News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by lbacaj on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:52PM (#18528957)
Unfortunately for Apple, I do think the App Store being an exclusive and default way to purchase and load apps on iOS is in fact causing prices of Apps, in many cases, to be higher than they should be.

The perfect example of this is the subscription services, right now you can get a cheaper subscription to a service such as Spotify if you buy it off the App Store. That is a prime example of how much the 30% payment to Apple is hurting developers and ultimately consumers... Apple is so upset about this they won’t let developers like Spotify link to buying the subscription on their own website anywhere on the app that is sold through their App Store, if that’s not Monopoly abuse I don’t know what is.

As much as I love Apples products I do feel that they have gotten away with a lot here, especially since there is zero other ways to load apps into iOS devices, in the very least consumers are paying 30% more for apps if there was a competing App Store on iOS that charged less to load apps.

Edit: whether the Supreme Court will see it this way or not is a whole other issue.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ihuman on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:43PM (#18529831)
How long have you been using the iOS app store for? IMO App prices now are lower than they were when the app store first opened in iPhoneOS 2, and way lower than they were before the iPhone. I remember simple games for Palm OS costing at about $20 [0] . Nowadays that game would either be <=$5, or free to play.

[0] https://web.archive.org/web/20040418012411/http://astraware....

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:19PM (#18530285)
> IMO App prices now are lower than they were when the app store first opened in iPhoneOS 2

This provides no basis for comparison because the App Store has been the only way to install apps on iOS that whole time, so that changing can't have been the difference.

Moreover, the market they're monopolizing isn't the market for apps, it's the market for app distribution. So the relevant price isn't the price of apps, it's Apple's 30%. Which is obviously higher than in markets where there isn't a single-party distribution monopoly, e.g. payment processing is typically ~3%, various packaging systems like apt are free (or user can download binary from website as on Windows), and the binary hosting cost per user is negligible.

There is also a tying argument. App Store ties payment processing, distribution and curation together when the buyer might want different providers for each.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by RKearney on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:22PM (#18530804)
> This provides no basis for comparison because the App Store has been the only way to install apps on iOS

This has never been the case. You’ve always been able to side load apps that are either signed by an Enterprise code signing cert (used to be $300/yr), or your own developer code signing certificate ($99/yr). The former allowed for redistribution outside of the App Store.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:34PM (#18530842)
Neither of those methods permits the general public to install the app.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by RKearney on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:49AM (#18533676)
They absolutely can and absolutely did back in the day. Now it’s even easier because you can load apps on to your own device for free via Xcode.

Anyone who claims Apple prevented side loading clearly never bothered to research that claim.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by askafriend on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:23AM (#18531261)
Good, imo.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by binomialxenon on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:59AM (#18531430)
Okay, I used to be an iOS user, I'm not rich, and blowing $99 per year to sign apps is a lot of money for something that should be free. What if I'm just a normal techie who wants to use software that Apple doesn't like? Sure, bury sideloading in the settings or make it only able to be activated from a computer, but charging that much money for the privilege of loading software is ridiculous.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by RKearney on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:46AM (#18533654)
You can sign and run apps on your own device for free now. You no longer have to pay $99.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by mmebane on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:11PM (#18536833)
You can, but you have to reinstall them once a week, AFAIK.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sbuk on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:13AM (#18531494)
> ...for something that should be free

What reason should it be for?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by binomialxenon on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:35PM (#18535670)
The reason that my devices belong to me.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sbuk on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @02:50AM (#18549914)
The devices do, the software doesn’t.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by binomialxenon on Friday November 30, 2018 @09:10PM (#18574598)
And that's why I'm no longer an iOS user.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by myhf on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:52PM (#18530141)
Price of "Angry Birds" in 2009: $0.99 one-time

Price of the same "Angry Birds" in 2018: $0 to install, $1.99 per 80 gems, no way to disable in-app ads or purchases.

