News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by twoquestions on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:47PM (#18393206)
It doesn't help that job ads are wanting "Top 3% only!" or "Only top 1% Ninja Rockstars need apply!". Kind of reminds me of the market for singers or concert pianists, you absolutely need to be the best, even imperceptibly worse makes you unemployable.

Should those of us who aren't top 5%/didn't go to a top school just find another industry, one where sub-perfect work doesn't actively make other people's jobs harder?

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by saulrh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:08PM (#18393391)
Notice that, when they say they only hire the top 1%, there's a vicious sampling bias at work: even in a worst case where they're being literal they're actually hiring the top 1% of their applicants, not the top 1% of engineers. Think about how many jobs you usually apply for before getting one. Now imagine someone that's less successful than you at getting hired and think about how many times they're interviewing. Now think about the population that the interviewer sees. Now add college students that are just practicing and people that are required to interview for every job on the board to maintain unemployment. Now think about how much time interviewing you spend for every day working and how that might change as a function of quality - staying longer at better places, maybe?

I obviously don't have any statistics, but I think I could imagine a situation where the top 95% of software people constitute the top 1% of the interviewing population. Also one where interviewers are terrible at math, but that's no surprise. Anyway, you're fine, just go for it. That fact that you are self-aware enough to worry about it puts you in good standing all by itself.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by Spooky23 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:29PM (#18394658)
I've observed that in pursuing the 1% unicorn candidate, many people step in unicorn shit and hire smart people who are bad employees.

My goal is to not hire the bottom 50% of the workforce in a given discipline. IMO, you're better off building teams that make the average+ person more productive.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by fizx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:35PM (#18397106)
>I've observed that in pursuing the 1% unicorn candidate, many people step in unicorn shit and hire smart people who are bad employees.

What's fun is that this isn't just a possibility, its likely! Despite the following being a clearly artificial argument, the general shape of it is true.

Let's say that you can rate employees 1-10 on each of technical skill and employability/soft-skills, and that both are equally sought by the market. Given how attractive your company is to work for and what you pay, its quite often true that you can allocate around 12 total points between the two categories. 13 point candidates have better offers from Google; 11 point candidates fail your interview process.

If you only hire people that strongly pass a strong technical interview, ensuring that their technical skill is at least an 8/10, then your employees will have at most 4/10 soft skills.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by slededit on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:56AM (#18397366)
Microsoft in the 90s figured out how to work around that. Just silo them and have their manager do the external interfacing for them. This was assuming they really were at least an 8/10 which was required to make the whole thing worthwhile.

That of course works much better when everyone has their own office so the angry outbursts are only heard by the 2-3 closest neighbors.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by benibela on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:51AM (#18398547)
Or everyone works remotely, so no one hears their outbursts
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by carlmr on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:06AM (#18397718)
>If you only hire people that strongly pass a strong technical interview, ensuring that their technical skill is at least an 8/10, then your employees will have at most 4/10 soft skills.

Why most companies find it hard to find good sales engineers.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cheez on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:20PM (#18396686)
Yes! I love to build teams with average people that create above average results due to their configuration. It's my secret sauce.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by Double_a_92 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:28AM (#18398034)
Reminds me of that baseball movie where a manager hired low-value players, that very extremely good at only something.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by chupasaurus on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:22AM (#18398232)
"Moneyball" is the name of both the movie and the book it was based on.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by nestorD on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:35PM (#18393650)
There is a great article on the fact that everybody hires only the top 1% : https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2005/01/27/news-58/
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by spectre256 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:33PM (#18395520)
The fact that people still parrot the top 1% idea after it was pretty thoroughly debunked by Joel almost 15 years ago is...interesting.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by mmirate on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:44PM (#18396252)
When you discover that an intuitive result is wrong, the production of a thorough debunking is but a tiny sliver of the total work needed to change the world's minds away from that wrong result.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by jobigoud on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:45AM (#18398097)
We are still making many of the mistakes laid out in The Mythical Man-Month so…
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ethagnawl on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:36PM (#18395096)
> people that are required to interview for every job on the board to maintain unemployment.

I'm pretty sure you're being hyperbolic, but that sounds hellish. I have GAD and dread interviewing so much that I'd forego unemployment and just work as a Task Rabbit or something.

To preempt the inevitable responses: Yes, I do have a family to support and, yes, I have worked as a Task Rabbit or done manual labor when faced with similar situations in the past.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cirgue on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:06PM (#18394457)
We hire the top 5% of applicants. This says a lot about our applicant pool. It says very little about our team. No one here is from a top program. Many don't even have CS degrees.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:25AM (#18398927)
No you don't. I know you don't because you have no idea who the top 5% of applicants are. Not after interviews, not after 6 months on the job, not even 10 years in the job. You can't distill something as complex as humans working in teams that form a part of a larger organisation into a single number like that. That's not how the world works. For example Bob was doing great work but then his wife cheated on him and he is doing less great work. Is Bob in the top 5% or not?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cirgue on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:48PM (#18401780)
You're completely right of course, we hire people who we believe are the top 5% of the applicant pool. The point remains the same: what a company says about their hiring standards has little or no bearing on what their standards actually are in the context of the entire universe of software engineers (or any other field)
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:44PM (#18404198)
I'm still not quite sure what you think the 5% measures?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by kamaal on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:10AM (#18404792)
This discussion came up in even during that Netflix thread.

These companies aren't looking for top 1% people. They are looking for top 1% people who are in form currently.

The day you get unlucky and slip out of form, they don't want you.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:27AM (#18405257)
Which means they will miss the real top performers. The savants who are capable of flashes of brilliance that can make whole new industries. These people will most definitely fall outside any measure / quantifiable scale that any company uses for comfort.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by kamaal on Thursday November 08, 2018 @08:17AM (#18406022)
They apparently want people are having flashes of brilliance at this moment. They don't want them on their payroll once the flash dies. Then they want the next set of savants in form.

