News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Emma_Goldman on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:00PM (#18417975)
Speaking as someone from the UK, I'm a little alarmed that you have to pay to enter national parks in the first place.

Are they all that busy?

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by gumby on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:36PM (#18418632)
The parks are heavily curated and managed — think of them as open air museums. Personally I don’t like visiting national parks because of this - I prefer the pretty unregulated wilderness and BLM land. But many people aren’t prepared for the wild (and it really is wild; there’s nothing like it in the UK, more like the Aussie bush in level of isolation) so these parks are great to get people exposed to the outdoors.

Parks constitute a tiny percentage of public open land. And for the ones I’ve visited really have been built around special places (Grand Canyon, Yosemite, Larsen, etc) and why not? If it’s someone’s only exposure to nature why not make it the best. And I won’t have to see them when I’m in the desolation wilderness.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by mattbierner on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:20PM (#18418849)
This generalization is very misleading. Many national parks are massive, with vast tracts that can only be reached by days of hiking or an off road vehicle or an aircraft. This is true even of extremely popular parks like the Grand Canyon, Yosemite, Zion, Joshua tree, Smokey Mountains, and Denali.

The Yosemite valley in summer for example can feel like Disney in terms of crowds, but that is just a small area of the park’s land. The entire eastern part of the park is far less busy even along the roads, there are plenty of remote trails for backpacking, and then there are true wild spaces without any official development.

The national parks offer a range of natural experiences that can suit almost everyone.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nostrademons on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:39PM (#18418966)
I think he means relative to the size of America. Here's a map of all national parks, overlaid on a map of all publicly-owned land in the US:

https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/programs/public_lands/pr...

The big splotch in California is Death Valley. To the immediate west is Yosemite; southeast is Mojave; to the south is Joshua Tree. These are big areas: Death Valley is about the size of the 9-county Bay Area with 7.68M people, while Mojave is about the size of the Los Angeles Basin with 15.7M people. Nevertheless, they're tiny compared to BLM-managed lands, which basically includes the whole state of Nevada.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by GuiA on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:45PM (#18419229)
This is a fascinating map, thanks.

Does anyone know why federal land is so concentrated to the western half of the US? Is the “empty land” in states like Texas state owned? Why?

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by int_19h on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:28PM (#18419760)
The idea of the government (and especially the federal government) holding massive swaths of land for conservation purposes did not occur until late 19th century. By that time, most of land that was still available was in the western states, that were still the frontier then, and sparsely populated. Doing something similar in the eastern states would be far more expensive, since that land would have to be bought from existing owners at substantial cost.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by zbentley on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:58PM (#18419283)
Because development and homesteading proceeded from east to west, and so did private claims on land. Substantial preservation programs (by area) took off nearly a century later.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nostrademons on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:21PM (#18419372)
In addition to this, there's likely also a climate reason. Here's a map of the U.S. by rainfall:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_rainfall_climato...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by chiph on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:40PM (#18419437)
Recall that Texas was it's own country before joining the United States (The Republic of Texas [0]). So all the land in the state at one time was privately owned, unlike states like Wyoming and the Dakotas. Any public parks & land in Texas (primarily Big Bend out near El Paso) is public because it was donated by the owners.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Texas

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by kd5bjo on Saturday November 10, 2018 @09:00AM (#18421349)
Well, none of the land was owned by the US government. I'm not sure if land owned by the Republic of Texas (now State of Texas) really counts as "privately" owned.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by chiph on Saturday November 10, 2018 @10:27AM (#18421667)
That's my point - very little land was owned by the Republic of Texas government. It was all (or nearly all) owned by individuals/families. And after running up large debts to fund the national military in order to keep Mexico at bay, they didn't have the money to buy any land to be turned into parks anyway. Part of the deal upon joining the USA was that Texas would give up large areas of land out west in return for $10 million, to be used to pay off the debts.

