News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:31AM (#18292711)
> But people put an always on spy device connected to Amazon (or Google, or Facebook [honest, we won't spy on you, maybe]) into their homes.

Do you not walk around with one in your pocket most of the time? (I don't have one of these devices either, just playing devil's advocate)

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by sonnyblarney on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:38AM (#18292764)
Your iPhone is not listening to you right now, but your Echo is. That's a big difference.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mikestew on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:27AM (#18293227)
My iPhone most certainly is listening right now. "Hey Siri, turn on the living rooms lights", and look Ma, no hands. I've got these things littering the house between a couple iPads, iPhones, watches, and two HomePods, all of which are happy to do my bidding simply by speaking to them.

Perhaps I have misunderstood you, but I fail to see the difference between my phone and an Echo. Now the difference to me is that Apple claims (claims that appear to be backed by evidence) that they won't sell me out. But as far as listening, I believe they function in similar manners.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by kenferry on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:33AM (#18293279)
Apple's is recognizing specifically "hey siri" at all times - it isn't otherwise listening. Perhaps you find the distinction uncompelling, but there you go!

https://machinelearning.apple.com/2017/10/01/hey-siri.html

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mikestew on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:38AM (#18293325)
Pardon me for being dense (and ignorant, no Echos in my house), but isn't the Echo doing the same thing? Just waiting for it's catch phrase?

As for the distinction, doesn't really matter to me, I'm in the "no way in hell is Amazon getting one of those in my house" camp. :-)

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:52AM (#18293479)
You'd be correct: they do the exact same thing. But people need to justify their opinions when they are inconsistent with reality, so here we are. Android and iPhones both have always on mics. But nobody is dropping their phone.

I don't see a conflict if people admit the potential invasion of pirvacy is worth the utility of a phone, but not the utility of an Echo device. But apparently that alone isn't good enough.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by telchar on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:48PM (#18295732)
It's not that I think they're really that different, but one is very optional and the other is so hard to live without these days. I'm absolutely not happy about the inclusion of those features in phones but the alternatives to having a smartphone are slim and difficult to live with.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:34PM (#18306340)
> It's not that I think they're really that different, but one is very optional and the other is so hard to live without these days.

You can buy a non-smart phone right now. It's not hard to live without one, it's a choice that you are now downplaying because it fits your narrative.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by stanmancan on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:13PM (#18293723)
The distinction for me is that Google is an advertising company, and Amazon a retailer; they both stand to make non-trivial amounts of money by listening, storing, and analyzing every little bit of audio they can from your devices.

So far at least, Apple claims to be privacy focused and makes money hand over fist by selling essentially luxury goods. Aside from selling your data to some third party (which seems unnecessary for a trillion dollar company), there's not much Apple could do with it.

TL;DR Personally, I have more trust in Apple not to "spy" because they seem to have nothing to gain from it. Amazon and Google have plenty to gain from spying.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by Filligree on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:08PM (#18294877)
Your phone is only listening for 'Ok Google', though. It isn't streaming the audio; you can easily verify that.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by stanmancan on Thursday October 25, 2018 @12:42AM (#18298581)
I never said they were streaming audio. They can, however, pick up more audio than is required, and listen for things other than the commands being spoken. Just because someone says "OK Google, whats the weather?" doesn't mean there isn't a conversation going on in the background that they can pick up on.

Google purchasing MasterCard purchase transactions so they can link to their profile of users is a great example of them having zero respect of your privacy.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:23PM (#18306291)
> Google purchasing MasterCard purchase transactions so they can link to their profile of users is a great example of them having zero respect of your privacy.

You signed the paperwork that gave MasterCard the right to sell your data and your bitching about the company that bought it? For real?

It blows me away just how many people are willing to use services where they are the product (and that's MasterCard and Visa these days too) and then whine when they get sold. Google is just doing what it can to remain competitive. Don't sign anything that means signing away your identity and stop whining.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by stanmancan on Friday November 02, 2018 @10:32AM (#18363274)
The conversation is about Googles lack of respect, not Mastercards.

