News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:15AM (#18531232)
> It's "unconscionable ... an experiment on human beings that is not morally or ethically defensible," said Dr. Kiran Musunuru, a University of Pennsylvania gene editing expert and editor of a genetics journal.

This is 100% correct.

(COI: Kiran was my postdoc while I was a student in the lab a decade ago.)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nathan_f77 on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:12AM (#18531667)
I don't know if I agree with that.

Some theists believe that we shouldn't tamper with God's perfect creation, because everything happens for a reason (including miscarriages, birth defects, and genetic diseases.) Atheists might believe that natural selection has got us this far, so it must be a pretty good process. A scientist shouldn't change anything, because they will be adding unnecessary risk to the natural process of evolution.

But you have to think about the "baseline". Natural selection is actually a brutal and horrific process where genes are just mutated at random. 50% of all pregnancies end in a miscarriage. Birth defects occur in 3% of all live births, and they account for 21% of all infant deaths. Nature is already a mad scientist that runs random experiments on babies.

I read that humans have about 30 genetic mutations per generation [1]. So imagine if a scientist picks 1 gene at random, and they use CRISPR to randomly change that gene. Now the embryo has around ~31 random mutations. Isn't that basically the same result as natural selection? You probably wouldn't even be able to tell that the scientist had changed anything.

Is that an accurate way of looking at it, or am I missing something?

[1] http://www.cs.unc.edu/~plaisted/ce/genetics.html

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by bencollier49 on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:29AM (#18531718)
"Theists believe that we shouldn't tamper with God's perfect creation"

Steady with the generalisations there. Your polarised US and various other places might be home to fewer liberal religionists, but that is not necessarily an accurate statement.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @08:04AM (#18533011)
This is an inaccurate understanding of CRISPR, which is not yet at the point where zero off-target effects can be expected. That is an important aspect of this discussion.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by hackinthebochs on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:03AM (#18533765)
But if the off-target effect is random, then its not really any worse off than an unmodified embryo, with around 30 random mutations naturally. Of course, the actual numbers matter but in principle this isn't a worse situation.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:55AM (#18534173)
> But if the off-target effect is random, then its not really any worse off than an unmodified embryo, with around 30 random mutations naturally. Of course, the actual numbers matter but in principle this isn't a worse situation.

There is strong evidence that high mutation rates are selected against, to the point that some have speculated that driving down mutation rate is one of the key functions of selection[1].

Point being that increasing the number of germline variants is an extremely important consideration. The fact that the underlying biological replication mechanisms are not 100% perfect does not alter this point, and certainly doesn't mean that when you artificially increase the number of mutations that "this isn't a worse situation".

1 = https://www.nature.com/articles/nrg.2016.104

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by Noos on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:46PM (#18536212)
I don't think Christians (theism is just a code word for this, true lower-case theists are rare) feel this way, since they acknowledge the world is not pristine due to the fall of man, and suffering and pain exist. Usually the argument on that is that man is made in the image of God, and has special value due to this. They act as stewards of creation and reflections of God himself, and shouldn't be treated like animals.

I'd also argue that non-natural selection can be worse. We have crude forms of it through pet breeding, and cats come to mind. The Scottish Fold in particular:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_Fold

I worry non-natural selection could follow the path of the fold and various toy breeds.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nathan_f77 on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:49PM (#18536674)
That's a good point. I'm sure there are many Christians who would be comfortable with gene-editing to prevent disease. And people hold a wide variety of beliefs, so I shouldn't have made such a broad generalization.

Also pet breeding is a great example. But I think that's one of the advantage of CRISPR over selective breeding. Selective breeding results in lots of genetic problems like hip dysplasia, arthritis, etc. because the gene pool is too small. But I think CRISPR could probably fix most of these issues by splicing in the healthy genes from other dog breeds.

Although I just found this article: https://splinternews.com/meet-the-guy-biohacking-puppies-to-...

I didn't realize there was a DIY bio-hacking community just playing around with CRISPR in their backyard shed. This is concerning.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by sho on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:11AM (#18532289)
> Nature is already a mad scientist that runs random experiments on babies.

Excellent way of putting it. I'm adding that quote to my arsenal..

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by freeone3000 on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:28AM (#18531715)
It's an accurate way of looking at it, but it assumes humans have a lesser value because lots of them already die, so what's a few more? The difference is a few humans, and that's too big a risk, in my opinion, to take lightly.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nathan_f77 on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:52AM (#18531781)
Sure, but the scientist is trying to reduce the risk of death and suffering. (They're not just flipping a coin to see what happens.)

We already know a lot about certain genes and what they do. For example, mutations in the HBB gene cause sickle cell anemia. Removing the mutation in that HBB gene is a good idea 100% of the time. You can just look at the 99% (?) of healthy people who have an HBB gene without that mutation.

