News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by apk-d on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:42PM (#18763772)
Our descendants are going to be seriously confused by our practice of limiting or taking away people's ability to earn money because they publicly used a wrong word. Or so I hope, at least.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by endisukaj on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:46PM (#18763806)
The right to free speech protects you from being persecuted by the government. Patreon and any other private company reserve the right to choose their customers (and workers) based on what they say. This has always been the case. There are countless examples, even in the past, where companies have fired employees for saying things they shouldn't have.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by atom-morgan on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:51PM (#18763860)
The issue is Jack Conte said behavior that isn't on "Patreon the platform itself" wouldn't be policed by Patreon.

And here we are.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by ng12 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:54PM (#18763892)
Free speech as a concept has been around for a lot longer than the US government.

The problem is if free speech is effectively banned from the internet due to the internet being controlled by a handful of private companies, do we still have free speech?

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:59PM (#18763939)
Let's stay on topic here; being banned from Patreon doesn't limit his speech at all.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by ng12 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:14PM (#18764051)
But what happens when Patreon, Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, Reddit, Twitch and PayPal all work together to create collective censorship? Is your speech being limited if you're functionally blocked from the meaningfully accessible parts of the internet?

Yes, these are all private companies. In fact someone already tried to create an alternative Patreon (called Hatreon, iirc) that was shut down by Visa. Allowing censorship by private companies doesn't work if private companies control who gets to exist on the internet.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by ryandrake on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:54PM (#18764361)
What happens is what's already happening: These platforms start becoming less and less diverse echo chambers where only Silicon Valley approved opinions and world views are allowed, and people who do not hold those opinions or views go off and find alternative services, further isolating people from each other, into their own ideological rabbit holes.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @04:30PM (#18765099)
We're talking about Patreon here. These guys are effectively selling their opinions; their supporters want to give them money so that they keep producing their opinions.

What happens if I try to exercise my speech by selling little racist caricature dolls? Walmart, Target, KMart and 7-11 would refuse to stock them. Is my free speech being limited if I'm functionally blocked from the meaningfully accessible parts of our capitalist system?

No, and it would be ludicrous to suggest that grocery stores owe me shelf space.

(Facebook, Reddit and Twitch are a different animal altogether; Comcast, Time Warner, etc. are yet another leve lremoved.)

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by lancesells on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:41PM (#18764256)
No, your speech is still safe even if Comcast cuts off your service. The internet does not equal freedom of speech. Just because the barrier of entry to Twitter or Facebook is considerably easier than appearing on CNN they are companies that can have rules regarding who they allow on.

If people are being arrested for what they are saying then that's censorship and something to be worried about.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by harimau777 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:56PM (#18763921)
As I see it, a functional democracy requires tolerance of unpopular opinions not just by the government but also by society at large. I don't agree with these sorts of statements, but I believe that censoring them is harmful to society.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by zimpenfish on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:56PM (#18764379)
> a functional democracy requires tolerance of unpopular opinions not just by the government but also by society at large

If you insert "some" before "unpopular", I'm with you. If you require "all" before "unpopular", then no, I disagree - e.g. people who believe "LGBTQ people should be done away" with, well, that's an "unpopular opinion" that should not be tolerated and, in fact, should be made anathema for anyone to express.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by PavlovsCat on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @11:20PM (#18767275)
That's because it has other properties besides being unpopular.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by zimpenfish on Thursday December 27, 2018 @01:46AM (#18767894)
What other (I'm assuming redeeming since if they're not redeeming, why would we care?) properties could the opinion "LGBTQ people should be done away with" have?
[dead]
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by dang on Thursday December 27, 2018 @04:02AM (#18768397)
This comment breaks several of the site guidelines. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and post civilly and substantively, or not at all.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by zimpenfish on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:15PM (#18764507)
> So we should do away with them?

With some unpopular opinions, yes.

> Your comment is illogical.

Could you explain why?

