News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by btilly on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:01PM (#18135883)
You'd have to survey their customers.

Speaking personally, my wife and I are new customers. This is the first time that we've spent over $30k on a car.

Between rebates, the cost of gas, and reductions in maintenance costs, we think that we save somewhere between 1/3 to 1/2 on the lifetime cost of ownership over the life of this car versus an ICE car. It is still a luxury, but between features like the driving assist, crash safety ratings, acceleration and so on, we are happy to spend it.

Based on data for other models from other drivers, we have reason to believe that, barring accidents, the battery could realistically last us 500k miles. But we have set it to never charge over 80% of capacity to maximize that limit.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by mikekchar on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:43PM (#18136109)
> Between rebates, the cost of gas, and reductions in maintenance costs, we think that we save somewhere between 1/3 to 1/2 on the lifetime cost of ownership over the life of this car versus an ICE car.

My wife wanted a new car (I'm stubborn and don't drive ;-) ) because the old one was getting pretty expensive to maintain. I crunched the numbers and we ended up buying a recent used Leaf. I live in Japan and Nissan has this deal where you pay about $30 a month and get unlimited recharges at public charging stations (essentially all Nissan and Mitsubishi dealerships, highway rest stops, major hotels, etc). I pay about 30 cents per KWh, so this is a pretty good deal. We should save enough money on various thing that the cost of the new car is negligible. We don't actually pick up the new car until November (lots of weird paper work in Japan and we're out of town for a few weeks as well), so possible I'll be singing a different tune in a few months, but I was really surprised at how the numbers worked out on paper.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by haberman on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:12PM (#18135958)
> But we have set it to never charge over 80% of capacity to maximize that limit.

New Tesla owner here, hadn't heard that!

Will you not charge above 80% even on trips?

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by btilly on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:41PM (#18136096)
The factory default is that you only charge to 90%, and they advise you to only go to 100% for trips.

We do 80%, but are willing to raise it for trips.

The reason why it matters is that charging lithium ion batteries to 100% lowers their lifespan. Since we don't need the range normally, we leave it at 80%.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by greglindahl on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:04PM (#18136219)
You might consider reading the manual! It does discuss the issue.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by mrfusion on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:30PM (#18136044)
I’m not convinced on the lower maintenance costs. Can you speak to that a bit? It seems like there’s still a lot that can go wrong and you’re stuck paying whatever tesla wants to charge you to fix it.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by samcheng on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:37PM (#18136080)
Look under the hood of a Tesla, and you'll understand why maintenance costs are lower.

There is still a lot that can go wrong on the body, notably the infamous door handles, but the power train is just much, much simpler. Notably, no oil changes, no gas, and due to regenerative braking, the physical brakes last a lot longer. Longer-term, while there is a coolant change required, there is no timing belt replacement, no spark plugs, no catalytic converter / muffler, etc.

The batteries themselves have seemed to hold up relatively well, but in the 10+ year range, that is indeed a concern, as they represent a large fraction of the value of the car. But prices are dropping, and maybe a cheaper and better battery pack can be retrofitted when the time comes?

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:47PM (#18136744)
> The batteries themselves have seemed to hold up relatively well, but in the 10+ year range, that is indeed a concern, as they represent a large fraction of the value of the car.

Current Tesla Model S fleet data is showing substantial longevity (80% initial storage capacity retained) well past 10 years/500k+ miles [1] [2]. This can be credited to their thermal management system and an advanced battery management system.

[1] https://electrek.co/2018/04/14/tesla-battery-degradation-dat...

[2] https://www.engadget.com/2018/04/16/tesla-battery-packs-live...

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by samcheng on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:05AM (#18137108)
The Model S was released in the summer of 2012; we don't know what the batteries will look like after 10 years yet.

I agree that they will likely still be serviceable, though.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by webkike on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:32PM (#18136061)
Sure, but electric cars have far fewer moving parts. Components are simply less likely to break.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by jcrben on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:59PM (#18137082)
Depending on what you mean by "break". What about bitrot and software bugs? Quick search reveals articles like https://electriccarsreport.com/2018/06/gm-recalls-model-year... and https://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/07/15/toyota_recalls_6250...

The kind of component matters. Altho in the long, long term we can expect software bugs to trend to 0.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by King-Aaron on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:39PM (#18136090)
> Components are simply less likely to break

I wouldn't say that they're less likely to break, but rather there's just fewer parts to potentially break. Your point is still completely valid of course.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by pretendscholar on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:41PM (#18136098)
Fewer moving parts does not mean that the components are less likely to break. A car with only one gear would have fewer parts but would break down more often.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by btilly on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:05PM (#18136226)
That's a bad example. Early Teslas had 2 gears, but then got rid of that and now only have one. That got rid of the transmission and gearbox, and the car breaks less as a result.