Its basically the equivalent reducing the great people to Kleenex. Once used, they want to throw them. Then buy the next Kleenex box.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:12PM (#18394943)
How do you measure this? I would wager that, at best, you're hiring the top 5% of applicants based on interview performance. It's likely you know little or nothing about what that says vis a vis job performance, because your interview probably doesn't exercise skills used on the job, except in a very tangential way.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by eberkund on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:41AM (#18397308)
I think he just means that they hire 5% of applicants, by definition they are the top 5% because they are the ones they chose to hire. Unless of course they have a significant number of people going through the entire interview process only to decline the offer.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:39PM (#18401130)
That's pretty close to the point I was making. They call it the top 5% because 5% of people pass their interview. The company doesn't have any idea whether those people (out of the entire pool) are the best candidates to do the job they were hired to do, because the company probably doesn't measure that. And, they sure don't know that their "top 5%" is representative of the top 5% of all engineers. For starters, how do you measure that?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by kradroy on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:50PM (#18394780)
It's less of a thing to put that childish language in a job posting these days. It'll come around again though. The more insidious thing is the requirements themselves. They're usually broad and often don't fit the role well, especially for roles above entry level. And sometimes I even come across entry level postings that seem too demanding.

I recently had to proof-read a job req for a lead dev role on our team. It was insane and the person it was targeted at 1) wouldn't work for the compensation we were offering 2) would likely be running their own business. When I gave my opinion to my manager he said "If we can get someone who can meet a third of those requirements and doesn't come off as an asshole, we'll give them an offer."

My husband is applying for jobs now and he says the same thing about senior positions he's come across. "This seems like it's a director's role, not a senior!" I tell him to apply anyway because they're just chest-puffing and won't find that ideal candidate before they make a desperation hire.

Those types of whacked out reqs are written by the employees who are exiting the role. They're likely exiting the role because they took on a bunch of extra responsibilities and weren't getting substantial raises or promotions. If you can do half the shit they did, you'll probably be fine. Although you'll eventually end up leaving that role for the same reasons the guy before you did.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ethagnawl on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:41PM (#18395134)
This is insightful and reassuring. Thanks for sharing.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ravenstine on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:15PM (#18393460)
There's another similar problem that I'm seeing that I don't think has been pointed out before.

Recently, I've been applying for web developer positions and am coming across applications with these sorts of questions:

- What's the coolest thing you've done both in life and at work?

- What are your dreams?

- Where do you see yourself in 10 years?

I certainly do have answers for these questions, but I can't tell if they're the ones that employers want to hear. And are these things for other random people to know?

There are things I've done that I think are cool, but that doesn't necessarily mean that most people will think they are cool. Honestly, there really isn't anything about my life that is conventionally cool, even by the standards of the nerdiest nerds. Should my life have been more unique and exciting by this point?

The same can basically be said of my dreams, although I do not aspire for big dreams. I haven't made enough money yet to even think about anything more grandiose than simply living comfortably. Do my dreams need to be more exciting? Should I be shooting the moon? I feel like any honest answer I give to the question will sound disappointing to any startup.

Should I see myself anywhere in particular in 10 years? Beyond making more money and taking on more responsibilities in my career, where should I be in 10 years? My field evolves so rapidly that I can't honestly predict that far ahead, let alone 5 years into the future. But maybe I'm not cut out for what I do if I can't see that far ahead?

I could very well be what's wrong in the picture, but it seems to me like we are culturally intolerant of "normal" people who have a skill and want to make a living. Everyone needs to have dreams, grand aspirations, and a little clairvoyance. I tend to have pretty high confidence, but seeing this kind of language when applying for jobs does stir up that feeling of imposterhood in me.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by alxlaz on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:37PM (#18394231)
I've made a point for myself to never ask questions like "what are your dreams" or "where do you see yourself in 10 years" in an interview, ever. For a long time, I've used these as a filter, too. Getting this kind of question in an interview is a big red flag for me and a huge disappointment.

Let me elaborate a little.

My dreams are none of an interviewer's bloody business. I'm here to work not share the things that give me hope in my darkest moments or the aspirations that shaped my adulthood. I find this question very creepy and extremely unprofessional.

I could maybe figure out a "lesser dream" to share, but then what's the point of this question? To find out the most intimate thing that I'd be willing to share?

Where I see myself in ten years is a meaningless question to ask after I've had, what, fifteen minutes of exposure to a company's culture? Maybe I'm the kind of person who sees themselves in management over ten years, but you've got such an amazing working culture that you could convince the most ambitious career builder to stick to engineering instead. Or vice-versa. Or do you really want to hire the kind of people who get an idea in their head, and then do it, even if it takes them ten years and it's really, really, really bad idea?

I've heard all sorts of ways to justify these things. That it's a way to see if a candidate can relate to you and evaluate their empathy -- if anything, this will say more about an interviewer's biases than about anything else. To see if a candidate can communicate about abstract matters -- as if there are not countless questions about ethics, aesthetics and epistemology in our profession that you need to start prying into personal things. That it's a way to see if they're "career-oriented", whatever that means, as if someone who writes amazing code but wouldn't hustle for a promotion is a bad hire.

So far, it hasn't turned out to be a bad idea.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:54PM (#18394363)
I see these types of questions as the sign of an inexperienced interviewer. Given how many inexperienced interviewers one can see interviewing at tech companies, I would call that a chartreuse flag at best due to lack of signal.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ricardoreis on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:42AM (#18397850)
I see these types of questions as the sign of an inexperienced interviewer.

Yup - that's all it is. And you're going to have a certain envelope of negatives (usually far worse than this) in any environment.