For Maastercard, hiding “we can sell your data” in a 8+ page contract full of small print legalese that’s designed for people to skip over is hardly fair notice. Should people read and understand it? Yes. But most don’t.

Also, it’s silly to say that “you’re the product” with Visa and MasterCard. Most cards have a fee associated (with the norm for any rewards card being around $80-120 in Canada) and they have a insane 20% interest on purchases. That’s vastly different than using Facebook for free.

The privacy quip was directed to Google. Just because they -can- do something, doesn’t mean they should.

The third most valuable company in the world hardly needed to purchase offline purchases to further profile people who don’t know they’re being profiled “to remain competitive”.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by Filligree on Thursday October 25, 2018 @09:49AM (#18300851)
> Just because someone says "OK Google, whats the weather?" doesn't mean there isn't a conversation going on in the background that they can pick up on.

And filtering out the background conversation is a difficult problem in machine learning, but one that has to be accomplished in order to make the service work correctly.

We don't store the audio, much less the filtered-out noise, but I don't imagine there's any way I can prove that. Maybe an appeal to cost? There's way too much data to do that, even if we wanted to.

The parser output (text) is stored, mind you. You can find that on the Google dashboard.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by stanmancan on Friday November 02, 2018 @10:39AM (#18363329)
Storing the data no, but text output as you’ve mentioned, or even passing it into some algorithm that update your profile with some signal that “may be interested in...” is entirely possible with minimal data requirements.

And I’m not saying Google or Amazon are doing this today. If not then it may be one bad earnings call away for some engineer to say “well....we could...”.

Anything is possible in the pursuit of profits. I’d Google is willing to buy users offline credit card transactions to link to their profiles, it’s clear they will slurp up all data available for them. Why not that listening device in people’s home? “Overheard user X saying they signed up at google-ads-customer.com” “overheard user Y saying google-ad-customers service is fantastic”

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by toss1 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:56PM (#18294764)
With Amazon Echo, if Drop In is enabled, any of a number of people can turn on the mike to listen anytime [1].

This has gone wrong when erroneous connections were made, and IMO, Amazon are overly aggressive about enabling this feature.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=...

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jki275 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:36AM (#18293304)
It can't hear "hey siri" if it's not listening at all times.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by wnkrshm on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:54AM (#18293502)
You can also do data analysis locally, reducing the information down to something you can believably argue does not contain the information of what is said (like spectral analysis etc.) and then periodically upload that. You can claim that your product is not 'listening' in the classic sense.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jki275 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:56AM (#18293525)
Agree with the first part (I'm not certain how they actually do it), but the latter does not follow. It's still listening, even if it's not actually sending the data elsewhere for processing.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by dwighttk on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:06PM (#18293648)
you can use siri without "hey siri" being active.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jki275 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:11PM (#18293700)
I'm aware.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by cimmanom on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:06PM (#18294292)
IFF you've enabled Siri.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:43AM (#18292823)
A software control prevents your iphone from spying on you, and a software control prevents your echo from spying on you.

In both cases you aren't really sure it's the case, you wouldn't know if it were suddenly disregarded or circumvented, and you're just trusting in the good behavior of your chosen provider.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by _jal on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:13AM (#18293110)
You also don't know that you're not being tailed by a PI, that your neighbors are not focusing a mic on your home, or that your dentist isn't on the lizard-peoples' payroll.

However, we all make certain risk tradeoffs based on numerous things, including proxy signals. For instance, I would be intensely surprised to find out my downstairs neighbor was recoding me, based on multiple years of interactions. Likewise, I find the signal Apple sends ("We need a US-based GDPR") about privacy rather more compelling than the signal Amazon sends ("scour the mic for hints about product we can shift").

I mean, sure, while both $huge_bank and your hypothetical deadbeat relative might both steal your money, I bet I know which one you choose to to leave your money with.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by 52-6F-62 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:19PM (#18294416)
> You also don't know that you're not being tailed by a PI, that your neighbours are not focusing a mic on your home, or that your dentist isn't on the lizard-peoples' payroll.

