Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by gabeiscoding on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:23PM
(#18289207)
The author of this post wrote klib/khash, and uses it in his very popular cpu-intensive bioinformatics programs such as bwa (short read alignment against the human ref genome).
I've been learning rust recently. As a learning exercise, I compared the robin-hood hashing of std::collections::HashMap in rust to his klib/khash he mentions in this article , and then tried various hash functions to try and match his performance:
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by woadwarrior01 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:21AM
(#18290871)
The split keys and values arrays in Python 3.6 dictionaries make it more compact than dictionaries from earlier versions of Python, which makes it more cache friendly. But Python dictionaries (and sets) use a variant of double hashing for collision resolution, which is less cache friendly than Robin Hood hashing's linear probing. It's certainly possible to combine both techniques to come up with a hybrid dictionary with the best aspects of both split keys and Robin Hood hashing.
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by rurban on Thursday October 25, 2018 @03:45AM
(#18299203)
Python, ruby, php hash tables are roughly 2x slower. perl5's being the worst maybe 4x slower.
Damn fast is only relative. It's damn fast compared to the previous implementations. Wikipedia even dares to say that the worst hash tables of all, perl5, is one of the very best. Bias all over.
SIMD optimized hash tables, such as the Swiss tables tricks have the potential to be much faster than khash. And khash is not cache oblivious at all, with its double hashing scheme.
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by romed on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:51AM
(#18290017)
Hrmm this is the first I’ve heard that Google has opened swisstable[1]. Strangely the three submissions to HN of this attracted no comments. This blog is interesting but a write-only benchmark of a hash<int,int> is sort of niche.
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by jorangreef on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @01:10PM
(#18285254)
I recently wrote https://github.com/ronomon/hash-table for Node.js, which has a few more design tips listed in the Readme, specifically around optimizing a cuckoo hash table by reducing cache misses.
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by attractivechaos on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @09:57PM
(#18289081)
Of course. Notable libraries implementing quadratic probing all use addition instead of multiplication. The example in the blog post is just for demonstration purpose.
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by namibj on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:01PM
(#18289095)
klib could do with a bit more documentation for what the abbpreviated argument and function names do.
Apart from that, I just have praise for this. It's succinct, performance-oriented and comparatively portable. From what I reversed for the purpose of grasping the effect of parameters, I like the interface/API, but the scope over which I am speaking is pretty much limited to basic kbtree, due to the lack of documentation.
Re:Advanced techniques to implement fast hash tables
by timClicks on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @11:11PM
(#18289413)
If you're writing code in C/C++/Rust/... then your code will benefit from understanding hash function performance because the choice of function can be another parameter to tune.
I've been learning rust recently. As a learning exercise, I compared the robin-hood hashing of std::collections::HashMap in rust to his klib/khash he mentions in this article , and then tried various hash functions to try and match his performance:
https://github.com/gaberudy/hash_test
No dice, his hash table is smaller and faster.
My next step is to try and implement his data structure and hashing functions directly in rust and see if I can get it to near-C performance...
Damn fast is only relative. It's damn fast compared to the previous implementations. Wikipedia even dares to say that the worst hash tables of all, perl5, is one of the very best. Bias all over.
SIMD optimized hash tables, such as the Swiss tables tricks have the potential to be much faster than khash. And khash is not cache oblivious at all, with its double hashing scheme.
https://abseil.io/blog/20180927-swisstables
What is the advantage of this?
That may mean wanting something else less.
If that's not acceptable, they didn't want to.
And that's fine.