Yet, despite the entire Western world being at the tail end of a decades-long process of deregulation, corporations are bigger than ever. That's not because of the State, it's because of technology. Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, Google--all are the result of massive economies of scale enabled by technology. Amazon isn't monopolizing retail because the State is giving it special privileges. It is doing so because smaller retailers cannot compete with Amazon's nationwide logistical infrastructure and footprint.
I disagree, not with your premise but with this conclusion, because there's also little evidence of monopolies that broke down without involvement from the state. One also has to consider industries and states are all different.
In a country like the US with a codified anti-monopoly law, yeah, you need collusion with the state to turn the blind eye. But precisely cause this anti-monopoly law exists, it's that monopolies HAVE been broken down, by the state.
There's industries like software where a random developer can create something that grows into a huge corporation, or a OSS project that completely changes the industry, etc. because the cost of entry is so low. But there's also industries that are ridiculously hard to get into and require massive investments that only other big companies can make. The free market IS rich-gets-richer territory.
That's not evidence that anti-trust laws are necessary.
> monopolies HAVE been broken down
My premise is that those monopolies existed as a result of state involvement in the first place.
You can't use the existence of anti-trust law as evidence that it's necessary. You must give evidence that monopolies which existed before anti-trust were bad for consumers. You must also show that those monopolies weren't created by other government actions (the solution in those cases would be to just reverse such government action, not anti-trust).
> ridiculously hard to get into and require massive investments that only other big companies can make
The capital barrier-to-entry argument is exactly what I was referring to by "mistaken economic theory". Competition doesn't just stop happening because it's expensive. You gave the solution yourself: cross-industry competition. Capital gains from one industry flow into competition in others.
Only in a situation where one company controlled a majority of the industries in the economy would preventing competition would possible. And such a firm would be hugely inefficient.
> free market IS rich-gets-richer territory
Getting richer requires risk. Risk is often rewarded, but risk goes both ways. Also, there's no evidence that the free market is any worse in this aspect than other systems.
You think this is "your" premise but in fact its the dominant ideological belief of anti-trust enforcement since the Reagan administration.
This dogma is WHY we are in such a bad straight with companies with aggressive monopoly power in market after market (it extends FAR beyond tech).
Libertarian'ish ideas like yours are in fact the consensus reality in public policy.
I don't care about just anti-trust. The entire bureaucracy of the regulatory state affects the competition throughout the economy.
https://www.yalelawjournal.org/note/amazons-antitrust-parado...
For bonus points -
Please list a successful libertarian society - contemporary or historical.
In fact you can't. That because libertarianism is a type of utopianism. The society you aspire to can't exist with actual human beings in it.
This is one of the things that is really annoying about economics. Because the result of economics depends on money, even the simplest most obvious things will be disputed. In physics nobody will seriously say that gravity on Earth makes things fly up, but boy in economics there will be an endless supply of serious scholars writing books and articles and earnestly arguing on TV shows that up is down and down is up.
Because of course if you convince people that up is down and down is up in economics, you can get really rich. If you can convince the public that there is no such thing as a natural monopoly, there will still be natural monopolies but they won't be treated as such by the government, and then you have a license to print money.
The water example you gave is an example of the government proactively monopolizing such utilities. It's exactly what I was talking about.
Never have I seen evidence of water, power, etc naturally monopolizing and being hostile to consumers. Firms just can't keep out competition without state intervention.
If there isn't then you would have to rethink your theories don't you.
The fact of the matter is that there is such a thing as a natural monopoly and just a cursory examination of the facts on the ground and the history of the last 150 years or so will prove it.
Not really
> Is there any place where I can buy a house with five different independent water delivery and sewage removal systems attached to it?
I never claimed that it exists. I claimed it was possible. A thing doesn't need to exist to be possible.
> The fact of the matter is that there is such a thing as a natural monopoly
Name some, then. Show me the evidence of all these natural monopolies which cropped up on their own, taking advantage of consumers, and resulting in the necessity of making them state utilities.
http://file.scirp.org/pdf/JWARP20120700002_74310948.pdf
I think two responses to this would be a) that sounds like terrible public and private provision, and b) the competing water providers don’t all use pipes — they use boreholes, tankers, and rainwater collection, so they don’t count. But that’s probably how competition against an apparent natural monopoly would work: what might undermine Comcast, say, isn’t another cable company digging up the road, but a wireless broadband provider, or some technological alternative that circumvent the apparent advantages of the monopolist.