Maybe the CRISPR process is risky and can cause lots of unexpected mutations. In that case it's not so black-and-white. But if you can edit a gene to prevent a disease, and it can be done in a safe way, then I don't think it's inherently unethical. (Although you could argue that it might be more ethical for parents to adopt a baby and donate money to charity, instead of spending a lot of money on gene-editing and IVF.)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by danenania on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:58AM (#18532012)
The problem is that we don’t know whether this would prevent diseases with any reasonable certainty, and using non-consenting human beings to try to find out implies a profoundly dangerous devaluation of human life and individual rights.

If you can reach a high certainty level through other kinds of tests, then that would be another story.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nathan_f77 on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:25AM (#18532337)
Sickle cell disease affects millions of people, and it's the most common inherited blood disorder. We know for sure that certain mutations in the HBB gene cause sickle cell disease, so I think there is 100% certainty when you're correcting this specific mutation. People who don't inherit this mutation don't get sickle cell anemia. (Because their HBB gene doesn't produce blood cells that are shaped like sickles.)

I didn't realize that CRISPR gene editing can cause damage to other genes [1], so it might not worth it yet. If there was a perfect CRISPR procedure that had no other side effects, then it would be hard to argue against that.

[1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180719165032.h...

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by zeroname on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:51AM (#18532645)
> The problem is that we don’t know whether this would prevent diseases with any reasonable certainty, and using non-consenting human beings to try to find out implies a profoundly dangerous devaluation of human life and individual rights.

I sure hope you are pro-life, otherwise making "consent" and "individual rights" a foundation of your view would be pretty hypocritical.

In my view, if you aren't even a fetus yet, you can't possibly have any rights. You're not a human being. During IVF, you select the embryo with the best health prospects - the rest may be destroyed.

Keep in mind I only disagree with the foundation, I still think the procedure is unethical because the scientific basis is poor.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by danenania on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:47AM (#18532932)
Being pro-choice doesn’t require nullification of an unborn child’s rights. It’s the recognition that the mother’s right to agency over her own body takes precedence.

That does not imply that a doctor or researcher has the right to risk causing debilitating life-long symptoms to another human being at any stage of development without a clear medical justification.

By your reasoning, because an embryo has no rights whatsoever, it would be fine to experiment wantonly for the sake of producing circus attractions. I presume you wouldn’t actually support this?

I also fail to see how the scientific basis is relevant to the ethical question. Whether the science is good or not, we’re talking about unnecessary procedures with inherent failure rates that can have brutal life-long consequences. I can’t see how someone can support this unless they are fundamentally lacking in empathy. As I asked another poster elsewhere in the thread, do you really think you would feel the same if something like this had been done to you and caused you to live with a painful deformity? Would you care then whether the science was good?

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by zeroname on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:51PM (#18535282)
> Being pro-choice doesn’t require nullification of an unborn child’s rights. It’s the recognition that the mother’s right to agency over her own body takes precedence.

> That does not imply that a doctor or researcher has the right to risk causing debilitating life-long symptoms to another human being at any stage of development without a clear medical justification.

It's not the doctor making the decision to go ahead with this procedure, it's the mother. So, according to you, a mother has the right to kill an unborn child in the womb because it's the wrong gender (not uncommon in China) and that's "agency over her body" but then she can't attempt to mitigate the HIV risk it has given her child by procreating with an HIV-positive male. This is absurd.

> I also fail to see how the scientific basis is relevant to the ethical question. Whether the science is good or not, we’re talking about unnecessary procedures with inherent failure rates that can have brutal life-long consequences.

Nobody knows if there will be "inherent failure rates that can have brutal life-long consequences". That's why the science is bad. If the science was good, you'd know if the procedure is really that risky or not. If the procedure was 100% safe and effective, it would be unethical not to perform it.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by danenania on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:47PM (#18537117)
Again, you are effectively arguing that it would be ethical for a doctor to try to experimentally create a glow-in-the-dark baby if asked to by the mother.

Good or bad science has nothing to do with the outcomes--that's good or bad medicine. There's plenty of 'good science' practiced on lab rats that would immediately become horrifyingly unethical if practiced on humans, but that has nothing to do with how well the scientific method is being applied and what can be learned.

Anyway, this discussion doesn't seem to be going anywhere productive, so I will bid you good day.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by zeroname on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @01:09AM (#18539886)
> Again, you are effectively arguing that it would be ethical for a doctor to try to experimentally create a glow-in-the-dark baby if asked to by the mother.

No, I am not arguing that. That's an embarrassingly absurd conclusion to draw.

These babies have a risk of life-long HIV impairment. This intervention may prevent this. With any medical intervention, you need to trade off risk and reward. Obviously, for an unborn child, there can not be any consent here.

It would be unethical to not give the babies the treatment if there wasn't any risk associated. What makes it unethical is that the risk profile isn't even known. The scientific foundation is poor.

> Anyway, this discussion doesn't seem to be going anywhere productive, so I will bid you good day.

