News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dekhn on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:09PM (#18169805)
As a Xoogler I agree completely. The whole social debacle distracted the company from a more important goal (cloud) and now google has to play catch up to AWS and Azure.

This was a case where a very large number of Googlers tried to advise leadership on some of its more boneheaded decisions and had to work overtime to deal with the problems and fallout.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by cft on Monday October 08, 2018 @02:19PM (#18169891)
Very good insight. If you think about it, Google benefits from proliferation of third party websites, thus cloud business is synergetic with Google search. Facebook and Google+ are competitive with Google search since they centralize the web.

For many, Google search reduced to a search engine for Wikipedia and StackOverflow and a couple of other big sites. This poses a long-term threat for search.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Latteland on Monday October 08, 2018 @03:23PM (#18170486)
When I was at google, the one thing I took away was that most of the terrible decisions such as described above were very widely panned before being released inside the company. Everyone one of them. That doesn't mean the group of engineers was always right, but they were very good at pointing out bad, controversial ideas.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by JoblessWonder on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:05PM (#18170837)
Is there an example of an idea that was panned that turned out to be a (even moderate) success?
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dougb5 on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:18PM (#18170931)
The acquisition of YouTube is one that comes to mind. While it wasn't universally panned, there were a lot of engineers (myself included) who felt it was wildly excessive.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by village-idiot on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:18PM (#18171400)
The acquisition of YouTube might’ve not been bad for Google, but I could make the argument that it’s been bad for the rest of us.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by andybak on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:45PM (#18171975)
I generally still think of YouTube as a global good. Obviously it's a mixed bag but I'd be really sad if it ever vanished.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Aeolun on Monday October 08, 2018 @08:24PM (#18172413)
Vimeo would just take over.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by village-idiot on Monday October 08, 2018 @08:26PM (#18172421)
Considering it’s one of the driving forces of radicalization, I really can’t agree with that.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by Latteland on Monday October 08, 2018 @04:31PM (#18171024)
I can't reply to that YouTube message, too much nesting? Anyway, I'll agree that YouTube was a good one. My office was doing Google video, so that project lost out.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by vl on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:23PM (#18171446)
> cloud business is synergetic with Google search

The funny thing is that while it's obviously synergetic, up to 2012 it was a Urs' toy project on the back-burner. It was mostly run from SEA/KIR with MTV leadership largely oblivious. There were gems like this, for example: once they forgot to cover cloud organization in the company OKR meetings broadcasted to all employees :) Only when they realized that external clouds grow so fast that Big G can loose it's preferential access to volume discounts GCP suddenly became the priority (to detriment of TI, which now largely is after-thought).

I'm convinced that Google going to cloud too late is going to be seen in history books in the same light as Microsoft/IE fiasco.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by andybak on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:43PM (#18171964)
> SEA/KIR, MTV, OKR, and TI

Please don't do this. It's alienating for people not in your gang.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by djsumdog on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @01:52AM (#18173621)
I get SEA only because I know the city. MTV makes me thing of that channel that use to have music videos in the 90s, before it became the shitty reality TV network, OKR makes it sound like you misspelled Chicago's airport and TI makes calculators.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by didip on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:13PM (#18171781)
What are these abbreviations? SEA/KIR, MTV, OKR, and TI.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by mejari on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:23PM (#18171836)
SEA/KIR is Seattle/Kirkland, a main Google headquarters, MTV is Mountain View, the Google headquarters. OKR is Objectives and Key Results, a measurement system for company/individual goals. Not sure about TI, but GCP is Google Cloud Platform.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by vl on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:38PM (#18171926)
TI is Technical Infrastructure, organization responsible for management/storage/database/analytics/scheduling, etc. software in datacenters. TI and Cloud used to be different branches in the same PA (product area), but TI consumed Cloud Org once cloud became a priority and now it's a single organization (itself a part of PA which also includes G Suite).

Since external-facing cloud projects have very simple and transparent metrics (unlike internal TI projects), Cloud/TI organization mostly concentrates on cloud projects nowadays.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by cletus on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:31PM (#18171887)
TI = Technical Infrastructure

If memory serves this was the PA (Product Area) originally responsible for GCP before Cloud became its own PA. But TI was headed by Urs and is responsible for the internal Google infrastructure (Colossus, BigTable, Spanner, etc).

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by isoprophlex on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @02:10AM (#18173675)
My god this abbreviated office gossip makes it sound like you're discussing some alternate version of the church of scientology
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by fulafel on Monday October 08, 2018 @05:25PM (#18171455)
Why is the hosting business more important?
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dekhn on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:39PM (#18171932)
cloud, not hosting. hosting is just part of cloud. Well, the first reason is that if Google misses this growth opportunity, they will be punished badly in the market, which will affect their ability to complete long-term against Amazon and MSFT. Growth in cloud is what growth in mobile was 10 years ago: critically important to remain relevant in a market. When cloud switches to "profitable mode" some time in the future, if Google isn't in a position to benefit from that, they'll have huge revenue and ultimately profit issues compared to Amazon (which has already surpassed Google on the basis of its cloud growth). So it's an existential thing.

Everybody thought social growth was critical (5 years ago, everybody thought Facebook would eat Google due to growth in mobile ads), but it turned out that social growth was not necessary, instead maximizing watch time on youtube and maximizing app installs in Play both turned out to be far more important. Google isn't worried about Facebook like they used to be- they're worried about Amazon and Apple.

Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by why_only_15 on Tuesday October 09, 2018 @12:13AM (#18173289)
The cloud is already in profitable mode - AWS has 25% profit margins.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by romed on Monday October 08, 2018 @06:51PM (#18172010)
But Facebook is and did take a huge bite out of the total ad market. Facebook has roughly 1/3rd as much ad revenue as Google on a far smaller investment of infrastructure and a narrower range of products.
Re:Shutting Down Google+ for Consumers by dekhn on Monday October 08, 2018 @07:55PM (#18172302)
That's true but the market grew, rather than staying constant size, and nobody considers Facebook an existential threat to Google any more (which helps Google in the market).