So while it does make the flag a bit bless verdant... to call it a "red flag" seems to be a bit of a stretch.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by FabHK on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:32AM (#18398050)
Props to both of you for the lovely synonyms for "greenish" :-)

(And as for the substance: agreed, and a capable interviewee should know how to work around those questions and similarly silly ones, like "what's your greatest weakness?". It's a two-way street. And while it's not a positive datapoint, it's hardly a KO-criterion. (viridescent? aquamarine? turquoise? :) )

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by GauntletWizard on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:21PM (#18395023)
"Where do you see yourself in 10 years" is a simple way of asking how you expect your career to advance and what they should expect of you in the future - It's totally reasonable for a company to be interested in an employee's personal growth plans and yes, your long-term commitments to yourself

If you don't have any work-safe dreams, you might want to see a psychiatrist. Again, though, you've misinterpreted the question - They're looking for you to express your spark of passion. It doesn't even have to be for the job. People like people who can talk about something passionately.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by tremon on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:18AM (#18398215)
They're looking for you to express your spark of passion

That's the charitable reading. The adversarial reading is that they're looking for the emotional buttons to push to maximize your output while minimizing their investment in you.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by _Tev on Friday November 09, 2018 @05:19AM (#18413519)
Why this has to be only "them maximizing your output" and not "giving you opportunity to grow in a direction you want and company can make use of"?

There's so much zero sum game thinking here when it comes to job relations ...

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:34AM (#18398971)
Who works somewhere for 10 years these days?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by dagw on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:23AM (#18398021)
"what are your dreams" or "where do you see yourself in 10 years"

To me these are two entirely different classes of questions. The first is open ended and meaningless, while the second is directly connected to your career and thus highly relevant for both you and the company. I know where I want to be in 10 years career wise and thus I want to know if this job can help me get there. Equally the company probably knows where it wants to be in 10 years and as such wants to know if you can help it get there.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:32AM (#18398961)
I ask a variation of this question. It is along the lines of "how would you like your career to progress over the next 3-5 years?". I am it because I don't want to hire someone for whom the organisation doesn't have a career path for. Any answer is fine. I'm not looking for a particular answer just an honest one.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by milansm on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:04AM (#18399139)
> I don't want to hire someone for whom the organisation doesn't have a career path for

and

> I'm not looking for a particular answer just an honest one.

are contradictory one to another.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:17AM (#18399220)
How so? I'm having an open conversion. The goal is to align expectations. It makes little difference to me on a personal level what their answer is. I'm representing the company and they are representing themselves so they have way more skin in the game. It's my moral perogative to have this open conversation with them. I don't want to hire them if the lack of career opportunity/progression makes them unhappy but if they still want the job even after it becomes evident that they may have difficulty reaching their goals in this organisation I'll still extend the offer. I'll only ask this question to people I've already decided to try hire.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by robaato on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:08PM (#18394468)
And what happens if you answer as you have just done (slightly edited for politeness if appropriate)??
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by i_cant_speel on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:35PM (#18393656)
Imagining coming up with an answer to something cool that has happened in my life makes me feel anxious. I have lived a pretty happy and fulfilling life up until this point but I can't think of one thing that I've done that would be super cool to talk about. I hope I never have to answer that question.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by MrMember on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:39PM (#18394245)
Not only that but having to come up with an answer on the fly in a super high pressure situation like a job interview. I'm sure I'd fumble it somehow, and then eternally wonder if I didn't get the job because I couldn't answer a question about something cool I've done.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:59PM (#18393898)
I don't use these questions when interviewing, but I do try to find out what really excites/motivates candidates (assuming they've survived the first ten minutes of technical, where I probably already have a no and I'm just trying to finish politely). For me, interviewing the good candidates is largely about deciding whether or not I really want to work with this person - I've already decided they're technically competent and can do the job, but I actively avoid working with assholes if I can, and I strongly prefer to work with people I think are interesting. And part of that is that they're passionate about something - a hobby, their kids, whatever.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by turtlecloud on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @08:39PM (#18396511)
Ugh I hate interviewers like that. Just brings in bias like not wanting to work with black people and other stereotypes (older people/ethnics) etc.

That type of culture is unbearable to those that don’t perfectly fit your monoculture.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by Stratoscope on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:26AM (#18397265)
Wanting to work with interesting people is somehow correlated with not wanting to work with black people? I'm having trouble making sense of this.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by astura on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:35AM (#18397288)
"People I find interesting" is usually synonymous with "people who are like me." Even if it's not intentional, we tend to perfer people like ourselves.

My opinion is uninteresting people are just fine for coworkers, you're interviewing for an employee, not a drinking buddy.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by __bjoernd on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:03AM (#18397707)
On average I'm spending way more time with my colleagues than my drinking buddies, so I would really like someone that I can get along with.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by astura on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:12AM (#18398856)
"Get along with" is not the same as "find interesting."
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:36AM (#18400238)
You raise a good point, but at least in my case, I don't think that's what's happening, and here's why. Bias tends to strike and morph into "no" before it ever hits that "getting to know you" phase. There have been plenty of studies about the effect of things like "black" names or gender on the initial screening.

A big part of the hiring process, at least at big companies, is taking a pile of 100 resumes and reducing it to a pile of 10 resumes, because there's no way you're interviewing 100 candidates. So 90% are eliminated before ever meeting, and bias is huge there.

But the bias starts even before that. The pipeline itself is biased. There are more men than women, more whites than non-whites (proportional to society as a whole). This is a problem that needs to be addressed at the society level, not the interview level, but it affects the interview level, because candidates who are "different" lead to unconscious bias.