Free-to-play is an increase in price.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by GordonS on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:44AM (#18532165)
I really despise the move from transparent, one-time pricing, to opaque IAP.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ghaff on Monday November 26, 2018 @08:42AM (#18533249)
I agree. Unfortunately the complaint is mostly about hating a market dominated by people who increasingly won't pay anything for goods that aren't actually welded in place but will grudgingly fork over money in the form of eyeballs (i.e. ads) and "tricks" (in-app purchases, hidden fees, etc.). Personally, I'd mostly prefer honest up-front pricing (though subscriptions make sense for some things) but the market mostly doesn't want that.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by prewett on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:48AM (#18531385)
Even if it is an increase in price (debatable), that doesn't mean that Apple's distribution monopoly is responsible. I expect that prices on Android have done the same thing, and Google doesn't even monopolize the distribution there.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by zimpenfish on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:59AM (#18532241)
The exact same thing has happened in the AAA games market (see EA, Activision, or Jim Sterling's many videos on the topic) which is provably nothing to do with "Apple's distribution monopoly".
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by lbacaj on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:24PM (#18530017)
I have had an iPhone since the first one and access to the App Store since they introduced it in the 3G.

I completely agree that prices on Apps have come down but that is just what happens when a new market is created. Supply and demand has to set in. Developers are guessing what people will pay at first and if they find they can sell millions more if they just drop the price to 99c then they might just do that. In my opinion the Apple App Store has had very little to do with those prices coming down.

While I do admit the App Store was incredibly innovative and has ushered in an era of new ways for developers to create/distribute/monetize this stuff it is hard to deny that if there was any competing way to load Apps that the 30% fee Apple collects would stand... not to mention the many practices that developers (and consumers) disagree with that Apple regularly does such banning apps that may compete with their products or somehow upset them.

Edit: I don’t want to come off as overly negative here, I love Apple and their products. I am simply arguing that a little competition here would do consumers good.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sbuk on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:17AM (#18531515)
How would it do consumers good?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by threeseed on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:25PM (#18529150)
Apple provides a service for that 30% though. They handle the payment processing, they build, moderate and curate the App Store apps and they provide a lucrative channel to market for app developers. So allowing Spotify et al to get all the benefits of the channel without paying for it is actually unfair to Apple.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by samat on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:15PM (#18529418)
This argument will easily hold if there were any way to have a competing store on iOS devices. Apple banning any competition in that field makes ‘buy they provide value for the money’ look like forcing consumers hand.

Not sure if I want to have a second AppStore (APNS, etc, etc.)

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by threeseed on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:40PM (#18529812)
No. The argument holds irrespective of whether there is 1 store or a million stores.

Spotify wants to use Apple's distribution channel without paying for it.

That's unfair and doesn't reflect what happens in the real world. If I sell my software through a retail store they still take a cut.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sulam on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:02PM (#18530193)
Let’s use the Kindle app as an example then. The app cannot link to their site when I search for a book I don’t have. If it did, the app would be banned. So Apple is trying to extract a 30% premium from Amazon and the only way for them to avoid that is to give me a shitty experience that quantifiable harms me (I waste time to search for and then hop through the download behavior, adding friction to what should be a seamless flow). In return for their 30% they are adding very little value. Amazon does it’s own payment processing, curation is surely not worth almost a third of every book I buy, storage is paid for by Amazon, and the transmission costs are paid for by me.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by dwaite on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:09PM (#18531002)
I disagree with it being called an Apple premium.

Apple has a store. Amazon has a store. Who is to say that Amazon's portion of operational costs and profit isn't the premium?

Amazon could choose to have a Kindle experience which doesn't go through the App store, such as a HTML 5 app. They distribute in the store because of the discoverability (and likely because they prefer to have a native app that can enforce their store's content DRM.)

Amazon could choose to expose more functionality through their app, such as title search, being able to look at reviews, download sample chapters, and even be able to fetch new books through the kindle unlimited and other prime features. They prefer to drive everyone to their own store instead.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sulam on Monday November 26, 2018 @03:50PM (#18536684)
Have you used the Kindle app?

