News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by amluto on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @05:48PM (#18802906)
As a personal anecdote, I've spent quite a bit of time watching toddlers interact with the world. In my experience, if it looks like a button, a toddler can tell it's a button and will be interested in pushing it. (And might even say "button"!) If it looks like a switch, a toddler will be interested in switching it. If it looks like a button on a touch screen, a toddler might still think it's a button. If it's a flat blob that looks like every other flat blob designed by that designer (but looks nothing like a flat blob by other designers!), toddlers don't recognize it as a button. Shocker, I know.

Obviously, the majority of computer users aren't toddlers, but I think there's a lesson here. I really miss the old Windows 3.1 / 95 / 98 days when controls were more or less standardized and you could reliably tell which were buttons, which were radio buttons, which were okay buttons, etc.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by eitland on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @12:53AM (#18804458)
> Obviously, the majority of computer users aren't toddlers, but I think there's a lesson here. I really miss the old Windows 3.1 / 95 / 98 days when controls were more or less standardized and you could reliably tell which were buttons, which were radio buttons, which were okay buttons, etc.

Agree.

Also: tooltip help when you hover over an icon.

Also: menus (for discoverability)

Also: manuals/help files (yep, most software shoudn't need one, but now we are in a worst-of-all-state: new software is not self explanatory, doesn't use familiar designs and the manual is gone :-/)

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by buboard on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:40AM (#18805145)
Sounds like reinventing the wheel and ending up with a square was not a great idea. Not a good sign for the tech industry when it starts going around in circles instead of advancing.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by m_mueller on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:39AM (#18805362)
IMO human device interfaces have been going in circles ever since Doug Engelbart's demo in 1968.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by eitland on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @11:03AM (#18807039)
Larger and larger circles to some degree (a large percentage of the earths population now have access to advanced technology.)
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by m_mueller on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:38AM (#18805360)
even better regarding discoverability: the macOS menu search, available under "help".
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by ericol on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:50PM (#18803405)
When my youngest daughter was still a toddler, she would try to swipe on our 32" bedroom TV that was more or less at her height. What I'm trying to say is that your mileage might vary. I think it all depends on their experiences.

If something looks like a button and they try to push it, is because in real life buttons have a certain look and feel.

But I'm pretty certain that if you teach them at an early age to discern what does what in a flat UI, they'll have no problem switching from one UI to the other (I actually learned _from her_ that in the Android YT app you can swipe those pesky lower right corner videos to make them go away). And we're still to try flat in real life ;)

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by chrismorgan on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:58PM (#18803446)
> And we're still to try flat in real life

Plenty of appliances have electronic buttons, which are close to flat (though definitely not flat) and commonly paired with a flat visual style on top of them. They work pretty well, in that context.

And now plenty of appliances have capacitive controls, which are in my experience normally a disaster and literally never good (I exclude situations where a screen is involved; those are hit and miss). To take an example, microwaves: almost without fail, I find that the newer it is, the harder it is to use—though the old dials were only easier to use in certain ways, lacking precision. I now have one with a capacitive touch surface, and it’s very hard to use unless the room is brightly lit, at which point is’s merely quite painful unless I want to turn it on for exactly 30 seconds.

Decide for yourself whether these things are “real life”.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by seandougall on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @10:45PM (#18804029)
My brand new (just arrived today!) stove has these capacitive buttons, and in terms of visual style it does indeed function perfectly; it's entirely clear which parts of the interface are buttons, even though most of them have only unadorned text.

But I think that analogy falls short in one major way, which is that these buttons are logically grouped and evenly spaced across a surface that consists of _nothing but_ buttons. If there's silkscreened text there, you can press it and do something. The visual display of information happens in an LED display set aside in a well-defined area, so things to look at and things to press are 100% clearly delineated. In a desktop/mobile/web app, where content and interactive elements are interspersed, you lose that obvious context clue. That inevitably adds cognitive load, even if the interface is still technically usable.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by samatman on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @01:11AM (#18804504)
An additional problem for capacitative buttons in the kitchen is that my fingers are often moist or even wet, and this is a disaster when it comes time to punch cap. buttons.