For older technical people... well, I'm one of them. I'm 53, which means a lot of my social group is the same age. I freely job-hop and don't struggle to find work. I've never felt that my age was a bias against me. What I do see, and I see this a lot, is people my age who worked at the same company for 10-20 years and then lost their job, for whatever reason (usually reorgs or dying companies). Their skill set has become largely about intra-company specialization rather than broad industry skills. I watched my spouse go through this. She lost her job of 13 years in a buyout, and it took her six months to find something else. She had gotten deep in a narrow business field (international e-commerce analyst), and there just weren't many jobs for her, even in our busy town. We didn't want to move to the Bay area or New York, and while she could do generic business analysis or project management, without industry-specific skills, she's not much better than someone barely past entry level. Eventually she found a job that suited her long-built skills, but it took a while. And this story is common as dirt, it's happened to a lot of my friends.

That's how age bias works. It's not discrimination, it's just being unprepared for the job market after too many years in one place. Keep your skills up to date and switch jobs regularly, and age is just a number.

So when you talk about monoculturing and bias at the interview point... nah, that's not the problem point. The problems of bias prevent the interview from happening in the first place.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by Double_a_92 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:41AM (#18398084)
But how does not having an exiting hobby make them an asshole?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:38AM (#18399781)
Why did you correlate those? They're in the same comment, but not dependent or related. I know plenty of assholes with fantastic hobbies.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by aplummer on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:23PM (#18393532)
> What's the coolest thing you've done both in life and at work? - What are your dreams? - Where do you see yourself in 10 years?

Hey, I ask a lot of these questions in consulting. What I’m looking for is to tell if a) you can communicate a point clearly b) if you can talk generally about your career and are growth oriented.

If you said that field evolves rapidly bit above that would be a good answer. If you span it as a joke “surely writing angular 25, the last web framework ever” even better.

I wouldn’t ask the dreams question, but the coolest question is loaded with coolest, I would say “tell me about a previous project you enjoyed working on” and see if you have had a good project you are passionate about.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:08PM (#18393986)
I often ask interviewees about a project they worked on that was very successful, and why it was successful - what did they like about it? That's a good way to find those passion points. It's also a good way to find weak candidates without independence or leadership skills, because they can't really talk about their role in a big success - they didn't have much of a role, usually.

A flip-side question is to ask about projects they worked on that failed. Failures rarely appear on resumes, and it can be an uncomfortable topic. But if you can get them going, you can learn a ton about how they handle adversity. Do they make excuses, or find scapegoats? Do they take responsibility? Do they give credit where credit is due for colleagues? Do they recognize the big-picture conditions that affected the situation?

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by HarryHirsch on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:44PM (#18395151)
projects they worked on that failed

That's a bad one, considering that everyone is supposed to be upbeat and positive in the face of adversity. You can't place blame on management and the environment that was in no way conducive to success because that's not culturally acceptable.

Are we supposed to prepare an answer for that question now as well because the true answer (unrealistic expectations from upper management and insufficient infrastructure) will make you fail the interview? What you could ask is what will make a team fail, and my answer would be autocratic management.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:15PM (#18395395)
- Are we supposed to prepare an answer for that question now as well?

Nope. I don't want a prepared answer. I want an honest answer. Hence throwing them a rough, non-technical question that absolutely will not be on the resume, but has been part of the career of any experienced candidate.

"Autocratic management" isn't a good answer, because it's too general. What did autocratic management do? Were the requirements incomplete? The schedule unrealistic? Beaten by the competition? Depended on unproven technology? Sometimes, everyone does everything right, and a project fails anyway. There's still a reason it failed.

But when I hear a candidate talk about failure in the form of "I was a hero, but my idiot co-workers and malicious bosses ruined everything", I hear them finding someone to blame, rather than a problem that didn't get solved correctly. And that tells me a lot about what working with them will be like, when we have our inevitable failures.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by HarryHirsch on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:42PM (#18395582)
How would a life scientist coming from Theranos before it became common knowledge that the company was a sham talk about their experience in a culturally acceptable manner? Developing reproducible blood tests from tiniest samples was never going to work, and upper management was actively malicious at that company. We now know where the blame was (with Holmes and Balwani), but if you started there because their projects sounded exciting and then were looking for a new job because the task was impossible and management was crazy you had a problem, and you can't say that in an interview.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by xkcd-sucks on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:13PM (#18396860)
"I worked on an awesome project and just kept my head down and worked like a good employee. Then one day I read the WSJ one day, and what do you know, my boss was getting investigated for fraud! Then the company shut down! I had no idea, because the sub project I was on worked perfectly. I heard people complain about managers, but they were on other teams and I didn't see them very much."
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by reificator on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:35PM (#18397108)
> before it became common knowledge that the company was a sham
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:35AM (#18399767)
I'm not worrying about corner cases here. Theranos is an exception. But someone coming from a startup that died? Yeah, they can talk about it, and I'd like them to talk about how they saw it in an honest way.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by HarryHirsch on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:35PM (#18400669)
Theranos was founded in 2003 and when people first started asking hard questions in 2012 or thereabouts they were marginalized. Holmes was the darling poster woman of Silicon Valley until the WSJ started investigating in October 2015. They were very much alive for over a decade.

Startuplandia has a way of attracting hucksters, unscrupulous businessmen and crazies with a firm disregard for what is physically possible. I notice that Ubeam was founded in 2011 and they are still around!

I once worked for an outfit where one founder was named party to an investor suit (he had awarded himself stock options after a clinical trial came out favourable) and the other was frankly incompetent and afflicted with cluster B personality disorders. It ended as well as one would have predicted. Failing startups because of founder personality and founder competence issues are unfortunately common, they are not corner cases at all, and for the person coming out of one the incidence is 100 %, but discussing such matters in an interview will torpedo your chances. No honesty for you, it's counterproductive for the jobseeker!

Seriously, Dave, if you were interviewing a candidate that had been working on the gluebot that Carreyrou mentioned in Bad Blood, how would he have to spin the story to get an offer out of you?