You can do title search, look at details of books, see reviews, download sample chapters, and download Kindle Unlimited books directly to your library with one click.

I presume what you _can_ and _can't_ do is directly dictated by Apple's policies, not what the Kindle team has been able to implement. As others have pointed out, native apps are a far superior user experience to HTML "apps".

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by GranPC on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:29PM (#18531087)
Wait, so are you arguing that an HTML5 app is a perfect replacement for a native app?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by metildaa on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:23AM (#18531264)
They are arguing that the janky, hamstrung progressive web app infrastructure for iOS is a replacement for a native app.

Sadly, due to Apple forcing everything to use Safari's browser engine, PWAs are redheaded stepchildren on iOS: https://mobile.twitter.com/jbogard/status/104788904642763161...

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by binomialxenon on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:03AM (#18531447)
HTML apps are never even close to working as well as a native app, they're generally a shitty compromise. If $COMPANY makes an app that would be crippled by Apple's policies, they should be free to distribute it through another channel to iOS users.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by drawnwren on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:11PM (#18529954)
I suspect Spotify would prefer to have their app on iOS without using Apple's distribution channel if they could.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by dwaite on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:10PM (#18531007)
Only because they could then do direct sign-up and billing without having to pay anyone a cut.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Tsubasachan on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:37AM (#18532135)
One of the most powerful things the internet has done for us: cut out the middlemen. Even Amazon is not safe, I foresee a future where people will order directly from the factory.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Oletros on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:57AM (#18532443)
Spotify is not using Apple distribution channel
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by nothrabannosir on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:12PM (#18529960)
> Apple provides a service for that 30% though.

Money is universally reviled, and rightfully so: it is a dark, vile, evil thing. It brings out the very worst in the very best of us. It brings entire countries to their knees. Money corrupts. Money is awful.

But there is one thing that money does better than anything else, bar nothing. No contest. No competitor on the horizon. Many have tried, all have failed. Money quanitifies value.

It is not up to you to defend how much money Apple should get. It is not up to us to contradict it. It is up to the market. This is the one and only thing it does well, so let's at least give it that.

Because allowing Apple to get all the benefits of determining the value of their app store, without letting the market give it a go, is actually unfair to Money.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by hamandcheese on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:39PM (#18531118)
> Money quantifies value

Money quantifies value... in our money based economy. Which is basically a tautology. Money in many cases fails to quantify utility and the same quantity of money has wildly varying utility from market to market.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by gobengo on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:30PM (#18530329)
> It is up to the market.

Insofar as Apple is a US Company, the US Government also gets a say.

Profit is a privilege. The US has a mixed economy, not a 'free market'.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by lighthazard on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:31PM (#18529183)
This was true a few years ago but in 2018, it's not a curated place to get software. It's the only marketplace to get software for your device. 30% is disproportionate to what's being offered today.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ken on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:18PM (#18529993)
- Payment processing, yes (though no other payment processor charges anywhere near 30% -- Stripe is 2.9%, I think?).

- Build, not exactly -- only in the sense that they can handle minor upgrades via bitcode for new ARM variants, if you choose to enable that.

- Moderate/curate, sure.

- Provide a lucrative channel? Yes, but only because they've made it the only channel by fiat.

I'm not sure I see 30% worth of mandatory value here. Is Apple's moderation so good it's worth 27% the cost of my app? Do developers think they're paying for bitcode upgrades, and do they think that justifies the fee? Recompiling for new minor architectures isn't difficult.

For that matter, is there more value provided in moderation for a more expensive app? If they approve my app at $5, and then I up the price to $25, did their moderation process retroactively become more valuable to anyone?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sbuk on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:20AM (#18531530)
Storage/hosting, support and distribution (bandwidth) are missing frim the list. Arguably, it may not cover 30%, but it does provide for more than 2.9%
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Oletros on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:56AM (#18532438)
Spotify/Kindle/etc subscriptions and purchases are not hosted or distributed by Apple.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sbuk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @12:24PM (#18544341)
No, but the apps are. Spotify comes in at 98MB, and Kindle at 113MB. That is a lot of bandwidth. Since Amazon don't offer IAP, they get that for free, Spotify do offer IAP, so contribute that way.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Oletros on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @03:36PM (#18546418)
Then Apple or Google can make developers pay for the size.

