News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by cletus on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:01PM (#18169738)
This is Vic Gundotra's legacy and perhaps the first major strategic decision Larry Page made in the post-Eric Schmidt era and it was the design and launch of Google+ and (IMHO) it marked a turning point in the company's culture.

Internal resistance to aspects of G+ was enormous. People outside the company get this idea that Google acts as some kind of singleminded (possibly nefarious) entity when "herding cats" is so often much closer to the truth. In G+'s case, the rank-and-file was largely against things like the Real Names policy yet leadership went ahead with it anyway (Vic often quipped that you didn't want everyone named "Dog fart", which was a pretty ridiculous argument).

And while it may have been Vic driving this, Larry backed him so has to bear shared responsibility.

Probably the worst decision made in this whole mess was (again, IMHO) trying to unify the account model. Youtube accounts have different permission models to Gmail accounts, etc. It would've been sufficient to simply link them (and not require they be linked) rather than jamming single-sign-on down everyone's throats, which really gained nothing except a lot of user backlash.

The worst part of this was that the for the longest time some policy violation (like your name not being "real") could lock you out of your entire account. Whoever made this decision needed to be fired. Deciding someone's name wasn't real enough should NEVER lock you out of your Gmail (or Youtube or any other service).

I was reminded of this in a thread yesterday about the disaster that was the Snapchat redesign. Leadership ignoring user feedback as people start to attribute luck to skill and vision (people have a tendency to socialize losses and privatize wins). Is this merely hubris? Because it's very reminiscent of the dismissal of internal feedback that is now routine (at Google).

It's unfortunate how much Google-hate is on HN these days because I think it's largely unjustified. There are definitely some bad (IMHO) leadership decisions but the rank-and-file are still culture carriers for a lot of the things that made Google great.

Still, as the Chinese say, the fish rots from the head.

Disclaimer: Xoogler. All opinions are entirely personal and I don't speak for this or any other company.

EDIT: TIL the origin of "a fish rots from the head" is disputed and possibly Turkish not Chinese: https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/fish-rot-from-the-head-d...

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dekhn on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:09PM (#18169805)
As a Xoogler I agree completely. The whole social debacle distracted the company from a more important goal (cloud) and now google has to play catch up to AWS and Azure.

This was a case where a very large number of Googlers tried to advise leadership on some of its more boneheaded decisions and had to work overtime to deal with the problems and fallout.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by cft on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:19PM (#18169891)
Very good insight. If you think about it, Google benefits from proliferation of third party websites, thus cloud business is synergetic with Google search. Facebook and Google+ are competitive with Google search since they centralize the web.

For many, Google search reduced to a search engine for Wikipedia and StackOverflow and a couple of other big sites. This poses a long-term threat for search.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Latteland on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:23PM (#18170486)
When I was at google, the one thing I took away was that most of the terrible decisions such as described above were very widely panned before being released inside the company. Everyone one of them. That doesn't mean the group of engineers was always right, but they were very good at pointing out bad, controversial ideas.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by JoblessWonder on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:05PM (#18170837)
Is there an example of an idea that was panned that turned out to be a (even moderate) success?
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dougb5 on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:18PM (#18170931)
The acquisition of YouTube is one that comes to mind. While it wasn't universally panned, there were a lot of engineers (myself included) who felt it was wildly excessive.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by village-idiot on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:18PM (#18171400)
The acquisition of YouTube might’ve not been bad for Google, but I could make the argument that it’s been bad for the rest of us.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by andybak on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:45PM (#18171975)
I generally still think of YouTube as a global good. Obviously it's a mixed bag but I'd be really sad if it ever vanished.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Aeolun on Monday October 08, 2018 @08:24PM (#18172413)
Vimeo would just take over.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by village-idiot on Monday October 08, 2018 @08:26PM (#18172421)
Considering it’s one of the driving forces of radicalization, I really can’t agree with that.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Latteland on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:31PM (#18171024)
I can't reply to that YouTube message, too much nesting? Anyway, I'll agree that YouTube was a good one. My office was doing Google video, so that project lost out.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by vl on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:23PM (#18171446)
> cloud business is synergetic with Google search

