News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by elbasti on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:38PM (#18477729)
At risk of being labeled a "neoliberal idealist," why isn't the answer here simply taxing tourists more?

Pigovian taxes have been a thing for fifty years, yet they are still seldom used. It seems like such an obvious solution to me that the fact it's not used more often (ex: towns banning airbnb vs taxing it) suggests to me that I'm missing something obvious.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by frio on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:54PM (#18477815)
Yeah, this is roughly where my thoughts lie. When my partner and I were travelling around Europe, many of the popular cities charged a bed tax — usually only a euro or two a night, so not enough to put us off in anyway, but in aggregate allowing the cities to invest in facilities that could support the tourist influx.

Back home, there’s been debate about doing this too. I hope the pro-tax side wins. Our country is suffering under the annual tourist load, and we need more money in the pot to support it — at the basic end of the spectrum, there are lots of popular places that desperately need toilets and rubbish facilities for the tourists (and the locals) to use. Private industry cannot fill that gap (or, so far, has not) — and while the public are profiting from the visitors, more of that profit needs to be diverted to public coffers to enable the government to fix the problem. A bed tax is a great tool for helping that to happen.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by pj_mukh on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:44PM (#18478014)
"usually only a euro or two a night, so not enough to put us off in anyway, but in aggregate allowing the cities to invest in facilities that could support the tourist influx."

This is exactly the right strategy! And the "infrastructure to support more tourists" is exactly what this article lays out.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by buboard on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:47PM (#18478034)
but if it's not enough to put them off, the tax doesn't work
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by pj_mukh on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:51PM (#18478052)
The idea isn't to put them off, that seems like a mindlessly cynical goal. Build the infrastructure to support the larger numbers. If the infrastructure needs to discriminate against tourists, that's fine too (e.g. added trains for tourists vs. commuters), new digital methods tool can allow for this.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by jpalomaki on Sunday November 18, 2018 @01:56AM (#18479206)
I believe in many places the problem is that locals don’t want to live in a city built for tourists.

Huge number of visitors for example affect the local stores and services. Places catering for locals getting replaced by tourist attractions.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by akvadrako on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:16PM (#18478700)
No, the idea is to put them off. It's basically impossible to "build infrastructure" to support them, whatever that means. There is no more room for trains or even sidewalks, so it would mean totally changing the cities into something else.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by pj_mukh on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:29PM (#18478732)
Yes. Cities change. All the time. Why is this suddenly a problem? New train/subway lines are built (even in SF! [1]), sidewalks are widened (car lanes can be collapsed). None of this is new, in fact, this kind of growth and change has been the standard in the last 100 years of urban development. This doesn't stop now.

[1]: https://sf.curbed.com/2018/11/15/18096775/bart-second-crossi...

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by akvadrako on Sunday November 18, 2018 @01:10AM (#18479101)
It's obvious why this is a problem. Just look at Venice - when a city is mostly filled with tourists it becomes like a theme park. Are you serious about building subways and widening sidewalks there?

I suppose you'll say everybody should just move out if they don't like it, but most people consider it the better option to plan how their cities evolve.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by frio on Sunday November 18, 2018 @01:58AM (#18479212)
Venice is an extreme case, I agree. That's one of the places that we visited that had the small kind of bed tax I'm thinking of; unfortunately that probably isn't fixing their problems. Many of their tourists stay in cruise ships (which have to have the lagoon dredged to support them; sinking Venice itself...); a bed tax doesn't target them, and they're completely and utterly overwhelmed regardless. It was a fascinating and deeply depressing place to visit.

A bed tax in general, applicable to both hotels and AirBNB, I suspect probably deals better with the other end of the spectrum. At the end of the spectrum I'm thinking about (and probably my co-poster), extra funding is necessary for the municipalities that can sustain further growth of their tourism industry, but are struggling to keep up with demand. New Zealand falls somewhere in here; we have significant problems with tourists literally shitting on walking trails because the previous Government dropped all its tourist budget on global advertising, and didn't anticipate the sheer success they'd have; we therefore lack basic amenities like toilets in many popular tourist spots (or -- if there are toilets -- they're long drops maintained by the Department of Conservation, which most tourists won't use). We can do better with a little extra cash; I believe the new Government is currently investigating a border tax, but a bed tax would help the regions too. Other major metropolises popular with tourists like Paris, Rome, Barcelona etc. could use the extra cash in broadly similar ways; supporting the growth of transit systems and developing infrastructure that supports and promotes distributing the tourist load to other attractions.