You'll see the importance of private land ownership to the residents even today. When the Texas Central Railroad tried to acquire land for a bullet train a few years ago, their attempted use of eminent domain fell more than flat.

https://www.texastribune.org/2017/02/23/come-and-take-it-emi...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by kd5bjo on Saturday November 10, 2018 @11:35AM (#18422054)
I can certainly believe that Texas, in practice, never had much public land -- I readily admit my ignorance on this point. I'm still not convinced of your original statement, that it has no public land because it was previously an independent country.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nostrademons on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:30PM (#18419406)
Also, to answer who owns the "empty land" in Texas - it's largely private ranches:

https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-us-land-use/

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by davb on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:14PM (#18418819)
> The parks are heavily curated and managed — think of them as open air museums.

Most museums in the UK are free to visit too. They generally have donation boxes which is a great way to let those who can afford to do so support the museum. And those who can't are not excluded.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by dnautics on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:04PM (#18419306)
The national parks and most museums in the us you have to pay for certainly have programs to discount the price if you can't afford it. Despite popular worldwide opinion, We're not heartless greedy jerks in this country.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by throwaway427 on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:23PM (#18419143)
The Smithsonian in DC is also free to visit.

We aren't really talking about the same thing here. Many National Parks are massive properties with extensive ecological concerns and staff overhead. But they aren't even close to the sole extent of publicly owned land, that's where the BLM comes in. And there are the national grasslands and the forest service lands as well. We haven't even touched on state owned public lands or conservancy lands.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by njarboe on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:26PM (#18419387)
The amount of land set aside for wilderness and parks in the US is amazing. More than all cities and towns (urban) combined. This webpage[1] as a lot of cool maps of US land use.

[1]https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-us-land-use/

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by robbyking on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:56PM (#18418725)
You can definitely get off the beaten path in National Parks, it's just that very few people choose to.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by TomMckenny on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:35PM (#18419425)
Not to be pedantic but "think of them as open air museums" may not be the best analogy for a question from the UK: Their most important museums are free.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by lostlogin on Saturday November 10, 2018 @02:01AM (#18420289)
> The parks are heavily curated and managed

The Bill Bryson book on the Appalachian Trail (A Walk in the Woods) gives a very different impression. It seemed to him to be underfunded and pretty badly managed with individuals trying very hard despite limited funds and support. Alarmingly there was even logging being done. I have never been to any of them.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by gumby on Saturday November 10, 2018 @02:40AM (#18420375)
The Appalachian trail isn’t a national park, it’s a collection of trails that pass through various locations. Ditto PCT, continental dividing trail in Australia etc.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by lostlogin on Saturday November 10, 2018 @06:30PM (#18424089)
Thanks. I even checked before posting and assumed this meant it was. “Strong Parks, Strong Communities Through Strong Parks, Strong Communities, the National Park Foundation (NPF), National Park Service (NPS), and Friends Alliance (the Alliance) enhance local philanthropic organizations, bringing park philanthropy to an elevated level”

https://www.nationalparks.org/explore-parks/appalachian-nati...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by black-tea on Saturday November 10, 2018 @03:19AM (#18420449)
> The parks are heavily curated and managed — think of them as open air museums.

Oh. I hate that. I hate things being fake.

In the UK there is Dartmoor which is wild, but obviously no wolves or bears etc. which might be what you mean.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by iscrewyou on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:06PM (#18418030)
This is why the fee is charged: https://www.nps.gov/aboutus/fees-at-work.htm

Ones near urban areas are usually busy. I’ve lived close to one and there’s usually a line on the weekend in the middle of the day to enter the park. It gets especially worse during holidays or when school is out during the summer.

So I always make it a point to go during weekdays when school is in session.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by irrational on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:35PM (#18419197)
Even ones nowhere near an urban area, like Yellowstone, are extremely busy.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by benatkin on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:39PM (#18418964)
That isn't why. That's why they say that it's charged. The government has other ways of collecting money and there are other ways they could prevent overtourism. I don't know all the reasons why it is the way it is, but people working for the NPS are the last people I'd trust to give a good answer on it.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by ghaff on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:47PM (#18419014)
Come on. If you're going to a national park you're probably driving a significant distance, often flying, etc. The $20 or so admission fee is not remotely keeping anyone who would otherwise go to a national park from doing so. Maybe there's some weird corner case somewhere but it's reasonable to assume it's vanishingly rare.