And no, Amazon doesn't get it for free, they pay the developer fees like ALL the other developers

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sbuk on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:35PM (#18547496)
> Then Apple or Google can make developers pay for the size.

They do; it's part of the 30% margin for the price of an App/IAP.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Oletros on Monday December 03, 2018 @10:17AM (#18589362)
IAP doesn't have any size for Apple
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ksec on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:08AM (#18531468)
Apple do offer iTunes Credit and often does discount of up to 15% from Retailers. ( I am betting those iTunes Credit are wholesale at anywhere between 13% to 10% discount, and Retailers takes in ~10 - 8% after deducting processing fees )

Still, not many buy iTunes Credit. Most just use Credit Card direct from Apple Pay. But even if we have included all these, the 30% is still excessive.

The problem Apple is having is similar to their phone, it is not about the price tag or the 30% charges, it is people paying for it fail to see or justify its value. Apple will need to offer more "values". From Developers to its Users.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by darpa_escapee on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:54PM (#18530150)
If Apple's involvement is worth a 30% cut, surely they can compete in the free market with other App stores and distribution methods.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by zuminator on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:17PM (#18529727)
So if Ann's a developer and doesn't want their payment processing, and Bruce is a consumer and doesn't want their curation, then the buyer and seller should be able to dispense with the surcharge if they dispense with the "service." But they can't (without jumping through hoops.) And what's more, if Trusty App Corp. were to come along and set up a 20% cut Trusty App store that could be conveniently installed via an exploit, they would be undoubtedly sued for IP violations, due to the state protecting Apple's exclusive right to Apple IP. This is pure rent-seeking on the part of Apple, and ultimately antitrust laws exist to discourage rent-seeking even more than discouraging monopolies per se.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by dd36 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:30PM (#18529174)
So charge the developers for that underwriting service.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Tsubasachan on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:29AM (#18532108)
Developers love Apple because there is no piracy or competition from F-droid. Also the Apple clientele are proven to be bigger spenders.

I love the Android community because they come up with cool things like DNS66 or YouTube Vanced. Ad blocking on iOS is halfhearted.

All that said Apple can do what they want consumers have a choice: buy an Android phone.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by GordonS on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:41AM (#18532147)
Is piracy really an issue on Android? I've never pirated an Android app in the 10 years or so I've been using Android, and I don't know anyone who was.

Would love to see some unbiased numbers on this.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by Tsubasachan on Monday November 26, 2018 @08:44AM (#18533268)
Well providing numbers for something that is illegal and happens on shady websites is difficult, just as nobody can tell you exactly how much cocaine enters the port of Rotterdam each year. But I found this to be an interesting read.

https://www.xda-developers.com/piracy-testimonies-causes-and...

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by screye on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:55AM (#18533714)
I think part of the problem is that whales use Apple.

Despite having 80+% of the market mobile market share, most of these customers are low spending people looking for vfm phones and good enough free apps. Apple is the one that captures the top 5% of customers who spend on subscription services and expensive apps.

This gives the false appearance of Android being piracy heaven. Because, why else would a 4 times bigger consumer base generate a smaller revenue.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by delinka on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:31PM (#18529187)
"...an exclusive and default way to purchase and load apps on iOS"

If the court allows the definition of 'trust' to include "a company gatekeeping developer access to their own operating system" when that operating system represents a much smaller share of the market than the next biggest competitor.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by vatueil on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:11PM (#18529389)
It's true that iOS has a smaller share of the market globally, including many parts of Europe, but this overshadows the fact that iOS is almost on par with Android in the United States (44.3% to Android's 54.5% as of May 2018), probably higher among affluent users, and the leading mobile operating system in other countries such as Britain: https://www.statista.com/statistics/266572/market-share-held...

