Or just hundreds of other organizations and corporations.
as opposed to, you know, somewhere in a poorly designed system which gets hacked.
(sorry, apparently joined a chorus)
Practically, anyway, GDPR seems like a much more effective measure.
For many private actions companies demand ID number. That reduces identity theft to a bad movie plot.
If that's banned I'll be in the Resistance!
One of my local gyms this week switched to requiring fingerprints or you were barred from access
If this is a membership gym with contracts, wouldn't they have to wait until your next contract to impose such a change?This is actually a nice hypothetical for that idiotic vision of replacing law and the court system with algorithms. It's extremely unlikely that the specific case would be foreseen in a contract. There is a continuous spectrum of such changes, and it's impossible to formulate any specific rule that would capture them all.
Example A: The gym changes from keys to plastic membership cards. Would this be a breach of contract? I think most everyone would agree that no, it isn't.
Example B: The gym requires whole-genome sequencing (once), then requires a drop of blood every time you enter to check your identity? Breach of contract? -> Obviously.
For any two such changes, you can probably come up with yet another example that's somewhere in between. The closer they get, the more often you will find people disagreeing, yes. But that just shows how justice is a constant conversation not easily set in stone.
As for the specific case: European law really doesn't like biometric data, and it's unlikely they can get away with it.
(the following is based only on my knowledge of German and Portuguese law)
BUT, ) if they do, the pro-rated refund is the most likely outcome. It works both ways, though: if you move away, they also cannot require you to keep paying fees. It's a concept loosely translated as a "cessation of the foundational requirements of the contract).
But they probably can increase the price to cover "administrative costs/..."
What’s the reasoning for this? Shouldn’t I have the freedom to pick the conditions under which I offer my services, except for discrimination? Is it discrimination if I only offer biometric ID, say for business convenience?
Thankfully in the EU we have GDPR. It considers biometrics as a similar sensitivity to medical data, so unless you genuinely need it (maybe a hospital) then you can only get it with explicit consent. If consent is not given then that can not bar you from service.
So I reported a company to the ICO this week for the introduction of fingerprint scanners and was assured they consider it was a breach and will deal with them. GDPR isn't perfect and I think defaulting to consent is wrong and alternatives must be called out but you can't help people sleeping walking into it, it is very convenient.