News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Yuioup on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:37PM (#18378682)
My prediction for 2019: Microsoft announces Microsoft Linux, with many Microsoft store apps working via a compatibility layer. Office for Linux coming early 2021.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by adrr on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:07PM (#18378797)
Why would they do that? Linux desktop has no penetration into the market. It would be a big investment to capture an additional 1% market share.

I can see MS porting all their server apps(MSSQL, Exchange, etc) to run on linux since Linux is dominating the server market and it would be a significant opportunity for them.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jimnotgym on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:33PM (#18378915)
IMHO thing an MS Linux could really add for SME IT teams is.

1) An easy way to join a Windows domain. Being able to use AD user auth and Windows file sharing with AD groups that is as easy as it is on Windows server would remove a major scare factor for Windows admins trying Linux. I hope this could be implemented by contributing to SAMBA and being a wrapper for SAMBA rather than a reimplementation. I have had frustrating times with Linux unmounting Windows shares and having to reboot to get them to remount.

2) Training. MS have a well trodden path for learning to be an MS admin. Bringing it to Linux would surely help more people test-the-waters.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by noinsight on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:56PM (#18379008)
> 1) An easy way to join a Windows domain.

Red Hat's sssd already makes this trivial. You can join a Windows domain from the Fedora "first run wizard" or via a simple "realm join xyz.tld" command. It works pretty well mostly. You get AD integrated logins and SSH/sudo access and can use AD groups for access control just like normal groups. Kerberos SSO to Linux boxes works fine etc.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by slededit on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:38PM (#18385226)
AD is all about group policy, logins are merely table stakes. If you want to distribute firewall rules to every machine in your arg AD is the way to go. Ditto for forcing updates (or preventing them), and any other manner of mass configuration. Then there is also centralized logging and auditing.

Linux has most of this in an ad-hoc fashion, but the key benefit comes from the centralization.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by pnutjam on Monday November 05, 2018 @03:13PM (#18385513)
SSSD makes joining AD easy for any linux. Suse has integrated it into Yast and it's super easy. There are also tons of linux training initiatives. The simple fact is alot of Windows admins are incurious or set in their ways. It's true for Linux as well, but not as true.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by btgeekboy on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:14PM (#18378836)
SQL Server's already been ported and made available.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by dc_gregory on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:26PM (#18378882)
It works quite well too. As I understand it, SQLServer itself is effectively running on top of its own "OS" like layer (even on windows), so porting cleanly was made significantly easier.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by mythrwy on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:35PM (#18379443)
Seconded. SQL server does work quite well on Linux and was surprisingly easy to get going. I prefer Postgres but sometimes we don't always get what what we want and hey, I'll take it cause I can use it on Linux!

As for MS Windows, WTF? Not only the forced ads making it seem like in some kind of casino built for 4 year olds (assume it's some kind of play to suck the kiddies in?), it's an abortion of mismatched UI, half of it trying to look like a cheaply built web app, then on next screen dumping you back into some NT style select panel. It's just awful. To say nothing of invasive updates and general Windows unpleasantness. I can say without reservation I have no use for the OS at all, Linux is just so much more pleasant to use at this point.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by 72deluxe on Monday November 05, 2018 @10:53AM (#18383254)
Thankfully you can still run Windows+R > control

Or "control [shortcut]" eg control fonts

Or can still use MMC, or blablabla.msc, eg. devmgmt.msc

and hardly have to interact with the snow-blindness Settings app.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by statictype on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:29PM (#18379415)
How is it performance wise?

Is there any advantage to running it on Linux (except maybe the cost of a Windows license which is probably trivial compared to the cost of Sql Server itself)

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by cptskippy on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:04PM (#18379575)
I haven't seen benchmarks but I would guess that there isn't going to be much of a performance difference. It's like comparing the performance of your VM on different hypervisors, unless something is very wrong you won't see much difference.

As the OP indicated, MS SQL has it's own facilities for managing memory and disk I/O. It basically asks for all the resources from the OS and then does everything itself internally. I'm exaggerating obviously but it does try to avoid costly calls to the OS whenever and however possible which is why it was so easily ported to Linux.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by din-9 on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:42AM (#18380351)
The Docker images are smaller for Linux for one. Our team use the Linux version in tests during builds just for that. We are relying that Microsoft manage to keep the two versions close enough that it's meaningful.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Ari_Ugwu on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:38PM (#18378935)
This is my guess and the one I'm excited about:

Azure is a cash cow. Windows brings in money but is increasingly difficult to monetize _and_ its increasingly difficult to keep bringing legacy app support forward and stay competitive.