Not only do they not work, no only do they sometimes trigger adjacent controls, but to get function back I now have to dry both my hands and the control surface.

I will never purchase a kitchen device with capacitative controls, but I run into them enough when traveling to experience this frequently. It's a mess.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by solarkraft on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:11AM (#18805259)
This is bad, but then again they will be easier to clean.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by samatman on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @07:21AM (#18805735)
The old paradigm of sealing a rubber dome button under an unbroken sheet of plastic worked just fine, my folks had a microwave for 20 years that worked that way with no switch failures.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by virgil_disgr4ce on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @09:44PM (#18803847)
With you on capacitive controls (other than touchscreens). Very often terrible, useless garbage from a UX perspective. From other perspectives they're great: can be cleaned perfectly and easily, and has no potential for mechanical failure. But none of that matters if they just aren't useable X-)
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by Double_a_92 on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#18805227)
The problem with e.g. microwaves is that with digital controls it's easy to give the user too many complicated options. All I want is to set the timer and the power, not some extra mode to specifically thaw fish...
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by sjwright on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @05:50AM (#18805402)
I agree wholeheartedly but I will say my new LG microwave is pretty good. It lets you close the door, twist a knob and press start. All the complexity of weird preset modes is condensed down to a few essentials. You can dial up a frozen bread defrost setting, but it's done in a way that keeps the interface simple for everyday use.

The buttons are capacitive but they're very responsive and it's easy to wipe down.

https://www.lg.com/au/microwave-ovens/lg-MS4266OBS

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by chrismorgan on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @07:15AM (#18805715)
Such knobs are fairly lousy in this way: they lack a start and end point. This is a standard failing of modern things: it’s easier to implement generically useful functionality this way, but it’s objectively inferior in most concrete cases. (Another example: ebooks with unanchored scrolling instead of physical books with pagination where you can feel how far you are through the book. You have no reference point.)

Old microwaves had a clear, directional knob with a start point, an end point, and markings for the values they represented. Barring the question of precision (which could be more or less solved with a more strikingly non-linear dial), that’s positively superb. My ideal microwave has only the following controls: such a dial (you could do some pretty fancy active magnetic design on it to improve it and make it precise, over the old knobs), probably another dial or slider (I’m open to trying it out) for power level, and that’s it. I’d be willing to discuss a +30s start button which moved the knob into the right place for you, and some sort of digital timer for potentially easier reading from a distance. No start button or stop button or open button, because the door opening and closing is better than the old microwaves.

Now it is possible for an unanchored knob to be good; I have in mind a tuning knob from a fairly expensive radio from fifty or more years ago, where they had clearly put a lot of effort into its friction profile. But I’ve never seen such a thing in the digital age, only ever in the analogue world. (Hmm… I wonder whether sound boards count. They may be an exception.) In the digital age, knobs are normally just glorified less/more buttons with very coarse quantisation.

My microwave is similar to yours, but a cheaper model, with most notably a capacitive touch strip instead of the knob; it’s awful.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by sjwright on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:09PM (#18809672)
Half the time, my microwaving action consists of closing the door and pressing [start/+30sec] however many times is required.

Sometimes I twist the knob until the display shows the desired time—in this respect it works like an iPod.

And when I want to defrost bread, I know it's Defrost program 4. Or if I want something else, the list of programs is helpfully silk-screened behind the door.

Maybe my expectations are low, having owned a Panasonic for the previous 9 years. But I'm genuinely happy with it. It works for me.

(I did see the capacitive touch strip model and actively avoided it. I knew I'd hate it without even trying it.)

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by buboard on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:42AM (#18805157)
Depth perception contours and borders are instantly recognizable by our visual system, even toddlers. Learning to read letters fast comes much later in life so i would say it's probably much more difficult to teach little children
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by amluto on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @09:57AM (#18806515)
In modern flat UIs, it seems fashionable to have clickable things that are not visually distinguishable at all.

As a silly example, I just opened the Google Maps app. Basically everything is clickable or swipable, but there is no visual consistency whatsoever. I suppose “everything is a control” is a viable model, but it breaks down if you want to show content, too.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by dehrmann on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @06:43PM (#18803147)
> I really miss the old Windows 3.1 / 95 / 98 days

You could say the same for early iOS apps that just used the default Apple widgets and style. I think ~every app I use know has its own style.