ADDED: And to be clear, I'm also strongly opposed to raising prices as a way to use market forces to depress use.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by dnautics on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:07PM (#18419318)
If you prevent overtourism with quotas you will screw the underprivileged in other ways, e.g. by making it impossible for them to expend the time and effort to make it in under the quota.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by ip26 on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:12PM (#18418086)
Worth noting in many cases the fee applies only to entering by vehicle, not bike or foot, and indeed many of the fees go towards accommodations for vehicles- roads, parking lots, traffic management, etc.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by sureaboutthis on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:56PM (#18418726)
A few years ago, I took a car trip out west and went through three or four of them. I was astounded at the level of knowledge, friendliness and helpfulness of every park ranger I met and every service provided at the parks.

Side note: at a lookout at the very top of the Rocky Mountains, I was alone and staring out between two peaks when a ranger came up and started chatting with me and answered a few questions. After several minutes of that, I thanked her and she mentioned she was actually a volunteer. She and her husband did this work for fun for a month or so but, far more interesting, it turns out she lives less than a mile from my house back home!

By the way, if you are 60+, the parks are free but you must apply for a Parks Service card at any park entrance. The regular price, if I recall, is still only $10 or so.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by davidw on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:06PM (#18418032)
A lot of them are. OTOH, we have a lot of other public lands that are free to use. This one's right near where I live, and clocks in at 7,300 square km.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deschutes_National_Forest

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by KingPrad on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:15PM (#18418507)
I'm American and have mixed feelings on this. National Parks can definitely be massive operations during the summer months so I understand charging a fee. But it also removes this public good from the poor and I think that's wrong. Maybe the park system provides free/cheap passes via welfare programs.

I'm more concerned that many state parks charge up to $15/day usage fee. A fee just to enter and hike or play around a lake. I think that's very wrong. Simple fun in the outdoors ought to cheap recreation option - the cost to get there and whatever food you want to bring. It is gross that we fund these great places through taxes, then only those you can easily pay again can use them.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by r00fus on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:29PM (#18418904)
I liked the CA prop a few years ago that pushed fees into your vehicle registration and just made it free to arrive if you showed a registration.

It would have made the parks a lot more sustainable in terms of revenue and increase the quality while making it cheaper for anyone who went more than once or twice a year.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by vinay427 on Saturday November 10, 2018 @02:26AM (#18420345)
I don't think this is a great solution. For one thing, it favors car owners, which would discourage many people who live in Denver cities and people who have particularly low incomes. For another, it's not really a fee for the parks anymore when people are obligated to pay it for something largely unrelated. That's more of a tax, and while I wouldn't have a problem with paying it myself, it moves away from the current status quo that people who use the park help pay a little more for its maintenance. I think that's alright in principle for public wonders like the parks, but focusing the fee on car owners seems a little arbitrary.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by glitcher on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:34PM (#18418622)
Similarly, it just feels plain wrong whenever there is a government shutdown and huge national parks are "closed". I'm sure there are good arguments on both side of this, but to me the idea that you can close a large expanse of wilderness seems absurd.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by skissane on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:36PM (#18418946)
> it just feels plain wrong whenever there is a government shutdown

I don't know why Americans put up with that silly government shutdown nonsense. In most countries that never happens. I think the solution is really simple – all a President has to do is call Congress' bluff and order the government to stay open, and to apply the previous budget on a pro rata basis.

"But that's illegal!", people say. Well, it would violate the Antideficiency Act. But, the Antideficiency Act is rather toothless. Nobody has ever been prosecuted for violating it, and the President can always use prosecutorial discretion and the power of pardon to prevent any such prosecutions. Would the Supreme Court order the government to close? Maybe it would, maybe it wouldn't, the Supreme Court is very unpredictable. But, assuming it doesn't, Congress can either accept it, or impeach and remove the President. Given removal of a President requires a two-thirds vote of the Senate, it probably wouldn't happen.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by dragonwriter on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:03PM (#18419076)
> Well, it would violate the Antideficiency Act.