PowerShell, .NET Core, and MS SQL are all happily running on Linux.

By all accounts WSL entered the market with little drama is pretty great to use (IMHO).

The idea of doing a native SSH from WSL into a Linux container on Azure running a bootstraped 'MS' version of *nix with official support for a discounted price compared to a Windows VM is certainly appealing.

I would run MS Linux as a dev environment in a heart beat. MS would do well to _not_ to brand a desktop and just run a very clean gnome or plasma default.

Then a dedicated app store can really push PWAs like Teams,Skype and fully manage the interop layer for other apps that need a little more hand holding (wine, mono, etc).

tl;dr - I'm into this.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by gmueckl on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:46PM (#18379493)
Given the tight cooperation between Canonical and MS for WSL I would somehow expect that MS would use Ubuntu if they were to ever sanction a desktop Linux. This is just my guess, though.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by testrun on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:09PM (#18379598)
Following that thought:

If Microsoft buys Canonical it will be very interesting. Seeing that IBM bought Red Hat,

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by steve19 on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:46AM (#18380125)
This. It's the first thing that came to mind when the redhat deal was announced. Oracle has Sun, IBM has RedHat, it would seem logical for MSFT
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by cookiecaper on Sunday November 04, 2018 @11:09PM (#18379810)
Windows is more or less over and MS has been gradually coming to terms with it, helped along by inflection points that made it painstakingly clear that the Windows way was beyond outmoded, like containers and cloud. I don't think MS is even pretending otherwise anymore.

I wouldn't be surprised at all to see MS give up on WSL, acquire CodeWeavers, and reimplement "Windows" as a proprietary desktop environment for a nix-ish OS with a super-souped-up WINE doing much of the legwork. At this point such a contraption would be less painful than some of Apple's recent transitions (e.g. from PPC to x86).

Selling software, as a general business model, is on the ropes and this is a great indication of that. The victory of open-source here is both blatant and decisive.

Had it not been for every major software company deciding they can subsist on a combination of a) rental fees and b) advertising/demographic data, we'd probably have another RIAA v. The Internet-style showdown to confront over the next decade. In this respect, I suppose we should be grateful for the opportunity to pay 6x more to be in "the cloud".

As an observer, it's a weird situation to see, and still trying to orient my feelings and understand what to make of it.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by din-9 on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:54AM (#18380405)
I would be very surprised to see them take that reimplementation path as their backwards compatibility has been so important for decades (yes I know not everything runs still; but a large amount does). They have provided an evolutionary path and that would be revolution. The benefit to them seems likely to be outweighed by the disruption. And they know points of disruption are where they are more likely to lose customers.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by M_Bakhtiari on Monday November 05, 2018 @07:52AM (#18381885)
> At this point such a contraption would be less painful than some of Apple's recent transitions (e.g. from PPC to x86).

I find that hard to believe. Apple only had to build emulators for their ISA changes, just translating instruction set into another. Doesn't sound painful at all. WINE on the other hand has good reasons for pointing out that it's not an emulator.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by cookiecaper on Monday November 05, 2018 @07:09PM (#18387172)
WINE runs most applications extremely well. With actual backing from a MegaCo, especially the MegaCo that owns all of the IP around Windows, I have no doubt that a year of work would round out the rough edges such that compatibility differences don't exceed what would be expected between major versions of Microsoft Windows.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by tgtweak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:02PM (#18461605)
Get a working version of .net 4.6 working in wine with text that actually renders like it does on Windows and I'll admit wine is a viable alterative.

It is getting an appropriate amount of love though in the last year. I'm really hopeful that it will keep getting better.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by _emacsomancer_ on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:52PM (#18378995)
I'm not enthusiastic about this possible future, but here's why:

it means they could eventually just adopt Linux as the platform for Microsoft applications. That would do away with a lot of historical reliability issues, and would mean that they would have less to support internally. They're making more and more money on things like Azure and Office365 etc, and none of that really depends on Windows.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by suby on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:37AM (#18380106)
> They're making more and more money on things like Azure and Office365 etc, and none of that really depends on Windows.