I agree and let me say this: You're by far the worst discussion partner I have ever had on HN.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by danenania on Friday November 30, 2018 @05:12PM (#18573192)
"You're by far the worst discussion partner I have ever had on HN."

Woe is me!

I somehow doubt you're very high on anyone's list yourself :-/

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by jamesrcole on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:07AM (#18533406)
> The difference is a few humans, and that's too big a risk, in my opinion, to take lightly.

You're assuming it's riskier, in terms of lives, to try this technology. But it could be -- and obviously it's up in the air, which is my point -- that without such technology many more people will end up dying.

The status quo is never neutral with respect to risks.

What if it was used to provide immunity to malaria, as a hypothetical example?

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wagutina on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:25AM (#18533921)
Are you trying to justify innocent human experiments by saying nature is doing it anyway ? Nature is a mad scientist, unfair and horrible so let's be like it ?

Maybe if you were seriously ill because of a genetic experiment we did on you (and that you did not need) as you were an embryo, then you would not hold the same view.

I don't think you get where the morality problem is... It's not about being Amish that say "we shouldn't temper with God's perfect creation".

It's about a country doing human experimentation on innocent people that do not need it, it's not to cure them from an heridetary problem but to breed a stronger race. China will only show the success of their experiments and will hide from the eyes of the world all the failures, handicapped babies, secondary effects of their human experiments. They'll make experiments on babies with lots of failure (it's science, you never get it right at the first experiment) and once in a while they'll put a video on YouTube like they just did saying "Aw look how healthy they are". But behind there going to be a lot of guinea pig children with serious secondary effects. And the worth part is how they'll make sure the rest of the world never see those "failed" children. This might be Nazi-level stuff that's going to happen and this is what people with a glimpse of ethics left are concerned about, it's not about "not tempering with God's perfect creation"

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nathan_f77 on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:16AM (#18534350)
I think you're mainly talking about the worst case situation, which is obviously terrible: Unethical scientists performing unethical experiments for an unethical government.

I'm not arguing for that, and I don't think it's the only possible situation.

> "it's science, you never get it right at the first experiment"

> "there is going to be a lot of guinea pig children with serious secondary effects"

I don't think so. If this does happen then it would be extremely sad, but I don't think it's very likely. Scientists are far more careful than that. A new drug has to go through many stages before it is ever tested in clinical trials, and these human trials are generally very safe. So I'm just trying to say that if this is done properly and with a lot of safeguards, then gene-editing is not inherently unethical.

But you're probably right about China. They have a horrible history of human-rights abuses, and I think they are much more likely to get this wrong. Even if it's not a government program, Chinese companies don't have a great track record [1]. I wouldn't be surprised if they were already performing some reckless experiments, and all of these people should locked up.

[1] https://qz.com/1323471/ten-years-after-chinas-melamine-laced...

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:20AM (#18531252)
Perhaps this is true. I do not know. But human enhancement through genetic engineering is coming. Changes in traits, such as IQ, by 5+ standard deviations looks possible. We would be fools to outlaw it here, for we would become as children compared to future citizens of nations that do not share our taboos.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by skosuri on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:31AM (#18531302)
"Changes in traits, such as IQ, by 5+ standard deviations"... Where in the world are you getting this from? This is unlikely to be true for a long time. Intelligence, as far as genetics controls it, is a complex trait... with few if any large effect (especially positive) mutations.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:46AM (#18531374)
Though thousands of alleles contribute to intelligence, we would only need to edit a few hundred to get extremely large increases in IQ, especially if you perform a round of embryo selection (or even iterated embryo selection) before editing.

Editing hundreds of alleles may sound incredible to you now, but I don’t think it will sound so incredible for long.

Even ignoring GM, embryo selection can get us pretty far with current technology: https://www.gwern.net/Embryo-selection

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by skosuri on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:03AM (#18531448)
What you are saying is just not supported by evidence. For example, polygenic analysis of the latest meta-analysis from >250K individuals seems to say that the top several hundred variants explain in aggregrate only 5.2% of the variation in intelligence. Source: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41588-018-0152-6 (Supplement section 2.3.3 if you don't have access).
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:08AM (#18531470)
There is no human with all the positive variants; it is the the distribution of these variants that explains 5.2%. GM would allow you to create such a human.

That paper does not imply what you think it implies: that editing all these variants in an individual embryo would have a small effect.