I suspect that if you were to put in a large bed tax with the explicit goal of discouraging visitors in places like Venice... it might not work? The rich would put up with it and go anyway. You'd probably cut out many of the poorer visitors, but I doubt you'd see a big net drop unless the tax approached a point that it killed the tourism industry altogether, and sunk the local economy. I suspect that for somewhere like Venice, there needs to be stronger intervention; the category of idea I'm thinking of is a lottery system like the US parks or something.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by isostatic on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:37AM (#18479557)
Significant bed tax in Venice leads to people staying in Mestre or further afield and commuting in. From your post it sounds like cruise ships are the main problem. Why not increase the cost for them to dock?

A tourist tax doesn’t really increase the cost of staying somewhere - if I’m willing g to spend $200 on a hotel in Venice it doesn’t matter if it’s $190 for the hotel and $10 for the tax, or $100 each.

On the other hand if the hotel could get customers willing to pay $300, they would charge that anyway.

A tourist tax shifts the money away from the hotel owner to the local government to pay for the externalities the hotel owner doesn’t. By targeting tourists rather than beds it also means that people on a business trip pay less, helping diversify the economy.

The problem with charging a tourist tax is of course defining what a tourist is, ensuring that Airbnb hosts pass on the tax, and ensuring it’s leveed on day trippers

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by rightbyte on Sunday November 18, 2018 @11:23AM (#18481061)
Shouldn't a bed tax increases the price? Low margin hotels will be forced to shut down since the margin just is taxed and if they increase the price they will lose guests.

A bed tax is essentially cutting the demand.

You could make the bed tax season adjusted. The peak months are the main problem.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by skilesare on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @12:00PM (#18495361)
Put up a toll booth on the highway in? Doesn't London do something like this where it costs a ton to come into the city center?
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by bogomipz on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:32AM (#18479549)
>"The idea isn't to put them off, that seems like a mindlessly cynical goal. Build the infrastructure to support the larger numbers."

Except in many places there is no room to build that infrastructure to support larger numbers of tourists - Venice, NYC and Amsterdam being examples. Nor do many of the people living in places that are over-touristed want infrastructure built to support yet more tourists. "Putting them off" is exactly the point in the tax.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by taysic on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:30AM (#18484544)
Where there are historic buildings or city towns there should be a limit to the number of tourists visiting - to help persevere the work (ie walls crumbling under pressure) or simply to make living around the area livable or getting to the area a decent experience.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by dorchadas on Monday November 19, 2018 @09:40PM (#18491471)
The second reason should be reason enough. People don't want to live in a town overrun with tourists. All their stores and bars and such become touristy gimmick places, cause those can charge huge markup on stuff that tourists buy and make more money. Tourists drive the locals out (AirBnB is a fairly large factor in rent prices increasing in Ireland, for instance) and make it so only tourists are in town. It's horrible.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by kaffee on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:51PM (#18478050)
Check out Chicago or Montreal. The tourist tax is just massive.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by sologoub on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:46PM (#18478246)
Montreal looks to be only 3.5% extra, not exactly massive.

Their sales and goods/services taxes are high, which works out to close to 20% total tax on a room. Still not that crazy.

Source: https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g155032-i51-k6671607-H...

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by kaffee on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:46PM (#18478434)
I think YUL has some of the highest airport fees for any major North American city. For example, there's an "Airport Improvement Fee" of 30 CAD (on every flight) https://www.aircanada.com/us/en/aco/home/legal/surcharges.ht... My sense is that this is just one of many fees that hit you when you fly into Montréal. I think the total fees are more like 60-90 USD on every flight.

