News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @09:15PM (#1867189)
I suspect that part of the problem is that, at least with climate deniers, is that there's no real meat to their arguments. I know a few, and most of their arguments boil down to hearsay or "denier blog X says so, and who trusts Obama/the UN world government anyway". If they provided a link to something supporting their position I'd probably pass out from shock.

At least 95% of the argument with deniers is basically saying "No, you're wrong, that's been disproven by numerous studies - and here's the link". So yeah, arguing with them (or even just trying to put your point of view across) is annoying and tedious. Like any good programmer, Nigel's just automating away the drudgery.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by codefisher on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @11:29PM (#1867544)
"If they provided a link to something supporting their position I'd probably pass out from shock."

Ok I will take that as a challenge to produce a link, so how is this.

http://scienceandpublicpolicy.org/originals/policy_driven_de...

Did you pass out?

My stance is that all the name calling (ie. deniers) does not help. In the field of science a healthy level of scepticism is required, and it helps further study. It is only when an issue becomes political (Global Warning) or religious (Evolution/Creationism) and leave their scientific basis that people get pilloried for saying they are not convinced and such n' such an issue is not up to scratch and needs more research to confirm or disprove it.

As the the 95% of people. Yes that stat would be right. 95% of people are always out of their depth in any argument of any complexity. But it says nothing about their position. I have lots of friends that believe things, but if faced with a skilled debtor can't hold their own position. Nor should they have to. Life is too busy to be on top of every issue.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @12:03AM (#1867623)
Ok, so overlooking that SPPI are a notorious denier hack site, how do you explain the correlation between surface temperature records and satellite temperature records, both of which show an increase? Also, how do you explain the strong correlation between the temperature trends (ie. increase in temperature) between urban and rural areas? See http://www.skepticalscience.com/surface-temperature-measurem... and http://www.skepticalscience.com/urban-heat-island-effect-int... for details/pretty graphs.

Btw, that argument is #6 in the list of common denier arguments http://www.skepticalscience.com/argument.php

> In the field of science a healthy level of scepticism is required

Scepticism is fine, but the level of scepticism needs to be in proportion to the level of data available. The bulk of the data available strongly indicates that global warming is real, and is caused by humans. Which is why people who don't believe in global warming are now called 'deniers' - they're not really skeptics.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:35AM (#1867814)
You lost the argument at "notorious denier hack", which is ironic given that you're just re-asserting the same assertions, sans evidence, that every religious adherent to global warming always asserts. By the way, props for having the balls to cite an uninformed blog that, is using exposed-to-be-fraudulent-by-the-climategate-emails data to make your "Argument".

This is why actual debate is impossible-- you're not even aware of the terms of the science that are relevant to debate.

The absorbtion of CO2 and proportion in the atmosphere. The fact that the planet is getting colder, and that we're overdue for an ice age, and even the historical temperature cycles of the planet seem to be beyond your ken.

But you're great at calling people names and pretedning like you've got science on your side, while rejecting the scientific method itself.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:53AM (#1867857)
Sans evidence? So, satellite data, weather station data, ice core data, coral reef data, tree ring data, ad infinitum - all independent measurements, all agreeing with each other, is not enough?

Let me put it another way - what evidence would make you change your mind and accept that global warming is happening?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:00AM (#1867867)
If the planet were actually getting warmer, as CO2 goes up, over the last decade, that would go a long way towards making your theory worth listening to.

You did not provide any evidence at all. You just linked to propaganda from an advocate of your position who made assertions, sans evidence. Yet you linking to propaganda, as far as you're concerned, allows you to claim that you provided a laundry list of evidence-- yet you never even saw the evidence you claim you presented.

This is how your position is fundamentally anti-science. You don't understand the science, you haven't seen any evidence. But a link to a propagandist, proves, in your mind, that you're on the side of "Science".

By the way, the fact is, if you actually studied that data, it doesn't actually agree. Only be selectively choosing samples can you get tree ring data, ice core data, etc to agree, and only by distorting with arbitrary factors (also known as fraud) can you get weather station data and satellite data to agree.