An individual with the top 200 IQ-enhancing variants edited in (and an otherwise normal genome) would be far, far smarter than than than you seem to think, even though the variants edited only explain 5.2% of the differences within the population.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:14AM (#18531501)
There is a lot to unpack here. But this is basically science fiction, given how far out we are from understanding how to cosmetically modify complex traits in this way.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by skosuri on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:11AM (#18531483)
Ahh I see, you are just making stuff up.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:25AM (#18531543)
No. I think the claim "one can raise IQ several standard deviations by editing <200 alleles" is likely true:https://arxiv.org/pdf/1408.3421.pdf
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by skosuri on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:44AM (#18531592)
Yeah, know his work, and I don't think he'd agree with you: http://www.genetics.org/content/210/2/477
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by kanzure on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:32AM (#18533567)
Your method of modifying human height is naive because it assumes that your genetic modification technique to increase height would need to modify or even know about height alleles. edit: We last talked October 2015, hi.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by skosuri on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:44PM (#18537884)
Hello :-). My method???
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by gwern on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:09PM (#18538019)
You are misunderstanding what 'variance explained' means. It means 'variance', as in, average differences between individuals; nothing to do with the average effect size or possible maxima or anything like that. It refers only to predicting the net effect after, being distributed at population frequencies, most of those hundred variants have canceled each other out. In editing, the population frequencies & distribution don't matter, only the summed effect size of all the variants flipped. Confusing one for the other is like confusing waves on a beach with a tsunami: https://www.gwern.net/Embryo-selection#limits-to-iterated-se...

Since they have an average effect size of ~0.05-0.1 IQ points or so, a few hundred of those would in fact be many SDs. You can download the PGS, grab the top few hundred or thousand betas, and sum them if you don't believe me. (I show this with Benyamin et al 2014 in that section above, but no reason one couldn't redo it with a better PGS; the results won't change much.)

And yes, Hsu really does believe this, he is quite explicit in that 2014 paper that that is how it would work (in addition to countless places on his blog & Twitter) and I've discussed it with him in the past.

(As other comments point out, the real problem with this logic is that the hits are usually not causal but tag the causal variant, even if you had some magic CRISPR which could make hundreds of arbitrary edits. That's soluble, but not easily. It is, however, not a problem for selection procedures.)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:07AM (#18531467)
In addition, even with that much or more explanatory power, we generally do not think we have necessarily identified causal variants in most cases. We identify groups of associated variants that signify an interesting locus. There isn’t currently a generic framework that lets us decide which ones are causal.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by sanxiyn on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:28AM (#18531549)
You need causal variants to do editing, but tagging variants are sufficient for selecting.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by blueblimp on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @12:00AM (#18549407)
I'm bullish on selection approaches generally, but I think editing is not as promising at the moment. Editing via double-strand breaks is just way too unreliable for use in embryos, and base editing is too limited to make use of GWAS info.

This could change if the tech improves, but it would need to improve A LOT.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by krastanov on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:59AM (#18531426)
Just checking: you do know that there is a difference between change of "5 standard deviations" and change of "5 IQ points". 5 standard deviations is equal to "1 in 3.5 million", which makes your claim fairly farfetched with the tech of today or of the future decade or two, especially given how IQ is much more function of nurture than of nature.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:03AM (#18531451)
I am aware of this. Genetic engineering implies far more power than Gwern mentions for one round of embryo selection. 5 standard deviations may sound a lot for you, but in animal breeding we have changed the distribution of various traits by far more than 5 standard deviations. Into the dozens.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nradov on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:29AM (#18531290)
Genetic engineering might be able to prevent certain inherited diseases, but otherwise major net improvements are unlikely. A boost in one area tends to cause problems in other areas. That's why evolution through natural selection hasn't significantly increased average human intelligence over the past few thousand years. The average human genome appears to be close to a local maximum.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by BurningFrog on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:42AM (#18531364)
Human intelligence has not increased because it has not been strongly selected for. If it was maximized, at the expense of other traits, a lot could definitely happen.

> The average human genome appears to be close to a local maximum.

Absolutely, but it's maximized for the environment we lived in 10-100 generations ago.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nradov on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:52AM (#18531402)
"Superior IQs are associated with mental and physical disorders, research suggests"

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/bad-news-for-the-...

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nostrademons on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:12AM (#18531490)
Not saying the conclusion is wrong, but that experimental methodology seems sketchy as hell. Why? Their sample consisted entirely of Mensa members. Mensa != the general population of high-IQ individuals.

You join Mensa if your IQ is a large part of your identity. Individuals who have a high IQ but also have a lot of other things going on in their lives (like career success or fulfilling personal relationships) tend to concentrate on those things rather than join Mensa. Therefore, membership in Mensa tends to overselect for individuals whose self-conception is both narrow and focused on their intelligence. There's a lot of other evidence in psychology that a narrow self-conception correlates highly with mood & anxiety disorders. You can also get correlations with physical ailments like environmental allergies and asthma as well, because someone who doesn't have these physical ailments is more able to get outside or pick up sports rather than go to meetings of a high-IQ society.

So the way they designed their experiment, they introduced tons of conflating factors that may or may not actually have anything to do with IQ. It's certainly possible that high IQs are associated with mental and physical disorders - but what the experiment shows is that membership in Mensa is associated with mental and physical disorders.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by barry-cotter on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:50AM (#18532415)
IQ is positively correlated with physical and mental health, height and longevity. We have strong evidence for all of those. Given it’s generally positive effects and the fact that we have copious examples of high IQ success stories this result seems unlikely to hold up.

IQ predicts health and longevity.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.0963-7214.200...