ICE cars can't do that because their engines work best in a fairly narrow range of RPMs. But electric has no such limit.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by greglindahl on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:12PM (#18136259)
That was the original Roadster -- and it reduces the top speed, that's the minus. Well worth it, in my mind.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by pretendscholar on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:12PM (#18136262)
The point being that having fewer parts in and of itself does not mean that it will break down less frequently.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by greglindahl on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:03PM (#18136212)
Most electric cars have only one gear. Why does it break down more often?
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Latteland on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:54PM (#18137060)
Electric cars break down less often, not more often, in general. They have less car fires too. Tesla has enough millions of miles that there are a number of comparisons of rates of various problems compared to the regular fleet about accidents, fires, etc. It's not magic but has generally been very encouraging.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by pretendscholar on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:11PM (#18136255)
Just saying as a thought experiment that having fewer parts does not mean it will break down less often.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by greglindahl on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:25PM (#18136342)
That's not what a "thought experiment" is -- you confidently said something that has no basis in reality and no argument behind it. You didn't say "maybe" or "might".

A "thought experiment" is when you set the stage to explain something using fundamental physics.

There are hundreds of thousands of one-gear cars on the road. There is data.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by pretendscholar on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:35PM (#18136402)
There's no basis in saying that single gear ice vehicles would break-down more frequently under conventional driving conditions?

A thought experiment needs to explain something using fundamental physics? What about a math or logic related thought experiment?

Why would I have to include maybe or might in a thought experiment?

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by greglindahl on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:15PM (#18136574)
You literally said "A car with only one gear", not "single gear ice vehicles".

I'm down with math and logic, as well as physics. But the problem here appears to be that you left out a word, so your audience is mystified.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by siidooloo on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:57PM (#18137078)
Here’s a thought experiment:

Product A has 100 parts. Each part has a 10 percent chance of breaking over the products lifetime.

Product B has 25 parts. Each has a 10 percent chance of breaking over the product’s lifetime.

Which product is more likely to break more often?

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by SEJeff on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:53PM (#18136766)
Things EVs lack or have less chances of breaking:

* Fanbelts

* Flywheels

* Transmissions

* Oil Changes

* Brakes / Brake pads (regenerative breaking makes them last a lot longer)

* Transmissions

* Spark Plugs and wires

When there are less moving parts, there is less chance of them breaking. It really is as simple as that.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by whamlastxmas on Thursday October 04, 2018 @10:18AM (#18140073)
* Pumps * Condenser * Gasket seals * Timing chain/belt * Valve clearances going out of spec * Injectors becoming clogged * O2 or other fuel related sensors failing * Radiators * Engine mounts failing causing terrible vibrations

It's such a tremendously long list. And all the items above are something I've dealt with on a vehicle at some point in my life.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by hndamien on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:14PM (#18136874)
Alternator, it's always the alternator.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by tim333 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:27AM (#18138613)
The motors in the Tesla basically act as alternators. I hope they last longer. It's funny with alternators that the heavy mechanical bit is always ok and it's the semiconductors that have packed up but they try to make you replace the whole thing.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by rootusrootus on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:24PM (#18136618)
You really expect it to work out cheaper than an ICE car? Interesting. The Model S, as a data point, is one of the most expensive cars you can own, by total cost of ownership over five years. The 3 is cheaper but still pretty expensive for the class it's in. I guess if you plan on keeping it 10-20 years it might eventually recoup the high capital cost in fuel savings, but that's a pretty daring bet. Good luck!
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by toomuchtodo on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:27PM (#18136642)
EVs, mile per mile, are less expensive by half to operate than an internal combustion vehicle [1]. Length of ownership, cost of petrol, and cost of electricity all play into the calculation of course. My Illinois home obtains power at 1-2 cents/kwh between midnight and 5am (Time of day metering, nuclear power); it's almost free for me to charge my Model S there, while my gasoline costs would be ~$3/gallon. I expect my cost of power to decrease as renewables continue to come online, displacing natural gas and coal (Illinois provides a zero carbon subsidy to Exelon's commercial nuclear fleet to keep them in operation).

[1] https://avt.inl.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/fsev/costs.pdf

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by rootusrootus on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:37PM (#18136970)
The national average is 12 cents per kWh and $2.90 per gallon. Cherry picking places with abnormally cheap electricity is great for Internet debates but doesn't inform much.

Right now an EV costs 20-30 grand more than a like-for-like ICE car, before the rebate (that is about to run out for Tesla). It's also too early to be planning on running the EV for half a million miles just to make it pay for itself in reduced fuel costs.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:21AM (#18137176)
> The national average is 12 cents per kWh and $2.90 per gallon. Cherry picking places with abnormally cheap electricity is great for Internet debates but doesn't inform much.