The funny thing is that while it's obviously synergetic, up to 2012 it was a Urs' toy project on the back-burner. It was mostly run from SEA/KIR with MTV leadership largely oblivious. There were gems like this, for example: once they forgot to cover cloud organization in the company OKR meetings broadcasted to all employees :) Only when they realized that external clouds grow so fast that Big G can loose it's preferential access to volume discounts GCP suddenly became the priority (to detriment of TI, which now largely is after-thought).

I'm convinced that Google going to cloud too late is going to be seen in history books in the same light as Microsoft/IE fiasco.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by andybak on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:43PM (#18171964)
> SEA/KIR, MTV, OKR, and TI

Please don't do this. It's alienating for people not in your gang.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by djsumdog on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:52AM (#18173621)
I get SEA only because I know the city. MTV makes me thing of that channel that use to have music videos in the 90s, before it became the shitty reality TV network, OKR makes it sound like you misspelled Chicago's airport and TI makes calculators.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by didip on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:13PM (#18171781)
What are these abbreviations? SEA/KIR, MTV, OKR, and TI.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by mejari on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:23PM (#18171836)
SEA/KIR is Seattle/Kirkland, a main Google headquarters, MTV is Mountain View, the Google headquarters. OKR is Objectives and Key Results, a measurement system for company/individual goals. Not sure about TI, but GCP is Google Cloud Platform.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by vl on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:38PM (#18171926)
TI is Technical Infrastructure, organization responsible for management/storage/database/analytics/scheduling, etc. software in datacenters. TI and Cloud used to be different branches in the same PA (product area), but TI consumed Cloud Org once cloud became a priority and now it's a single organization (itself a part of PA which also includes G Suite).

Since external-facing cloud projects have very simple and transparent metrics (unlike internal TI projects), Cloud/TI organization mostly concentrates on cloud projects nowadays.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by cletus on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:31PM (#18171887)
TI = Technical Infrastructure

If memory serves this was the PA (Product Area) originally responsible for GCP before Cloud became its own PA. But TI was headed by Urs and is responsible for the internal Google infrastructure (Colossus, BigTable, Spanner, etc).

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by isoprophlex on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @02:10AM (#18173675)
My god this abbreviated office gossip makes it sound like you're discussing some alternate version of the church of scientology
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by fulafel on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:25PM (#18171455)
Why is the hosting business more important?
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dekhn on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:39PM (#18171932)
cloud, not hosting. hosting is just part of cloud. Well, the first reason is that if Google misses this growth opportunity, they will be punished badly in the market, which will affect their ability to complete long-term against Amazon and MSFT. Growth in cloud is what growth in mobile was 10 years ago: critically important to remain relevant in a market. When cloud switches to "profitable mode" some time in the future, if Google isn't in a position to benefit from that, they'll have huge revenue and ultimately profit issues compared to Amazon (which has already surpassed Google on the basis of its cloud growth). So it's an existential thing.

Everybody thought social growth was critical (5 years ago, everybody thought Facebook would eat Google due to growth in mobile ads), but it turned out that social growth was not necessary, instead maximizing watch time on youtube and maximizing app installs in Play both turned out to be far more important. Google isn't worried about Facebook like they used to be- they're worried about Amazon and Apple.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by why_only_15 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:13AM (#18173289)
The cloud is already in profitable mode - AWS has 25% profit margins.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by romed on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:51PM (#18172010)
But Facebook is and did take a huge bite out of the total ad market. Facebook has roughly 1/3rd as much ad revenue as Google on a far smaller investment of infrastructure and a narrower range of products.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dekhn on Monday October 08, 2018 @07:55PM (#18172302)
That's true but the market grew, rather than staying constant size, and nobody considers Facebook an existential threat to Google any more (which helps Google in the market).
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dwc on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:19PM (#18170937)
> It's unfortunate how much Google-hate is on HN these days because I think it's largely unjustified. There are definitely some bad (IMHO) leadership decisions but the rank-and-file are still culture carriers for a lot of the things that made Google great.