Come to Florida and checkout FPL post hurricane. They are pretty notorious for restoring power to wealthy neighborhoods first. That’s pretty hostile. Otherwise I think most agree they have a difficult job and seemingly continue to get better in terms of preparedness and restoration in these events.
Going to the state intervention and water pipes as an example, even if the state said anyone can join in and compete whenever they want, it begs the question of how that would be possible without the state being involved. At any given point tom, dick or Harry want to start a water company the publi roads get ripped up yet again to lay pipe. Do Tom, dick and Harry all get to rip up my yard and connect to my home without my consent? If connections aren’t done all at once, do public roads get ripped up for every home that wants water connection from a new supplier?
The NFL May be such an example of a monopoly (according to the courts) that doesn’t rely on state intervention, but good luck building your own stadium or contracting to use theirs any given Sunday. Are the hostile to consumers? I suppose that question is debatable based on your definition, in the case of my local team they price out consumers and have record low attendance and didn’t allow competitors to use their stadiums (USFL) to the detriment of football fans who wanted alternative leagues.
It looks to me like FPL is a utility heavily regulated in its rates and operation by the Florida state government. Seems like a lot of government involvement to me.
> Going to the state intervention and water pipes as an example, even if the state said anyone can join in and compete whenever they want, it begs the question of how that would be possible without the state being involved.
The roads could be built to facilitate expansion and competition. Roads could be avoided altogether through technology like directional drilling or tunneling. Competitors could get started by servicing new development first, then expanding into existing areas.
As it stands, existing cities were designed with centralized utilities in mind. It makes it hard to monkey patch competition on top.
> Do Tom, dick and Harry all get to rip up my yard and connect to my home without my consent?
They shouldn't, but utilities use eminent domain all the time.
> public roads get ripped up for every home that wants water connection from a new supplier?
I don't think roads should be public either, but that's for another discussion.
> The NFL May be such an example of a monopoly
Talk about a bad example. The NFL gets all sorts of subsidies including cities building their stadiums for them! The military uses the NFL as a main medium for advertising.
I don’t think you can just imagine some magical road that allows for unlimited pipes and electric to run through it that just accommodates more competition without real hostility to consumers.
The military doesn’t “use” stadiums they form partnerships with the NFL and pay to advertise...the military isn’t helping protect the NFL monopoly the way OP says. And not all stadiums are build by the cities or tax payer funds. But in my case they did, admittedly, but again it can be argued they are hosilte (pricing out the local fans, while the stadium sits half empty).
I think you missed the part about OP claiming these State backed monopolies aren’t hostile to consumers (or I completely misunderstood this part of the post)...as your post seems to concur with mine, they are sometime hostile.
Which OP are you referring to?
> As you say if we open up water to competition, as many as possible can immeenient domain a pipe into my house. I could have 1,000 water pipes from 1,000 companies sticking out of my wall and I have no say.. that seems hostile.
I don't think that would actually happen of course. Nor do I think eminent domain is a valid power of the State. My point was that this already happens. I think a much better system could spontaneously exist when the market is involved. An example is given by WalterBright: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18536896
> I don’t think you can just imagine some magical road that allows for unlimited pipes and electric to run through it that just accommodates more competition without real hostility to consumers.
Obviously, scarcity is a thing. Unlimited competition isn't possible. I'd say 2-6 competitors is about right, depending on your situation.
> The military doesn’t “use” stadiums they form partnerships with the NFL and pay to advertise...the military isn’t helping protect the NFL monopoly the way OP says.
My point was that the military is a large source of NFL funding, but I shouldn't have even brought that up. It's entirely unnecessary, because the NFL isn't a monopoly. Sports entertainment is a super competitive arena, with multiple sports and multiple levels per sport, including college football.
> And not all stadiums are build by the cities or tax payer funds.
