The valuation of your flat could quadruple and the council tax would stay the same.
I think it makes sense. Council tax pays for amenities. The rent in London might be five times higher than $insert_northern_town but it doesn't cost five times as much for the bins to be taken out.
US states usually have percentage based against a variable basis.
I prefer the UK method, personally, but the US method that California uses is quite something to behold. It freezes your property tax to the date you bought your property except for a 1% change per year.
There's an upper band beyond which the tax rate is fixed regardless of how much the property cost in '91.
Also, see the above poster's comment for an example table:
https://www.cambridge.gov.uk/council-tax-bands-and-charges
A 200K (assessed in '91) property pays about 2.5x what a 40K (assessed in '91) property does. Not 5x.
Someone working at the Cambridge Science Park across Kings Hedges Road might be living in Kings Hedges area and pay GBP 1500/year to the local government. It's a substantial amount.
You could own a multi-million pound property in Kensington, and the sum of taxes you pay each year would be £2,246.14 [1]
[1] https://www.rbkc.gov.uk/council-tax/band-values-and-charges
Council tax pays for services like the roads and the bins being taken out.
Having an expensive house doesn't mean you use more of those.
(It increases a bit up to a cap, because you probably do use them more if you have more money, but it obviously doesn't linearly scale).
A flat in London might cost 5-10x a flat in the North, but both individuals use the bins and roads roughly the same amount so their council taxes are about the same.