I just did some googling, and it looks like Azure actually runs on Windows. It started out as a fork and then eventually merged back with server 2016.

The source for this is unfortunately a video, but here it is.

https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/resources/videos/mark-russ...

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by _emacsomancer_ on Monday November 05, 2018 @10:58AM (#18383303)
Azure can run on Windows, sure. But the majority of instances are running on Linux: https://www.zdnet.com/article/linux-now-dominates-azure/
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by suby on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:26PM (#18384072)
Poor wording on my part. I wasn't referring to the OS's running on top of the VM, but rather the infrastructure that's running the VM's.

https://www.quora.com/What-technology-is-Azure-running-on-Is...

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by _emacsomancer_ on Monday November 05, 2018 @09:48PM (#18387926)
Right, but that doesn't necessarily require all of the desktop parts of Windows. I see your point though.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by whoopdedo on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:20PM (#18378858)
Who said anything about desktop? Microsoft needs something for phones and tables and they don't want to pin their cart to Google's Android horse.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by imglorp on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:50PM (#18378984)
What, another mobile thrust? They gave up on that completely. All-in on cloud, unless something has changed?
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by adventured on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:29PM (#18379669)
I don't think anything has changed and it definitely wouldn't make sense now. There is zero growth in mobile phones, in the US and globally overall. That isn't going to get better, it's already a stagnate, saturated market. Now would be about the worst time for Microsoft to decide to re-target that market.

Azure can be a ~$30 billion sales business eventually, probably spitting off $6b or $7b in operating income. It's a dramatically better business than messing with smartphones again (other than building apps for Android & iOS). They should just keep focused on their booming cloud business.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by module0000 on Monday November 05, 2018 @09:52AM (#18382671)
I don't think any of this is likely, even remotely.... but if it was, they wouldn't be motivated by adding that 1% to their user base. The motivation would be to deprive the competition of that 1% user-base: weaker competition.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by MR4D on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:11PM (#18379611)
No need. Ms office is being ported to the browser. Once that’s done and it runs on chromium or Firefox, then all they have to do is test /fix it on the Linux versions of those browsers.

I played with it this summer and some of it actually works!

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by techntoke on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:34AM (#18380091)
This sounds absolutely awful. Electron is much slower and running Excel queries in JavaScript sounds like a terrible experience.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by fooker on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:53AM (#18380399)
Electron is, Wasm isn't. You won't be running it in javascript, it will be compiled just like desktop Excel.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by FridgeSeal on Monday November 05, 2018 @03:32AM (#18380757)
Wasm is a improvement on JS for sure, but proper native compiled still thoroughly beats it.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by M_Bakhtiari on Monday November 05, 2018 @07:55AM (#18381900)
Why wouldn't WASM implementations do native compilation? It's the norm for most modern language implementations nowadays, anything else would be silly.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by FridgeSeal on Monday November 05, 2018 @04:15PM (#18386040)
Many languages that compile to native are rolling out WASM support, or have it in their roadmaps, but there are many more architectures and formats that you have to handle in native land.

I guess theoretically, if we agreed to support the main desktop and mobile/tablet OS’s and chip architectures, and then got everyone to use a standard compiler and IL format (LLVM maybe?) then you might get some of the way, but that would be a lot of work (cool if it happened though...)

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by beatgammit on Monday November 05, 2018 @08:49PM (#18387697)
The IL format is WASM, it's already here. When the browser gets WASM, it's free to interpret it or compile it to native code. AFAIK, it is already getting compiled to native, and I'm sure we'll see some awesome JITs coming to WASM.

The problem right now with warm WASM is lack of features (e.g. you can't do threading), though those are getting sorted.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by M_Bakhtiari on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:07AM (#18389432)
Targeting multiple architectures is a solved problem, as you said with LLVM. I don't know if that's how WASM is currently implemented, as a LLVM front-end, but I'm pretty sure most implementations in fact are proper native compiled, or they intend to be. As I said it would be silly to do it any other way.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by TheRealDunkirk on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:41PM (#18384218)
So how big is the download the first time, and how big will the (weekly) updates be?
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by slededit on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:40PM (#18385252)
MS Office was ported to the browser 10 years ago. You can go use web Excel right now, and could have since forever.