I feel this is often overlooked in discussions where users from certain areas where iOS is less prevalent don't understand the perspective of users from other regions where iOS is more popular.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by bilbo0s on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:43PM (#18529555)
>(44.3% to Android's 54.5% as of May 2018)...

???

Doesn't that mean iOS has the minority market share?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by delinka on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:28PM (#18530323)
A minority/majority distinction is unnecessary. If the market share is significant and can be shown to harm enough consumers (and especially if the behavior can be shown to harm even users of competitors' systems), then there still could be a decision in favor of consumers.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by zepto on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:40PM (#18529816)
10% lower than the next competitor, and less than half overall.

Not a monopoly.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jp555 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:20PM (#18530002)
But definitely an iOS monopoly.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by scarface74 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:48PM (#18530123)
And Nintendo, Somy, and MS have monopoles on their stores. Just like if you don’t like what one console offers you are free to buy another one, if you don’t like what’s available for iOS, you are free to buy an Android.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by tokyodude on Sunday November 25, 2018 @09:55PM (#18530690)
4 wrongs don't make right. Nintendo, Sony, and MS should also not be allowed to have monopolies on their stores.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by scarface74 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:05PM (#18530738)
And now we are redefining “monopoly”. This has been going on for 30 years. The console manufacturers have had lock out chips on their cartridges, specially made disk, etc forever.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by kd5bjo on Monday November 26, 2018 @05:34AM (#18532370)
Not forever. This all started with the death of Atari, which was commonly blamed on poor-quality 3rd-party games ruining their reputation with consumers.

I haven't looked into the history enough to judge whether this perception is accurate in hindsight. Like most things, I expect it's a lot messier than the popular narrative.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by scarface74 on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:10AM (#18532495)
As I said, “for over 30 years”.

It started at least with the original Nintendo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIC_(Nintendo)

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jp555 on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @10:33AM (#18543057)
Yep! Monopoly just means there's only one supplier of any commodity. It does not mean there are no alternatives.

A patent is a government-issued monopoly.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by scarface74 on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @11:04AM (#18543443)
In that case you can define monopoly however you want.

You could say that YCombinator has a monopoly on posts to HN.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jp555 on Saturday December 01, 2018 @07:40AM (#18576526)
The definition of a monopoly is when there is only one seller of something. That exclusivity can be achieved in a number of ways such as patents, trade secrets, or some other monopoly moat.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jimktrains2 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:17PM (#18530787)
> Nintendo, Somy[sic], and MS

You don't need to purchase games directly from Nintendo, nor music or games or video directly from Sony, nor are Sony Videos only playable on Sony devices, nor do you have to only install Microsoft "blessed" executable for Windows.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by dwaite on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:24PM (#18531062)
You realize that Nintendo controls the title signing keys, their own App Store, and the physical manufacturing of cartridges right? They also require merchants to sign contracts saying they will not have a posted price below the retail sale price without approval.

I fail to see how saying you don't have to purchase "directly" from Nintendo matters.

FWIW, a similar setup to Playstation (you seem to have conflated Sony, which makes your point confusing considering that Sony has other subsidiaries that publish music and video). Playstation has a music and video store which will give you media DRM locked to your console.

Finally, Microsoft has an App Store which distributes "blessed" executables. There have been several editions of windows which only allow applications distributed through this store to run, such as the first iteration of the Microsoft Surface that ran ARM. There is speculation that this move is what prompted Valve to release their own Linux distribution, because Steam would be severely impacted if they no longer had an ability to run their own store.

Luckily for Valve, those limited distributions haven't made much headway.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jimktrains2 on Monday November 26, 2018 @10:59AM (#18534207)
Yes, I realize that for console gaming you need to be "approved" to write games.

However, my understanding is that this suite is about apple abusing the app-writing monopoly to also let only them sell apps, which is why I thought the console game analogy was sound.

As for merchants, I'm sure second hand stores and those at flea markets have signed all of these contracts. /S

Yes, I was sort-of referencing multiple arms of Sony. Sorry if that complicated things.