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:46PM (#18401178)
How to describe that? Simple, describe how management was setting up cage matches between competing development teams. I'm not saying "Don't blame management", not at all. I'm saying "bad management" is an insufficient answer. How did they go wrong? Playing dev teams off one another is a different problem than, say, insisting on using tech that isn't up to the task (a situation I've been in before), or an unwillingness to say no to the customer (a situation I've been in before, too).

Hell, I've talked openly in interviews about the problems with a project that I got fired from, and blamed both management and the customer in no uncertain terms. I fault myself mostly for not walking out on it. I still get job offers when talking about how I got fired by incompetent management of an out-of-control project. But part of that is that my story leads somewhere - it leads to my lessons learned, conditions I will no longer tolerate in a workplace, #1 of which is the bottomless budget.

So I care less about how you screwed up, or who or what you blame, and more about what you learned from the failure. Tell me that, and you win my heart.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:50PM (#18401208)
I should add, to get back to the idea of how a life scientist at Theranos would explain it... well, did you know you were doing something that couldn't be done? How did you feel about it? What did you do about it? Why did you stay/why did you leave? Did you feel your work was unethical?

Conceptually, Theranos was very exciting. I hope someone actually pulls it off someday. I can understand the attraction for a scientist.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by C1sc0cat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @07:17AM (#18398625)
how do you know that "reproducible tests from small samples " would never work? Is there an equivalent of Shannons law that you could prove this.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by HarryHirsch on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:05PM (#18400458)
Venous blood is simply venous blood. But capillary blood from fingertip samples contains variable amounts of interstitial fluid, and cell lysis is another issue there.

There are tests where it doesn't matter - consider the blood glucose - the variability of capillary samples vs venous samples is well understood and the introduced error sufficiently small compared to reference range.

But Theranos also tried electrolyte panels, and there you have a problem because the concentrations of ions in blood plasma are very different from the concentrations of ions inside cells. Both are tightly controlled in the healthy body. Slightly less than 50 % of blood is cellular matter, and even small amounts of lysis are sufficient to distort the numbers to render them clinically meaningless. You inevitably have lysis in capillary samples. Carreyrou talks about that in his book.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by aplummer on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:52PM (#18395619)
This is a really good point about expectations in job interviews. I think a lot of this comes down to "how you say it" and the data points you have to back it up.

For example, "we made several governance mistakes on a project that meant we didn't have enough time to finish the project. On the next project, I made sure to be clearer with estimates and buffer time, so that the team etc. etc." and "Our management doesn't listen" can describe the same situation.

Again, definitely agree you are in the danger zone so its important to be thoughtful.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by C1sc0cat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @07:13AM (#18398610)
Why and in which culture is this not acceptable
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by mdpopescu on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:41AM (#18397845)
Given that most people quit because of bad managers [1], I assume that a lot of projects fail for the same reason.

[1] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/employees-dont-leave-companie...

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:46AM (#18399027)
>they can't really talk about their role in a big success - they didn't have much of a role, usually.

I would wager that at least half of candidates are just good humble team players. Your approach optimises for egotistical braggarts at the expense of normal people.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:23PM (#18401500)
Egotistical bragging is pretty easy to spot. Good team players are easy to spot, too - they're the ones giving credit to leadership and co-workers even for work they take personal pride in. When I see a candidate's eyes light up talking about the manager who led them through a challenge into success, I know they respect others, and that matters.

It's hard for a lot of people to speak well of themselves, which makes the whole interviewing process difficult much of the time. We're trained to a beat-down that gets called humility, but it's not. Asking about successes is a way past that - it's giving them permission to say something good about themselves.

But to be fair, a lot of what I'm after is inflated claims on a resume, which are common as dirt, because people are much more comfortable deceptively bragging on paper than they are in person.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:00PM (#18400858)
That raises a question: how can “good humble teammates” answer these types of questions in a way that makes them look good without lying?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:24PM (#18401508)
Assuming they did good, valuable work, then telling the truth is an excellent way to answer in a way that looks good without lying.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:35PM (#18401632)
But, then, how do you show "leadership" and "ownership" and all those other wonderful things interviewers are supposedly looking for? And it's not just "good, valuable work" they're looking for. Fixing bugs is "good, valuable work," but I get the feeling interviewers don't want to hear about how many bugs you've fixed.

I often have a hard time putting my accomplishments into context (indeed, even seeing them as "accomplishments," because they're simply what I'm supposed to do).

(Incidentally, I hate the word "ownership" in this context. You don't own anything you can't take with you. Try taking work you did for a company with you when you leave.)

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by driverdan on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:16PM (#18394050)
Obviously I can't speak for every company but those types of questions are typically used as a filter.

- Anyone who skips those questions are rejected outright. If you're not willing to put in a little time you're not interested enough to be considered. You'd be surprised how many people skip these questions.

- If you've done something crazy cool or interesting it's a plus but if not it isn't a negative.

- Can you communicate something that's a bit abstract?

- Relevant jokes are usually seen as a plus.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by travisjungroth on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:48PM (#18394303)
Nothing can be a plus but not a negative when people are competing. If two people are going for a job and one of them gets an extra point, that's the same as removing a point from the other person.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by mdpopescu on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:37AM (#18397829)
> ... those types of questions are typically used as a filter.

Yep, same here.

> Anyone who skips those questions are rejected outright.

Any company using these questions is rejected outright. I'm looking for someone who is willing to give me money for code, not a wife.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by C1sc0cat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @07:10AM (#18398598)
That's a one sided view of work and how team dynamics work.

