News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Monopolization of America by pitaj on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:56PM (#18536718)
> there's also little evidence of monopolies that broke down without involvement from the state

That's not evidence that anti-trust laws are necessary.

> monopolies HAVE been broken down

My premise is that those monopolies existed as a result of state involvement in the first place.

You can't use the existence of anti-trust law as evidence that it's necessary. You must give evidence that monopolies which existed before anti-trust were bad for consumers. You must also show that those monopolies weren't created by other government actions (the solution in those cases would be to just reverse such government action, not anti-trust).

> ridiculously hard to get into and require massive investments that only other big companies can make

The capital barrier-to-entry argument is exactly what I was referring to by "mistaken economic theory". Competition doesn't just stop happening because it's expensive. You gave the solution yourself: cross-industry competition. Capital gains from one industry flow into competition in others.

Only in a situation where one company controlled a majority of the industries in the economy would preventing competition would possible. And such a firm would be hugely inefficient.

> free market IS rich-gets-richer territory

Getting richer requires risk. Risk is often rewarded, but risk goes both ways. Also, there's no evidence that the free market is any worse in this aspect than other systems.

Re:The Monopolization of America by WhatIsDukkha on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:04PM (#18536784)
Consumer harm has been THE ideological buzzphrase since the Reagan administration.

You think this is "your" premise but in fact its the dominant ideological belief of anti-trust enforcement since the Reagan administration.

This dogma is WHY we are in such a bad straight with companies with aggressive monopoly power in market after market (it extends FAR beyond tech).

Libertarian'ish ideas like yours are in fact the consensus reality in public policy.

Re:The Monopolization of America by pitaj on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:11PM (#18536834)
If libertarian ideas were the status quo, there would be a lot less regulation than there is.

I don't care about just anti-trust. The entire bureaucracy of the regulatory state affects the competition throughout the economy.

Re:The Monopolization of America by WhatIsDukkha on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:41PM (#18537060)
What I've said is historically uncontroversial.

https://www.yalelawjournal.org/note/amazons-antitrust-parado...

For bonus points -

Please list a successful libertarian society - contemporary or historical.

In fact you can't. That because libertarianism is a type of utopianism. The society you aspire to can't exist with actual human beings in it.