Sure, but regardless my point that they get huge subsidies from governments stands.
> missed the part about OP claiming these State backed monopolies aren’t hostile to consumers
I'm not sure who you're referring to by OP, but my position is that state-backed monopolies are the only ones which can be hostile to consumers. Otherwise, the hostility is just opportunity for competitors.
And you ignored hristov's challenge. He wanted evidence (though phrased in a way that implied presenting it was impossible), and you responded with argument. Produce the evidence: Where in the world are there no government regulations on water companies, and it resulted in five companies offering service to each house? Where? Show us the data. Without that, you have argument, but the real world contradicts you...
I don't need to give evidence. I'm not the one advocating for government action, I support inaction.
Look, theory that does not apply in the real world is meaningless. And in the real world monopoly’s exist without government backing, making your argument invalid. That’s perfectly ok, but now it’s time for you to realize you made a false argument and think of some new idea of how things operate.
When was that? He never named a bunch of natural monopolies which exploited consumers.
> in the real world monopoly’s exist without government backing
Where is the evidence of this. My original comment clearly stated that I hadn't seen any evidence of consumer-hostile monopolies occurring without government backing. And in this thread, I've yet to see any lists of monopolies period, let alone ones people claimed to be natural.
Large scale water delivery via underground pipes was the example monopoly given. That's literally a list of 1,000+ monopolies.
> The water example you gave is an example of the government proactively monopolizing such utilities.
Every water utility I know of is heavily regulated by local governments. Why? I don't know. I've never seen any evidence that such regulations were reactive in nature. But that fact of reality is not evidence that water delivery is an industry which will naturally monopolize to a point at which it is harmful to consumers.
This comes from the fact their are zero known counter examples going back thousands of years, worldwide.
I don't know what the interconnection between them was like.
But I can say that in the days before the internet achieved dominance, the various privately operated networks provided gateways so one could connect to the next. In fact, the term "inter"net came from connecting existing networks together.
Lastly, it's not necessary for competing water companies to run parallel sets of water pipes to your home. Your neighborhood may have a communal pipe, and then water companies compete to connect to that pipe. There may be pipes connecting various other pipes. The water companies compete to fill those pipes, or rent access to those pipes to deliver the water to individual subscribers.
I.e. a free market water system need not at all look like the current monopoly utility system.
I’m going from pure memory so correct if I’m wrong, but the only cross continental railroad that didn’t immediately go bust after finish was the only one not being paid by the mile by the government.
For example, if there was no regulation of water utilities, anyone could just put a big tank on their property (bought from anywhere) and hire any number of water supply companies to come fill it. To the best of my knowledge this isn't legal due to numerous laws and regulations.
Same applies to septic.
It's probably also going to be dependent on the town (presumably) whether you have to pay for a hookup if it becomes available.
I've been to places where the government doesn't or can't regulate water delivery and perhaps not coincidentally, you also can't drink the water.
According to microeconomic theory, a natural unprotected monopoly has to operate at a different price point than a legally protected monopoly, because attempting to operate at that point invites new firms to enter and attempt to unseat the incumbent. It therefore follows that every natural monopolist will attempt to seek legal protection for their monopoly, and would be willing to pay up to the marginal amount of profit between the price points of natural and protected monopoly in order to acquire or retain that protection. Where the legal framework is not available, the monopolist firm can just hire a brute squad to take out upstart competitors.
So because there is a real economic difference between protected monopoly and natural competitive monopoly, the mere possibility of protected monopoly is a source of political corruption. And once corruption has taken root, every natural monopoly can then invest in its own protection, even where such protection might not be needed, because protected monopolies can charge higher prices, which is all (economic) profit.
But why keep a war chest, when you could use the same funds to greater effect by buying political protection and distributing the remainder to the owners?
While it is possible to effectively protect a monopoly without help, appropriating the machinery of the state where possible is much more efficient. As I mentioned previously, where the state cannot be used, the company could hire a gang to burn down competitor capital more cheaply than trying to duke it out in a fair fight on the open market.
