News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by CiPHPerCoder on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:43AM (#18399014)
> Is it okay for doctors to lie about placebo treatments if it actually helps?

I mean, their oath is to help people, not to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by joshgel on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:55AM (#18399075)
Oh, no. It’s much more complicated than that. The ethical principle you describe might more clearly be defined as beneficence: acting in best interest of the patient. But what about when it conflicts with another ethical principle,namely autonomy: the right to decide what happens to your own body and what treatments you don’t get.

To my mind, there isn’t an obvious answer, but the conflict between these two is why there is debate about “using” the placebo effect as a treatment.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by yomly on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:49AM (#18399433)
A very interesting ethical discussion I had with a doctor friend recently is that in some cases where a doctor identifies that amputation is the right/only course of action, they will only present that as a soft option to the patient, if at all.

This is because studies have since found that amputations can cause a great deal of psychological harm and it can be better for the patient if they arrive at the conclusion to amputate of their own volition - even if that takes months of excrutiating agony spent realizing not having the limb is better than the pain.

It was an interesting additional dimension to consider - even if the doctor knows much better than the patient, sometimes the patient feeling a sense of autonomy could be important for their wellbeing, and that short term pain could be beneficial.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by joshgel on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:18AM (#18400097)
In some ways this applies to everything we do that we think might be helpful. Sure we could get patients to loose weight by locking them up and only feeding them 1300 calories of veggies, but for some obvious reasons that isn't really an option. We can encourage them to take medications, but they still have to take them.

Atul Gawande talks about how much we have discovered in medicine in the last century, but that the next century is going to be about how to effectively implement that knowledge to help people. This applies to both the first world and to the developing world, though the challenges in both are different.

(also we probably wont stop discovering new treatments that we will them have to deploy...)

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by derefr on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:47PM (#18401751)
> Sure we could get patients to loose weight by locking them up and only feeding them 1300 calories of veggies, but for some obvious reasons that isn't really an option.

Yeah, but a lot of patients would consent to an offered treatment plan where they're locked up (and unable to sign themselves out!) and fed only 1300 calories of veggies.

The weird thing is, there are private businesses willing to provide exactly that kind of service (see: de-tox centers.) But doctors and hospitals generally don't see this as a valid form of in-patient medical treatment. Why is that? Do doctors think that patients have an inalienable right to bodily autonomy? (If so, how would surgery ever work?)

(The annoying point about this difference, to me, is that if a doctor were to diagnose you with X thing that keeps you at the hospital for a month, unable to leave—then your insurance would likely pay for that, and your employer would likely consider you on sick leave. But if a private business like a detox center keeps you for a month, then you have to pay for that out-of-pocket and you're likely to be fired from your job if you don't have the requisite vacation days saved up. From what I can see, it is in the patient's long-term interest if doctors get into this business!)

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by TheCapn on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:08AM (#18399164)
I figure the ethical debate extends into our societal issue of greed as well. Certain institutions would love to be able to give you no medication/treatment, charge you as though you had received it and you're none the wiser.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by collyw on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:32AM (#18399317)
Homoeopathy comes to mind.

I am in two minds about it. On the one hand it would appear pretty ridiculous and there is no way that it should be paid for. On the other hand if it works via the placebo effect in a cost effective manner, is that a bad thing?

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by hobs on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:50AM (#18399438)
The placebo effect isnt bad, lying about the effects (homeopathy) charging much more than the cure is worth (homeopathy), and outright selling poison to people (homeopathy) is not ok.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by delecti on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:08AM (#18400025)
The weird thing about homeopathy is that it's advertised as selling poison, but actually isn't. One of the ridiculous premises is that "like cures like", so it should be poison, but then there's the other ridiculous premise of diluting it to make it more powerful.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by dwighttk on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:21AM (#18400122)
except when it is selling dangerous levels of poison:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2017/01/28/fda-toxic-b...

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by icebraining on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:01AM (#18399962)
But isn't the lying necessary to be a placebo?

And what is the cure worth? How do you measure that?

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by hapidjus on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:15AM (#18400070)
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by Udik on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:06AM (#18400009)
How is it supposed to work as a placebo if you're told "hey, this is a glass of fresh water: drink it. And by the way, it's free'.

In other words the lie is integral to the working of the placebo. This is the whole source of the issue.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by svachalek on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:14PM (#18400964)
It does work even without deception, which makes it all the weirder. It's covered in the article.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:41PM (#18401689)
What's interesting is that it seems to depend on which truth you tell. To oversimplify, "take this, it's not medicine" doesn't help. "Take this, it's not medicine but it will help you anyway" does.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by nkrisc on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:17AM (#18399218)
Which is interesting because presumably if they didn't charge you it would shatter the placebo effect. I wonder if cost of the procedure actually impacts the efficacy of the placebo?
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by CiPHPerCoder on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:18AM (#18399229)
Sane middleground:

"We did procedure X, but your insurance covered all of it."