More to the point, it would violate an express prohibition in Art. I, Sec. 9 of the Constitution: “No money shall be drawn from the treasury, but in consequence of appropriations made by law”.

> Would the Supreme Court order the government to close?

Yes, the Supreme Court would very likely order the executive branch to stop expending non-appropriaed funds.

> But, assuming it doesn't, Congress can either accept it, or impeach and remove the President. Given removal of a President requires a two-thirds vote of the Senate, it probably wouldn't happen.

Maybe not right now, where Congress is dominated so much by partisanship over protection of institutional traditional, legal, and Constitutional power that you can imagine the President's party backing such a blatantly unconstitutional usurpation of Congressional authority. But that's sort of aberrant historically; most of the time, even the President’s party is keen to keep the executive out of legislative branch’s clear Constitutionally-reserved powers.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by njarboe on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:32PM (#18419410)
Like Rome, it seems that over time the legislative body finds less and less to agree on and with that inaction, the executive slowly takes over the power vacuum.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by skissane on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:28PM (#18419394)
> More to the point, it would violate an express prohibition in Art. I, Sec. 9 of the Constitution: “No money shall be drawn from the treasury, but in consequence of appropriations made by law”.

Well, you are right, I wasn't really thinking about the appropriations clause in my previous post. Although, a President could argue that Congress is violating (at least the spirit of) the Constitution by refusing to present an appropriations bill for signature, and that the President's action is forced by Congress' own dereliction of its constitutional duty. Furthermore, the President could argue that by applying pro rata last year's appropriation acts, the President is still appropriating "by law", just using a previous law faced with Congress' failure to pass a new one. If the President can present an interpretation of that clause by which keeping the government open is constitutional, then the President can insist they are not violating the Constitution, unless and until the Supreme Court says that the President's interpretation is wrong.

> Yes, the Supreme Court would very likely order the executive branch to stop expending non-appropriaed funds.

But how often have the Courts enforced the appropriations clause in the past? There seems to be very little case law. The Executive has violated it in the past (e.g. the Reagan administration violating the Boland Amendment) and the Judicial branch has tried its best to duck the issue (Sanchez-Espinoza v Reagan).

If the Supreme Court wants to stay out of it, they have the tools to do so – standing, the political question doctrine, etc. Whether they choose to do so or not may ultimately turn out to be a political rather than legal decision. If the Court has a Republican-apppointed majority, and a Republican President is refusing to shut down the government, the Court might decide to stay out of the matter, while they might decide differently if the President were a Democrat.

(Although in theory the Supreme Court is apolitical, in practice they sometimes appear to be motivated by political concerns, see e.g. Bush v. Gore, and also Roberts and the Affordable Care Act.)

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Godel_unicode on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:03PM (#18419074)
We don't do monarchy in the United States. We believe in checks and balances, and limited power.

Edit: also, the power of the purse is a matter of constitutional law, not the antideficiency act. The supreme court would absolutely order the government to close. No Federal employee would follow executive orders to violate congressional authority.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by krapp on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:46PM (#18419815)
>I don't know why Americans put up with that silly government shutdown nonsense.

Many Americans believe that government is useless at best, malicious at worst, and grossly incompetent either way, and that shutting it down would probably do more good than harm.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by SamReidHughes on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:25PM (#18419753)
> In most countries that never happens.