In fact, the claim that all this data agrees with each other is itself a bit of scientific nonsense because it presumes this data were actually measuring the same thing in the same method and were actually independant.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:15AM (#1867897)
Ok, I give up. If you want to "engage in meaningful debate", you need to read the blog post, click through to the data and scientific papers where you disagree with what's said, and argue the details of what you disagree with.

Notice how you're completely avoiding the two questions that I've put to you. If you want me to continue to respond, or stop calling you a denier, or whatever, address either of those two questions. Here they are again:

How do you explain the correlation between surface temperature records and satellite temperature records, both of which show an increase?

or

What evidence would make you change your mind and accept that global warming is happening?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:24AM (#1867917)
You're saying that the only way to debate you is to go to some blog, do a bunch of research, construct arguments against that blog post, and then post them here?

Must be nice to not have to do any thinking at all- you just link to some propagandist and have your opponents (anyone foolish enough anyway) debate them.

I fell for that once, and the person's response? "Well, I never said that!"

Meanwhile, you completely ignore the arguments that I have put forth, ignore the science and facts I have referenced, and continue to demand that I answer questions that presuppose facts you have not presented.

Maybe you're just incapable of debate. Or you don't care- because this is a religion and the science really means nothing to you.

The ball is in your court. You can respond, or you can continue to equivocate. I really don't care.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by jokermatt999 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:28PM (#1869856)
Look, I'm not the guy you're arguing with, and I'll be honest and admit that I haven't looked at the data on either side enough to form a solid, evidence based opinion on AGW either way. I am not arguing for either side here. But what you're saying is ridiculous.

>You're saying that the only way to debate you is to go to some blog, do a bunch of research, construct arguments against that blog post, and then post them here?

He's asking you to look at scientific papers, the actual data on what's being argued here. This is completely reasonable when you're discussing a scientific matter. Looking at the evidence is how science is conducted.

> that presuppose facts you have not presented.

This would be the papers he linked.

> because this is a religion and the science really means nothing to you.

Look back up to your first sentence. Look back down here. Look up at that first sentence again. Do you see the inconsistency? He linked to the science. You refused to look at it.

Once again, I cannot honestly say that I know enough to make an informed opinion about this, but your arguing in this topic was horrible. You continually failed to address his links in every single post, and then complained he wasn't looking at the data.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by grammaton on Thursday November 04, 2010 @09:53AM (#1868848)
"If the planet were actually getting warmer, as CO2 goes up, over the last decade, that would go a long way towards making your theory worth listening to."

Um....you do realize that's exactly what has happened, right?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by brazzy on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:02AM (#1868006)
Your last paragraph very aptly describes your own mode of arguing. Your're not doing your cause any good that way.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lutorm on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:16AM (#1867900)
Out of all the arguments against AGW, the complaints by McIntyre against the Mann analysis are the only ones I've heard that seem to warrant being taken seriously. If you really can get rid of the entire 20th century warming by removing a small set of proxies, regardless of the statistical analysis, it's a serious problem.

And the response on the "skeptical science" web site, that new data has confirmed the hockey stick shape, doesn't sound convincing either. You can't both say "ok, the Mann analysis was wrong, and the field has moved on" and then say "subsequent data confirm the hockey stick" without needing to explain the remarkable coincidence that the initial incorrect study ended up getting exactly the same shape as the new "correct" data.

What I've not seen anywhere is an analysis of the extent to which projections about future warming is driven by the exact shape of the 20th century temperature record and how changing the temperature record would feed back on the GCM projections. If anyone knows of such a study, please post the reference.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:56AM (#1867996)
You mean this page? http://www.skepticalscience.com/broken-hockey-stick.htm

My reading of it is that the original Mann analysis stands up, ie. Mann 1999 is largely correct, and that McIntyre's analysis is flawed. The Wahl 2007 paper contains some "interesting" language:

"Altogether new reconstructions over 1400–1980 are developed in both the indirect and direct analyses, which demonstrate that the Mann et al. reconstruction is robust against the proxy-based criticisms addressed. ... Also, recent “corrections” to the Mann et al. reconstruction that suggest 15th century temperatures could have been as high as those of the late-20th century are shown to be without statistical and climatological merit. Our examination ... leaves entirely unaltered the primary conclusion of Mann et al. (as well as many other reconstructions) that both the 20th century upward trend and high late-20th century hemispheric surface temperatures are anomalous."