Yes, I know Microsoft has a blessed app storeb however, like Android, you can still install your own, unsigned executables or use another app store (there are some more recent package managers for Windows iirc? It's not really what I deal with.)

I remember the issues with the arm based surfaces. Iirc one of the current selling points of a surface ia that you can run any software on them.

I think this case will be interesting because there are platforms that come close to, but don't have quite, the control apple does over both who can generate applications as well as who can sell them. Where those platforms evolve 8s directly related to the outcome here I think.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by scarface74 on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:09PM (#18535923)
However, my understanding is that this suite is about apple abusing the app-writing monopoly to also let only them sell apps, which is why I thought the console game analogy was sound.

Sure other game makers can sell games anywhere they want - as long as they do it in the console makers terms, get approved by the console maker,and pay the license.

Back in the cartridge days, only Nintendo could make the cartridges even for third parties.

Yes, I know Microsoft has a blessed app storeb however, like Android, you can still install your own, unsigned executables or use another app store

Not for the Xbox.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by scarface74 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:45PM (#18530885)
No, but every game that you buy that runs on any of the consoles have been preapproved by the console manufacturers and each game has been cryptographically signed by the manufacturer - even those sold on disc.

You don’t have to buy music from Apple. Music you buy hasn’t been wrapped with DRM for a decade. You can buy movies from Google, Amazon or Vudu, download the Movies Anywhere app, connect the app to your various accounts and they automatically show up as iTunes purchases (completely legally), there is an Amazon Video, Google Play, and Vudu app available for iOS. You can go to the Amazon store in your web browser and buy a digital video just like you can buy anything else from Amazon.

We are talking about consoles. Just like the other console manufacturers, you can not sell a video game on disc that has not been approved by MS and without paying MS a licensing fee to run on the XBox.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by zepto on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @08:57AM (#18542264)
No. Not an iOS monopoly either. Look up the definition of monopoly.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jp555 on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @10:30AM (#18543018)
Apple is the only supplier of iOS devices.

"A monopoly exists when a specific person or enterprise is the only supplier of a particular commodity."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by GeekyBear on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:42PM (#18529237)
Didn't we already go through this in the courts when game consoles like Nintendo, XBox, and PlayStation put the same restrictions on game developers?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by MBCook on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:05PM (#18529364)
Back in the NES era with licensing restrictions, yes. I believe it was Tengen vs Nintendo? Also Atari vs Activision?

But the Switch, PS4, and XBox One ALL have closed app stores exactly the way Apple does.

If Apple loses a lot of people will have to find a new business model.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by p1necone on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:09PM (#18529380)
I would love game consoles to have third party stores. As it stands I almost never buy console games through the PSN store/xbox store/whatever because (at least with AAA titles) games remain at initial launch price way too long, and are usually more expensive than retail stores.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by p1necone on Sunday November 25, 2018 @10:34PM (#18530840)
Although, it isn't only limited to online console stores, some publishers are pretty terrible on PC too. As an example - in my region (New Zealand) Call of Duty Black Ops is still $99 on Steam, and that released in 2010...

(Activision, you there? I still want to buy it but I can't justify that price for an 8 year old game, or even the half off sale price right now...)

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ariwilson on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:08PM (#18529937)
You can buy digital codes to redeem games on those stores from third party retailers. Often at a discount.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by MBCook on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:12PM (#18529961)
Really? I think I’ve only ever seen that for Steam/GOG.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ariwilson on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:23PM (#18530016)
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by MBCook on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:08PM (#18530229)
I’ve seen the digital codes before, but that’s actually MORE expensive than disk.

I assumed they weren’t allowed to sell at a discount

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by delinka on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:58PM (#18529324)
Honestly I don’t recall. Do you have any links I could read?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by bilbo0s on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:44PM (#18529565)
I think he is referring to the Tengen case.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 25, 2018 @09:04PM (#18530479)
> If the court allows the definition of 'trust' to include "a company gatekeeping developer access to their own operating system" when that operating system represents a much smaller share of the market than the next biggest competitor.