That's because the U.S.A. has three parties that have to agree to a bill.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Rebelgecko on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:05PM (#18419314)
There's a state park by me that charges $40 or so (although you can hike in for free)
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by teej on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:07PM (#18418041)
America's national parks got 331 million visits last year. The most popular parks get very busy.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by tcdent on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:03PM (#18417995)
I live near Joshua Tree National Park. We pull upwards of 3 million visitors each year and growing. Expecting this weekend will be extremely busy around town.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by desas on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:26PM (#18419155)
I live near the Peak District National Park in the UK. It pulls 13 million people per year and is 550 square miles, which is much much smaller than Joshua Tree National Park
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by newman8r on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:16PM (#18418112)
I've got a 5 acre parcel in that area as well, wonder valley. I've talked to at least one other HN user who lives out there too. Perfect time of year to be out there, it's like beach weather.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Rebelgecko on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:04PM (#18419307)
I would not have guessed that there would be any HN users in Wonder Valley. Do you have any sort of structure on the property, or just a lot? What (if anything) do you do for water/electricity?
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by newman8r on Friday November 09, 2018 @11:25PM (#18419929)
I brought my trailer out there but it was vandalized. There's a small existing cement foundation where a building used to be (which is common for the parcels out there). I started basic work on some outbuildings using dry stone masonry (there's a rocky outcropping on about half of the property so there's an unlimited supply of big rocks)

I started working on a well, but for water I mostly filled up my tanks at the Joshua Tree visitors center once a week (the water is free for the public).

For power, I used a generator and a battery bank. I purchased some solar panels, but I decided not to put them in until I build a real cabin.

For internet, I used cellular. Since there's a 100 foot outcropping on the property, I was able to get a great signal by setting that up on top of the hill.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by timtyrrell on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:51PM (#18418349)
It is $80 a year to get an annual pass, not too bad if you visit a few.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by scythe on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:13PM (#18419337)
The busy ones have a fee. From the site (linked downthread):

>Out of the 418 units in the National Park Service (NPS), 115 parks charge an entrance fee.

The majority of national parks are free! However, the most famous ones -- Yosemite, Yellowstone, Death Valley, Great Smoky, etc -- have an entrance fee.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by garysahota93 on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:53PM (#18418710)
Many times, they are super busy, but the cost of admission really goes towards paying the Park Rangers and for overall upkeep of the park. Government funding decreases year over year, so these admissions become more and more necessary.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by npsbackcountry on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:09PM (#18418060)
Some are that busy, indeed. My base of operations takes >20 million visitors annually.

The glitterati Parks like Yosemite, Yellowstone, or Zion are overrun. It’s a difficult situation compounded by lack of budget for staff and upkeep.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by outworlder on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:29PM (#18418201)
Went to Yosemite two weeks ago. The area around the visitor center is indeed packed full. Looked more like a city downtown, rather than a park.

The rest of the park though? Crossed the park via the Tioga Pass to reach Mammoth Lakes (which is outside of the park). There was very low traffic and a handful of people.

I feel that most people are concentrated in a few areas only, which should help. But the park is MASSIVE (takes almost 3h across by car). The entrance fee is a bargain considering how beautiful it is, and the sheer size of the area that has to be maintained and patrolled.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by npsbackcountry on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:41PM (#18418291)
Grand Canyon of the Tuolumne for victory. I dont live or work in CA, but have hiked it and it’s known amongst backcountry employees to be the “secret,” best route in the park.

Only mention it here because the sheer Kantian sublime will keep the hordes out ;)

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by chabes on Friday November 09, 2018 @04:54PM (#18418370)
Careful of the rattlesnakes back there. I almost got bit once when I was deep in the backcountry, and I would NOT want to be forced to find out what it takes to endure that situation
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by saltcured on Friday November 09, 2018 @11:02PM (#18419863)
To be fair, Tuolumne and the Tioga Road are already in their off-season where no overnight parking or camping is allowed and all services are closed. Anyone up there has to be on a day trip, unless they have a wilderness permit and either packed in a long distance or had someone drop them at a trailhead up there. During the summer months, Tioga Road can be clogged like an amusement park too.

Also, while there is an entrance fee that applies per vehicle and gives you access for 7 days, there is also an NPS annual pass which costs about $100 and lets you enter every National Park and National Monument. So, you never have to pay more than approximately three Yosemite entrance fees in a single year, no matter how often you visit.