(I'm not suggesting that high taxes are bad. I support aggressively high VAT taxes refunded to the poor and lower middle class.)

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by eigenvector on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:29PM (#18478567)
All Canadian airports have high AIFs (Toronto's is $25 for instance), and they are charged to everyone not just tourists.

It's more to do with how airports are structured and managed in Canada versus other countries. It's a user-pay model rather than having them subsidized by the government. In fact many actually pay ground rent to the federal government.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by volkl48 on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:06AM (#18479483)
It's arguably not a model that has actually worked out very well for Canada. They push a significant portion of their air travelers over the US border for much cheaper flights.

And they wind up with fewer flights and worse route options to their own domestic airports as a result.

Ex: Burlington VT is about 40% Canadian, Plattsbugh + Niagara Falls NY are almost entirely Canadian traffic.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by bobthepanda on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:03PM (#18477861)
Part of it is also restricting location. Every large city has a tourist quarter that becomes devoid of everyday services for residents in favor of trinket shops and expensive, mediocre restaurants (e.g. Times Square in NYC). By introducing AirBnBs everywhere you run the risk of turning residential quarters into these dead zones. In contrast, hotels are very easy to restrict using zoning.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by ip26 on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:01PM (#18478288)
The promise of Airbnb (I'm not a booster though) is that if you spread out the impact, you don't have to have any dead zones.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by dorchadas on Monday November 19, 2018 @09:42PM (#18491474)
Except it doesn't work. People buy out apartments simply to AirBnB them, meaning one less local can live there. Others get driven out due to noise, and then yet another AirBnB company comes in an snatches them up. AirBnB is a huge issue that nobody seems willing to face, imo.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by mc32 on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:48PM (#18478444)
Bhutan provides an example of capping the tourists and charging a hefty visa fee for visitors. Tourism is not a human right and as such it's a luxury. It taxes all natural resources and exacerbates pollution (more disposable items and short lived items). Therefore, something akin to Bhutan could work for places which feel overwhelmed by tourists.

(not proposing all places instate this, but rather places where the footprint of overtourism is too much to bear)

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by bobthepanda on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:25PM (#18478724)
IIRC, Saudi Arabia does something similar with the Hajj, which they have to do because it's one of the largest annual human migrations.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by klipt on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:05PM (#18478824)
An Arabian started a religion that mandates visiting Arabia. Now that's advertising!
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by no_wizard on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:26PM (#18477952)
In the USA I think the general populace is tax averse. Passing a new tax even one that could arguably be good for the local population or region, is a good way to get unelected, even in very liberal states.

Local governments are incredibly susceptible to this, but it very clearly plays out nationally as well. The idea that government can “do good” in the USA is very co troversial at best.

This is a great article about it, as a simple litmus

https://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/15/business/economy/slipping...

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by closeparen on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:33PM (#18477981)
This is why hotel taxes are popular. Voters don’t pay them.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by DoreenMichele on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:27PM (#18478190)
Generally speaking, "obvious" and very simple solutions of that sort to any kind of social problem tend to come with a raft load of unexpected and unintended consequences that can be difficult to prove and can be a net negative.

I'm keenly interested in better understanding the problem space. I am very leery of such "obvious" answers.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by the_mitsuhiko on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:05PM (#18477873)
> At risk of being labeled a "neoliberal idealist," why isn't the answer here simply taxing tourists more?

Because that's really tricky to do without reducing the town to just tourism. Some people forget that in tourist towns there are also people who live, who have families and friends and some of their activities look very much like tourism.

Sure, you can try to do all kinds of things to work around this but ultimately the solution of taxing tourists does not work well in practice.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by elbasti on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:28PM (#18477958)
Quite the opposite. If the worry is "too much tourists" well, just raise the tax until you have the desire amount of tourists! (and a lot more money in the coffers).

What am I missing here?

As an example, the country of Bhutan has zero desire for tourists, but instead of banning them they just charge a $250USD tax per day.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by selectodude on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:38PM (#18477997)
>but instead of banning them they just charge a $250USD tax per day.

