News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by therein on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:10PM (#18115806)
I remember reading a while ago that every $1 that goes into IRS to fund tax fraud cases yielded $1.2 in return. When that's the case, it seems like a no-brainer that it should be well-funded.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by jdminhbg on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:24PM (#18115938)
The average $1 yielded $1.20, not every $1. The marginal rate of return surely goes down as you spend more, otherwise you could spend $10 trillion dollars and get $2 trillion for free. What would be interesting is what the marginal $1 spent yields.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by Retric on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:50PM (#18118228)
That’s direct revenue, enforcing laws has a deterrent effect that vastly outweighs the direct revenue gained.

Tax Evasion is around 40 times the IRS budget and gets worse with lowered enforcement as the cost / benifit heavy favors evasion.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by grapehut on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:33PM (#18116007)
That is ignoring the enormous externalized costs. I have known business to have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in professional services when being investigated that have done absolutely nothing wrong.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by gamblor956 on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:48PM (#18116144)
As one of those former professional services providers, I can count on one hand how many former clients out of hundreds that had done "absolutely nothing wrong" and of those few clients, I can't name any that spent anywhere close to hundreds of thousands of dollars to deal with the audit.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by milesvp on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:24PM (#18116504)
As a funny anecdote, I know one person who did so much wrong with his taxes for a high value personal business that he received a check from the IRS each of the 3 times he was audited after the business folded. I don't know the specifics, but apparently, his business was some sort of an anomaly and the IRS was sure that he underpaid his taxes for a number of the years the business was running. He was sort of clueless about his expenses, so when the IRS audited, they ended up finding a whole lot of expenses that he hadn't properly accounted for and when he refiled, he got a rebate check. This happened 3 times before the IRS finally accepted that his taxes were correct.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by dsfyu404ed on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:04PM (#18116305)
>I can count on one hand how many former clients out of hundreds that had done "absolutely nothing wrong"

I think the person you're replying to means "violated the tax code in a minor and non-malicious way" whereas you mean "literally did not violate the tax code at all".

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by gamblor956 on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:14PM (#18116413)
I'm sure he did, but I don't know any clients that were audited over "minor and non-malicious" issues. There's a materiality threshold in place before the IRS will initiate audits, due to the resources required.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by schmookeeg on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @02:14AM (#18119191)
Too bad I wasn't your client, you'd have experienced one. :)

I owned a business that was randomly selected for an NRP audit a few years back. Spent 35 grand on CPAs and defense. After 4 months of an "up to the elbow" exam of our books, received this from the IRS:

"After our audit, we are making the following changes to your return:

"

...that was it. Nothing. No changes. Not even embarrassment or "lol just doing my job, them's the breaks kid" attitude. A total goat rodeo, the entire process. Imagine having to justify every cent on the books in OR out -- for a $2MM revenue business -- 3 years after the return was filed. Seriously impossible. Worse, just before the above letter, we were offered a settlement offer from the IRS for $20K -- to make them just go away. We declined.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by jcranmer on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:58PM (#18118700)
I was audited by the California tax agency. I did have an error--I mistyped the code of the tax credit, so they thought I was claiming some solar energy tax credit instead of the Other State Tax credit (apparently, the line on the tax form that says the name of the credit doesn't matter; all that matters is that three-digit code). The sad part is the first I heard of the audit was when I got a letter saying "you owe us $700 ($450 in unpaid taxes, the rest in interest), pay us NOW or we will garnish your wages."

Considering that anyone who actually looked at the tax packet should have figured out immediately that the only fault was a mistranscription in the code, they must have wasted quite a bit of money to gain back ultimately nothing.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by gamblor956 on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @01:06AM (#18118949)
They wasted about 25 cents, or the cost to print up the computer-generated notice and send it out.

A notice is not an audit. If you're being audited, you'll know. The IRS examiner auditing you will make sure you know who he/she is, and they will be your primary contact with the agency for several months.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by village-idiot on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @12:49AM (#18118885)
I got a scary letter from a former state I lived in saying "you didn't pay any taxes for the the year X, pay us YYYY + 20% immediately", when I had actually left the state right before the start of X, and returned shortly after X.

