Re:The Monopolization of America
by dannyobrien on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:23PM
(#18539342)
I’m not sure it directly helps anyone’s argument here, but 5 minute’s searching gave this study of water service in Nigeria, with a mixture of public and private services competing to provide potable water using different strategies.
http://file.scirp.org/pdf/JWARP20120700002_74310948.pdf
I think two responses to this would be a) that sounds like terrible public and private provision, and b) the competing water providers don’t all use pipes — they use boreholes, tankers, and rainwater collection, so they don’t count. But that’s probably how competition against an apparent natural monopoly would work: what might undermine Comcast, say, isn’t another cable company digging up the road, but a wireless broadband provider, or some technological alternative that circumvent the apparent advantages of the monopolist.
Not really
> Is there any place where I can buy a house with five different independent water delivery and sewage removal systems attached to it?
I never claimed that it exists. I claimed it was possible. A thing doesn't need to exist to be possible.
> The fact of the matter is that there is such a thing as a natural monopoly
Name some, then. Show me the evidence of all these natural monopolies which cropped up on their own, taking advantage of consumers, and resulting in the necessity of making them state utilities.