Hard to call that a tax when it includes lodging, a personal guide, a driver with car, food, and entrance fees to the things you go see. All you have to cover while there is tips and alcohol.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by linkregister on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:02PM (#18478095)
> ultimately the solution of taxing tourists does not work well in practice.

Got any examples? Many cities in the world have tourism taxes, charged as a per-night fee added to hotel bills. Miami has a beach fee for tourists. Somehow, despite no income tax, Miami manages to stay solvent.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by yardie on Saturday November 17, 2018 @09:14PM (#18478524)
Just a small correction. Miami has a hotel bed tax, not a beach fee. I have friends and family that visit and stay with us regularly. They have never been charged to stay with me nor go to the beach. Compared to the rest of the tourist traps down here the beach is one of the best values.

As for the cities of Miami and Miami Beach being solvent, LOL. Depends on who you ask. There is never enough money for the things we need (public transport, housing, education) yet plenty of money for things we never asked for (stadiums, Amazon HQ2).

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by linkregister on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:08AM (#18484489)
If you are staying at a hotel and want to use its beach chair, you are charged a usage tax. It's somewhere around $10.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by yardie on Monday November 19, 2018 @08:55AM (#18486385)
Which I think is fair. The hotels have basically staked out a part of the public beach to put their chairs and umbrellas on, indefinitely. This takes space away from the public use.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by linkregister on Monday November 19, 2018 @11:56PM (#18491887)
I agree. The subject is tourism taxes, which the original parent poster claimed did not work. I asked for evidence and provided a direct counterexample, with no avail.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by mrep on Saturday November 17, 2018 @11:21PM (#18478864)
> Many cities in the world have tourism taxes, charged as a per-night fee added to hotel bills.

How do they differentiate between business travelers and tourists or do they just pass on the fees to both?

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by andrewflnr on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:50PM (#18478452)
I don't think Miami is worried about becoming reduced to just tourism (aren't they already?), so it's not really a counterexample to GP's point.

Ed: explicitness

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by linkregister on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:14AM (#18484508)
Tourism is the primary component of Miami's economy, though it is hardly the only sector. International trade and banking together occupy a larger proportion of Miami's economy.

http://www.city-data.com/us-cities/The-South/Miami-Economy.h...

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by holografix on Sunday November 18, 2018 @07:15AM (#18479998)
I guess it’s up to the city to decide whether it wants to: A) use tax and revenues from tourists to progressively change it self to accommodate more and more tourists. B) raise taxes so much that only cashed up tourists can afford to visit. C) preserve the city as it is, and install some form of tourist lottery to avoid only cashed up tourist from visiting.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by jpalomaki on Monday November 19, 2018 @07:41AM (#18485970)
Very high bed tax can make "unofficial tourist accommodation" more competitive compared to official hotels and hostels. Even though regulation tries to prohibit that, tracking down the providers can be difficult.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by dgzl on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:54PM (#18477816)
How would you differentiate a local vs. a tourist?

Edit: is that even legal?

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by gsnedders on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:02PM (#18477856)
It's typically a tax on accommodation, rather than anything else.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by dgzl on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:36PM (#18477990)
That's what I thought. Unfortunately that also affects locals, which diminishes the benefit.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by thenanyu on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:54PM (#18478070)
Locals who stay at hotels? Usually these taxes are only on short term accommodations like hotels and Airbnb
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by dgzl on Sunday November 18, 2018 @12:34AM (#18479013)
Yes, if the destination is say a city, then those who live even just an hour away want to come and stay sometimes. Same is true for beaches and lakes, near ski resorts, ect.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by isostatic on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:41AM (#18479564)
They’re tourists, so they pay the tax
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by maccard on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:20PM (#18478164)
They're also usually limited by duration. So it'll be x euro a night for the first 7 nights, with a max of Y per stay
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by longerthoughts on Saturday November 17, 2018 @05:56PM (#18477831)
In the US cities use things like hotel tax to target areas skewed towards tourist spending.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by buboard on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:47PM (#18478031)
its not possible to do that in a viable way mainly because in many places tourists come from richer countries. An exorbitatly high deterrent-tax would paralyze the local market.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by captainwhoreal on Sunday November 18, 2018 @03:38AM (#18479408)
What if someone local wants to use Airbnb, but there is a bed tax? What if you want to visit family in next town that happens to be touristy or what if you have a work placement? How do you distinguish tourists from non tourists?
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by forrestthewoods on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:35PM (#18477987)
Gross. Gross gross gross.