Please don't take this the wrong way but "presenting" in this way at an interview is not helping you.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by mdpopescu on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:26PM (#18401537)
My worldview might be skewed because I am normally looking for short contracts (6 months or less), not long term employment. I get bored with never-ending projects; I prefer projects with a clear finality. Given that, I am highly unlikely to care much about team dynamics - I want to do a (good) job and get paid for it.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rhizome on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:48PM (#18393787)
I think those questions come from both naïvete and a desire to increase information asymmetry in the hiring process.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:58PM (#18394393)
Can you elaborate on the "desire to increase information asymmetry" bit? I mean, I get that the employer always wants to be on the upper hand in that way, but I don't see how questions like this do that.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rhizome on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:28PM (#18395061)
Try and extract that level of detail about the company's internal dynamics, desires, and plans in an interview and see how far you get.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:54PM (#18395215)
Well, I find I answer those types of questions at such a vague level of detail anyway that I don’t think anybody’s getting any real information out of my answers.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rhizome on Friday November 09, 2018 @01:05AM (#18412637)
Eh, they're extracting more than a story from you. In the spirit of this post overall, the question is a great informal trigger for Imposter Syndrome: what you describe, and how you describe it.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by lysium on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:23PM (#18393534)
I used to have the same thoughts until I did interviews myself. I don’t use these questions but I understand how other interviewers use them to get to know people. They won’t find your stuff cool (or maybe they do) or judge your cool stuff. And if they do you are at the wrong place anyways.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rhizome on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:52PM (#18393830)
Is that the old "person bad at small talk judges your small talk skills" interview strategy?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by beat on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:03PM (#18393942)
Bah. I'm brilliant at small talk, which means that when I'm conversing with someone I don't know, either as interviewer or interviewee (or any other situation), I feel it's my conversational duty to make others feel comfortable and entertained, and help them along if they're uncomfortable with small talk. Good conversationalists are great listeners, because they are trying to draw interest and excitement out of other people.

It's different from being a good talker, which can be entertaining, but isn't really two-way.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by __bjoernd on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:00AM (#18397698)
Let's focus on the 'cooolest thing' questions as the others are indeed useless in an interview. The whole point of this question is to see if you are excited about something you did and if this excitement resonates with the interviewer/the company. At this point you're trying to see if you and the job match in any way. If your excitement doesn't match expectations, then eventually you might not end up happy with the job. By all means, don't answer what your think they want to hear, but what you really find cool.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:39AM (#18398997)
Why do people have to be excited? Some people work for a living and only a living. Things they find exciting may get them fired but they're perfectly good employees all the same.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by arandr0x on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @11:01AM (#18399968)
I wouldn't use these questions but they're usually coming from interviewers who are trying to have a sense of you as a person/get you out of your shell. (Except the "Where do you see yourself in 10 years" question. That's used to figure out if you want to be management. I have never given a fully honest answer to this question my whole career, and the right answer usually can be found in the job ad.)

Talk about something that you can sound excited/relatable talking about. Friends, family, volunteer work, that all works.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:01PM (#18393919)
Saw a similar title, back in Seattle 2013 timeframe. Top 1% of ninja dev guru superstar something or other. The days when ninja was titled on EVERYTHING. So cringey. Had to have a masters in CS. I think it was 5 years of experience or something in a big tech firm only. Lots of conflicting programming languages and tech as well. Pay: $35,000 a year.

It's not hard to find relevant examples these days though. Thankfully, ninja is no longer acceptable.

Makes me imagine they literally are not looking for someone. It's got to be a scam of some sort. I heard these types are posts are put up so firms can bank off of some sort of "lack of experience" in their area tax break or something. Rumor, read on internet. I don't know. Never understood it.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by jki275 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:06PM (#18393969)
Sounds like a way to do H1B fraud.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:09PM (#18393996)
That was it!

I think that's what I heard back in the day.

It just sucks that kids these days are judging themselves off these bullshit advertisements. Now they're getting mental issues where they don't have a good self-image in their skill sets.

Jesus...it's like the fashion industry for young girls...

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by geggam on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:02PM (#18394419)
How is that different from the past ?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:54PM (#18394814)
Not sure if I understand your question. Do you mean the mental issues part?

If so, back then we all just thought the HR posting the job was retarded. If I saw something stupid, the person was stupid. It never hurt me.

Nowadays the whole imposter syndrome is becoming a bigger issue. People are becoming more and more inadequate in their own skin. It’s all just getting offended by stuff seen, no matter how small.

I grew up on, “Do they not like you? Fuck them. Move on.”

Just saying that, I feel like a “back in my day” old man. And I’m only 31.

Now kids are taking the most random things to heart. And it’s sad. Really is. And I don’t have a solution for that other than they’re to just ignore the garbage and plow on. Maybe one day I can figure that out. But as it sits, this over artificial world is poisoning from all directions.

You know that movie Interns with the wow actor going to Google. The two older guys had to convince the kids that their lives haven’t even started yet, even though they thought it was going to end if they don’t get into Google? I use to think that movie was silly. But the tech industry is grooming kids to believe this. These ridiculous job interviews. Ridiculous expectations. Tight crunch times and shit hours. All to think they’re making the world a better place. But let’s face it. There’s no difference between big oil and big tech. They’re the same machine spitting out a different product.

Maybe I’m just the last gen that sees it and shows up to meetings drunk.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by geggam on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:19PM (#18395004)
Just wondering why people think that being challenged is a terrible thing. Its almost like being mediocre is good and having some mental problem is better than good performance.

Begs the question.. "What is society rewarding ? "

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:57PM (#18395242)
Maybe it's a coping mechanism for unrealistic expectations?

I'm not saying 100%, but playing with that idea. If you grow up your whole life on stories of teens making millions and you're a loser if you don't. What else is there for you?

I grew up that making bank like that was rare. Super rare. You work for it. Some way, some how. Through connections or through ideas. But it's not "normal". Thus, don't think it is. It does seem on social media and the filth, that being stupid rich is normal and you're a loser if you're not.