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by Lkjhmnbv on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:32PM (#18764626)
How do you do away with unpopular opinions when people decide they disagree with you?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by zimpenfish on Thursday December 27, 2018 @01:49AM (#18767902)
If they're unpopular opinions, people are already disagreeing, aren't they? Anyway, the same way we do away with anything - gather support, shun the opinion makers, educate the rest, make it economically unviable to support the position, etc.
[dead]
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by dang on Friday December 28, 2018 @03:28AM (#18775523)
We've banned this account for violating the site guidelines and ignoring our request to stop.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by ivl on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:39PM (#18764689)
This runs into the paradox of tolerance[1]. Net, when the things being censored are say, advocating for genocide, the harm they can lead to is much greater than not having people advocating for genocide.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by iguy on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:56PM (#18763919)
No, the 1st Amendment attempts to protect this valuable thing in the same way that the 21st Amendment protects your booze supply.

Free speech is a much bigger, and older, idea. And can be seriously threatened by many small changes in our public culture, which need not have anything to do with Washington.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by OscarCunningham on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:02PM (#18763965)
Just because one form of free speech is enshrined in The First Amendment, doesn't mean that other forms aren't also good.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by jhawk28 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:52PM (#18763866)
The danger is related to the centralized power of aggregators becomes close to the power that governments have over a single part of society.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by cm2187 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:04PM (#18764434)
But then what do you think of the McCarthy era, when private companies (Hollywood majors) wouldn't touch someone who was suspected of communism, making it impossible for them to find work?

By your standards it's all OK, because it's not the government?

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by avbor on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:53PM (#18763872)
The English language is pretty large. There are a good number of alternatives to using the word he did that would be safe. He didn't have to use that word, but either did because he uses it often and is comfortable with it, or purposefully thought it would be a good use there. Both of which are questionable.

I'd also argue that Patreon isn't obligated at all to help him earn money here. It's not a employee employer relationship here, and they can choose to not to continue to help a person that they deem harmful to other customers.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:46PM (#18763800)
> taking away people's ability to earn money

On a single platform. Nobody's preventing Mr. Benjamin from making money; they're just not allowing him to use one specific platform.

He's welcome to sign up for Hatreon, or to use a payment processor directly.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by fb-denier on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:01PM (#18763956)
One does not simply use a payment processor directly. Stripe and PayPal both deplatformed within a week the Patreon alternative that the guy went to after being kicked off Patreon (SubscribeStar). Hatreon was also deplatformed by their payment processor, as noted below. In another recent instance, MasterCard demanded that Patreon kick off another person for political reasons [1]. Social network Gab is now accepting USD payments only by mailed check for their premium tier. Of course, the pioneer modern instance of being financially deplatformed was Wikileaks, who was deplatformed by both Visa and MasterCard for political reasons. I've gained a new respect for Bitcoin from this incident. If you can't digitally send USD to another person to do legal things, USD has a problem.

[1] https://twitter.com/Patreon/status/1029551216886341634

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by darkpuma on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:09PM (#18764014)
> "MasterCard demanded that Patreon kick off another person for political reasons."

If true that's disturbing. At a certain point you have to wonder if we're getting close to the spirit of Marsh v. Alabama (e.g the constitutionality of restricting speech in towns that are privately owned by corporations.)

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by zimpenfish on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:00PM (#18764406)
> If true that's disturbing.

"Jihad Watch" seems a fairly obvious hate site.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by PavlovsCat on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @11:23PM (#18767291)
What's a "hate site"? Anything the law would care about? If no, nuff said, if yes, why would anything but the law have to play gatekeeper?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by thelasthuman on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:43PM (#18764272)
What's stopping these people from creating a "MasterRacecard" and fulfilling their payment processing?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by username90 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @05:08PM (#18765351)
The card would need to get deals with banks and dealers, which it wouldn't get. So they would need to create their own banks as well, and then they would need to construct all supporting services for those banks as well...

I think you realize that this isn't doable.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by majkinetor on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:46PM (#18764297)
> I've gained a new respect for Bitcoin from this incident.

This

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by harimau777 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:53PM (#18763877)
I think that the potential issue is that those other options are not realistically viable. In effect private companies have become the public square. Therefore, for all practical purposes, being banned from them is the same as being banned from the public discourse.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by cambalache on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:53PM (#18763880)
And when the new payment company bans him, then what? And are you OK if Twitter bans all left leaning people just because of their beliefs?