A WASM version of the local apps would be interesting though.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by chiph on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:52PM (#18378747)
I wonder if they still hold the rights to the Xenix name? Looks like no - the product was sold to SCO in 1987.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenix

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Alex3917 on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:57PM (#18379547)
Having used OS X for the last 15 years, a good Microsoft Linux is probably the only thing that could conceivably get me to switch to either Microsoft or Linux. I don't think it will happen, but it's a good idea.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by satysin on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:00PM (#18379020)
I don’t see Microsoft releasing a desktop Linux but I can see them releasing a Microsoft Azure Linux distro.

Linux is already massive on Azure so it makes a lot of sense from a support POV. Whether they go with their own version or just buy a distributor (Ubuntu for example) is an interesting question though.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by exikyut on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:18PM (#18379092)
Eep, MS buying Canonical. With GitHub, I can't even sweepingly dismiss the idea.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by gmueckl on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:54PM (#18379535)
MS buying Canonical would be an epic irony given how Mark Shuttleworth promoted Ubuntu at the beginning and how he wrote Bug #1 ( https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/1 ).
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by sebazzz on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:58AM (#18380181)
That bug only affects 2450 people. That's ironic.

Still, I don't think Microsoft would have a Linux distribution itself, for consumers, the cloud and related services is the current focus for Microsoft.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by bpye on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:20PM (#18379389)
At least they can kill Launchpad then right? I can't be the only person that hates it.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by SwellJoe on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:19PM (#18379100)
That doesn't make any business sense for Microsoft. They might do a server fork of RHEL for their cloud offerings (as Amazon has done, very poorly, for AWS), but desktop? That'd be nuts. It would just lend an air of respectability to an OS that still has no traction on the desktop.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by snacktaster on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:48PM (#18378732)
I actually thought for the longest time that they would eventually acquire red hat. But now I'm thinking it will be canonical
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jimnotgym on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:06PM (#18378790)
I can imagine MS wanting control of a Linux server edition for Azure, and Canonical looks like a good target. Not least as canonical seem to have been preparing for a sale. I suppose the real question is how they will treat desktop Linux. I can imagine they would be interested in it as a development environment for their Azure Linux, but less interested in supporting it as a competitor to Windows.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jefurii on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:18PM (#18378849)
One step closer to Debian...
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jrs95 on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:58PM (#18378762)
Now that IBM bought Red Hat I think that would actually be good for Linux.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jrs95 on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:00PM (#18378770)
Why would they have any interest in Linux on the desktop? I could see them having their own distro, but I feel like that would have to be geared towards servers.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by signal11 on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:38PM (#18378936)
> Why would they have any interest in Linux on the desktop?

Short answer: Chrome OS (also Android).

Chrome OS is a Linux distribution being aggressively promoted by a large, well-funded competitor. It can already run Android apps (in release versions) and Linux applications (in beta). Ironically Visual Studio Code runs really well on Chrome OS, as do the Android versions of Word, Excel and Powerpoint -- full screen like a proper laptop application[1]

Microsoft's applications already run on Linux; it's really up to Microsoft to decide whose Linux distributions they get to run on.

[1] https://imgur.com/a/rp0VFR4

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jrs95 on Monday November 05, 2018 @05:06PM (#18386403)
It would probably make more sense for them to support Android/Linux applications on Windows rather than trying to make Windows applications work on Linux. Especially since they're continuing to work on slimming down Windows and getting to run efficiently on ARM, I don't see why they would invest any resources into Linux on the desktop.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:41PM (#18379188)
Considering how good a job Microsoft has done of fragmenting the UI, breaking things with frequent updates, and generally turning Windows 10 into a Goldberg-esque nightmare, it looks like they're already practicing running their own Linux Desktop Distro.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by sjwright on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:21PM (#18378859)
If their prediction is that if Linux starts getting a share of locked-down corporate desktops (think insurance companies, warehouses, big retail, etc) it would make sense to be playing in that field, given that it's a familiar name for people transitioning from tired old Windows XP Embedded or similar.

It would be very clever for Microsoft to start offering Office 365 for Linux but only support it on their own distro. And it's understandable; getting that bucket of ugly bolts to work on Linux would be an epic hack job and probably would never be particularly stable on random distros.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by phire on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:05PM (#18378786)
Microsoft have shown a tendency in the past to unifying their server, workstation, desktop and even phone operating systems.