Totally tangential, so feel free to disregard:

This statement reminded me of my experience during my brother's TS clearance (Canada). CSIS readily had accurate data (in surprising detail) about my time spent during a short period they must have observed his family members to use during an interview with him. It was pretty fascinating, mildly disconcerting— but in this case didn't bother me (in the context, I understood why. I certainly wasn't interesting at the time). They only could have captured the data they had by a combination of tailing (however brief or otherwise more expensive much more technical means) and bank records. I was of course none the wiser.

Advertisers are another matter. I have a Google Home Mini. It remains unplugged 100% of the time we're not using it. My phone can always go in another room. If we decide to turn it on to play with it (search something benign or play trivia) then we'll have it on. It's good for that kind of thing, and those are useful enough we don't mind letting Google have the little data that might produce.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:49AM (#18293440)
I'm just saying it boils down to trust either way, not weighing in on which way that trust should lean.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by chrischen on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:59AM (#18292979)
Well, Apple doesn’t have the patent mentioned for a software control to spy on you.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:28AM (#18293234)
I see your point, but it's conflating a couple of issues. The comment I'm responding to was saying that a smartphone isn't a spy device because it doesn't listen to you, and the Echo does. My point is they're both spy devices, just opaquely crippled to varying degrees.

To the other point, I'm not entirely sure I'm comfortable with the patents, but it's at least an Echo simply gleaning more from a voluntary engagement with it. I think the general feeling is an Echo is "spying" when it engages itself to listen to your home.

Of course, I have no way to know if my echo is doing that, or if it were to start, and it's out of my hands to prevent it. The same with a smartphone.

If Amazon wanted to spy, probably a smart tactic would be to deliberately "flaw" the wake word recognition such that it could plausibly be a bug, but the result is activating very often randomly. They already kind of do that, it would just need to be more frequent.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by orbitingpluto on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:25AM (#18293207)
Apple did buy Shazam last December with its "always-on technology".
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by chrischen on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:01AM (#18315987)
Actualky Siri is already always on, and it’s opt-in. Shazam is only always on when the app is open.

In any case having the capability to spy on you is fundamentally different from having the actual on-paper intent of doing so, such as a patent.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by illvm on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:54AM (#18293496)
I'm fairly certain it's baked into the chip or part of the firmware which is not easily writeable, which is why the wake words are static.

One can check if a device is compromised or not behaving as expected fairly easily by monitoring network traffic.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by comex on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:16PM (#18294382)
As far as I know, the hotwords are static because the detector uses a neural network pretrained specifically for those words. Training a new network for a custom hotword would require way too much training data. While it would be possible to instead use a generic network that decodes any type of speech – like it does when in full speech-to-text mode – and then use the outputted representation to compare to a custom hotword, that would be far more compute and power intensive, whereas the specialized network is relatively small. (The specialized network is also probably more accurate.) At least on battery-powered devices, more power usage for something that‘s always running is a dealbreaker. The same pressure doesn’t necessarily apply to home devices that are always plugged in, but all of the major in-home voice assistants also run on phones, and the providers probably prioritize a uniform user experience across devices.

Disclaimer: I could be completely wrong, and/or the situation could change over time due to improved hardware and software. There was a rumor earlier this year that the Google Assistant might add custom hotword support in the future:

https://9to5google.com/2018/01/29/google-app-7-20-assistant-...

Main source: Apple’s article about “Hey Siri”:

https://machinelearning.apple.com/2017/10/01/hey-siri.html

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by felix_nagaand on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:07PM (#18293654)
Obfuscating the data would be no more difficult than obfuscating tor traffic by delaying, stuffing, and merging packets. Has anyone done a long term packet analysis of an echo, home, iPhone, pixel, or galaxy?
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:31AM (#18293260)
There is a huge difference between “my phone is probably not listening to me” and “my home surveillance device, built for the sole purpose of recording as much as possible about me, in order to manipulate my buying habits—is definitely listening to me.”
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:54AM (#18293494)
Your phone is always listening for the command "ok, Google" or "Siri" in the exact same way the echo is listening for "Alexa". So there's not a huge difference. They are the same thing.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:16PM (#18293754)
You know how my phone is configured? Mine doesn’t respond to any of those phrases, so I conclude there is a small, but nonzero chance that it is listening to everything I do. Conversely, the sole purpose of an Echo is to listen to its environment and take actions based on what it hears. There is a high probability that it is listening at all times. You don’t see the difference?
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:20PM (#18306274)
No, because much like your phone the Alexa can be muted and entirely controlled from the very device you have deemed "safe". You don't need voice commands, they just happen to make it better than a typical bluetooth powered speaker.