Half the country has power costs below 12 cents per KWH. Even without cherrypicking, the math is solidly in favor of EVs. If you can't afford a Tesla, the Nissan Leaf and Chevy Bolt are affordable alternatives, before considering state and utility incentives (which can be substantial).

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Latteland on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:05PM (#18136820)
You'll need to explain your basis for the S being one of the most expensive cars you can own. There are dozens of cars that cost more than an S, but those are all high end cars - those cars all need expensive maintenance, well known for porsche and bmw.

My s is 3.5 years old, had one visit to fix something and has had 0 maintenance. No gasoline (electricity is about 1/4 the price of buying gas per range, which is why they rate it at around 100 mpg), no fuel filter, no oil changes, no air filter, no anything. It's wasn't 0 because they did all the maintenance under some prepaid thing either.

Where do you think all the tesla costs come from? Compare to say a 50k bmw or a 75k+ porsche?

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by rootusrootus on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:32PM (#18136948)
Perhaps I'm wrong, but I've tried to make the numbers work. It would cost a quarter as much as what I pay in gasoline, sure, but that's because I don't drive an efficient car. If I compare it to something that actually gets good mileage it ends up being more like 1/2. Nice, but not enough to offset the up front capital cost anytime soon.

As for maintenance... well, Tesla doesn't exactly have a great reputation there. Lots of people with multiple motor swaps, random problems with everything from door handles to the doors themselves, etc. I don't think I would take the bet that it's actually cheaper to maintain than a German car, and that's saying something :-).

I'm glad you've had a good experience so far, and I hope that becomes the norm.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Latteland on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:38AM (#18137242)
You are entirely right that the initial cost is a lot more for the electric car, and comparing it to a cheaper gas car means you have a lot of ground to make up and it not be just a sensible financial decision on that basis. It's not going to be cheaper than a basic cheap gas car that can do the same. Like compare a 15k econo box to the cheapest currently produced long range (330 mile) tesla, which you can see at tesla.com.

I thought you were comparing it to an equivalent 'luxury car' with similar specs like a porsche or bmw. I'd compare an AWD M3 (priced at 63k) with an AWD bmw, priced at about 45k, both plus tax. Before Jan 1 you get a 7500 tax credit; after that you get half the tax credit, 3750 back. So that puts it at about 55k for ease of math. Now you want to get back 10k. Those cars are really really expensive for maintenance, that might get you the money back right there. But your fuel price will be about 1/4 the cost or even greater discount than the gas car. You'll never have an oil change, muffler, etc.

All that Tesla maintenance should be free, and they give you a loaner when they are broken. I got a tesla loaner when my car had it's problem that took a few days to fix. There have been some cars with problems. All things made by humans can break.

You'll be able to trade in the tesla for a decent amount of money but it doesn't make it free. As an example, my S is 3.5 years old and I was just offered half the original price as a trade in towards a model 3 - I decided not to do it because my car is working just fine. This was by far the most expensive car I've ever bought, more than double my previous cars. It's not about saving money, it's just so much fun to drive and there's no more fun tech toy I've ever seen. I can use it to go skiing (roof rack), taken multi-thousand mile trips. And you can do all that with a Toyota prius - that wouldn't be awd like my car so dodgy in the snow, but I could have bought a cheap awd drive. I never thought I'd spend more than 30 or 40k for a car, but my old car was 10 years old and I couldn't resist Tesla once I drove it.

The m3 is a much lower price point than the S. If you really wanted to try a tesla, I'd encourage considering a used S with a 4 year warranty from tesla included. See tesla.com or the third party listing site is better, ev-cpo.com. Since electric cars don't break down like regular cars, it's generally considered okay to drive them up to 100k miles. But you have to check out any used car even if you buy from tesla in person to make sure it is in proper shape. The cars come with an 8 year unlimited mileage for the drive train, increased over the original ones that had like an 8 year 100k mileage drivetrain warranty.

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by SEJeff on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:46PM (#18136741)
And this Luxury Taxi company has actual numbers that disagree with you vs conjecture:

https://www.tesloop.com/blog/2018/7/16/tesloops-tesla-model-...

Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by rootusrootus on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:34PM (#18136958)
Is it fair to compare a consumer to a taxi company? It is generally well understood (at least amongst car folks) that mileage isn't generally what degrades a car, it's mostly time. Taxi companies put huge miles on their cars in a short period, which is quite a lot different from Joe Consumer driving 12K/year.
Re:Tesla’s Model 3 Is Becoming One of America’s Best-Selling... by Latteland on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:51PM (#18137038)
Taxi companies still have to change the oil at least based on time. You can wait longer but eventually it needs to be changed, spark plugs, air filter, etc. after a very long time there is a new muffler. Teslas never need to change the oil, get a new muffler. They don't need exhaust inspections.