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by InitialLastName on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#18400674)
Nobody sane would ever believe that.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by soperj on Thursday November 08, 2018 @11:51AM (#18407634)
Nobody in the Western world outside the US would have any reason to question it.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by yesenadam on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:28AM (#18404510)
I'm guessing you're in the US.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:02PM (#18400877)
Anyone with a decent HMO would, for broad classes of procedures.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by njarboe on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:28PM (#18400624)
They are still providing a service and even pills with starch in them cost something to make. I don't see any reason the doctor and hospital shouldn't charge.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by wlesieutre on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:28AM (#18399300)
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by viggity on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:01AM (#18399535)
this is a small study - but yes, it appears that way https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25632091
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:29AM (#18399302)
If it works, its treatment, even the right treatment. Would you know when its safe to give a placebo? That takes diagnostic skill.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by OscarCunningham on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:26AM (#18399285)
If they're just administering placebos do you still have to pay for real doctors?
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by goldfeld on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:15AM (#18399629)
But then we go deeper into what placebo is. If the patient needs the psychological comfort of being seen and OK'd by real doctors, staying home mentalizing their own well-being won't do much. It's about taking responsibility for self-care--to the extent possible, of course--as opposed to externalizing any ill state to a sanctioned (sacred?) pill.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by bambax on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:16AM (#18400075)
I think placebo can be self-administered. I can make many pains decrease in intensity (or sometimes go away) just by thinking about it.

Last year I fell while mountain skiing and was in great pain at first (could barely move, standing up from lying down was excruciating, etc.)

The first day I didn't take any pain killer; the second day I did but it didn't really help. The third day I stopped taking the pills and just kind of "decided" I wouldn't suffer that much.

The pain didn't disappear completely, and it still hurt too much to get back on skis, but it stopped being so intense. When I got back home I did an x-ray exam and MRI and found I had broken a vertebra in two, that had lost 25% of its height. The doctor was super surprised I could walk normally and said: "do you not feel pain". I said I did but it was very manageable. She didn't investigate and just said "ok then, good for you!"

Also, I used to get hiccups that lasted a long time (30 minutes); and then I discovered you can make them stop very fast by being super calm and concentrating. Not only that, but since I found this out, I barely get hiccups at all anymore.

I think we can consciously control much more of our own body than we think, and we're only scratching the surface.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by ulucs on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:42AM (#18399824)
You could train actors to give out placebos for a fraction of price. Less work for doctors and more jobs for actors. It's a win-win.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by Spooky23 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:58AM (#18399942)
IMO the power of the mind and attitude is really key to how people perceive and function with pain. I don't think that we adequately understand it.

We see that all of the time... I recall working in a bakery in the mall in high school and chatting with a Vietnam veteran with chronic pain from a lung issue and a missing leg who would walk 8-10 miles on crutches every day at 5AM and sometimes do push-ups in our cafe area. He was the most positive person that I have ever met, which was striking when you'd see other folks with very minor issues grouse and complain and be visibly ill.

My mom was taught "therapeutic touch" in the 1960s in nursing school, which I believe isn't considered pseudoscience today. For certain types of patients, it was helpful, but the technique was mostly placebo.

Fundamentally, changing how people think is ethically problematic if it becomes manipulative, but it's a key factor for our well being as well.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by projektir on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:42AM (#18400296)
> We see that all of the time... I recall working in a bakery in the mall in high school and chatting with a Vietnam veteran with chronic pain from a lung issue and a missing leg who would walk 8-10 miles on crutches every day at 5AM and sometimes do push-ups in our cafe area. He was the most positive person that I have ever met, which was striking when you'd see other folks with very minor issues grouse and complain and be visibly ill.

This might simply be that the Vietnam veteran happens to have much better and more stable chemistry than people with, say, depression.

It seems one danger with this placebo discussion is that we may end up at square one, blaming depressed/anxious/ADHD/BPD people for their problems...

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by Spooky23 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:11PM (#18401976)
Absolutely... every question seems to open up a minefield of ethical problems, fraught with unknowns.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by closed on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:16AM (#18399213)
I suspect that much of this issue is resolved by looking at how they sought consent for their study, since they had to inform participants about what they were going to do to them (though they could have phrased it as, I may do A, or I may do B).