Intelligence Predicts Health and Longevity, but Why? Linda S. Gottfredson1, Ian J. Deary

Low iq is a risk factor for several mental health disorders.

https://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/doi/abs/10.1176/appi.ajp.20...

> Results: Lower childhood IQ was associated with increased risk of developing schizophrenia spectrum disorder, adult depression, and adult anxiety. Lower childhood IQ was also associated with greater comorbidity and with persistence of depression; the association with persistence of generalized anxiety disorder was nearly significant. Higher childhood IQ predicted increased risk of adult mania.

Childhood IQ and adult mental disorders: a test of the cognitive reserve hypothesis

Karestan C Koenen

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by BurningFrog on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:36AM (#18531564)
In the random high IQ population, this is probably true.

In a population that got carefully selected traits for high IQ, these tradeoffs could over time be understood and the effects minimized.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:38AM (#18531343)
This is not true. Intelligence is polygenic. The average human is no Von Neumann. At the very least genetic engineering could raise average IQ to Von Neumann’s level. We know that phenotype is possible with no ill effects. It will likely take us much further.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nradov on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:42AM (#18531363)
You haven't addressed my point. No one disputes that intelligence is partly genetic. However if it was possible to raise intelligence through genetic engineering with no ill effects then why hasn't evolution increased the incidence of that phenotype already?
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by ganz on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:56AM (#18531412)
Not my area of expertise, but I think the intuition for why evolution didn't make us all Einstein's comes in two parts:

(1) IQ is very polygenetic - a big IQ gene might be 0.1 IQ, and there aren't a lot even that large, if I recall the large genome wide association studies done on this. As GWAS studies get larger we find more, but they're all super small effects.

(2) Having an extra 0.1 IQ point is easy to lose in the noise of other effects on having offspring.

So even if we assumed IQ was perfectly correlated with more surviving offspring in modern societies, it might take an extremely long time (even longer than a whole planet and a thousand years) to make a detectable difference.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by cygx on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:53AM (#18531790)
Why aren't all birds as smart as crows? Because the Blind Idiot God of Evolution doesn't care that you think increased intelligence is an obvious 'win'.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by barry-cotter on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:56AM (#18532435)
Gwern has written an essay on why.

https://www.gwern.net/Drug-heuristics

Here’s a brief snippet

> the intervention may be simple, give major enhancements, but result in a net loss of reproductive fitness The famous Ashkenazi theory of intelligence comes to mind. According to this theory, the Ashkenazi were forced into occupations demanding intelligence, and micro-selected for high intelligence. Except the high IQ genes were not previously prevalent among either Jews or gentiles because - like sickle-cell anemia - when they became too prevalent, they result in horrible diseases like Tay-Sachs. In 2007, a unique mutation in a Scottish family was found to increase verbal IQ in afflicted family members vs non by something like 25 points; this would be great for them - except for how that mutation starts causing blindness in one’s 20s or later. (In general, it’s much easier to find mutations or other genetic changes breaking intelligence than helping in cases of retardation26 and autism27.)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by gwern on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:16PM (#18538083)
It's worth noting that the Ashkenazi theory remains unproven. No one has actually found any variants which would increase intelligence markedly. At some point that starts to look suspicious - maybe they don't exist after all.

Based on all the GWASes and additional studies which have been done since 2007 and a continued absence of confirmed examples of IQ-boosting variants with negative pleiotropic effects, I now would explain the lack of optimization of intelligence as being an example of 'too complex for evolution because too many little changes to do simultaneously', that is, mutation load: essentially, there are too many little effects (which sum up to make us far stupider than we have to be), which have been created & maintained by too many demographic bottlenecks and genetic drift and other effects, too much background selection, and too much selection on other traits (plus some level of dysgenics), for the various harmful variants to have been meaningfully selected against over the past 50kya. And that's why we could boost intelligence a lot with few harmful and many beneficial side effects.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by FloatingVertex on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:59AM (#18531427)
Historrically inteligence has been a trait that had to be balanced with other factors in natural selection, traits such as having lower energy consumption, lower reaction time were important in the past in a way they simply aren't today. Sacrificing in other less relevent areas could easily lead to intelligence gains.

(Note I am not advocating for gene editing)

Also I don't think we have reached a local maximum, human society kind of fucks with natural selection so I imagine there is room for improvement.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by wycs on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:50AM (#18531394)
Most likely because it seems to be a phenotype that does not reproduce itself. None of Von Neumann’s children had kids if I recall correctly. This environment does not select for IQ past a certain point; this does not imply we cannot engineer people to be more intelligent any more than it implies we cannot engineer people to be dwarfs.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by buboard on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:48AM (#18531989)
because nature does not optimize some axis, it selects the most survivable. nature can be dumb too
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by choot on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:40AM (#18532394)
I've IQ of 90 (taken it multiple times) which is considered below average on Standford Binnet test.

