing to pay them through sites like Patreon. The recent Covington mis-reporting by the mainstream media should start to wake people up regarding the need to receive one's news from independent journalists. Regarding specific recommendations... He's a little more left wing than I'd prefer, but I'd still recommend Tim Pool's YouTube channel.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by yuy910616 on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:44PM (#19019393)
i'm not sure if you're trolling..but i'll bite. buzzfeed has done a lot of good, real journalism. the trashy, click-bait articles in a way is funding good journalism, which, if you purely consume buzzfeed through fb or something like that...you might think that is all there is. besides, you should read the article, not just the headline. as ben addresses your issue in the opening paragraph.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by reaperducer on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:40PM (#19019890)
the trashy, click-bait articles in a way is funding good journalism

The problem is that the trash tarnishes the brand its reputation. Buzzfeed may do great things, but I won't read any of it because the overwhelming majority of what it publishes is crap, and I never know if a headline is important, or clickbait.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by mgfist on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:43PM (#19020407)
It's pretty easy to tell which side of Buzzfeed the article comes from. The investigative side has proper titles while the clickbait ones have a "Click here to see these 10 crazy news titles, #7 will blow your mind" kinda title
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Bartweiss on Monday January 28, 2019 @04:37PM (#19021319)
This is sort of true - you can at least discern the listicles - but even their Pulitzer-nominated work has titles like "From Russia with Blood" and "The Man Who Knew Too Much".

I'm not inherently against those titles, even the NYT gets a bit cute with their longform stuff to draw in readers. But it is a bit more frustrating when there are lots of vacuous articles to sort through; it's still pretty hard to discern their investigative stuff from the fluffy longform pieces.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Bartweiss on Monday January 28, 2019 @04:29PM (#19021251)
In principle, BuzzFeed could just be a site with deep news coverage alongside fluff, not much different than a newspaper with real news, comics, and 'society' pages. To some extent, Buzzfeed even managed that: their BuzzFeed News subheader has lots of award-winning content without garbage listicles.

Of course, the BuzzFeed News imprint has a whole section devoted to R. Kelly right now, and seems to be aiming no higher than a CNN or USA Today mix of hard news and fluff. Add to that the occasional bout of serious hackwork written in their "real news" style, and I'm not overflowing with hope.

Perhaps more to the point, it looks like this composite approach didn't actually balance the books, or we wouldn't be seeing layoffs right now.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Aunche on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:23PM (#19019718)
From a branding perspective, that seems like it would be doomed to failure. They can capture some of the younger demographic but completely alienate anyone who already who already pays for the news. For example, I personally find Buzzfeed News articles to be more sensationalist than most reputable newspapers, but that's probably because I subconsciously am more skeptical of anything that comes out of buzzfeed.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by Bartweiss on Monday January 28, 2019 @05:28PM (#19021672)
> the trashy, click-bait articles in a way is funding good journalism

I used to be pretty optimistic about this model, starting around the time Buzzfeed hired Mike Giglio from Newsweek and started doing in-depth stories on Syria. After all, traditional newspapers run cartoons and ads; even the NYT runs an extensive Features section. BuzzFeed looked like a modernized version of that same practice, with its fluff model updated to interest an online, click-based audience instead of a subscriber on Sunday morning.

But these layoffs call into question whether clickbait is in fact a way of funding good journalism, or whether Buzzfeed was just converting investment money into respectability. Buzzfeed overall is cutting staff 15% over multiple rounds of layoffs, but Buzzfeed News already dropped 17% of staff in round one. The entire teams for national news, national security, and health went, as did the Spain office. Maybe tellingly, the entertainment desk kept two staffers.

I think it's still an open question what the role of serious longform work is for Buzzfeed. One narrative says that the individual readers value both investigative and fluffy content from one source. If that's true, good reporting isn't an act of charity. It's just low-margin content produced to keep readers (or maybe staff?) in the same way that grocery stores sell staples like eggs basically at-cost while they profit elsewhere. Another narrative says that listicle readers (and writers) don't care about the presence of serious coverage (at least from Buzzfeed), so if any part of Buzzfeed News isn't running a profit it's not advancing the company.

(Even more broadly, I think it's an open question whether there's any known way to profit on mass distribution of investigative journalism. It seems to rely on patronage models, outright charity, or in a few areas contract work like Bloomberg Terminal.)

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by swebs on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:29PM (#19019786)
Award winning reporting right here:

http://archive.is/X4eRs

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by thecatspaw on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:42PM (#19019913)
They have indeed gotten nominated multiple times for the pulitzer award https://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/staff-buzzfeed-news
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by TheHypnotist on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:56PM (#19020062)
BuzzFeed and BuzzFeed News are different in this respect.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by bernardlunn on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:37PM (#19020371)
Yes
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by pornel on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:43PM (#19019379)
It's worrying, because it's another indicator that journalism is fucked (BTW, BuzzFeed is known for clickbait meme-crap, but BuzzFeedNews was surprisingly serious publication).