Now, they can say, "I may do A, and I may do B, and there is evidence that both are effective"

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by 794CD01 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:31AM (#18399747)
Autonomy isn't a meaningful principle when it comes to medicine. Even patients who are doctors can't really give informed consent since they won't necessarily be knowledgeable in the specialty relevant to their treatment. And the vast majority of patients aren't doctors.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by delecti on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:48AM (#18399860)
Not to invoke a slippery slope argument, but there are a lot of really horrible things that have been done without giving patients autonomy. We as a society need to consider it extremely carefully before any instance of acting against a patient's bodily autonomy.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by 794CD01 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:48PM (#18400763)
It would be interesting to compare that against the horrible things people do because they do have autonomy.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by delecti on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:16PM (#18401448)
If horrible things are being done to people, I'd pick the ones those people are doing to themselves almost every time over the ones being done to others in violation of their bodily autonomy.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by snowwrestler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:43PM (#18403002)
The whole point of autonomy is that there is an ethical difference between doing something to yourself, vs. doing something to someone else.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by 794CD01 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:25PM (#18403217)
Yes. Obviously you'd narrow things down and compare like to like. Anti-vaxers being the hot example of the day. Sometimes it's so obvious that we act on it, like with secondhand smoking, but I bet there's a lot more to dig into.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by snowwrestler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:49AM (#18399865)
Autonomy means that you get to consent (or not) even if you are not informed.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by 794CD01 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:52PM (#18400788)
Right, that's the problem. The fact that doctors must ask for the consent of people who don't understand what they are consenting to.

The idea itself isn't that controversial - age of majority laws for contracts, voting, and even medical treatment clearly acknowledge the idea that some people are too young to know what they are agreeing to, so the decision should be made by someone else who takes responsibility for them (most things), or there should be no decision because there doesn't need to be one (voting).

We just need to refine our understanding to reflect the reality that as old as you may get, you will never understand some things.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by snowwrestler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:08PM (#18401367)
Autonomy is not a problem of medical treatment, it's a fundamental principle of an ethical society.

Without autonomy, the concepts of voluntary/involuntary lose meaning, which can enable some very nasty scenarios. Exceptions to autonomy are rare and come with stringent legal duties and obligations on the responsible party. Doctors are not responsible for their patients in that way; they are service providers.

Lack of understanding should not be sufficient to undercut an ethical principle like autonomy. Imagine if I had the power to decide that you don't sufficiently understand the concept of autonomy, and must be shipped off to a re-education center.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by ArchTypical on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:35PM (#18402160)
> Autonomy is not a problem of medical treatment,

Talking about it outside of the specific conflict, is disingenuous. Everyone understands how important Autonomy is. That's part of the issue, not a supporting argument to value it over the health of a patient. If there's no patient, there's no Autonomy either.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by snowwrestler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:41PM (#18402995)
The GP comment was "Autonomy isn't a meaningful principle when it comes to medicine."

So, I do not agree with you that "everyone understands how important autonomy is."

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by 794CD01 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:29PM (#18403233)
Not agreeing isn't the same as not understanding.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by 794CD01 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:27PM (#18403226)
If I legitimately didn't understand it, it would be right to teach me. That's why we have mandatory schools for children.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by jschwartzi on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:49PM (#18401785)
The point of autonomy isn't to treat the patient as the most knowledgeable person in the room, but to present the options, all considerations and drawbacks that you're aware of, answer any questions, and then ask them to make a decision. If you think that patients aren't smart enough to understand the implications of drug side effects and weigh the costs and benefits of treatment versus the original disease, then I really hope you're not a doctor. And I really really hope you're not my doctor.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by ArchTypical on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:36PM (#18402169)
> then ask them to make a decision

You don't see the irony in that, when talking about the Placebo effect? This discussion is about an implicit assumption.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by Nasrudith on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:24PM (#18402536)
Is uninformed consent meaningful in the first place?
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by vanattab on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:23AM (#18399259)
What about pricing and marketing? Is it ok for a doctor to create a new "placibo treatment" and market it as the real deal on late night tv just because some non zero percentage of people will mark that they had improved symtopms. What is the fair price for a sugar pill that the doctors and compaines are empowered to lie about. Ones mind and mindset play a big role in healing the body and we have far more powerful tools for effecting the mind then future doctor's lies and sugar pills. We have therapy, counseling and the love of family and friends. In my mind its all about hope which doctors can deliver to patients far better with smiles and compassion then sugar pills.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by CiPHPerCoder on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:28AM (#18399298)
> What is the fair price for a sugar pill that the doctors and compaines are empowered to lie about.

$0.

Health care costs have ruined many, and that's frankly unethical. I don't see a point treating the unethical American health care system as a premise in these ethical debates.

Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by njarboe on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:31PM (#18400649)
Why would you think manufacturing and distributing a sugar pill should cost $0? Many drugs are basically the same cost as sugar and those aren't free. How about $5 for a bottle of 100.
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by pishpash on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:31PM (#18403240)
Precisely, what is advertisement and marketing if not creating an incremental value from a placebo effect?
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by justsomedood on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:43AM (#18400298)
What if it being $0 reduces to placebo effect so that it no longer is effective?
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by CiPHPerCoder on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:44PM (#18400735)
Re:What if the Placebo Effect Isn’t a Trick? by conanbatt on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:21AM (#18399677)
The practice of medicine is at the service of the patient: the doctor should not make decisions for the patients unless he has to: the final say is always from the patient.

If the doctor lies to the patient, the patient cannot make a proper decision for himself.

So yes, it truly is an ethical dilemma.