Plenty of appliances have electronic buttons, which are close to flat (though definitely not flat) and commonly paired with a flat visual style on top of them. They work pretty well, in that context.
And now plenty of appliances have capacitive controls, which are in my experience normally a disaster and literally never good (I exclude situations where a screen is involved; those are hit and miss). To take an example, microwaves: almost without fail, I find that the newer it is, the harder it is to use—though the old dials were only easier to use in certain ways, lacking precision. I now have one with a capacitive touch surface, and it’s very hard to use unless the room is brightly lit, at which point is’s merely quite painful unless I want to turn it on for exactly 30 seconds.
Decide for yourself whether these things are “real life”.
But I think that analogy falls short in one major way, which is that these buttons are logically grouped and evenly spaced across a surface that consists of _nothing but_ buttons. If there's silkscreened text there, you can press it and do something. The visual display of information happens in an LED display set aside in a well-defined area, so things to look at and things to press are 100% clearly delineated. In a desktop/mobile/web app, where content and interactive elements are interspersed, you lose that obvious context clue. That inevitably adds cognitive load, even if the interface is still technically usable.
Not only do they not work, no only do they sometimes trigger adjacent controls, but to get function back I now have to dry both my hands and the control surface.
I will never purchase a kitchen device with capacitative controls, but I run into them enough when traveling to experience this frequently. It's a mess.
The buttons are capacitive but they're very responsive and it's easy to wipe down.
Old microwaves had a clear, directional knob with a start point, an end point, and markings for the values they represented. Barring the question of precision (which could be more or less solved with a more strikingly non-linear dial), that’s positively superb. My ideal microwave has only the following controls: such a dial (you could do some pretty fancy active magnetic design on it to improve it and make it precise, over the old knobs), probably another dial or slider (I’m open to trying it out) for power level, and that’s it. I’d be willing to discuss a +30s start button which moved the knob into the right place for you, and some sort of digital timer for potentially easier reading from a distance. No start button or stop button or open button, because the door opening and closing is better than the old microwaves.
Now it is possible for an unanchored knob to be good; I have in mind a tuning knob from a fairly expensive radio from fifty or more years ago, where they had clearly put a lot of effort into its friction profile. But I’ve never seen such a thing in the digital age, only ever in the analogue world. (Hmm… I wonder whether sound boards count. They may be an exception.) In the digital age, knobs are normally just glorified less/more buttons with very coarse quantisation.
My microwave is similar to yours, but a cheaper model, with most notably a capacitive touch strip instead of the knob; it’s awful.
Sometimes I twist the knob until the display shows the desired time—in this respect it works like an iPod.
And when I want to defrost bread, I know it's Defrost program 4. Or if I want something else, the list of programs is helpfully silk-screened behind the door.
Maybe my expectations are low, having owned a Panasonic for the previous 9 years. But I'm genuinely happy with it. It works for me.
(I did see the capacitive touch strip model and actively avoided it. I knew I'd hate it without even trying it.)
As a silly example, I just opened the Google Maps app. Basically everything is clickable or swipable, but there is no visual consistency whatsoever. I suppose “everything is a control” is a viable model, but it breaks down if you want to show content, too.
If something looks like a button and they try to push it, is because in real life buttons have a certain look and feel.
But I'm pretty certain that if you teach them at an early age to discern what does what in a flat UI, they'll have no problem switching from one UI to the other (I actually learned _from her_ that in the Android YT app you can swipe those pesky lower right corner videos to make them go away). And we're still to try flat in real life ;)