I didn't do good at school but i had many friends! I never felt i was less intelligent than my friends which make me question the IQ score thing.

My Dad has high IQ (135) and he's a mathematician.

So how did i inhert low IQ? My mom's score is average at best, 102.

I've sold 3 companies, i am married and I've managed to be quite wealthy.

You don't need to posses high intelligence to survive and reproduce in this world that's why it's not selected for.

We don't walk out of womb and given a puzzle to solve where if we fail, we are instantly killed.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nradov on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:34AM (#18534018)
Right so you're getting into deeper questions of what intelligence really means, and whether our measurements are meaningful in practical terms. Even if it was possible to genetically engineer humans with much higher IQs (and that is yet to be proven), there's still no evidence that those hypothetical supermen would end up ruling over us or having more children or whatever.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by mmirate on Monday November 26, 2018 @08:12AM (#18533053)
> A boost in one area tends to cause problems in other areas.

Some problem areas are no longer as such because today's environment is much better at compensating for them than the environment that we actually evolved-for.

Energy efficiency comes to mind prominently: we've never been better at producing human-consumable energy in our entire history, yet we can't actually use the stuff because our bodies still interact with energy much like children-of-the-Depression interact with money.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:23AM (#18531259)
> Perhaps this is true. I do not know. But human enhancement through genetic engineering is coming. Changes in traits, such as IQ, by 5+ standard deviations looks possible. We would be fools to outlaw it here, for we would become as children compared to future citizens of Asian nations.

What is the relevance of "Asian nations?" to this conversation?

Also, we're talking about a specific experiment that was allegedly conducted in human beings with (good but error-prone) genome editing mechanisms, outside of the purview of peer review or, from what I can tell, an IRB.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nostrademons on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:55AM (#18531408)
"What is the relevance of "Asian nations?" to this conversation?"

I would assume it's because the article describes genetically-engineered babies in China, so obviously it's not outlawed there (or if it is, the law is not enforced). Grandparent poster is pointing out that if genetic engineering gives survival or competitive benefits to those who do it, it doesn't matter what your personal ethical, moral, and legal standards are, because your whole society will be outcompeted by societies without those strictures.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by anvandare on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:50AM (#18531776)
The purists need not be worried. There's always the hope the descendants of those humans who do take the path of editing their own genetic code will, a few centuries from now, give those purists' descendants a nice small patch of land as a reservation.

Or maybe a cozy cage in a zoo, with a little sign next to the bars which reads: "homo sapiens inferior".

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by coldtea on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:42AM (#18531971)
Or, you know, the purists will be spared untold suffering that those others will have to go through because of "magician's apprentice" style editing...
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by anvandare on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:45AM (#18532169)
Of course the first period of experimentation and discovery will lead to unexpected and unpleasant results. All new technology takes time to mature, for the users to get an understanding of its tricky implementation bits and long-term impact. It's not wise to immediately put all your eggs in a brand new basket. But the ones who experiment and adapt will always eventually outperform those who refuse to change and stick to tried-and-tested. That's the very nature of evolution.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by coldtea on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:45AM (#18532626)
>That's the very nature of evolution.

Evolution is blind to such concerns. Those who "experiment" might be wiped out because of their experiments gone wrong, and evolution wont care at all.

A creature inventing tools might have an evolutionary advantage over others. A creature inventing e.g. biological warfare and nuclear weapons might have less an advantage, it can easily wipe most of its own kind and even collapse its civilization (losing even more advantages).

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by alehander42 on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:06AM (#18532267)
This is so arrogantly naive, that I hope it's sarcasm
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by dqpb on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:27AM (#18531283)
"good but error prone" describes all of medical care right now. Hell, pharmaceuticals aren't even good in many cases.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by ethbro on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:12AM (#18531489)
"Good but error prone" seems to aptly describe our current method of producing offspring.

Gene editing is mandatory, if only because we've managed to turn many previously lethal mutations into livable, and reproducible, ones.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:31AM (#18531304)
That's absolutely not the standard for deciding to conduct an experiment on humans.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by barry-cotter on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:01AM (#18532459)
Only true if your country and culture cares about IRBs. China doesn’t, it’s a quarter of the human population and it won’t be long until it’s that of global GDP at least. What a bunch of post Christians with delusions about the universality of their ethical code think does not bother them at all.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by goatlover on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:51AM (#18533688)
Yeah, but then maybe India will counter-balance that. From what I've heard, their ethical code will be against any such modifications.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by coldtea on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:38AM (#18531954)
>Changes in traits, such as IQ, by 5+ standard deviations looks possible.

This looks totally unlikely.

Not to mention generally undesirable (people with IQ over 150 or so often have severe problems in their social life, and a lot of them don't ever even create or discover much, not to mention the insufferable part whose main accomplishment is to be members of MENSA).

