We don't have property tax in the UK.
I'm frankly quite glad that we don't. If it were instituted at anything other than a token rate I'd leave.
If someone buys a home and lives in it, they should not have to care a single jot how it's valued externally. It is their home and their castle and they have every right to live in it.
The idea that, say, my grandmother should just get kicked out of her hometown that she's lived in forever, that she bloody _built_, because a bunch of kids decided they like her city is completely absurd.
Financialization needs to end somewhere. Let people earn their opt out.
Well, the council tax looks an awful lot like one, but if you insist.
> I'm frankly quite glad that we don't. If it were instituted at anything other than a token rate I'd leave.
Depends on what a 'token rate' is. Cities I've lived in have set it at around 1 percent a year, and is used to fund the emergency services, schools, roads and parks in the area. In most places in the US, that's a $1-2k annual expense. Houses around here, largely built in the 1950's, sell for around $1.4 million, and thus taxes would be around 15k a year. Complaining that you can't afford taxes on a million dollar home is perhaps the epitome of First World Problems. Moreover, higher taxation is simply one effect of high rents. Labor here is expensive; fast food joints here aggressively advertise help wanted signs at 15 dollars an hour. I can only imagine what in-home health care costs, and there's a neverending stream of interviews with public service workers who cannot afford to live near the communities they serve.
However, there is a second order effect -- if a fraction of the people who felt better off in Sacramento or anywhere else in the 1k tax regions moved out, prices in SF would fall. And if owners were more directly impacted by refusals to build high density housing, they'd probably be more in favor of new construction on average.
> The idea that, say, my grandmother should just get kicked out of her hometown that she's lived in forever, that she bloody _built_, because a bunch of kids decided they like her city is completely absurd.
Sounds a lot like you're asking for rent control for the wealthy.
There's a post further down in which it's explained how CT is nothing like a property tax. It's levied on the occupier not the owner and it's not percentage based. It's ostensibly for services rendered e.g. bins taken out, roads etc.
Your home and all the homes in your town could quadruple in externally assessed value and the absolute amount paid would remain static because it's formulated in such a way that it's paid based on relative home value within an area (rather than absolute).
> Sounds a lot like you're asking for rent control for the wealthy.
I'm pretty much baffled by what you mean here.
My grandmother is not wealthy. Neither is my mother. Neither would they become wealthy if the town around them suddenly turned into an SF/London.
The external valuation of their home that they live in would increase which is a completely different matter entirely.
It's an injection of financialization into a situation where none exists. I won't be dragged in to that game, sorry.
We wouldn’t humor a stock market investor in denial about his wealth; we shouldn’t humor a real estate investor. The preferential treatment of housing as an asset class is a big part of why it’s so inflated in the first place!
If someone doesn’t want to be accountable for their house’s appreciation, they can give up the right to benefit from it at sale. Capital gains and deferred property taxes coming due at sale is probably the fairest proposal - doesn’t force anyone out, doesn’t let them free ride either.
I don't mean to misquote you, and apologies if so, but you seem to have decided that homes should be rented and not owned.
If that's your viewpoint, fine. I don't agree with it at all, and I'll go and live somewhere in which ownership of property is permitted.
I wish you the best of luck with whatever you're trying to do in your corner of the world.
Owning a house while it appreciates is less socially useful than working or investing in productive businesses, and sometimes more lucrative. Why should it be taxed at a lower rate?
If it’s not an investment, what do you care about the return?
I appreciate that lots of people like suburbia, and I wish them well too. Only that government policy will also allow urbanism to thrive.
In the UK, real estate investors are taxed. A significant number of individuals here believe they should be taxed more.
A family or individual living in their single home (whether it be a house, apartment, shed, or whatever else) are not real estate investors. Very few people believe they should be paying taxes on their primary residence.
So, yes, a businessman, conglomerate, or just an 'accidental landlord' who owns a building and derives rent from it in perpetuity is taxed in a different way to someone who just lives in and owns their primary home; people want that to be the case, and for the most part it is. (We have our share of loopholes as every taxation system does).
Is it different in the US?