If you're DeBeers, and someone opens a diamond mine that threatens your cartel in a place with little law enforcement, your carrot is a buyout offer, and your stick is murdering key personnel and destroying vital equipment using "security contractors". You don't need to lower prices, if you can make the new guy go bankrupt without ever bringing anything to market.
AT&T creates the first phone network. No one can use their network because it's their property, and the phones installed in people's homes are also owned by AT&T, rented by consumers. How is competition going to appear?
I suppose you could say the state is enforcing property laws, but even in the absence of functional governments people often prevent theft (there was a time before police, after all).
It probably would have happened like this:
- phone is invented
- consumers want it
- AT&T starts in one city, other companies start up in other cities
- eventually people want to speak between cities
- different phone companies start networking with each other to provide that service
- AT&T has old infrastructure in the city where they started and consumers aren't happy, so one of AT&Ts competitors goes into that city and starts setting up a newer network that's higher quality
and so on, and so forth
Regardless, you see the exact same thing happen with railroads, with them holding monopolies on the rail lines they built (sometimes with incompatible rail).
" Around 1917, the idea that everyone in the country should have phone service and that the government should promote that began being discussed in government. AT&T agreed, saying in a 1917 annual report: "A combination of like activities under proper control and regulation, the service to the public would be better, more progressive, efficient, and economical than competitive systems." In 1918 the federal government nationalized the entire telecommunications industry, with national security as the stated intent. Rates were regulated so that customers in large cities would pay higher rates to subsidize those in more remote areas. Vail was appointed to manage the telephone system with AT&T being paid a percentage of the telephone revenues. "
I think any liability is tied to the power of the State.
You are, after all, being found liable through the legal process (probably the courts.)
On your last point, one natural monopoly that thrived completely independent of any States, is the monopoly of force exerted by Warlords over their domains.
Given the choice between Warlords and a State Government, I chose a State Government, even with all its other problems. Hopefully the government is reasonably democratic, and a nation of laws.
This is a creation of the state. Without LL, destructive corporate actions could result in suits against the shareholders or at least the operators of the company. Shareholders would like to limit the risk they take, so they would be likely to pressure firms to act more carefully. With LL, firms can take whatever risk they want, and the only consequences stockholders see is if the stock price of the company falls.
In addition to that, the idea that a state arises to prevent warlords is fantasy. In reality, warlords evolve to become the state as they legitimize their position as rulers.
That article is awful. Truly terrible.
But it's not worth my time pulling it apart, if you're not interested in genuine Dialog.
Let me know.
It doesn't necessarily disprove your correlation, but its food for thought.
Those monopolies either weren't bad for consumers, or were consequences of government action.
Note that anybody could have built a competing railroad... but it hadn't happened.
The Central Pacific — which was built by the “Big Four” of California, on federal subsidies — was the railroad which was guilty of all the evils popularly held against railroads. For almost thirty years, the Central Pacific controlled California, held a monopoly, and permitted no competitor to enter the state. It charged disastrous rates, changed them every year, and took virtually the entire profit of the California farmers or shippers, who had no other railroad to turn to. What made this possible? It was done through the power of the California legislature. The Big Four controlled the legislature and held the state closed to competitors by legal restrictions—such as, for instance, a legislative act which gave the Big Four exclusive control of the entire coastline of California and forbade any other railroad to enter any port. During these thirty years, many attempts were made by private interests to build competing railroads in California and break the monopoly of the Central Pacific. These attempts were defeated—not by methods of free trade and free competition, but by legislative action.
This thirty-year monopoly of the Big Four and the practices in which they engaged are always cited as an example of the evils of big business and free enterprise. Yet the Big Four were not free enterprisers; they were not businessmen who had achieved power by means of unregulated trade. They were typical representatives of what is now called a mixed economy. They achieved power by legislative intervention in business; none of their abuses would have been possible in a free, unregulated economy.
The same Central Pacific is notorious for a land deal which led to the dispossession of farmers and to bloody riots in the late 1870’s. This is the incident which served as the basis for the anti-business novel, The Octopus, by Frank Norris, the incident which caused great public indignation and led to hatred of all railroads and of all big business. But this deal involved land given to the Big Four by the government—and the subsequent injustice was made possible only by legislative and judicial assistance. Yet it was not government intervention in business that took the blame, it was business.