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by nugget on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:14PM (#18535485)
150+ IQ is a lonely place to be because there aren’t many other people to connect with, especially for kids born in more rural areas without resources. It’s easy for these kids to self destruct. Turning a kid that smart into a happy, stable, productive member of society is an intensive 18+ year process that usually involves curated peers and experts with specific domain expertise. Check out Davidson Academy in Reno to read more.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by shubb on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:31AM (#18532360)
They didn't actually specify positive. It would be pretty easy to reduce IQ by 5+ standard deviations. Plenty of monogenic disorders cause learning disabilities, just gotta knock out those genes...
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by yters on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:54AM (#18532951)
"It is inevitable that stumbling blocks come, but woe to him through whom they come!" - Jesus
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by linkmotif on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:46AM (#18531597)
So be it. Let them have it, if it means not being human.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by fooker on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:39AM (#18531348)
> not morally or ethically defensible

Sure, that won't stop progress by people who do not follow your flavor of morality or ethics, though.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:10AM (#18531475)
What is your evidence that the post-WWII flavor of bioethics inhibits real progress? If that were true, why do we not see other systems leading?
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by jpgvm on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:17AM (#18531513)
We do. In China. Not just in biology but also AI/ML. They are willing (and able) to do the things others find reprehensible. It's already apparent just how far ahead they are in the AI/ML field, I suspect biology/medicine will follow.

It's a very real threat and believing that The West has a head start and is more intelligent/better funded/other excuse is not going to end well for us.

China achieves goals though brute force with very little regard for ethics or norms.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by buboard on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:50AM (#18531996)
The west has spent far more brainpower in making up bioethics regulations than actually talking about the procedures themselves. Cue the threads over here.

Also note the differences in culture: the chinese parents consented to it. I m not sure how easy it would be to find this in the west.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:54AM (#18532955)
The unfamiliarity of random HN commenters with genetics is overwhelmingly clear, but that does not mean that geneticists in the US are not thinking about this.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by empath75 on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:17AM (#18533471)
> is not morally or ethically defensible

Based on whose ethics and morals? Eventually a country is going to go all in on robotics and genetic engineering, ethics be damned, and the rest of the world is going to be left in the dust -- economically and militarily.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by buboard on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:56AM (#18532005)
maybe we should be screening couples before we allow them to copulate, then. taking gambles with randomization experiments is 100% ethically indefensible.

please, spare us the "100% correct" and certified ethical positions

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by jobigoud on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:17AM (#18542032)
You can argue that not fixing biological defects when you have the means to is ethically indefensible.

It's not black and white.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by feelix on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:22AM (#18531258)
calling an opinion "100% correct" seems 100% indefensible
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by DennisAleynikov on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:24AM (#18531268)
"an experiment on human beings [is] not morally or ethically defensible" is not an opinion but an assertion of how genetic editing fits into our current moral and ethical frameworks.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by logicchains on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:02AM (#18531442)
>our current moral and ethical frameworks.

Clearly those moral and ethical frameworks are not shared by at least one Chinese scientist.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:12AM (#18531486)
And we can find people who disagree with the broad consensus on climate change, too. Is there a broader point you are getting at?
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by jpgvm on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:24AM (#18531540)
Facts are not opinion. Morals and ethics however definitely are.

You can show with empirical evidence that climate change is true.

However no matter how hard you try you can't show with evidence that your moral framework or ethics are somehow the "one true moral/ethical truth".

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:57AM (#18532971)
Kiran is 100% correct in describing the scientific ethical consensus. These things are far more closely related than you believe.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by aaronharnly on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:21AM (#18532538)
> Facts are not opinion. Morals and ethics however definitely are.

Is that a fact, or an opinion? :-)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by elcomet on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:37AM (#18531335)
But it is an opinion. Being an assertion doesn't prevent it from being an opinion.

You and I could very well find arguments for defending it, even while fitting the current morale.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:47AM (#18531378)
The semantic argument about how I phrased my agreement is more worthy of discussion than the ethical argument about the alleged human experimentation?
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by paganel on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:21AM (#18531876)
I think some people are trying to rationalize this way too much, that's why they end up going after semantics and such.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by yesenadam on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:29AM (#18532823)
Who is the "us" in "our"?

(Straight question, that really isn't obvious to me at all.)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:24AM (#18531265)
Since this implies that you find this action more than 0% defensible, I'm curious to hear your defense of it.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by dqpb on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:28AM (#18531287)
Here is a simple argument - if you can prevent disease, you should.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:34AM (#18531320)
"Can prevent disease" implies that you are not doing experimentation. If you're doing experiments, it means you don't know if you can.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by chr1 on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:32AM (#18531921)
You can prevent disease if you make experiments and learn how to prevent it.

So in this case experimentation is a first step in preventing disease.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:58AM (#18532975)
In what ethical framework is experimenting on humans the first step?

(The answer is none.)

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by throwa789 on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:27AM (#18533941)
Ethical frameworks are optional, humans sacrifice other humans to acquire power and knowledge regularly, that's the nature of the world
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by zxcvvcxz on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:28AM (#18531286)
Why?

