It seems like you're blaming management for the fact that the stock market mispriced the long-term value of crypto mining.
I think a lot of people see an opportunity to try to take a slice of the big compute market for ML/AI. who knows if these alternatives really are viable....
but google has a lot of smart people and building your own silicon seems like a great idea these days..so I think other people will attack their stack.
I am really hoping to see AMD entering the battlefield. AMD GPUs are more than capable of handling the workload it is just a software problem.
Nvidia based their own revenue guidance on the same assumptions about crypto mining that market analysts made. They missed their guidance in November because of that.
The only cheaper deal is used (probably mining) hardware on ebay, still closing for %60-%75 of new launch price.[2] If there is really a glut, it sure isn’t reflected in consumer prices. Maybe the new big GPUs can use whatever production capacity isn’t needed yet for mid range products, and make up for lower volume with higher margins. It seems like AMD can’t really compete on efficiency right now – just price and raw performance up to whatever power limit consumers will tolerate (e.g. RTX2070 mostly outperforms Vega 64 with almost half TDP) so they can’t really compete on the high end. As far as I can work out Nvidia earnings aren't falling on low volume (yet); Q3 2018 earnings were up %2.[3]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nvidia_graphics_proces...
[2] https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_nkw=gtx+1060&_sac...
[3] https://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-announces-financia...
If that was the case they wouldn't have 90 days ( 3 months ) of inventory sitting in channels with high volume orders signed with TSMC until December. One of the reason I believe TSMC lowed their 2019 forecast was because AMD and Nvidia have too much inventory.
As you say, there are other forums which have fewer rules about self-expression -- and those forums provide a continually renewed justification for HN's content guidelines.
They didn't overbuild fabs during the gold rush, because they expected it not to last. This is one of the reasons for the GPU price hikes, and supply shortages over the past few years.
As it turned out, this was the correct call.
It's only "failure" for the investors who prodded the inflated valuation along for the past 12-18 months.
That's what happens with those stocks. Companies like NVidia expect it to happen from time to time so the price itself doesn't mean much (if anything they will buy their own stock when at a low price and sell it at a high price). It doesn't change the value of the company (which may or may not be priced correctly by the market at any given time).
The same thing AMD did?
> "So our forward looking estimates when we set out our financial analyst model, it didn’t have crypto in it. It had growth through high performance CPUs, high performance GPUs, some of our base business. If we overlay some crypto on top of that, that’s great. And if crypto goes down in 2018, that’s totally okay, we have plenty of other growth drivers in the business." http://cryptoblockchainresearch.com/2018/01/01/amd-crypto-ex...
But really, when crypto was booming, what was Nvidia supposed to do? They were the guys selling shovels and pickaxes when the gold rush was in full swing. They rode the bubble and reaped the benefits when they could. So the price drop doesn't necessarily reflect a failure of strategy on their part.
What I'll be curious to see going forward is what Nvidia does with the cash from their bumper year. If the end result of this saga is that Nvidia lined their coffers and invested in R&D for the next generation of of video cards, that bodes extremely well for the company.