When I was a kid, we also had a "Golden Eagle" pass which combined the NPS annual pass with similar unlimited access to all California State Parks. I haven't seen that option in a long time though.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by throwaway427 on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:13PM (#18419106)
Went to Acadia a couple of weekends ago, was amazing. Went one time in the dead of summer a few years ago, was annoying.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by ahi on Saturday November 10, 2018 @01:40AM (#18420236)
Acadia is relatively tiny compared to the western parks. Still possible to get off the beaten path, although it's more like a public summer retreat than wilderness area.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:44PM (#18418668)
What I don't understand is why they are so cheap, especially in places like California where certain weekends are so crowded that trails get quota and lottery allocations.

Surely a bidding system would lead to a better allocation of those (public) resources, finance the conservation and management costs and avoid the dreaded tragedy of commons...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Marazan on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:45PM (#18418671)
And then poor people couldn't afford to go.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:51PM (#18418699)
Why? The less wanted parks or time slots could bid even under current costs.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by joshuamcginnis on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:58PM (#18418736)
There is only one Yosemite.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:03PM (#18418764)
Indeed. And it certainly can't fit all 8 billion of us during the same 4th of July weekend.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by CobrastanJorji on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:18PM (#18418838)
Right. But your proposal maximizes profit but minimizes access for the poor. It's a good choice for a business, but profit isn't really the goal of national parks.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by njarboe on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:54PM (#18419500)
You know that year in advance auctions really does deny access to the majority of poor people. They don't plan vacations a year in advance. They have a little extra cash for gas money one weekend and head out. This situation is sort of like rent control in Berkeley. The poor people are always moving around for various reasons and don't benefit much from it. It mostly benefits the white progressive-voting Berkeley-grad trustifarian hippy living in the same apartment for 50 years. Not people currently struggling to make ends meet.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:32PM (#18418923)
No, my proposal just solves the access allocation problem using the only mechanism we known for finding out the actual value of things: free markets.

Profit is just a nice side benefit which you can use any way you like: to build more parks, improve access to existing ones or simply subsidies access for the poor during less requested periods.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by CobrastanJorji on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:33PM (#18419186)
You propose that your solution is the only mechanism for finding out the actual monetary value of visiting a park. Let's say that's true. But why is knowing the actual monetary value of the park good, and why is it so good that it outweighs the downside of preventing the poor from visiting the national parks?
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by SamReidHughes on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:19PM (#18419729)
What's the downside? For every poor person that can't go, a rich person can go in their place. So we get equally many people enjoying the parks. Unless a poor person is more worthy to you, I don't see what the big deal is.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Emma_Goldman on Saturday November 10, 2018 @04:15AM (#18420566)
I can't tell if you're being serious, but the downside is that there would be egregiously unequal access to an important and collectively owned part of their country. Why should how much money you have determine whether you can step foot in a national park? That would be horrifying.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by SamReidHughes on Saturday November 10, 2018 @03:37PM (#18423355)
It's not how much money you have, it's how much you pay. Money is generally gotten by having done useful stuff for other people. If you're going to limit access, it's more fair that people who sacrifice some of that money get priority.

It's not egregiously unequal -- it's a fair admissions fee that everybody (visiting during peak season) has to pay.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Emma_Goldman on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:26PM (#18445055)
"Money is generally gotten by having done useful stuff for other people."

I do not agree. I think there is a very wide divergence between what is of exchange value and what is socially valuable. Capitalism is a system with its own structural tendencies and deformations. It cannot reduced down to just so many bilateral exchanges in which both parties achieve utility-improvements.

"It's not egregiously unequal -- it's a fair admissions fee that everybody (visiting during peak season) has to pay."