The fairly small number of people I know who are Googlers or Xooglers are all pretty awesome as techies and as people. That does little to change my opinion of Google itself. Sometimes it makes me even more cynical, thinking that management might take special care in internal messaging lest the rank-and-file revolt.

But from my perspective, from the outside, what Google does as a company is what counts for me and for society. All the good people inside don't ameliorate the external behavior of the company.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by ubernostrum on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:54PM (#18171650)
lest the rank-and-file revolt

The rank-and-file are extremely well compensated, with cash, with stock, with on-the-job perks. Why would they bite the hand that feeds them? A lot of people will put up with incredible violations of their principles before they'll risk losing a comfortable position.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by lrem on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @04:03AM (#18174104)
Googlers will and have on multiple occassions revolted. Many have resigned when their personal red lines were crossed, usually over things the external world would not have noticed. Various top-down decisions have been reverted due to this, up to walking back an announcement that already went public.

Big part of the reason is that finding the next job after Google is nowhere near a hard problem. Chances are you might even get paid more by the next place.

Source: I'm a Googler that has signed some of these petitions, never got his red lines crossed and is still happy to work here.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dleslie on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:44PM (#18171965)
This is one of many reasons why it is worthwhile to compensate well, at all levels: loyalty can be purchased.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by jklinger410 on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:44PM (#18170142)
>Probably the worst decision made in this whole mess was trying to unify the account model.

Trying it at all after realizing it was not going to be complete. I think the unified account was an all-or-nothing strategy, and they met with early resistance from every dedicated user silo on all of their previously very separate products.

But instead of launching some big unified account thing to really force Google+, they did a kind of half-assed thing. Some accounts migrated and auto-signed up, there were some weird account-links, people had multiple accounts (youtube, gmail) etc etc. They backed out, pandered, etc. It was an absolute shit-show from the perspective of a power user.

If someone would have had the prescience to say "our products are too silod for a successful merger" at the onset, and then either spent 5 years slowly breaking down those silos FIRST, or just tearing the walls down AT ALL, it might have worked.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by agumonkey on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:59PM (#18171700)
I lost my original youtube account due to the merger. The idea of social mirror of society using a single point of identity is (in hindsight) totally ridiculous. We liked so much having pseudos and different personas depending on the context.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by CamperBob2 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:19AM (#18173316)
That's a very important point, IMHO, and an underrated one.

The next big social network -- the one that turns Facebook into MySpace 2.0 -- will be one that lets users maintain not just multiple 'circles' but multiple identities. I don't just want to separate what my parents see from what my coworkers see, or separate what my (hypothetical) friends from church see from what my (hypothetical) fellow members at the local underground S&M club see. I want to be different people as far as they're all concerned.

This will scale in interesting ways. For one thing, advertisers will actively benefit from this model because it will let them target individual personae.

The notion of keeping the name you were born with and using it forever, everywhere, is the original "single sign-on" paradigm. To the extent single sign-on, single identity is suboptimal in cyberspace, it will eventually be seen as such in real life. The use of real names online already ranges from a useless practice to a hazardous one, depending on how common or how obscure your name is.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by djsumdog on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:58AM (#18173635)
I kinda doubt that. It's not in those networks best interests. They need as complete a picture of _you_ as possible to sell you shit.

You can have semi-multiple identities based on the pages you manage/control, but most sites don't want to make it easy to switch accounts because it could lead to ambiguity to their data.

For example, to use multiple accounts on Reddit, you need either The Reddit Enhancement Suite (RES) plugin or some type of cookie isolator like container tabs in Firefox or multiple browsers. I think you need to do something similar for Twitter (or use a desktop client).