Seriously why? We do so many unnatural things to us through technology. The article discusses editing genes to try and prevent viruses.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:33AM (#18531314)
The modern biomedical ethical framework comes out of Nuremburg in response to Nazi atrocities.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuremberg_Code

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by barry-cotter on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:12AM (#18532507)
There’s nothing in there that would obviously prohibit the experiment we’re all discussing here. I can see how someone who deals with university IRBs or professional bioethicists might think there is but if we used risk reward thresholds as high as they do, or held to the precautionary principle that strongly we would still be discussing whether fire was a good idea. IRBs are a one way ratchet with tiny incentives to approve and large ones to deny. They are a cancerous growth on science.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @08:00AM (#18532994)
You’re saying that you can see how an expert would think that there is something in the Nuremberg Code that prohibits the experiment we are talking about here, but you know better than the experts?
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by barry-cotter on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:38AM (#18533606)
You are an expert in your field of medicine. You are much better at making predictions from data in it than lay people and you are vastly better at effecting changes in your domain of expertise than laymen. That’s real expertise, like engineers, meteorologists, astronomers, microeconomists, or engineers have. Then there are people who are experts on talking about something but have no expertise in doing. Art historians are quite close to astronomers here in that they can be very good at out of sample tests and prediction but have limited ability to do things because their field doesn’t call upon them to do more than render accurate judgments. Then there are people who master a body of lore, who are called upon to discuss things. Ethicists are in this group, like priests, pastors or imams.

Ethicists are experts in talking about ethics. They have no special expertise in acting ethically, compared to other philosophers[1].

Ethicists have expertise in what amounts to a body of administrative law, like rabbis, imams or canon lawyers.

And we have strong evidence of actual harm caused by them. If bioethicists can’t get their shit together enough to defend compensated kidney or gamete donation they aren’t even broadly neutral. There are people being paid to argue against saving lives, and against helping to bring into the world new lives that are actively wanted. There are ethicists who argue that poor people can’t really consent because the offer of some good to sufficiently poor person qualifies as duress.

The Nuremberg Code is good. The system of IRBs and bioethicists built up around it is not just bad, it’s genuinely awful.

[1]The moral behavior of ethics professors: Relationships among self-reported behavior, expressed normative attitude, and directly observed behavior Eric Schwitzgebel & Joshua Rust

https://philpapers.org/rec/SCHTMB-4

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by carbocation on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:48AM (#18534631)
What I often observe on HN is that SlateStarCodex didn't understand how IRBs work, wrote about it, and therefore many people think that IRBs are bad. So, I am wary of IRB arguments here. Not implying that your information on IRBs comes from that one person, just saying that I don't love arguing about IRBs on HN because of a repeated pattern here.

If your point is that "IRBs could be improved in various ways", I'd be happy to agree in many cases. But also, there are some shining examples of enlightened IRBs that make human research at scale quite practical.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by barry-cotter on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:47PM (#18538910)
I feel ok with supporting Scott Alexander’s position when it is both (a) obviously correct, (b) IRBs regulate sociologists and psychologists doing surveys which is farcical, and (c) Carl E. Schneider, professor of medicine and law at the University of Michigan wrote an entire book on how IRBs fail to work.

http://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/?p=7193

https://kiej.georgetown.edu/carl-e-schneider-the-censors-han...

IRBs do not have a problem. They are a problem. If we must have IRBs they should be deprofessionalised to the fullest extent possible rather than staffed by people whose job and motivation is to find problems where none exist and add more bureaucracy to prove they are actually doing some work. IRB as jury service seems like it could be acceptable. Twelve people, a three hour course on the Nuremberg code and the scientist presenting their application. And absolutely no bioethicists.

If you’re interested in the book put it on an Amazon wish list and email me the link at barrypcotter at iCloud. I’ll buy it because more doctors and scientists should know IRBs are a cancer on society and science.

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by danenania on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:58AM (#18531423)
Because it requires medical experimentation on human beings who can’t consent to it. Is it really so difficult to understand why that’s wrong?
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by ajmurmann on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:21AM (#18531532)
If a few dozen or even thousand suffer to prevent the suffering of many millions or even billions in the long run, is that not a trade off one would have to make? It all comes down to the old debate of deontology vs utilitarianism
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by danenania on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:41AM (#18531583)
It’s called an experiment because no one knows whether it will prevent the suffering of anyone at all.

If you had to live your entire life with a painful deformity because someone experimented on your genes, do you think you’d find this argument convincing?

Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by linkmotif on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:49AM (#18531603)
I hope you’re first in line to be among the those who suffer.
Re:First gene-edited babies claimed in China by ajmurmann on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @10:01AM (#18542747)
Fortunately that won't be necessary. Both of us are safe. The Chinese are doing the research for us. If they don't succeed they suffered and we are not impacted. If they do succeed, they suffered, get some food jobs and money and we likely get to benefit from most of the results. So we can have our cake and eat it to. Yay \O/