Still doesn't change the fact that placement of the Alexa is stationary, so your phone (regardless of how low the probabilities are) is still a considerably more "high risk" device in terms of what it could pick up than an Alexa.

To me this just sounds like another person in a whole line of them that screams about privacy unless they have to give up something that's extremely valuable to them. The Alexa isn't valuable to you. Your phone sure is.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:56AM (#18293536)
You've just persuasively reworded "both my phone and my echo are currently configured to not spy on me and the vendor assures me of this"

At the base of the claim that Amazon is listening to what your echo can hear is the assumption that they're lying, and at the base of the claim that your iphone isn't listening to you is the assumption that Apple is not.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:13PM (#18293721)
Are you saying there is an equal probability that an iPhone is recording everything and that an Echo is recording everything? Just because the two things might be happening doesn’t mean they are equally likely.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:30PM (#18293896)
I think you're responding to the point you want me to be making instead of the one I am. I'm saying they're both very capable, switched-off spy devices, without assigning a trust metric to any provider.

Personally, I wouldn't put it past either company to massively violate my trust if the incentive stars aligned just right, and I think it's silly to pretend otherwise.

The problems of putting a surveillance device in your home and carrying one in your pocket are roughly equivalent, and the rest is a debate about which huge collection of people with a wide array of beliefs and ethics is gooder

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:00PM (#18294222)
I think we can agree that the problems are similar but the risk is very different. Just like plane crashes and car crashes have similar problems but different probabilities/risk.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:18PM (#18294394)
That's reasonable. Amazon may decide on its own before Apple, their motives are closer today, but I think it's unlikely for either. It'd have to be one hell of a prize to risk what they'd be risking.

A more likely path is law enforcement's habit of putting them in the PR hell of "we could have saved Little Tiny Baby X if these companies weren't so hell bent on protecting perverts and terrorists". Once you have the device, it's only a matter of someone making a sympathetic enough public case that they need access to it.

On that front, I think Apple is taking more proactive steps to keep themselves out of the situation, I'm just not sure it's possible to avoid it completely.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by kranner on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:53AM (#18292910)
Of course your iPhone is listening. The difference is that it's supposed to listen only for commands after "Hey Siri..." instead of "Alexa...".

Even if you turn Siri off, it is up to Apple whether or not to really stop listening.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jbb67 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:50AM (#18292890)
It might not be listening to you but it's almost certainly reporting on everything you do on it, your location, your contacts etc all the time.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by dave84 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:53AM (#18292913)
It’s constantly listening for “Hey, Siri”, unless I missed your point.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:48AM (#18292868)
I recognize the difference, but still think that he makes a very valid point.

My phone probably doesn't listen to me right now, but what exactly do I know?

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by InfamousRece on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:35AM (#18293292)
I have one device that potentially spies on me. Therefore it is logical that I should also get tons of other devices that spy on me -- or else I will be a hypocrite, no? Also I should refrain from any criticism directed against the spying features that companies put into their products these days. That would also be hypocritical because I have this one device that can spy on me....
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by SamBam on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:48AM (#18293430)
I thought the question was valid: you looked down on people who would buy a device that spies on them, yet you bought a device that spies on you.

The point was that the vast majority of people, even us techies, are willing to sacrifice some privacy for the benefits these devices bring us.

(And yes, sometimes these benefits are the direct result of spying. When I shop on Amazon, I often look at the section "Customers who looked at X ultimately bought Y." Thank you, Amazon, for spying on those customers, and recommending a better product.)