While it was easy to dismiss failures of pre-internet publications as merely failing to adapt to the new medium, BuzzFeedNews was Internet-native, and still failed.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by brettnak on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:53PM (#19019463)
It's interesting to see so many new businesses forget the lessons that previous businesses learned. Brand identity and trust used to be the foundation of businesses, and at some level (I'm not sure what level) it still is. Even as someone educated on the differences between BF & BFN, I still never knew how to take BFN seriously with all the regular crap on BF. I don't really feel like it's my job to figure out how they fit together, and it would have been pretty simple just to completely split the brands if they actually wanted to have the two faces of the company. To the average internet reader, there was no difference between BF and BFN. People have either always known, or are learning (however slowly) that they can't vet every story themselves and they have to trust. BF corrupted that with their two faces.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by NeedMoreTea on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:05PM (#19019573)
> Brand identity and trust used to be the foundation of businesses, and at some level (I'm not sure what level) it still is.

I think that was much more the case when the brand was the only brand. When the company lived or died by its chocolate, or single brand of appliances etc, even if the founder was gone, I think a lot of care was taken. Now a brand is commonly one of 10 or 30 in a portfolio, I don't think there's much care left.

When the parent has a dozen appliance brands you can play loose with the trust of any or all. Half the product may be little more than badge engineering. When there's dozens of food brands in the book, or the market leading brand gets bought, it's virtually certain they will be worse than they used to be. Often quite a lot. The perception of the brand might carry that for years.

BF is an odd one as it's trying to become a respectable news outlet, without letting go of the junk that made them. Now the perception has to go the other way, up. A much more difficult move.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by bmurphy1976 on Monday January 28, 2019 @02:15PM (#19020196)
The appliance makers are particularly insidious. They have cheapo brand and luxury brand, but luxury brand is often just slightly modified cheapo brand. As people get wise to this, suddenly luxury brand becomes the new cheapo brand and ultra-luxury brand is the new must have luxury brand. Cheapo brand goes away (end of life!!) so time to upgrade!

At least (for now) if you buy a Samsung or LG you know who to be pissed off at.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by dylan604 on Monday January 28, 2019 @06:51PM (#19022321)
It is weird how things have flipped, but at the same time makes sense if you look at it from the bean counter's view. It used to be that companies would start with the luxury brand. These would cost premium prices, and would last in a time frame in line with their prices. They would then take features away (or just disable them) to make the lower tiers. Sometimes this meant replacing a metal something with a plastic something. The prices would be cheaper reflecting the missing options. It might not last as long, but it was a fraction of the price. Now, it seems like everything is just a cheap plastic something, and the entire thing is cheap enough to just buy a new whole thing instead of repairing the broken component. The prices are now in the middle pushing back up towards the premium pricing, but for much lower quality product.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by NeedMoreTea on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:56PM (#19022724)
Makes sense if you don't mind killing the golden goose. Same sales with far more profit, but only until public perception catches up with the reality that the big brand is now as bad, or worse, than some cheap competitor.

Sometimes you only need to buy the reformulated market leader once to realise there's no reason to ever buy it again.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by NeedMoreTea on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:53PM (#19022708)
Vehicles too. Buy the same bearing where the price depends on whether it comes in a VW, Audi or Porsche packet. Touareg vs Cayenne.

Trust may turn out to have been a 20th century concept.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by CM30 on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:21PM (#19020715)
Well perhaps Buzzfeed News shouldn't have had the word 'Buzzfeed' in it. I mean, most large companies make sure their brand names are far more distinct than that...

(like Buzzfeed's equally dodgy counterpart, News Corp and its different newspaper/news site names).

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by AJ007 on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:15PM (#19020667)
I’m not sure that the average internet reader knew the difference between buzzfeed, buzzfeed news, the New York Times, and any random fake news site a 16 year old threw up.

At the time, my view was that, Buzzfeed, and others, were just attempting to ride the tsunami of free Facebook traffic for a wildly bloated valuation in hopes to hoodwink a legacy media company into buying them before the party ended. They spent what would have been their profits, and then some, on shining their turds. It was a gamble and they mostly lost.

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by minimaxir on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:54PM (#19019475)
The layoffs in this case are especially unusual as they are indiscriminate: BF employees with years of experience at the company and championed the company’s growth have been hit.

Here’a a new post by the Director of Quizzes who was laid off: http://www.fluxblog.org/2019/01/how-laid-off-are-you/

Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by sct202 on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:27PM (#19019765)
I love how fun his former title of Director of Quizzes sounds, but it's so sad to read his reflection that a random user in Michigan has been producing free content that has driven so much traffic to Buzzfeed that he's redundant.
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by berberous on Monday January 28, 2019 @01:00PM (#19019529)
Re:The Buzzfeed Lesson by monksy on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:54PM (#19019476)
They're good at getting their message out and submarining things.