You're talking about two different markets, the devices themselves and the app distribution.

Suppose there are many truck manufacturers and none has majority share, but only one makes diesel trucks. Then that company gets into the market for diesel fuel and makes it so that customers can't use any other provider's fuel in their trucks. They've just leveraged their diesel truck monopoly into a diesel fuel monopoly.

Your argument is that they don't have a truck monopoly, because other people make lots of gasoline powered trucks and electric trucks etc., and truck buyers could reasonably choose them instead. Many of them do. But those aren't relevant when we're talking about the market for diesel fuel. You can't use gasoline in a diesel truck. You can't use an Android app on iOS or install iOS apps on an iPhone with Google Play.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by nickm12 on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:48AM (#18531384)
Setting aside the question of the impact of prices completely, the fact that Apple controls the sites that apps can link to should be abhorrent to anyone. At one point, they even tried to control what programming languages were used to write apps for iOS.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by syntheticcdo on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:59AM (#18533741)
Your Spotify example is a good argument FOR Apple's model. In that case, consumers have a choice to either a) purchase a Spotify subscription via the web app, or b) purchase the subscription in app -- at a higher cost.

Some consumers still choose to purchase in app- for a variety of reasons: ease of use, speed, accessibility, streamlined with the rest of their Apple purchases, who knows. People choosing to overpay for Spotify shows the Apple ecosystem and model provides value to at least some consumers. Whether it is worth 30% is a different question.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by shaggerty on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:59PM (#18529332)
How is it a problem for consumers if you can get a cheaper subscription to Spotify by buying it off the App Store?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by kodablah on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:18PM (#18529433)
I think it's "off" meaning "outside of". It's a problem for consumers when confusing marketplace rules coupled with single-company-enforced limited options unnecessarily cost them more. That said, not sure I would want it illegal.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by sunflowerfly on Sunday November 25, 2018 @09:14PM (#18530517)
Apple does not hold a monopoly, Android is the dominate platform. To use antitrust law you must first prove a monopoly exists, then prove the monopoly is being used in anti-competitive ways.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by jm20 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:07PM (#18530218)
This is really only an issue with low-margin licensing subscriptions like Spotify and Netflix, where they would lose money on every purchase if 30% of their margins went to Apple. While I definitely think there are some problems with the App Store, the fact is that it is so easy and streamlined for people buying apps that it’s worth the 30% for the vast majority of developers.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:26PM (#18530312)
> While I definitely think there are some problems with the App Store, the fact is that it is so easy and streamlined for people buying apps that it’s worth the 30% for the vast majority of developers.

If people would still choose it even if there were competitors, then why is competition prohibited?

The answer is that the App Store would still exist, but might have to charge less or lose business to lower cost competitors. So you would get everything you want and with lower costs.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by dwaite on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:14PM (#18531027)
The security model is based on an entitlement system. Which other stores are trustworthy enough to be allowed to issue entitlements?

If the idea would be that an arbitrary other store can publish apps with limited entitlements, doesn't that just shift the "abuse" argument around?

If the idea is that users would be able to vet which apps or app stores should get entitlements... well, we've seen how well that works on Android.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by AnthonyMouse on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:24PM (#18531064)
> The security model is based on an entitlement system. Which other stores are trustworthy enough to be allowed to issue entitlements?

That's up to the user to decide. It's a lot easier to choose curators from among well-known companies like Apple and Amazon than to choose individual apps that are inherently developed by small shops or individuals.

> If the idea is that users would be able to vet which apps or app stores should get entitlements... well, we've seen how well that works on Android.

Exactly. Some of them do a better job than Google itself. There is probably less malware in F-Droid than on iOS.

And if you like Apple's store then... keep using it. Just because other stores would be available doesn't require you to use them.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court to hear Apple App Store antitrust dispute by ksec on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:14AM (#18531502)
I have to disagree where 30% is a low margin. This is different to real estate where there are actually foot traffic in front of your store. The App Store is more like a nation charging 30% tax regardless where you live, and that is on Revenue not Profits.