"without statistical and climatological merit" - heh. Them's scientific fighting words.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:43AM (#1867959)
The projections are based completely on the temperature record, and changing the temperature record would produce different projections. The projections are essentially fudged to get the result that is desired for political reasons.

I'm guessing you haven't been exposed to many arguments against AGW, or maybe not many good ones. But since you have an open mind, I'd suggest you look into the absorbtion of IR By CO2, the actual proportion of CO2 in the atmosphere, the lack of tropophere warming (where it should show up) and the historical correlation of CO2 and temperasture-- CO2 has been a lagging indicator and has, in the past, been much higher than it is now from natural events without causing a runaway greenhouse effect. These are basic facts that don't take much analysis and greatly undermine the AGW theory. Also, the planet is getting colder in recent years (past decade) while CO2 has been rising.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anigbrowl on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:24AM (#1868049)
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lutorm on Thursday November 04, 2010 @12:08PM (#1869467)
Radiation transfer is what I do my research on (though not in the atmosphere), and it's something we know how to do. I really doubt the scientific field has screwed that up. Certainly all arguments I've seen regarding that have had crackpot quality. (I have some hope of getting around to actually running that problem myself, but "real" work always seems to get in the way.)

The projections were not based entirely on the Mann temperature record. There are satellite data, other analyses, etc., and I haven't seen to what extent changing one of those data sets impacts the projections.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:22AM (#1867793)
Right. So - plenty of downvoting, zero actual debate. And you wonder why people are writing bots to argue with climate deniers.

Respond! Don't just blindly downvote.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:29AM (#1867804)
This is the problem you global warming proponents have. You demand a response or citations, yet you never povide them yourselves. You didn't provide an argument worth debating, you just claimed there was no basis for the opposing viewpoint and called them a name.

Global warming is an ideology that rejects science and includes the belief that all opponents reject science and therefore are not worth arguing with. This is why you will not find arguments from global warming advocates, you will just find derisive claims and namecalling.... which you provided an example of.

Note: I am not getting into the debate with you, I am merely pointing out why your namecalling produced, as you put it "zero actual debate".

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:47AM (#1867844)
Point taken about the name calling, but it largely stems from frustration. I don't agree with you about the lack of response or citations. I've provided plenty of data and argument - skepticalscience link to plenty of papers, independent, peer-reviewed, etc. - as well as the reason why deniers are called deniers instead of skeptics. In return, what do I get? One hack paper, non-peer reviewed, easily rebutted, and a whole load of scorn and downvoting.

If you want me to stop calling people deniers, how about they engage with the question: "How do you explain the correlation between surface temperature records and satellite temperature records, both of which show an increase?" Simple, no?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:08AM (#1867882)
I think that you are sincere and so I suggest you re-read the first paragraph of your response for the answer to your question. On one hand, you linked to a blog that links to "plenty of papers" and you think this is more relevant than a "one hack paper, non-peer reviewed, easily rebutted".

First of all, it is a "hack" paper, only because it disagrees with your conclusion. Secondly "peer-review" is not a barometer of science, it is a barometer of political correctness. (Trust me on this, as I've had papers peer-reviewed in much more esoteric and less politically and government-funding driven areas.) In fact, by controlling the peer review process via government fundeing ,the global warming movement attempts to discredit all science that disagrees with its agenda... and the need to do this is proof positive that science is not the foremost consideration.

