News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by saulrh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:08PM (#18393391)
Notice that, when they say they only hire the top 1%, there's a vicious sampling bias at work: even in a worst case where they're being literal they're actually hiring the top 1% of their applicants, not the top 1% of engineers. Think about how many jobs you usually apply for before getting one. Now imagine someone that's less successful than you at getting hired and think about how many times they're interviewing. Now think about the population that the interviewer sees. Now add college students that are just practicing and people that are required to interview for every job on the board to maintain unemployment. Now think about how much time interviewing you spend for every day working and how that might change as a function of quality - staying longer at better places, maybe?

I obviously don't have any statistics, but I think I could imagine a situation where the top 95% of software people constitute the top 1% of the interviewing population. Also one where interviewers are terrible at math, but that's no surprise. Anyway, you're fine, just go for it. That fact that you are self-aware enough to worry about it puts you in good standing all by itself.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by Spooky23 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:29PM (#18394658)
I've observed that in pursuing the 1% unicorn candidate, many people step in unicorn shit and hire smart people who are bad employees.

My goal is to not hire the bottom 50% of the workforce in a given discipline. IMO, you're better off building teams that make the average+ person more productive.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by fizx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @11:35PM (#18397106)
>I've observed that in pursuing the 1% unicorn candidate, many people step in unicorn shit and hire smart people who are bad employees.

What's fun is that this isn't just a possibility, its likely! Despite the following being a clearly artificial argument, the general shape of it is true.

Let's say that you can rate employees 1-10 on each of technical skill and employability/soft-skills, and that both are equally sought by the market. Given how attractive your company is to work for and what you pay, its quite often true that you can allocate around 12 total points between the two categories. 13 point candidates have better offers from Google; 11 point candidates fail your interview process.

If you only hire people that strongly pass a strong technical interview, ensuring that their technical skill is at least an 8/10, then your employees will have at most 4/10 soft skills.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by slededit on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:56AM (#18397366)
Microsoft in the 90s figured out how to work around that. Just silo them and have their manager do the external interfacing for them. This was assuming they really were at least an 8/10 which was required to make the whole thing worthwhile.

That of course works much better when everyone has their own office so the angry outbursts are only heard by the 2-3 closest neighbors.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by benibela on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:51AM (#18398547)
Or everyone works remotely, so no one hears their outbursts
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by carlmr on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:06AM (#18397718)
>If you only hire people that strongly pass a strong technical interview, ensuring that their technical skill is at least an 8/10, then your employees will have at most 4/10 soft skills.

Why most companies find it hard to find good sales engineers.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cheez on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:20PM (#18396686)
Yes! I love to build teams with average people that create above average results due to their configuration. It's my secret sauce.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by Double_a_92 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:28AM (#18398034)
Reminds me of that baseball movie where a manager hired low-value players, that very extremely good at only something.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by chupasaurus on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:22AM (#18398232)
"Moneyball" is the name of both the movie and the book it was based on.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by nestorD on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @01:35PM (#18393650)
There is a great article on the fact that everybody hires only the top 1% : https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2005/01/27/news-58/
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by spectre256 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:33PM (#18395520)
The fact that people still parrot the top 1% idea after it was pretty thoroughly debunked by Joel almost 15 years ago is...interesting.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by mmirate on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:44PM (#18396252)
When you discover that an intuitive result is wrong, the production of a thorough debunking is but a tiny sliver of the total work needed to change the world's minds away from that wrong result.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by jobigoud on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:45AM (#18398097)
We are still making many of the mistakes laid out in The Mythical Man-Month so…
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by ethagnawl on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:36PM (#18395096)
> people that are required to interview for every job on the board to maintain unemployment.

I'm pretty sure you're being hyperbolic, but that sounds hellish. I have GAD and dread interviewing so much that I'd forego unemployment and just work as a Task Rabbit or something.

To preempt the inevitable responses: Yes, I do have a family to support and, yes, I have worked as a Task Rabbit or done manual labor when faced with similar situations in the past.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cirgue on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:06PM (#18394457)
We hire the top 5% of applicants. This says a lot about our applicant pool. It says very little about our team. No one here is from a top program. Many don't even have CS degrees.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:25AM (#18398927)
No you don't. I know you don't because you have no idea who the top 5% of applicants are. Not after interviews, not after 6 months on the job, not even 10 years in the job. You can't distill something as complex as humans working in teams that form a part of a larger organisation into a single number like that. That's not how the world works. For example Bob was doing great work but then his wife cheated on him and he is doing less great work. Is Bob in the top 5% or not?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by cirgue on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @02:48PM (#18401780)
You're completely right of course, we hire people who we believe are the top 5% of the applicant pool. The point remains the same: what a company says about their hiring standards has little or no bearing on what their standards actually are in the context of the entire universe of software engineers (or any other field)
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @10:44PM (#18404198)
I'm still not quite sure what you think the 5% measures?
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by kamaal on Thursday November 08, 2018 @02:10AM (#18404792)
This discussion came up in even during that Netflix thread.

These companies aren't looking for top 1% people. They are looking for top 1% people who are in form currently.

The day you get unlucky and slip out of form, they don't want you.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by rorykoehler on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:27AM (#18405257)
Which means they will miss the real top performers. The savants who are capable of flashes of brilliance that can make whole new industries. These people will most definitely fall outside any measure / quantifiable scale that any company uses for comfort.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by kamaal on Thursday November 08, 2018 @08:17AM (#18406022)
They apparently want people are having flashes of brilliance at this moment. They don't want them on their payroll once the flash dies. Then they want the next set of savants in form.

Its basically the equivalent reducing the great people to Kleenex. Once used, they want to throw them. Then buy the next Kleenex box.

Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:12PM (#18394943)
How do you measure this? I would wager that, at best, you're hiring the top 5% of applicants based on interview performance. It's likely you know little or nothing about what that says vis a vis job performance, because your interview probably doesn't exercise skills used on the job, except in a very tangential way.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by eberkund on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @12:41AM (#18397308)
I think he just means that they hire 5% of applicants, by definition they are the top 5% because they are the ones they chose to hire. Unless of course they have a significant number of people going through the entire interview process only to decline the offer.
Re:Impostor syndrome strikes men just as hard as women in te... by pmiller2 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:39PM (#18401130)
That's pretty close to the point I was making. They call it the top 5% because 5% of people pass their interview. The company doesn't have any idea whether those people (out of the entire pool) are the best candidates to do the job they were hired to do, because the company probably doesn't measure that. And, they sure don't know that their "top 5%" is representative of the top 5% of all engineers. For starters, how do you measure that?