At the other side of the scale, the railroad that had the cleanest history, was most efficiently built in the most difficult circumstances, and was responsible, single-handed, for the development of the entire American Northwest, was the Great Northern, built by J. J. Hill without any federal help whatever. Yet Hill was persecuted by the government all his life—under the Sherman Act, for being a monopolist (!)."
From the chapter "NOTES ON THE HISTORY OF AMERICAN FREE ENTERPRISE"
- www.amazon.co.uk/Capitalism-Ideal-Ayn-Rand-ebook/dp/B002OSXD6E/
Historical evidence of the stated events mentioned in the excerpt could be found on
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Southern_Pacifi...
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Pacific_Railroad
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Northern_Railway_(U.S.)
And the GN wasn't single-handedly responsible for the development of the American Northwest. The NP was there first, for one thing.
The text you quoted seems to be reading history quite selectively.
Would DeBeers monopoly on diamonds count as not backed by a state? Reading their history, it seems like rhodes got lucky and reinvested.
The fact is that diamond supply has been under the control of warlords and other statist factions for a long time. I'd say that counts.
Yeah, this is more an example of monopolies naturally eroding. DeBeers held prices above equilibrium, and other players entered the market and now they don't have a stranglehold on it. (The extent of their hold on it was played up by journalists anyway...)
Just because it's true that certain regulations create economic minimums that prevent new entrants into the market doesn't mean that this is the sole thing that causes monopolies, as immense vertical integration can lower costs to the point where only the largest organizations can provide services at said lowest margin. The problem only becomes bigger once they prevent new entrants, and begin to raise prices since there is no competition.
Once this monopoly on coercion is secured before the state, the state's only responsibility regarding the markets comes down to enforcing property rights and establishing a system of courts and judical practices to resolve disputes between free agents in the market.
If such a government later decides to enter the market through nationalising industries, and/or establishing state-controlled for-profit organisations, and/or rationing/licensing entries to individual professions, it starts exercising coercion in the field of voluntarily trading agents, thus skewing competition in favor of those who is willing and is able to make deals with policy-makers. And once there's a regulation in favor of one of the players in the market, there's hardly any way for their competitors to outperform them, but to go to other policy-makers that might help to pass another set of regulations that would potentially harm the first player. And this is how monopolies are created in the first place - in the end, there's going to be a dominant player that has used all the opportunities to squeeze competition from the market through various regulations that work handy for their particular business, and at the same time prevent any other new player to enter the competition, even if they have enough money for it - precisely because they have to comply with the government regulations that already benefit the monopoly.
> The power of monopolies and indeed of corporations in general is directly tied to the power of the State.
That's a big claim with zero evidence. It would certainly seem that the lack of strong national government and insufficient power at the state level was what lead to powerful corporations/trusts like Standard Oil.
> It's no surprise to those who understand this that, as the federal government has grown in size, strength, and scope, corporations have followed.
My understanding of the Gilded Age was that corporations were only stopped because laws were passed at the federal level after monopolies had already become a problem and caused pushback from voters. eg.
> In 1890, Congress passed the Sherman Antitrust Act, which made it illegal to monopolize or restrain (or attempt to do so) interstate commerce. On the basis of this Act, the United States filed a suit against five sugar manufacturing companies to keep them from merging after one firm purchased the stock of the other four (E.C. Knight Co. was one of the four firms bought out). The American Sugar Refining Company had gained control over 98 percent of the sugar refining business in the United States in this way and was considered a monopoly. ( http://landmarkcases.org/en/Page/401/How_Interpretation_of_t... )
Further, I don't think there was a notable increase of federal government until the Depression and New Deal era, followed by significant military expansion before, during and after WW2. Arguably there was major growth in the 60s and 70s (HUD, DoT, DoE, DoEd, EPA, etc.) But I feel it's fairly clear that government size and corporate size change largely independently.
> In fact, I'd go so far as to say that consumer-hostile monopolies cannot exist for any substantial amount of time without the backing of the State.