As for "Easily rebutted"-- if it is so easily rebutted, please do so. Provide a rebuttal. It doesn't have to be a proof, but an argument would be sufficient. It is NOT rebutted by linking to the opinions of others. A simple rebutted is not that difficult. I can rebut the entirety of the global warming movement with a simple statement: Temperatures have been getting lower over the past decade while CO2 has gone up.

This references two easily verifiable and non-controversial facts, and rebuts the entirety of the hypothesis. so if this paper is so "easily rebutted" do so. A link to a blog post of opinion of someone you claim also links to papers is not a rebuttal. (I stopped following such links when I found that all of them referred to papers that did not make the claim that the forum poster was asserting.)

As to your last question, you haven't provided any such records. IF you would like to link to them directly, then I will have a look. (sincerely.)

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:35AM (#1867943)
I'll put the argument (against the paper) in simple terms:

The SPPI paper says that land weather station data is broken, temperatures are being reported as much higher than they should be, it's all the urban heat island, etc.

Yet the satellite data strongly corresponds with the land based temperatures and also shows an increase. See http://www.skepticalscience.com/pics/surface_satellite_compa... (or read the damn blog post properly)

In addition to this, both urban and rural stations show the same levels of temperature rise: http://www.skepticalscience.com/images/jones_london.gif

Which brings us back to my original question: If we take what you are saying about the land based temperatures at face value, how do you explain a) the extremely strong correlation between the satellite data and the land based data, and b) the extremely strong correlation in the trends between different stations if the data is flawed?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:51AM (#1867982)
First off, you've confused me with codefisher. Codefisher made his point by providing a link to support his argument, which you said couldn't be done because you said there was no science supporting his argument. Now you're changing the subject, and attacking me, including engaging in name calling, and dishonesty, trying to force me to defend a position that I have never taken.

And even so, you are easily defeated because you have provided no evidence supporting your position. You're taking some date, and asserting that it says something without considering the nature of that data and what it is actually measuring.

The thing that has tripped you up is that you think you're referring to science when you're actually referring to propaganda. People have massaged the numbers to support a hypothesis, and you link to it, thinking it is factual. It isn't. (otherwise there is no way the rural and urban areas would show the same warming, unless there was no such thing as a heat island effect, a position I presume you are not taking.)

Thus you have jumped the gun, insulted me, and made erronous arguments while ignoring, multiple times, it being pointed out that you're doing so, because you won't pay close enough attention to notice that you're attacking a person who didn't make the claim you erronously assumed.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:16AM (#1868035)
You, sir, are a troll wobbly. Good day.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by _b8r0 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @04:58AM (#1868208)
That you refer to people who disagree with you as 'deniers' shows that you are not open to debate on the matter, nor being proved wrong.

A lot of people used to think the world was flat and that the Sun went around the Earth. The atom used to be described as a pudding. The idea that illnesses were caused by creatures that you cannot see was considered ludicrous.

I would be happy to accept any of the above ideas if supported by fact. However I don't feel a need to refer to people who believe such things in a negative manner. The climate deniers you refer to are people too, probably a fair amount of them are intelligent and rational people, just with a different view to you. Name calling doesn't solve anything.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @06:48AM (#1868355)
I am absolutely open to debate on the matter, provided that it's constructive and relies on evidence and rational debate. When people make wild accusations of data tampering, fraud and shadowy world government conspiracies despite abundant evidence to the contrary then yes, they are deniers, and I use that word in an informed technical sense.

It's impossible to have any sort of reasonable discussion with people who claim to be scientifically informed, but dodge and evade as soon as you ask them simple, straightforward questions like, "where is the scientific evidence which supports your theory?", or "what is your explanation for this obvious hole in the logic of your argument?".

So yes, they are deniers. If they don't like it, they should start arguing properly, or admit that they're wrong. You know, like scientists do.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by _b8r0 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @06:56AM (#1868367)
To act as devil's advocate, this bit:

> It's impossible to have any sort of reasonable discussion with people who claim to be scientifically informed, but dodge and evade as soon as you ask them simple, straightforward questions like, "where is the scientific evidence which supports your theory?", or "what is your explanation for this obvious hole in the logic of your argument?".