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by nyxtom on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:01PM (#18293585)
This doesn't necessarily mean that product Y is better suited for you in particular it may just mean people might have been artificially funneled into purchasing it either through wide advertising reach or through models such as this. It's certainly useful in some regards but it's not a catch-all and a lot of that is simply because of wide reach advertising, better marketing, and in the case of Amazon many products may just have artificial reviews. You still have to consider the alternative that what you are being recommended, even the "Customers who looked at" doesn't automatically mean there isn't bias or artificial incentives that push people in one direction over another. There's a reason Thaler won the nobel prize in economics for his work on "nudge" theory.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by bhauer on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:16PM (#18295491)
Not only that, but a smartphone provides a spectrum of functionality and any "smart agent" function is just one of many. Many of us turn those features off, meaning that—unless the phone has been rooted or is not doing what its manufacturer claims—it is not even listening for wake words. But a smartphone with this feature disabled still provides its remaining suite of functions.

These in-home "smart speakers" exist only to be agents listening for wake words.

I am not sure why use of a smartphone is painted as hypocrisy when countering the argument that consumers should be cautious about installing smart speakers in their homes. Clearly most people who are cautioning against the use of smart speakers turn off the listening agent features on their smartphones and recommend that others do that as well.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mikeash on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:02PM (#18293612)
It’s fine if you want to minimize it or don’t like it. But don’t act incredulous that people do this, when you also do it.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:42AM (#18292810)
What can I say? Does a smartphone make me a hypocrite?

You make an extremely valid point, though. What I would actually like (and what seems really hard to find) is a dumb phone with a 4G hotspot and which does not run Android in any way, shape or form.

Any suggestions

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by bwood on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:12AM (#18293102)
This is pretty much what you're asking for: https://www.nokia.com/en_int/phones/nokia-8110-4g

It runs KaiOS, which is a fork of Firefox OS IIRC. It's basically a dumb phone, but with some critical "smart" features like wifi hotspot, contacts/calendar sync, etc. It was a breath of fresh air for me.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by abawany on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:32PM (#18295096)
This is an intriguing choice that I have kept an eye on for a while. However, the source is mostly open-source with some partner bits closed source [1]. Still a great choice, particularly since it has tethering available.

Edit: Review link: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/aug/16/nokia-811...

https://support.kaiostech.com/support/solutions/articles/350...

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by CaptainZapp on Thursday October 25, 2018 @05:13AM (#18299543)
I ordered one today.

Apart from the fact that it seems to be exactly what I'm looking for it's also reasonably cheap at ~90$.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by Loughla on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:04PM (#18293626)
Holy shit thank you for that link. I've been looking for something like that.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by dwighttk on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:09PM (#18293675)
Plus you can look like you are in the Matrix
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by CaptainZapp on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:19PM (#18293798)
Wow!

Just, thank you!

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by testvox on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:01AM (#18292994)
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by dfxm12 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:07AM (#18293049)
Does a smartphone make me a hypocrite?

That's for you to decide, I think. In terms of privacy, we decide what we're willing to give up. The usefulness of an Echo may be worth sometimes seeing ads for chicken soup to some. Some might even think of it as a feature!

If you don't want to know online advertisers to know when you're sick, you're going to be more mindful of just your cell phone and any nearby Echos. Don't have your friends tag you in posts on social media asking how you're doing (this one is completely out of your control), don't search for drug stores or which medicine you need to combat your symptoms, etc. I get the point is to limit your profile as much as possible, but this case seems unreasonably high on the effort to payoff ratio.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryanwaggoner on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:55AM (#18292931)
To each his own, I guess, but is the exchange of a little bit convenience to a potential privacy nuclear device really worth it?

Does a smartphone make me a hypocrite?

To me, it does. Not to pick on you personally, but 99% of the people freaking out about the Echo own smartphones and carry them around all the time. For the convenience. It makes no sense, unless you realize that the person has just drawn their arbitrary convenience-privacy tradeoff line differently than the Echo owners have.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by tjoff on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:08AM (#18293059)
There are no real alternatives to a smartphone (this is paramount). Not living with a smartphone is a real social handicap on many levels. You also still have some control over it (compared to an Echo).