You're moving the goalposts here, changing from discussions of monopolies in general to "consumer-hostile" monopolies. Further, I'd expect you're still wrong even here. Consumers might accept hostile monopoly situations if there's simply no alternative, ie, places where it's not cost effective for a company to build out to a rural location. Even if the service is bad for your power/telecom situation in some rural location, there simply might not be an alternative, aside from not getting that service.
> As far as I can tell, natural monopolies are a myth grown from mistaken economic theory.
I don't really know what to say to this. If you can look at the mechanics of road, power and telecom construction/distribution and say that natural monopolies don't exist, then clearly we must have wildly different understandings of the term.
> No it isn't.
Yes, it is for corporations (monopolies are a more complex question.) Corporations are creations of the state; everything done through them is an exercise of state power.
Legally, yes. Politically, it's more complicated. The banana republics were largely run by the domestic subsidiaries of foreign companies. Just because the subsidiaries were chartered by the state doesn't mean they didn't have more power than the state.
That was an exercise of state power (often quite directly, with implicit or explicit threat, and in some cases direct application, of conventional state power), just not exclusively of the state chartering the local subsidiary, often instead the one chartering the parent.
EDIT: But there is the point that, especially in a weaker government, the private power of people (foreign or not, individual or corporate themselves) that own a corporation may be more relevant than government power in determining the power of that corporation; that's not really about the power of corporations as such, though.
In these cases, the centers of power co-mingle. See Korea's chaebols; the House of Saud relative to Saudi Aramco and the state of Saudi Arabia; or Vatican City's relationship with the Holy See and Catholic Church. TL; DR Rising state power doesn't mean rising corporate power. In many arenas, the two compete.
I'm not immediately seeing the distinction you're trying to draw here, given the topic-can you elaborate on this a bit so that I can possibly understand your position a bit more?
Corporations are legal entities. For a legal entity to have meaning, it must be based on a set of laws. The state creates and administers laws. Therefore, corporations are a creature of the state. Theoretically, the state has unlimited power to create, destroy and manipulate corporations to its will.
In reality, it's more complicated. Just because someone has a legal right doesn't mean they have the political power to exercise it. When President Miguel R. Dávila of Honduras attempted to exercise state power over the Cuyamel Fruit Company, the latter raised a mercenary army and staged a coup d'état [1]. There are numerous other examples of private corporations running pet states for their own benefit.
Once you rise to the level of discussing sovereign power, the distinction between a state and a corporation becomes meaningless. What matters is power--how it's organized is something of a convenience. (For example, try drawing neat lines between the Saudi state, the House of Saud and Saudi Aramco. Or between Vatican City, the Holy See and the Catholic Church.) We're nowhere near that point in America--the federal government could fine into ruin, jail the leadership of or break up any company on earth.
This meme of states always having more power than corporations because the latter is a legal creature of the former is overly simplistic. It similarly doesn't follow that a strong state means strong corporations. In many arenas, states compete for power with corporations. Teddy Roosevelt taking on the robber barons required a strong state; in contrast, Korea is an example of a weak state relative to its corporations.
Dictatorships are monopolies.
> by experience.
I think you meant historically. What ever did you mean by "theoretically"? Theory is less useful if it doesn't match practice anyway.
And?
>I think you meant historically.
I don't know what you think adding that adjective is going to change, but sure.
>What ever did you mean by "theoretically"?
I meant in theory.
I'm interested in an example of an entire country run by a private entity that was not a dictatorship. It doesn't help that the terms "run" and "private entity" vary from person to person, but something akin to the HEIC - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_rule_in_India is what was conjured when talking about private entity rule.
> I don't know what you think adding that adjective is going to change, but sure.
I'm implying no readers/posters have "experience" as stated. The adjective is a clarification, in the case that there was something missed from the strange phrasing.
In fact, I'd go so far as to say that consumer-hostile monopolies cannot exist for any substantial amount of time without the backing of the State. Whether that be through IP law, limited liability, regulatory capture, or explicit utilization, monopoly in one industry requires the support of the largest monopoly there is: that on coercion, aka the State.
Never have I seen evidence of a lasting consumer-hostile monopoly that existed without the involvement of the State. As far as I can tell, natural monopolies are a myth grown from mistaken economic theory.