Could apply to people from either side. There's theories and evidence to support either direction. It's not a binary it is or it isn't happening thing. It's not a binary we cause it, we don't cause it thing. The problem with the debate is that it becomes a religion to both sides.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:27AM (#1868445)
It can and does apply to both sides. I have some "greenie" friends who are pathologically opposed to any sort of development, as well as a couple who are full-bore climate deniers. Neither group are particularly well informed on the issues.

However, it does seem that in most issues like this, and with climate change and evolution in particular, the non-science side seems to be particularly stubborn and bloody minded (perhaps because they don't have any evidence, and have to fall back on rhetoric).

Even asking one pretty simple question gets you posts and posts of chatbot-esqe evasion and denial: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1867623

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by _b8r0 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:39AM (#1868468)
In answer to your second point. There's scientific evidence to support both assertions. There's a really good infographic floating around that sums up the case for and against and what the scientists behind each side believe. However I can't find it.

If I remember correctly, much of the pro climate change case is based on core samples, tree rings and satellite recordings of air temperatures. The case against is centred on actual drops in temperature recorded and the absorption of CO2, so there's science for both sides and evidence for both sides.

For your final point and link I'm not sure what you're trying to show me. You seem like a pretty rational guy in our discussion, but come across as fairly irrational (perhaps unstructured would be better) in the other sub-thread. It's clear lzw responded because of your style of argument, I think in his first comment his first point leads to the last and he's pretty much spot on, but in his last point he falls into the very same trap you did.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @08:03AM (#1868512)
If there's scientific evidence against global warming, then where is it? All the evidence that I've seen - historical stuff, like core samples, and current temperature records - support it. I'm quite happy to take a look if you can find it.

The point with that link is that even when asked a straightforward question on the one piece of evidence (a non peer reviewed paper) that's been put forward so far, nobody wants to actually answer it. They'd much rather dodge and weave and pull out the same old tired talking points about how things are getting colder, we're overdue for an ice age, blah, blah, blah. Meanwhile, what does that have to do with the originally cited paper?

Not sure what makes me come across as unstructured, either. Perhaps I'm just too used to arguing these points, so I'm "talking" a bit fast?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by _b8r0 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @08:16AM (#1868538)
I think perhaps you're unaware of your emotional investment in the argument. I can tell this is something you're passionate about. Unfortunately in that argument your passion is working against you.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @07:16PM (#1871257)
Passionate? Sure, but also interested in the mindset behind the arguments. I've seen it multiple times, but nobody can quite articulate exactly what it is that convinces them that, say, global warming is a hoax, or that vaccines are dangerous.

It shouldn't do, but it also annoys me that people like lzw get voted up for saying basically nothing - it's either personal attacks or the same tired old cliches. Trying to keep things on topic instead gets interpreted as "refusing to answer the questions".

One question! That's all that I'm asking, and it might give some real insight into the opposing viewpoint, or spark some real discussion, but nobody's taken it up so far, which is sad.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by rick888 on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @10:17PM (#1867341)
"I suspect that part of the problem is that, at least with climate deniers, is that there's no real meat to their arguments. I know a few, and most of their arguments boil down to hearsay or "denier blog X says so, and who trusts Obama/the UN world government anyway". If they provided a link to something supporting their position I'd probably pass out from shock."

All of the global warming data is based on information that has been falsified. It's just as bad (can you show me proof that's not based on this falsified data?).

There is a lot of money in global warming. Al gore is not only invested in the carbon credit industry, but he is trying to get the US government to force businesses to purchase these carbon credits (the profits from these will go directly into his pocket). Nobody on the left seems to care about how unethical this is.

"Nigel's just automating away the drudgery."

No, Nigel doesn't actually want to defend his point. He would rather make fun of the "crackpots" because he arrogantly believes that he is right and everyone else is wrong.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by glhaynes on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @10:34PM (#1867397)
All of the global warming data is based on information that has been falsified.