It feels like I'm missing something fundamentally obvious in our discussion here, so maybe that's it?
My larger point is that either a) your house is an investment, so your returns come with social responsibilities, or b) your house is not an investment, so you’re not entitled to returns beyond having a place to live. The current regime, where you can make tax-free millions for being in the right place at the right time, is not a good one.
I agree with this.
In the UK - as earlier stated, we don't have property tax. No capital gains tax is charged on disposal of a primary residence.
The CGT situation makes sense in the event that the entirety of the gain is re-invested in another home.
Otherwise, you end up in the absurd situation in which a person moving between two identical homes on the same street would take a loss of 20%, incentivising them to never move.
It might make sense to require that the proceeds of the sale be put towards another primary private residence (and have anything left over taxed).
It seems to me like that's not really your issue though.
> As a side effect, municipal tax revenues don’t scale with the now-inflated costs of provisioning municipal services.
This is a question of overall taxation, no? It's not relevant whether the money comes from a property tax on everyone, or an income tax on those that are of working age, or a general wealth tax, or corporation tax, or whatever else - it just needs to be paid for.
Again, I'm assuming here, but I think your argument is that increasing property taxes would decrease the cost of property.
It's pretty obvious that this is the case because it's effectively turning homeownership into a 'shared ownership' scenario whereby you pay rent to the state.
I think it's just a misunderstanding. You're talking about a situation where your grandmother owns the place and he/she is talking about a situation where your grandmother rents the place.
It sounds like some US cities have a situation more like shared ownership, in which you can't actually own a home because there's no way to pay (or set aside) the full future stream of property taxes.
It seems bonkers to me because it would make settling down completely impossible, hence my comments about moving away to somewhere where homeownership exists.
In the place I already live (UK) we don't have that, so I'm not calling for any change.
In any case it seems that me (and people like me) moving out in this hypothetical situation of ownership being converted retroactively into rental gives you what you want anyway.
But the theory on taxation of monopoly rents is quite well fleshed out and that kind of tax has a number of positive effects on society. The fact that most of California’s housing woes can be traced back to a policy that limits this kind of tax is telling and there’s no way I’d want to live anywhere without reasonable land tax policy. That said, taxes should be based on square footage and not assessed resale value to encourage high-density building.
I'm talking about _homes_. You know, where David took his first steps, or where the swing used to be in the garden, or whatever else.
I despise this abstraction, sorry. My grandmother's home in which she raised her family is not some abstract piece of "land" to be stolen from her because you think it meets some economic goal.
You know full well that this idea of future individuals being relegated to 'living in the country' is complete nonsense.
What you really mean is that everyone can't just pile in to the same ten or so 'alpha cities' and expect to just completely disregard those already living there.
Thats the trade-off that is happening right now, when people can make a decision 40 years ago and get to control scarce resources from that point until they die.
>You know full well that this idea of future individuals being relegated to 'living in the country' is complete nonsense.
I don't think that's complete nonsense at all. I live in the Boston area and the majority of people I know making over 6 figures either have roommates or a 1+ hour commute.
Grandma living in a detached home on a quarter acre of land in the city means that 20+ people can not live near jobs because of the apartment building that is not there.
It is a perfectly valid opinion to think that this is an acceptable trade-off, but to act like the trade-off is not happening is just sticking your head in the sand.
Additionally a land value tax is not "stealing" the home from anyone. It's accepting that there are scarce resources and there needs to be a pressure to use them in the most efficient manner. If you can provide the value to keep your home on it's own, then fine you get to live there. If you can't you get to sell your highly valued home and reap the benefits of that value. That is capitalism at it's core. If Grandma thinks she should be protected from economic forces and isn't voting for socialist policies to give similar protections to others, then that's just pulling up the ladder after you which is not a viewpoint I'd give any consideration to when I vote
You can hide it behind fancy words but what you want to do is force existing residents who own their homes out in the name of 'economic growth'.
I don't have to agree with that.
> when people can make a decision 40 years ago and get to control scarce resources from that point until they die.
Yes, that's what buying something is. I don't want to live in a world in which everything is simply rented. We should be helping people get _out_ of that, not dragging them in to it.