It is unfair because: (i) it assume that people with less money have less claim to a natural part of the earth that is held in common; (ii) most - maybe all - of the reason that some people have more money than others is, (a) because they were born with genes with a set of highly determinate propensities, with a determinate family and social configuration, that made them who they are (i.e. it's not within their control, and so they can hardly claim credit for it), (b) they exhibit various vices, like greed, covetousness, ruthlessness, etc., and so spend more time doing worse things to make money (of course, this is a little polemical, and I only mean for it to apply to a certain class of people who are particularly zealous and proud of money-making).

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by SamReidHughes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:58AM (#18457211)
Suppose you distribute time slots by lottery. That's unfair because it assumes people with less luck in the lottery have less claim to the natural part of the earth that is held in common.

Making people pay money, likewise, is unfair in that sense. But I'm not sure it's a different kind of unfairness.

And often people have money because of positive virtues: diligence, hard work, not buying things you can't afford.

Among most people visiting a national park and paying an increased peak-hours fee, my bet is there is only a small lean towards such virtues.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Emma_Goldman on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:34AM (#18458477)
A lottery is randomly distributed across all those who put in their lots in, while charging an entry fee publicly and arbitrarily discriminates against those with less money.

A lottery has the merit, at least, of being procedurally fair, i.e. all those who enter have an equal chance of being chosen on non-arbitrary (random) grounds.

I don't see a good reason why having less money should invalidate your claim to a national park held in common among all citizens.

Consider the political equivalent: a system of sortition that elects citizens by lottery; and a system of oligarchy that elects citizens according to who is able and willing to pay.

It is a question about what kind of society and public life you want to encourage: greed, productivism and hierarchy; or inclusiveness, community and equality.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by SamReidHughes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:37PM (#18465469)
> I don't see a good reason why having less money should invalidate your claim to a national park held in common among all citizens.

A reason, besides fairness, is for one of the merits of charging a fee: so that people who value the experience the most are the ones that go. (In the case of campground reservations, one reason for having fees at all is to make people show up.)

You could focus more closely on this metric by making the fee be paid in the form of an increase to your adjusted gross income. But the poor already underpay taxes -- fairer would be for the wealthy to get into parks for free, as thanks for paying for the infrastructure that everybody else uses.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Emma_Goldman on Saturday November 17, 2018 @08:37AM (#18475463)
This conversation is going nowhere.

You clearly believe that it follows from the fact of being wealthy that you have a greater claim on collective resources, either because you manifest greater virtue than the poor, or because you have simply done more good.

I don't believe that people with wealth deserve that wealth in any deep sense - because people are who they are due to external forces, genetic and social.

I also don't believe that greed, acquistiveness, etc., are social virtues.

Most importantly, I don't think society should be founded upon productivism (accumulating as much wealth as possible) and hierarchy (the wealthy are better and have more claims on social goods than the poor).

Capitalism is based on demeaning and toxic hierarchies and inequalities, where everyone works nearly all of the time (except for those who don't work at all) in order to create masses of unnecessary commodities, that are slowly destroying the planet.

I cannot credit the view that wealth per se is good, or that we should bow before those who are lucky and oblivious enough to stand at the top of this scheme of things.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by ip26 on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:28PM (#18419160)
Why do we need to know the market value of visiting public land?
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by Marazan on Saturday November 10, 2018 @02:35PM (#18423057)
How does it solve the 'access allocation' problem better than a random lottery?
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by qlm on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:40PM (#18418970)
Only on HN will you see somebody unironically suggest a bidding system for access to a park.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by ghaff on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:15PM (#18419114)
I'm just stunned (but probably shouldn't be) that someone would not only openly advocate for but double down on the idea that access to national parks should be determined by who has the most money. It's not only on HN but the other places probably involve private clubs and drinking whiskey.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:29PM (#18419169)
You do realize that this is how access is granted to pretty much everything else in this world, and with huge benefits.

Why not have the same benefits for the national parks? Some are in desperate need of work and financing.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by shaki-dora on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:06PM (#18419697)
To use an argument that has a chance to convince even you (i. e. to appeal to naked greed, opportunism, and selfishness):

If you were to actually get your wish, you would arrive at a pretty accurate remake of Europe around the 18th or 19th century[0]. Only with money being passed down from generation to generation, not land of title of nobility.