Excuse me?

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @01:38AM (#1867819)
The brilliant thing about the global warming debate for proponents is that because they are not even aware of the science inovlved, but firmly convinced that they are on the side of "science" they can say whatever they want.

You think some of it hasn't been falsified? Provide a citation please!

See what I did there? Also brilliant about their position is that it is completely unfalsifiable (if I'm understanding it correctly, it is impossible to disprove, even though the planet is getting colder, because it is based on fantasy models-- you can't disprove a model because it is just a model. And these models having never worked with previous data sets is well known but advocates don't care.)

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by rtp on Thursday November 04, 2010 @02:45AM (#1867964)
You don't understand it correctly. Models are supposed to fit the evidence, otherwise they're incorrect. That's how science works. Say you've gathered evidence of the big bang. You create a model for it. Then, suddenly, for some reason observations and measurements of background radiation doesn't fit your model. If that is so, you'll have to either adjust your model as to fit the data, or throw it away and build a new model that fits the data.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:02AM (#1868009)
Yes, when you model the past, that makes sense. What AGW proponents use are models to project the future. But they are inconsistent with the data of the past. They don't fit it.

They are simply fantasies to try and lend "scientific" justification to a political movement.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by rtp on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:14AM (#1868033)
Are you saying that the projections for the future should fit the past? I'm sorry.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by rimantas on Thursday November 04, 2010 @04:23AM (#1868145)
Are you saying, that a model which does not fit past data will somehow correctly predict the future?
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Thursday November 04, 2010 @08:18AM (#1868540)
If you're talking about climate models, then they fit the observed historical data pretty well. lzw is wrong on that point.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by rtp on Thursday November 04, 2010 @11:14AM (#1869212)
Nope.

I'm saying that the models should fit the past data. I think I misunderstood lzw. :)

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by glhaynes on Thursday November 04, 2010 @04:33PM (#1870659)
The post I was responding to said that all global warming data is falsified. That's blatantly untrue and not even worthy of discussion.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by ceejayoz on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @11:29PM (#1867545)
> There is a lot of money in global warming.

Those poor, unprofitable energy companies must have trouble fighting all those overly-funded climatologists!

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by lzw on Thursday November 04, 2010 @03:05AM (#1868017)
You're being snide, but you're actually correct. Governments have spent billions upon billions to rationalize this political movement. Energy companies are not the only ones under attack, but they are some of the few with enough money to actually do research. Of course most of their money goes into exploration... but they have done science on this topic.

Have you noticed how, when they do so, AGW proponents reject the results out of hand? It is as if you believe politicians would never lie or cheat in order to gain power.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by anthonyb on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @10:56PM (#1867453)
>> If they provided a link to something supporting their position I'd probably pass out from shock."

> All of the global warming data is based on information that has been falsified....

Thank you for proving my point so concisely.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by rick888 on Thursday November 04, 2010 @10:52AM (#1869091)
really? I really have to explain this? You don't remember the breach of data, the emails, and all of the universities that came out and admit that all of their claims were based on the same data?

I figured everyone would know what I was talking about, but I guess some people don't pay attention to the news as closely as I do.

Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by astrange on Thursday November 04, 2010 @12:19PM (#1869520)
There are multiple sets of "data", in whatever sense you want to use it (prediction models and climate measurements), and I don't think you know which one you mean. They back each other up pretty well, anyway.
Re:Chatbot Wears Down Proponents of Anti-Science Nonsense by natnat on Thursday November 04, 2010 @09:35AM (#1868760)
There may be a few billion dollars to be made by some investment banks and hedge funds in carbon trading, but keep in mind that as of today, three of the six largest companies by market cap are oil companies (ExxonMobil, PetroChina, Royal Dutch Shell), and another is a mining company with substantial interests in petroleum (BHP Billiton). These four companies alone add up to over a trillion dollars in market value.

Also, the profits from purchasing carbon credits do not go directly into Al Gore's pocket. I don't have any idea where anyone would get such a stupid idea.