Tourists already get taxed. Hotel taxes are huge. It sucks. Traveling for conferences to meet new people and learn new things is soooo expensive and tourist taxes are a big part of why.

Tourist taxes are how you destroy diversity and trap people into the tiny bubble in which they were born. We should be striving for the opposite.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by viraptor on Saturday November 17, 2018 @06:52PM (#18478056)
A good solution here seems to be - don't organise conferences in places which are full of tourists already. You want to meet new people and learn? Great - book a country hotel and transport from the airport, or maybe a place in some town with reasonable plane connections. You want to also see the city? You're a tourist.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by forrestthewoods on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:03PM (#18478097)
I could not possibly disagree more.

Conferences are almost always a split of local and non-local attendees. Forcing conferences to be exclusively non-local attendees makes zero sense. It would be even more expensive, in absolute dollars and environmental cost, to have everyone travel to the middle of Nebraska.

I know it's not your intent, but your stance here reeks of elistism, xenophobia, and othering. Extrapolating your worldview I don't know why a country hotel would, or even should, be accommodating.

> don't organise conferences in places which are full of tourists already.

This is absurd. Conferences are about people. Places with a lot of people will naturally have those people come together for events. Things that make a place attractive to live can also make it an attractive place to visit.

Travel is so expensive it's almost crazy NOT to make the most out of your trip. Adding a day or two of tourism to a multi-day work or education trip is more than reasonable.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by jaggederest on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:16PM (#18478152)
It's funny, because I've actually been contemplating the total costs of having conferences in areas outside the SF bay, and it's probably net cheaper to have people fly to the middle of nowhere AND rent a hotel PLUS conference space, than it is to simply rent the conference space in SF.

Cost of living has grown so large that it's almost cheaper to fly into SFO every day from a regional airport instead of renting a hotel room.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by viraptor on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:30PM (#18478380)
It's not a recipe for all conferences and it will not work for all of them. It's a response to a specific issue - conferences in tourist cities are expensive. Really large conferences are almost entirely non-local anyway.

If you want to do work+fun trip, then a tourist destination could be great - but you have to be prepared to pay for it. (Or go to a nearby tourist place) If you want conferences for locals, they will always happen anyway.

The rest of your accusations don't make sense to me. How can something for mostly non-locals be xenophobic? How is an expensive conference in a big city less elitist (who can afford to live there?) than one outside of it?

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by isostatic on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:49AM (#18479587)
> Travel is so expensive it's almost crazy NOT to make the most out of your trip.

And you’re worried about an extra $5 a night to pay for tourist infrastructure?

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by longerthoughts on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:09PM (#18478120)
Who is avoiding travel because of tourist taxes? The relative cost of pre-tax airfare, lodging, etc. is exceptionally high relative to the typical hotel tax, for example. When did you last decide not to attend a conference because the destination’s tourist taxes were prohibitively high?
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by forrestthewoods on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:15PM (#18478150)
Who is avoiding travel because of costs? Almost everyone.

How much would a trip's cost be reduced with the elimination of tourist taxes? Totally depends. It's not the biggest cost. But it ain't zero either. They call it nickel-and-dime for a reason.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by maccard on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:38PM (#18478215)
> Who is avoiding travel because of costs? Almost everyone

This is patently untrue. NYC had just shy of 63million visitors in 2017, and is one of the most expensive places on Earth.

Edinburgh (where I live) has about 480,000 people, and we get about 2 million visitors in the month of August. Accommodation is full, and prices are 2 or 3 times what they normally are for the entire month, and yet the city is full. A tourist tax of 1.50 a night is not going to deter anyone from visiting Edinburgh when the bus from the airport is 5 times that, or a night in a hotel is 20 times that.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by longerthoughts on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:22PM (#18478169)
I very clearly did not ask who avoids travel because of total costs.