The older generation is strangling the subsequent ones, and their countries, because they refuse to change anything about their lives. This is forcing the younger generations to miss out on all the aspects of life that the older generations thought we're important and enjoyed in their youth.
When I hear a retire complain about proposed housing _and_ ask their 30 year old children why they haven't given them grandkids yet, all I can think is that brought that on themselves. They don't live on an island, and the choices they are making have downstream affects on everyone
Presumably your grandmother isn't living entirely independent of society - still reliant on social services, police, NHS and so on. Most of these are locally funded and badly paid. Plus the private sector: shop workers etc. Do you think they should be paid enough to achieve homeownership themselves? Where should that come from?
The council tax capping system is ridiculous, especially in London. I would quite happily swap council tax+stamp duty for a realistic property tax. Preferably with a bit more national redistribution so we can tax mansions in Kensington to pay for buses in Burnley.
We've completely stopped building council homes for no apparent reason, for example. I'd pay more in taxation to support that - hell, if we did it properly and treated it like a New Deal-style thing I'd be proud to come along and help build. We owe it to people. The fact that there are massive fields everywhere that people aren't allowed to build on because a man with a gun says no is asinine.
We can make transport faster and better as well.
At some point I think the population of London needs to be limited somehow because having 20 million residents would make it hellish to navigate under any system. The central bits would turn into a gridlock of pedestrians.
> Do you think they should be paid enough to achieve homeownership themselves? Where should that come from?
I think this gets the directionality confused. If people agree to work for a low wage, the low wage is going to persist.
I think people should refuse to work jobs that don't pay enough to exist. Individually or collectively, doesn't matter.
Personally I don't understand how London's service industry works at all.
I'd have left yesterday if I felt my options were limited to working in the local supermarket. The wages are farcical - literally _funny_ - can't afford a studio flat within the entire M25.
Meanwhile, as you know well, there are cities <5 hours drive away where one can buy a terraced house with a garden on a single minimum wage.
If people refused these silly conditions, wages would rise, residents would pay a bit more for services and it'd all work out.
It's funny because this is a really common (probably the overwhelming) opinion in my hometown. London is bloody expensive, no-one understands why anyone would live there unless they're rich. It's only people who have the idea that they "must" live there regardless of resources that get into trouble.
Decades of Tory policy, that one. Councils were forced by central government to sell it off way below market value and prevented from using the resulting money from building more houses.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/aug/26/right-to-buy...
> The fact that there are massive fields everywhere that people aren't allowed to build on
Greenfield building is hugely unpopular with voters, especially Tory voters. Planning restrictions have popular support.
> We can make transport faster and better as well
I'd like to see that, but decades of privatisation have preferred "cheaper".
> I think people should refuse to work jobs that don't pay enough to exist. Individually or collectively, doesn't matter.
And how should they eat and live in the meantime? Refusing jobs will get you taken off JSA, and possibly sent on the unpaid work programme.
> Personally I don't understand how London's service industry works at all.
Overwhelmingly staffed by immigrants and children of immigrants, often living in cramped conditions.
> "must" live there regardless of resources
For a lot of people in the peripheral towns, it's the other way round: if you want to better yourself and get a professional job, that's where you've got to be. The networking effects are huge.
> I'd have left yesterday if I felt my options were limited to working in the local supermarket
Every day hundreds of people leave peripheral towns and head to London because that's the choice they face.
Yes, we're not building council homes because our political system is broken. That's what I mean by 'no apparent reason'. Laziness on my behalf, sorry.
Your JSA point is silly, you know I'm not suggesting people starve, please don't do that.
We need to solve centralization of everything in London, yes.
If the city puts police in the block the house is in, cleans the street, puts a bus, and a subway, maintains parks, etc etc, they are all being perpetually funded by taxes, that if the landlord is not paying, he is mooching off someone else.
It's just not linearly proportional to the value of the home with no cap, because that makes no sense.
Cleaning the street doesn't become more expensive because your house became more expensive. Same for almost every other council-run service.