Federated Social networks that use either ActivityPub or OStatus (like Mastodon, Pleroma and GNUSocial) are interesting because you can have independent accounts on multiple instances, and be logged into all of them without browser tricks (since they're all on different domains).

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by gaius on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:11PM (#18170879)
Probably the worst decision made in this whole mess was (again, IMHO) trying to unify the account model.

This was a half-arsed attempt at inflating user numbers by counting every user of YouTube as a login to Google+.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by 394549 on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:59PM (#18170800)
> The worst part of this was that the for the longest time some policy violation (like your name not being "real") could lock you out of your entire account. Whoever made this decision needed to be fired. Deciding someone's name wasn't real enough should NEVER lock you out of your Gmail (or Youtube or any other service).

This is exactly what made me nope-out of Google+. At the time my gmail account was my primary personal email accoun, everything went there. There was no way I was going to take any chances with it.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Nelson69 on Monday October 08, 2018 @08:15PM (#18172389)
Google "hate" is a product of their success. IBM, MS, Apple, they all get it or have had it too.

What is frustrating with plus though, it was clear from outside Google that the company wasn't completely behind it. It also seems like it was good enough that they could have played with it to find the right recipe. I haven't followed it that closely, but from the outside, it looks like it launched, it didn't achieve facebook-like popularity immediately, they just sort of babysit it for a while and now it's shutting down. I know better, but it doesn't seem like the company tried very hard... Where were the stupid drug dealer games or some kind of fantasy football apps? It was only part social or something.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by kkarakk on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @03:16AM (#18173923)
except when they did throw their weight behind it they did it in weird ways - requiring google+ for youtube but then keeping all youtube tools on youtube and google+ as an abstracted login entity that had some old version of your data(google+ profile didn't pull your youtube banner or details in any way nor did it facilitate creator growth by automatically suggesting contacts based on the type of content you create - which is very much in the realm of possibility for google)
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by jedberg on Monday October 08, 2018 @07:11PM (#18172113)
> Leadership ignoring user feedback as people start to attribute luck to skill and vision

I think a lot of this is because of Steve Jobs. He did this but was for the most part successful at it. Everyone wants to think they are the next Jobs.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by justicezyx on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:01PM (#18170280)
Not relevant, but "the fish rots from the head" is relevant to Chinese? I cannot find any explanation of that connection. Just curious.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by gojomo on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:26PM (#18170511)
When I search Google for [fish rots from head], the top 3 results each mention some Chinese connection – one calls it a "Chinese proverb", others say it's been variously attributed to many traditions, often Turkish, Greek, or Chinese.

(So: maybe that's an origin. Or perhaps there's something vaguely similar in some Chinese traditions. Or perhaps it's just a common mal-attribution, as there's a tendency in the west to ascribe various highly-figurative or riddle-like pearls of wisdom to "the Chinese", or "the Arabs", or "the Buddhists", etc.)

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by monomyth on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:40PM (#18170646)
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by vl on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:09PM (#18171332)
It's widely used in Russia and considered to be a classical Russian proverb.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by paganel on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:33PM (#18171899)
It's also very much used in Romania, so I suspect we either got it from the Turkish (the source mentioned by someone above) or it comes from our Slavic roots (from where it might have originated in modern Russian, too). Living at the crossroads of different civilizations and migration routes can be fun like that.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by anyfoo on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:07PM (#18171309)
I cannot answer that question, but I can add that it's a common German saying as well, in a slightly different form: "The fish smells from the head."
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by oh-kumudo on Monday October 08, 2018 @07:03PM (#18172080)
I can't really think of a Chinese proverb out of my instincts that linked to this translation, the closest one being "上梁不正下梁歪", literal translation "When the upper beam (of a house) is not in the right place, the lower beam follows"
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by yuhong on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:06PM (#18169777)
Yea, I remember the debacle well. I think I had a few HN posts about it.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by tomjen3 on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:30PM (#18170549)
>Leadership ignoring user feedback as people start to attribute luck

Funny, that YCs motto is "make something people want".