Many of those who didn't quite appreciate the genius and efficiency of this God-given system left Europe in those times to seek their luck in...America!

That wouldn't quite work today, what with no more continents available for settlers, not even those willing to ignore a few existing people already living there.

Which brings us to the second great idea some European at that time had, the guillotine...

0: Not saying that national parks alone would do this. There are actually far more resources that people like you thankfully don't even recognize as escapees from capitalism, to varying degrees. Among those are police protection, basic education, the right to use even crowded sidewalks, clean air and water, etc.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by delian66 on Saturday November 10, 2018 @01:42PM (#18422750)
Well, reality seems to disagree with your bleak hypothesis about possession of money becoming strongly correlated with heredity/nobility:

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-...

https://taxfoundation.org/income-mobility-and-persistence-mi...

Just a reminder - you are talking about access to a freaking park, and not to a gold mine.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by int_19h on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:33PM (#18419776)
> You do realize that this is how access is granted to pretty much everything else in this world, and with huge benefits.

And yet several other countries have free access to national parks, museums etc.

Of course nothing is free. But the question of who pays, when it comes to public lands and public property, is a question of public policy. If the citizens decide that it is important to keep those things available to all, then it is certainly doable. Even in US we have quite a few things like that (e.g. beaches in most states). There's no reason why it can't apply to the parks.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by thatfrenchguy on Friday November 09, 2018 @09:28PM (#18419598)
No
[dead]
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:10PM (#18419328)
Call me stupid if you want, but I am actually convinced that the poor's access to national parks would be improved under my scheme. Just not during the most requested times, when rich aholes betting each other would easily make enough cash to subsidize access for free plenty of other (less popular) times.

Certainly not a politically popular opinion though, you are very right on that one...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:47PM (#18419012)
Oh, I am in favor of bidding systems for access to everything, but especially for government held, "public" resources.

Such systems would point out things people find valuable and encourage entrepreneurs and markets to create and offer alternatives.

I am still interested in hearing why this is such a bad idea (other than not being a very popular one, of course).

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by timmaah on Friday November 09, 2018 @06:56PM (#18419055)
Going for a hike or camping in on land preserved for the people by the people owned by the people should now be an exclusive playground for the rich? No. Just no.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:02PM (#18419072)
Well, let it be the exclusive playground of the lucky (winners of the lottery) then.

I am resigned to the fact that I won't reach Mt Whitney's summit during summer again in my lifetime...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by int_19h on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:34PM (#18419780)
I'd much rather it be the playground of the lucky, than the playground of the rich. Public lands are held in common trust in the name of all citizens equally, not in proportion to their wealth. If there's not enough access time to go around, then a lottery is an obvious way to approximate equitable access.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by njarboe on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:47PM (#18419468)
You can do it as a day hike from the Mitre basin to the south. I was there in Sept, no people, amazingly beautiful. Send me an email (see profile) for details.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by timmaah on Friday November 09, 2018 @10:01PM (#18419679)
That is basically how campsites in crowded national parks operate. I'm ok with it.
Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by longerthoughts on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:11PM (#18419101)
>I still want to hear why this is such a bad idea (other than not being a very popular one, of course)

Because it effectively prevents parts of the public from being able access a public resource.

If that isn't enough, think about what happens to the public's opinion of National Parks if most people can't afford to use them. At best the public would likely vote to reverse the new fee structure, at worst you create a public that outright opposes conversation of public land and parks are slowly dismantled.

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by nickpp on Friday November 09, 2018 @07:23PM (#18419145)
Parts of the public can't access these crowded parks right now anyways. It's literally impossible for everybody to access the parks at the same time.

But I'll concede your second argument because it's politics. Not the first time politics or religion win over rationality either...

Re:All U.S. National Parks Are Free to Enter on Sunday by dnautics on Friday November 09, 2018 @08:12PM (#18419332)
It would be a great idea, especially if coupled with (publicized) programs to get people who couldn't afford it in