News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:31AM (#18293260)
There is a huge difference between “my phone is probably not listening to me” and “my home surveillance device, built for the sole purpose of recording as much as possible about me, in order to manipulate my buying habits—is definitely listening to me.”
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:54AM (#18293494)
Your phone is always listening for the command "ok, Google" or "Siri" in the exact same way the echo is listening for "Alexa". So there's not a huge difference. They are the same thing.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:16PM (#18293754)
You know how my phone is configured? Mine doesn’t respond to any of those phrases, so I conclude there is a small, but nonzero chance that it is listening to everything I do. Conversely, the sole purpose of an Echo is to listen to its environment and take actions based on what it hears. There is a high probability that it is listening at all times. You don’t see the difference?
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by jhall1468 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:20PM (#18306274)
No, because much like your phone the Alexa can be muted and entirely controlled from the very device you have deemed "safe". You don't need voice commands, they just happen to make it better than a typical bluetooth powered speaker.

Still doesn't change the fact that placement of the Alexa is stationary, so your phone (regardless of how low the probabilities are) is still a considerably more "high risk" device in terms of what it could pick up than an Alexa.

To me this just sounds like another person in a whole line of them that screams about privacy unless they have to give up something that's extremely valuable to them. The Alexa isn't valuable to you. Your phone sure is.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:56AM (#18293536)
You've just persuasively reworded "both my phone and my echo are currently configured to not spy on me and the vendor assures me of this"

At the base of the claim that Amazon is listening to what your echo can hear is the assumption that they're lying, and at the base of the claim that your iphone isn't listening to you is the assumption that Apple is not.

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:13PM (#18293721)
Are you saying there is an equal probability that an iPhone is recording everything and that an Echo is recording everything? Just because the two things might be happening doesn’t mean they are equally likely.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:30PM (#18293896)
I think you're responding to the point you want me to be making instead of the one I am. I'm saying they're both very capable, switched-off spy devices, without assigning a trust metric to any provider.

Personally, I wouldn't put it past either company to massively violate my trust if the incentive stars aligned just right, and I think it's silly to pretend otherwise.

The problems of putting a surveillance device in your home and carrying one in your pocket are roughly equivalent, and the rest is a debate about which huge collection of people with a wide array of beliefs and ethics is gooder

Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by ryandrake on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:00PM (#18294222)
I think we can agree that the problems are similar but the risk is very different. Just like plane crashes and car crashes have similar problems but different probabilities/risk.
Re:Thermometer Tells Your Temperature, Then Tells Firms Wher... by menacingly on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:18PM (#18294394)
That's reasonable. Amazon may decide on its own before Apple, their motives are closer today, but I think it's unlikely for either. It'd have to be one hell of a prize to risk what they'd be risking.

A more likely path is law enforcement's habit of putting them in the PR hell of "we could have saved Little Tiny Baby X if these companies weren't so hell bent on protecting perverts and terrorists". Once you have the device, it's only a matter of someone making a sympathetic enough public case that they need access to it.

On that front, I think Apple is taking more proactive steps to keep themselves out of the situation, I'm just not sure it's possible to avoid it completely.