I can understand that if you grow up seeing that, a majority of your developing life... yea... I'd probably have a mental breakdown too. What else is there? You think, well, your life is over. It's too late to "become rich" or important.

In some respects, the hipster movement is a slightly interesting counter culture to that problem. Looking back to the old ways. I think they take it too far and are dumb about it sometimes. But, at this moment while writing this, I can respect it. What we have now is not normal. It's easy to deal with if you remember a day when no one had cell phones. You ran around outside doing dumbshit. No one cried if you called them an asshole, they just hit you in the mouth and the day was done. Hell, if I had a kid in school now, I'd be scared that they might call someone a boy or girl and end up on the news because of it. That's an irrational fear on my own right. But, yea, I seem to have it.

I don't know. I don't feel like this is well thought out. It's just a weird thing that I understand that there is an inherent problem with people growing up nowadays and mental illness is a bad result of it. Exactly what, I don't know.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by geggam on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:59PM (#18396009)
The ability of youthful indiscretions being forgotten is a thing of the past. I think that contributes to this issue.

Imagine the entire Internet landing on you instead of just your classmates ?

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ergothus on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:56PM (#18395638)
There's a definite line between "being challenged" and "You suck".

As far as I can tell, society is rewarding burning people out. The tech industry is actually MUCH better than most other industries. Check out assistant managers in most any franchise. We had an article on here(?) yesterday(?) about how everything in sales was "hustle" - even when it didn't need to be. Example after example. It's not new, but that doesn't mean it's not getting worse, and it doesn't mean we can't push back.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:49PM (#18395948)
Yea, I read that article. That and the suffering fetish or whatever it's also called. It's all whack.

It's funny how being an entrepreneur use to mean freedom from being a cog in a machine. Now it's turned into just being all the cogs in a machine. You ditch one slavery for another.

Who's the guy who talks about a 4 hour work week? I mean, it seemed silly at first. But to be honest, I think he was the closest to getting it all correct.

Work as efficient as possible so you don't have to work too much. Enjoy your life outside of work.

Sounds like a goddamn madman lol. Enjoy life. Only work as much as you need to. Crazy person.

There's a great podcast with Jocko, of him being candid about his own life and burn out/suicide attempt due to his Phd. What essentially started the whole 4-hour thingy.

Tim Ferriss, that guy. Here's a link to that podcast. Worth a listen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsxydhFqXug

But as a caveat, there's nothing wrong with busting ass when you need to. There was a project I got contracted for on doing a surveillance trailer from scratch. I barely slept for 2 weeks getting parts, learning/welding, wiring and configuring a mobile surveillance system for stadiums. Got paid for the prototype and vacationed for a month, because I could. That last part is the important part. Nothing wrong with hustling or running your self into the ground, sometimes. Just not ALL the time.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by mdpopescu on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:44AM (#18397861)
Being mediocre is GREAT. I love being average. I'm a much better programmer than the plumber, but a much worse programmer than Skeet or Hejlsberg - and I'm very much fine with that. (On the other hand, I would argue that I could hold my own against DHH so who knows.)
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by dabockster on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:49PM (#18395182)
There's other ways to challenge oneself that doesn't involve the workplace or their day job.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:00PM (#18395266)
You know what's funny, I don't think hobbies are an acceptable thing anymore. Seems like "hobbies" are demonized if they're not "productive".

I even have to combat the random feelings that "I should be working" instead of just taking time off for me.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by dabockster on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:07PM (#18396066)
> I don't think hobbies are an acceptable thing anymore.

That's just corporate America spewing their usual trash talk. Most people you'd meet on the street are totally fine with people having non-productive hobbies. Just as long as you're still able to make a 9-5 job, though.

EDIT: What I'm trying to say is that people care that you have a day job. After that, any decent human being wouldn't care what you do with your free time. That's yours and yours alone.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by corodra on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:28PM (#18396185)
Oh, no no no. I totally agree with you.

My point was it's demonized and there's like a stigma to it. Like masturbating. I just always feel like whenever I talk to random new people about wood working, it's almost like I'm talking about masturbating to them with they way they act about it. Since it's not money producing. It's not like I give a shit. I had a supremely bad burn out years ago and different hobbies have kept me from ever going back to that burn out mental state.

I think hobbies are a highly underrated form of keeping good, solid mental health.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by geggam on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:05PM (#18395304)
That is completely American and has been for a few generations.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by geggam on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:51PM (#18395196)
Fair point. Will be interesting to watch the next couple generations.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by RugnirViking on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:42PM (#18394736)
Depends on how far you go back - it wasn't that long ago in the grand scheme of things that in most places/industries there was no reliable way to get information about job listings - your best bet was to go to a recruiter or go directly to the front desk and ask about vacancies
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by C1sc0cat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @07:21AM (#18398639)
Or in the UK you read Computer Weekly and Computing (90% Job adds) and probably the Telegraph on a Thursday when the published the engineering jobs.

I got my first tech job out of the local news paper btw

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by eseehausen on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:52PM (#18393256)
Based on my experience, people who can acknowledge their issues and accurately compensate for them are more valuable than most of the people who think they're the top 1-3%. Obviously you have people who think they are, and it's actually accurate, but I assume they're doing just fine with their half-mill+ salaries at FANG. The rest of the world needs programmers, too, and a little bit of humility and willingness to keep improving goes a long way.

Maybe just keep that and learn to be a little more obnoxious in the self-assessments you give to others?