The question is in what case does somebody avoid booking a trip that they otherwise would’ve taken because they just can’t stomach the tourist taxes once they’re already paying hundreds for flights and lodging?

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by orangecat on Saturday November 17, 2018 @10:24PM (#18478717)
The question is in what case does somebody avoid booking a trip that they otherwise would’ve taken because they just can’t stomach the tourist taxes once they’re already paying hundreds for flights and lodging?

Marginal customers always exist. If you raise prices by a small amount, most customers will ignore it, but a small percentage won't. That's why the thing you bought for $X didn't cost $(X*1.01) instead.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by forrestthewoods on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:29PM (#18478195)
Most people don't even know how much they're paying in tourist taxes. I certainly don't. It's a hard-to-see line item on lodging, attractions, event space, etc.

What's the total cost? I don't know. Probably more than 1 percent and less than 5? How many more people would travel if costs were reduced by 5 percent? More than zero, less than a lot.

I was responding to a post arguing for MORE tourist taxes. I think we should we have less.

https://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/07/business/07taxes.html

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by longerthoughts on Saturday November 17, 2018 @07:42PM (#18478226)
Right, people hardly even consider tourist taxes and they’re often not visible when you’re rate shopping. So help me understand this claim from your original post:

>Tourist taxes are how you destroy diversity and trap people into the tiny bubble in which they were born

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by tropo on Sunday November 18, 2018 @10:59PM (#18484135)
Because tourist taxes are not visible, I assume the worst. This discourages me from travel. I may be wrong, but I just assume that the cost of a trip will be far higher than I'm told.
Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by forrestthewoods on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:01PM (#18478289)
People know hotels are expensive. People know that bullshit taxes and fees get piled onto the advertised price when they try to checkout. People regularly scoff at the final price. Who among us hasn't? If someone closes their browser is doesn't matter if they do or not understand what the taxes or fees are for.

To reiterate, my original reply was someone asking for MORE tourist taxes. We can probably agree that travel is already expensive. We can debate about what percentage of that cost is from tourist taxes and how impactful that added cost is.

Making travel more expensive will obviously cause fewer people to travel. If you make travel sufficiently expensive then fewer and fewer people will travel and more and more people will stay in whatever place they happened to have been born. I can not give you the equation for what increase in price leads to what decrease in travel.

Growing up in rural Tennessee I remember conversations about travel. The number of high school students who had ever left the country was tiny. The number who had never left the south eastern US was decently large. The number who had never left their home state was alarming.

I'm fortunate to work in tech and be able to travel. If I want to see half my family I have to travel to them. They can't afford to travel to me. I have on multiple occasions paid for travel costs for family. Because they otherwise couldn't afford travel costs for events such as our grandfather's funeral. I find the idea that people who want to make travel even more expensive to be morally reprehensible.

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by kinkrtyavimoodh on Sunday November 18, 2018 @03:45AM (#18479432)
You are making all kinds of emotional arguments but not addressing the topic of the discussion.

This whole comment thread is about how cities can deal with the problems that come with an excess influx of tourists. These problems are real, no matter how romanticized the tourists' view of their trip was. In short, the destruction that massive tourism waves leave in their wake (to use an exaggerated analogy) is ultimately an externality to their action that needs to be paid by someone.

Yes, modulo everything, paying more for things sucks. Paying for externalities that you are not used to paying probably sucks even more. Tourism is not special in that regard. But the problems caused by tourism to the locals also suck, and if one of the fixes for them is increasing taxes, then you can't argue it away by saying, effectively, "no! I don't want to pay more".

Re:How cities can fix tourism hell by isostatic on Sunday November 18, 2018 @04:47AM (#18479582)
What city has a high tourist tax that’s even 30% of the total cost of a typical hotel. I just checked in Rome. I can get a room for €88 for two, €8, or 9%, of which is the city tax.