I don't know if they will keep that tendency (plus, it's more likely to lead to them sticking with Windows on servers)

However, if they do move towards Linux on servers they will naturally explore Linux for workstations too.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by boogiewoogie on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:16PM (#18378846)
Can't believe I'm saying this but I think MS could own Apple if they took on Apple in any programming realm outside of objective c/Swift if they embraced Linux desktop.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by jrs95 on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:31PM (#18378902)
Unified frontend development with .NET is their big opportunity for this IMO. Something like Xamarin Forms but a lot more optimized like Flutter and supporting mobile, desktop, and browsers would be incredible. Right now .NET seems pretty unpopular but a really strong front end use case could reverse that.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by est on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:26PM (#18379656)
2018: IBM bought Redhat

2019: Microsoft bought Ubuntu

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Zhenya on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:35PM (#18379692)
Embrace Extend Extinguish
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by pknopf on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:00AM (#18380418)
Really though, how would you extinguish Ubuntu? GPL?

It doesn't seem possible.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by simias on Monday November 05, 2018 @08:05AM (#18381979)
I don't see why MS would want to do that but it's perfectly possible to "extinguish" GPL projects, especially something as massive as an OS.

You buy Ubuntu, put a lot of money into it, slowly force more and more of your MS software on people, make more and more third party software depend on it and eventually the effort needed to fork away and maintain "clean" version is simply too huge to be worth it.

But of course in this case there are many other Linux distributions out there already so it shouldn't be a huge cause for concern.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by unstuckdev on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:23PM (#18385105)
This is what happened with Android. Google bought it, released it, and made a big deal out of how it was open. Then they slowly moved functionality over to their proprietary systems under the guise of ensuring people could get some security updates on phones the OEMs stopped supporting.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by carlmr on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:32AM (#18380537)
Instead of taking away, which you can't do with GPL you can always push things that cause problems. You could make Ubuntu terrible enough that people stop using it.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by rakoo on Monday November 05, 2018 @03:43AM (#18380800)
Or just stop developing it. A massive effort would be needed to mount another organization to continue development back again.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by SmellyGeekBoy on Monday November 05, 2018 @04:31AM (#18380994)
And? There are plenty of other great distros out there. People can switch pretty painlessly. And I say that as a Ubuntu user.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by carlmr on Monday November 05, 2018 @06:41AM (#18381537)
I was just giving an example how you could destroy something if you were so inclined.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Lio on Monday November 05, 2018 @08:26AM (#18382121)
That seems unlikely to me but if I was playing fantasy CEO, I could imagine it going more like Windows grows better Linux compatibility to the point where they can push for Windows to be the primary development platform for Linux server software.

Next stage after that would be to launch Azure Windows VMs that are competitive with a "real" Linux OS for running Linux binaries but with access to Microsoft GUI management tools.

Once you depend on the GUI tools you depend on Microsoft as OS provider.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by oropolo on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:03PM (#18383885)
How would that be different from Azure App Service for Linux, a Platform-as-a-Service offering that runs apps that require Linux instead of Windows?
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by 72deluxe on Monday November 05, 2018 @10:58AM (#18383311)
A lot of the comments in this section appear completely uneducated about the Windows architecture eg COM/RPC and seem to think that it's just some high-level recompile to get it to run on another platform. It is unrealistic.

Eg their compatability layer for their own apps Metro > Win32 is quite thin.

Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by petecox on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:15PM (#18378843)
A few weeks ago MS suspended development of Office for UWP, so unlikely.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by iMerNibor on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:37PM (#18379176)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18097569 discussion for that, in case anyone else was curious
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by wwice on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:17PM (#18379377)
Maybe MS Android? That will make more sense.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by oropolo on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:12PM (#18383953)
MS version of Fuchsia is far more likely.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by xarope on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:43PM (#18378708)
MS lDOS: the New linux distro for 2019?
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Rychard on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:16PM (#18379628)
Microsoft OS^2 (Open Source Operating System)
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by krylon on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:42AM (#18380578)
That would actually be a really awesome name!!!
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by fergie on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:34AM (#18380092)
Its definitely coming, and its strange that so many people dont see it.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by Immortalin on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:36PM (#18379168)
I will bet that MSFT is going to embrace and extinguish Red Hat's position in the corporate Linux market.
Re:Microsoft Releases a Linux Version of the ProcDump Sysint... by cies on Monday November 05, 2018 @08:05AM (#18381980)
MS vs IBM once again :)