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by CodeCube on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:07PM (#18393378)
Like I always tell my kids, "Let other people tell you that you're awesome, just don't say it first" ;)
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by moomin on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:34PM (#18394209)
Those kind of adverts self-select for people with incorrect estimations of their own ability. Don’t be shocked when the environment turns out to be a cess-pit with no psychological safety.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by nradov on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:05PM (#18393357)
Obviously those numbers are silly because it's impossible to precisely quantify the relative ratings of knowledge workers. But generally that percentage is very much context dependant. Someone who was top 10% at one role in one organization could easily be bottom 10% in a different role at a different organization.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by thwy12321 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:50PM (#18393233)
The trick is these companies arent hiring top 1% talent, they're hiring top 1% interviewing talent.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by EddieRingle on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:54PM (#18393270)
The appropriate response is to ask for a top-1% salary, of course.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cynicalkane on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:56PM (#18393284)
Nowdays a senior role at FAANG will often pay a top 1% salary, and salary growth at these companies shows no signs of stopping.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by vonmoltke on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:39PM (#18394715)
How senior? Obviously not at the seniority I was just offered by Google (and rejected).
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by wil421 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:53PM (#18393267)
Do the 1% apply to jobs with such descriptions? I’m not in the 1% in my domain and I wouldn’t touch a job with those words or phrases in the description.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:25PM (#18393553)
I would imagine the real top 1% (if there were a good way to quantify that) never “apply” anywhere.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:00PM (#18393913)
Yeah, I can't image someone like John Carmack having to apply anywhere.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by konschubert on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:06PM (#18393363)
Exactly. The bottom 10% of engineering talent probably fill the bottom 90% of interviewing talent.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:50PM (#18393812)
> "Top 3% only!" or "Only top 1% Ninja Rockstars need apply!"

Do people apply to these places? I don't. Ever. Not that I feel bad about myself, but I don't ever ever want to work for a manager who approves this type of job ad.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by commandlinefan on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:12PM (#18394018)
I worked at one. I didn't apply - I was recruited by the owner (he knew me from a past job), so I didn't go through the interview process, he just asked me if I'd come work for him, quoted a number, and I said, "yeah, sure". It was a struggling startup, but it was making (some) money, and had (some) potential. But man, when I started interviewing people - he'd tell me, "we only take the best of the best", it was a struggle for me not to point out that the best of the best - or even the worst of the best - or even the best of the worst - had much, much better options than a struggling, no-name startup with no outside capital that was renting office space from an office hotel (and cramming people five to a room). I would go through rounds and rounds of interviewing people, determining that they were perfectly acceptable and would fit in well in the environment we had and could get the job done and help us move forward, and he'd reject them because they were "average". I was like, "so are you, you self-important idiot!"
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by dabockster on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:50PM (#18395192)
> office hotel

Is that what we're calling co-working spaces these days? I can get on board with that.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by dagw on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:28AM (#18397794)
Is that what we're calling co-working spaces these days?

It's at least what we where calling them in most of Europe long before the term "co-working space" was invented.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rothron on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @02:56PM (#18394379)
Wouldn't an ad like that attract the biggest egos, not necessarily the best coders, nor people you would ever want to be on a team with?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by fullshark on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:35PM (#18394693)
It would attract young coders who you can convince to work long hours for less pay.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ravenstine on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:50PM (#18395957)
The other day I ran across "programming athlete".
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:11PM (#18396656)
You mean someone who does stuff like TopCoder competitively?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by tathougies on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:30PM (#18402574)
Who has taught people today to lack confidence? I found my first software job out of high school by simply lying about my experience. I believed I was capable of doing the job advertised, so I said that I had ten years of experience (the requirement). I was called back, interviewed, and hired.

What is the big deal here? If you believe you can do it, then who cares what the job description says; just apply. If you don't believe you can do it, apply anyway. There is literally no drawback to applying for a job and there is little draw back to lying about it. When I was finally offered the job, I told the HR person that I had lied on my resume, and he said that he admired by chutzpah.

No one is going to fire you for coming clean after being given a promise of employment. And, if they do decide not to offer the job to you, you still haven't lost anything.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by bytematic on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @12:55PM (#18393273)
Kids at the top schools feel the same symptoms too. It's an eery environment out there
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ericmcer on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:10PM (#18396851)
I feel like a fairly average programmer. I have a few coworkers who are a little better, but when the CEO is talking about the engineering team it is always "world class" and an "amazingly talented team of engineers". I think the "genius programmer" stuff is just part of the tech industry.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by dev_north_east on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:42AM (#18399004)
There's a recruiter on LinkedIn I saw has taken to put the following into every job post "Only looking for the best of the best. No time wasters please." Reminds me of a dating site.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by C1sc0cat on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:51AM (#18398545)
Where do you see those sort of job postings I haven't seen many of those sort of adds - a tiny hand full less that 5 that I remember.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by fhbdukfrh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:08PM (#18394470)
Once you have your first job, the top 80% are rarely ever again actively looking unless they have some sort of extenuating circumstances, so the reality is they're only going to hire the to 1% of the bottom 20%

The top 5, 10, 20 out even 50% rarely hit the open market, inbound recruitment process. They get poached or go where former coworkers are

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by vonmoltke on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:37PM (#18394706)
Am I really that much of an aberration in this industry? I definitely consider myself in the top 50%, and I'm probably in the top 20%. In 16 years I am only on my fourth company, have only been "poached" once (and I was trying to get poached), and can count on two hands the number of former coworkers who are not either retired or still at the companies I left them at.

Of course, I spent the first 14 of those years in Dallas and the first 9.5 of those at a poor choice of company. I spent years having applications ignored. I sometimes wonder if thinking like this had something to do with that.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by erikb on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:08PM (#18393383)
You must really suffer from imposter syndrome if you can't find a company that is worse than you at software development.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by duxup on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:12PM (#18393423)
Just because they're bad (or worse) at it and you're better doesn't mean they'll hire you. That probabbly is why they're bad (or worse) at it.