Funny enough, this is less true on computers. Except games.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by emn13 on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @03:13AM (#18804892)
And "gamer tools". Boy, are those resoundingly, universally terrible. Have you ever touched an overclocking GUI or whatever management tool for "gamer features" your motherboard/other hardware has?

It's often ludicrously bad.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by buboard on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:41AM (#18805148)
do they also have midi music playing?
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by karmakaze on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @06:10PM (#18802996)
A similar 'experiment' with similar results is landing page optimization. You want to be very clear what you're trying to communicate and what you want the visitor to do with as few distractions as possible.

It turns out the same types of optimizations that you make on a landing page are good UI/UX features for past-middle-aged people to use. Computers don't have to be hard, we just put everything on the screen and have the user sort through what each thing does and whether it's in or out of context for the current action.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by iamben on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:17PM (#18803280)
100% agree with this and the parent.

Especially with landing pages I aim for the 'mum' test. She's in her 60s and is petrified of computers. If someone like her understands what has to be done / the messaging is clear / the flow of the page directs her to do what I want, it'll probably be a success.

Anecdotally I remember being on a call with my dad (in his 60s) trying to talk him through downloading and installing some antivirus software from download.com (or whatever it was back a few years back). Frustratingly it kept going wrong - "I'm pressing to the download button, but it's just not working!" Except he wasn't. Eventually we figured out he was clicking a banner ad because it "looked like a button," far more so than the flat, actual download button. On a site like that, I often wonder whether it's entirely by design. Happy advertisers get more clicks (albeit probably with shitty conversion), happy site owners get to charge more knowing they provide more clicks. Everyone wins. Except my 65 year old dad.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by userbinator on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:26PM (#18803316)
Eventually we figured out he was clicking a banner ad because it "looked like a button," far more so than the flat, actual download button. On a site like that, I often wonder whether it's entirely by design.

Most certainly yes. In fact, recognition of "false download buttons", and almost instinctively and subconsciously ignoring them in the same manner as banner ads, comes with experience such that there have been times when I've been confused by pages where the real download button looks exactly like the bloated fake ones that I've become accustomed to mentally filtering out. I find that when I'm looking to download something, I tend to go towards direct links that actually show a destination URL when you over over them, vs. buttons that don't.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by sizzle on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @02:43AM (#18804807)
More often than not, the landing page represents the internal (dis)organization of business units vying for the most valuable visual real estate (e.g. sales team wants contact info, marketing team wants clickable advertisements, etc) and designers hands are forced to oblige by senior management. These distractions are constant battles that take tons of time iterating placement and user testing to get right from a UX perspective and often is neglected. Usability testing gets most of the low hanging fruit given a sufficient sample size.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by sharpercoder on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @06:14PM (#18803016)
I suspect there's actually quite a market to develop such UI for. Given a service that standardizes UI over a wide array of applications (web apps, mobile apps, desktop apps), I bet there's a large enough market for it.

Implementation would be interesting and most likely quite hard to achieve, though.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by dredmorbius on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @11:45PM (#18804238)
Not all software came out of the Win32.dll (or earlier, or later) worlds.

Having worked on a number of platforms (MVS, CMS, VMS, Unix, plus the usual desktop kit), I'd come to recognise signatures of those platforms. Under Unix, recognising the original X11 Xt, Athena, Motif, Tcl/Tk, gtk, Qt, Java, and Gnome toolkits is largely second nature.

No, all applications don't look and behave the same. (Xt scrollbars FTFW!!!).

But: if you do recognise the toolkits, you've got a pretty good idea of the provenance of the application, and how it's going to behave and what quirks it will have. At least up to a point.

I do still prefer button-resembling-buttons.

Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by z3t4 on Tuesday January 01, 2019 @07:20PM (#18803290)
It's fun to see them trying to grab the icons, they probably look tasty.
Re:Flat Design vs. Traditional Design: Comparative Experimen... by buboard on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @04:39AM (#18805137)
Windows 7 is still nonflat.