I tend to favor the smallest government possible, because I think private companies tend to do a better work in many areas (not all of them) so I dont like government intervening. But when you have an almost defacto monopoly in certain areas (google, facebook, twitter) banning people who has not broken the law should be illegal, plain and simple.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:57PM (#18763926)
> And when the new payment company bans him, then what?

Then he'll learn a valuable lesson about what is and isn't owed to him in life. Why do you suppose that the world owes everyone a soapbox that dispenses money?

> And are you OK if Twitter bans all left leaning people just because of their beliefs?

I'd be miffed, but that's their right. For example, it seems like Tumblr is making almost that exact mistake, as did Livejournal before them. I'm annoyed by it, but in the end it's their court and all I can do is shake my head, take my ball, and head home.

> But when you have an almost defacto monopoly in certain areas (google, facebook, twitter) banning people who has not broken the law should be illegal, plain and simple.

Patreon isn't on that list, so I assume that your small-government philosophy allows for them to stop supporting Mr. Benjamin and his cohorts.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by cambalache on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:11PM (#18764022)
So would you agree with a new black listing in Hollywood for example?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:57PM (#18764820)
A what?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by cambalache on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @05:01PM (#18765309)
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by nkurz on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @05:33PM (#18765489)
The Hollywood blacklist—as the broader entertainment industry blacklist is generally known—was the practice of denying employment to screenwriters, actors, directors, musicians, and American entertainment professionals during the mid-20th century because they were accused of having Communist ties or sympathies.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_blacklist

He's asking whether you think it would be reasonable to reinstate this policy, but directed against "racists" instead of communists.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by thelasthuman on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:45PM (#18764293)
Sounds like there is a hole in the market to cater to haters. Feel free to use my idea to become rich.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by Millennium on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:05PM (#18763988)
Last I checked, Hatreon didn't ban people for this sort of thing. Let him go there with his basement-dwelling buddies; that's literally what it's for.

It's the capitalist way: if some private company doesn't want your business, go to another company. If there isn't one, make one. It's all perfectly free-market compatible, and well in keeping with the Internet's ethos of letting anyone set up shop.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @03:36PM (#18764668)
How does Hatreon compare with Go-Fundie-Me?
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by basic1 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:01PM (#18763959)
Seems like many went to SubscribeStar, more because Patreon pulled a Tumblr and purged the adult content than political reasons.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by exotree on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:49PM (#18763839)
I don’t think they will be. It’s pretty easy to parse: these users don’t own Patreon; therefore, users whose speech they disagree with are not entitled to their services. This is honestly pretty well established. Patreon does not owe anyone a platform.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by krick on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:48PM (#18764311)
Sure, but it depends on how you (and the people of the future) view Patreon. It's true that Patreon does not owe anyone a platform, but neither does Facebook, or Amazon, or privately owned bank or ISP or mobile network operator. And you wouldn't really view an ISP or a bank just as "somebody, who sells you a service", right? There's only so much alternative when you choose an ISP in most of the regions, and pretty much no alternative when you "choose" Facebook. In fact, even if I don't want to have any business whatsoever with the banks, I can't avoid it. My employer just won't pay me in cash. And in some countries you won't be able to pay in cash for most services either.

And, by the way, although I'm more fond of thinking of Patreon as "just a guy, who sells a service" than as a necessity, there's not so much of an alternative for it either. AFAIK.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by daverobbins1 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @01:58PM (#18763936)
Hopefully our descendants are more confused by how we failed to get society to a place that allows people like this guy to exist.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by daverobbins1 on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @06:33PM (#18765808)
Typo: I meant “doesn’t allow people like this guy to exist”.

Society should chew up and spit out anyone who’s world view is based on hate and racism.

Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by fb-denier on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:07PM (#18764001)
Maybe not. We might be shocked that people in Europe in the past got tortured or executed for heresy and apostasy, but we're not really confused by it: if your words undermine the creeds that hold up the power structure, you are punished. It's not complicated.
Re:Patreon Bars Anti-Feminist for Racist Speech, Inciting Re... by namlem on Wednesday December 26, 2018 @02:15PM (#18764056)
Our ancestors took away people's ability to earn a living, and sometimes much more than that, because of their ethnicity or sexual orientation. People can control what opinions they voice in public. No one is forced to make racist statements. I see nothing wrong with punishing people for their choices when those choices bring harm to others.