In a very indirect sense, it might cost more to employ street cleaners eventually if rent increases within a 30min-1h radius, but that's not in any reasonable sense linearly proportional to the value of a home in a specific area.
It's very direct: the same house 100 miles away into the wilderness will not be worth nearly the same. Its construction/capital value might be more fix to the cost of materials + labor, but the value of the land is very much related to what services and other externalities affect it.
In any case I'd agree that the tax shouldnt be on the value of the house, but on the value of the land it would be much more representative of the externalities.
Yes, the externally assessed value of the house will vary depending on where it is.
The cost of public services apportioned to the house is not linearly correlated to its' externally assessed value.
If you move a suburban flat into the centre, slice it into the middle of a skyscraper say, it'd be worth way more, but it'd cost about the same to maintain the roads and take the bins out.
(Actually it'd probably cost less in the city, so in that particular case the public costs would be inversely proportional to value...)
Example: San francisco has an 11 billion tax revenue[1] It has 880.000 residents [2] It has 121 km2 [3] It has 345,811 Households [3] (note this is an old census, the number has probably gone up a bit)
11 billion / 880.000 = 12.500 U$S This means that every resident in the city would have to pay 1040U$S a month (including babies and elderly) just to pay for the city revenues.
11 billion / 121km ~= 91 million in expenditures per square km.
11 billion / 350k household ~= 31,500: each household has to pay 2625 a month just to maintain the city revenues.
Kind of impressive isnt it!
[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/SF-s-budget-soar... [2] http://worldpopulationreview.com/us-cities/san-francisco-pop... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_San_Francisco#...
Nevertheless I agree with you, it is a pernicious wealth tax and should rightly be moved to a VAT or sales tax.
The valuation of your flat could quadruple and the council tax would stay the same.
I think it makes sense. Council tax pays for amenities. The rent in London might be five times higher than $insert_northern_town but it doesn't cost five times as much for the bins to be taken out.
US states usually have percentage based against a variable basis.
I prefer the UK method, personally, but the US method that California uses is quite something to behold. It freezes your property tax to the date you bought your property except for a 1% change per year.
There's an upper band beyond which the tax rate is fixed regardless of how much the property cost in '91.
Also, see the above poster's comment for an example table:
https://www.cambridge.gov.uk/council-tax-bands-and-charges
A 200K (assessed in '91) property pays about 2.5x what a 40K (assessed in '91) property does. Not 5x.
Someone working at the Cambridge Science Park across Kings Hedges Road might be living in Kings Hedges area and pay GBP 1500/year to the local government. It's a substantial amount.
You could own a multi-million pound property in Kensington, and the sum of taxes you pay each year would be £2,246.14 [1]
[1] https://www.rbkc.gov.uk/council-tax/band-values-and-charges
Council tax pays for services like the roads and the bins being taken out.
Having an expensive house doesn't mean you use more of those.
(It increases a bit up to a cap, because you probably do use them more if you have more money, but it obviously doesn't linearly scale).
A flat in London might cost 5-10x a flat in the North, but both individuals use the bins and roads roughly the same amount so their council taxes are about the same.
> those that own property as of N years ago are permanent residents, and will never really sell their properties, so it's just full.
In theory, property taxes should nudge people. In California, those are severely capped via ballot initiative Prop 13. People that should be paying $20k a year in tax on a $1.8 million dollar home are paying perhaps $2k. Long term residents have won some sort of cosmic lottery that they probably would have cashed in on and left town with if not for Prop 13. Or, if they value the community and services, would have found a way to borrow against the property appreciation, instead of effectively defunding state and local government.
> No-one wants to live in a block of flats unless they're too poor to afford a house.
Some of this is driven in the US by tax policy. Owners get a variety of tax breaks renters do not. In effect there's a sorting process by which people who cannot afford a downpayment rent by necessity, and the well off who want to avoid poor people for as neighbors can buy a home. This effect of paying to buy "good" neighbors is self-perpetuating and reinforcing -- people might be okay with having one sketchy neighbor but not be okay being the only non-sketch. It's a classist (and often racist) attitude, but is probably a decent model of the american population.