An Echo is just the tiniest subset of a smartphone but with some serious privacy risks, all of a very minuscule benefit in convenience. A gimmick most would probably say, the killer app to this day seems to be a kitchen timer. To compare that with a smartphone where tons of every day things can be quite inconvenient without one.

I get your point and on principle I agree. But the line most definitely isn't arbitrary set (even if you do find some practical use for an Echo). The difference is astronomical. That's not to say the current state of affair is depressing and we ought to really try to improve it.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mikeash on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:05PM (#18293642)
I think it depends on the attitude.

If you say that the relatively low utility of an Echo means it’s not worth the potential downsides, that’s perfectly reasonable.

If you say that people who buy an Echo are insane for willingly putting a spy device in their house, that’s hypocritical and irrational if you have a smartphone.

I think there’s a useful discussion to have in the former case, but alas most of the conversation involves the latter.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:08PM (#18293667)
Not hypocritical at all - phones would burn out charge in an hour if they were listening all the time. And anyway the listening feature of a phone is incidental, and they can be useful with it turned off.

Echo's only feature is listening and reporting. Its a different device in kind

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mikeash on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:17PM (#18294389)
Phones last several hours when actively doing real-time voice communication. The power draw for passive surveillance would be way lower. Many phones support constant background listening with wake-word activation just like the Echo, with minuscule impact on battery life.

If your phone has a spying feature, are you sure it can be turned off? How do you know?

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:41PM (#18295672)
Because you asked it to. If it didn't that'd be actionable, right? Whereas an Echo is explicitly useless unless its always listening. So the 'feature' would have to be illegal/surreptitious and exposing it would be big news
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mikeash on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:15PM (#18297295)
Well, what exactly are you defending against?

Echo, like phones, uses low-power, always-on algorithms to listen for a specific phrase. Only when it hears that phrase does it actually start recording and sending your audio back home.

Are you worried about that low-power, always-on part listening to you? If so, then avoiding the Echo while carrying a phone with the feature switched off is sensible. But I don’t see why this would be worth worrying about, since the data stays local and isn’t saved.

If you’re worried about the device secretly recording you and sending that data to someone else, then the two are equivalent in their threats.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by fouric on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @02:40PM (#18295159)
Not only that, but a cybersecurity researcher claims to have created a proof-of-concept for this very kind of low-power listening that you claim doesn't exist (https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35639549).
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:40PM (#18295661)
Cool!
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by 908087 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:04AM (#18293026)
Smartphones generally don't contain multiple directional microphones that give them the ability to pick individual voices out in a noisy room. They also don't have the advantage of being plugged directly into a wall 24/7, and so any audio surveillance being done would have to take battery life into account, as well as put consideration into the possibility of the device heating up and tipping the surveillance target off that something strange was going on.

Further, despite being generally pretty locked down to the average consumer, smartphones are far less of a black box than the echo/home/etc.

Both are a concern, but technically skilled users are at least able to take steps to reduce the potential for their phones to spy on them. The only way to reduce any spying potential with the echo/home/etc, is not to have one at all.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by shard on Thursday October 25, 2018 @02:59AM (#18299019)
iPhones have had 4 mics since the 6s, and that is enough to do some beam forming and target individual voices. Phones with 3 mics such as Pixel phones, iPhones starting with 5, and various phones from other manufacturers, can have some basic beam forming capabilities for picking out voices.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by mastax on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:55AM (#18292933)
Nokia 3310 4G
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ams6110 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:06AM (#18293042)
Yeah it's tough. I have an Android phone. I keep location services off on my phone unless I'm actively using maps or navigating. I have turned off location history, have no data plan (WiFi and voice only) and I have disabled the "Hey Google" listener. I use Firefox instead of Chrome browser on the phone, with uBlock Origin. But I'm still undoubtedly leaking some breadcrumbs.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by burger_moon on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:11AM (#18293097)
Isn't there also a thing about being trackable because you block everything out? Like it makes you unique and identifiable compared to the normal heard who don't block anything?
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by StavrosK on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:14AM (#18293126)
Also try disabling all retention on your Google account.