Thankfully I had records and an accountant, but a very stressful situation to find yourself in.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by datavirtue on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @06:57AM (#18120396)
Cities do that as well. I moved out of a city, closed out my taxes but ten years later they sent a threatening letter and tax assessment. My family runs a tax firm in that city so it was just a simple email for me to make it go away but most people would have to prove they left the city. Have fun. They did this to me for years after I left the city but the ten year anniversary was totally rediculous.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by village-idiot on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @06:55PM (#18126403)
Great, I look forward to sending the same message and documentation for the next decade.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by loeg on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @03:13AM (#18119399)
To be clear, the IRS and state tax agencies are different entities.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by village-idiot on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @08:05AM (#18120720)
Yes. I knew that, but good clarification for the reader.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by jdavis703 on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @01:09AM (#18118970)
I was audited for a mistake in the $1,000 range. I had forgotten to report one of the many 1099 forms I received one year. It seems like the IRS has systems in place to detect this kind of mistake. I paid the ~$300 I owed and went on my way.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by sokoloff on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:23PM (#18118583)
Not completely true. I was randomly selected for a TCMP audit. My tax professional is hoping to keep my compliance cost under $2500, but makes no promises.

That's for a reasonably typical (and by no means aggressive tax positioned) MFJ + 2 kids return.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by gamblor956 on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @01:22PM (#18123690)
The TCMP audit is the random audit. It's not based on any sort of categories or taxpayer attributes. It's why its so cheap to deal with, and most people do not usually hire accountants.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by sokoloff on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @09:27PM (#18127015)
$2500 is "cheap" for an individual?! Perhaps I'm golfing at the wrong club...
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by Nasrudith on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @12:09AM (#18118729)
Sounds like a client base bias. Since I know two major 'red flags' for audits which are completely innocent like self-employment and making lower quarter six figures in one case resulting in multiple failed audits. Even in the sense that cost money recalculations showed that taxes were overpaid. Cynically perhaps some of them operate on 'predator logic' of going after juicy enough but lacking dedicated accountants then perhaps petty spite once they already were made fools of by. There are some definite rotten apples within the IRS.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by datavirtue on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @06:50AM (#18120357)
My grandmother just helped a guy who was being harassed for $60k he did not owe. He was about to just pay it but she said "screw that" and ended up getting him cleared. $0
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by scrollaway on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @03:31AM (#18119468)
Does spending more on the IRS have increase those externalized costs?

Spending more, ideally, should also mean spending on simplification. Making it easier for both people and businesses to pay their due, and costlier not to. Reducing the externalities, not increasing them.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by Firadeoclus on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @06:16AM (#18120231)
There is that cost. On the other hand, there is money, time and energy spent on facilitating tax fraud because the perception is that you can get away with it.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by SamReidHughes on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:13PM (#18115836)
That doesn't follow, because there's a cost to the citizenry of being investigated. Also there's the increased ability of the IRS to abuse its power when you give it a bigger budget.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by belltaco on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:23PM (#18115932)
There is also the savings from people committing less fraud because they see it's harder get away with it, e.g cases against people they know like friends, relatives, coworkers.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by DenisM on Monday October 01, 2018 @08:52PM (#18118006)
Which is pretty much the foundation of law enforcement - make the consequences apparent before the crime happened.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by therein on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:15PM (#18115857)
You're right, it certainly doesn't scale to infinity. For instance shifting the entire military spending onto IRS would be unwise. Unless we are okay with living in an IRS police state. :)
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by SamReidHughes on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:22PM (#18115920)
Well, there's also nonfinancial reasons to spend more, like the inherent goodness of bringing people to justice.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by SilasX on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:58PM (#18116244)
"You get $10 billion more in your budget this year. Go pull some taxes out of Newfoundland. We got your back."
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by avs733 on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:57PM (#18116228)
So do people who are found innocent of other crimes. Would it solve your concern to say that anyone found innocent of a government cause of action could claim costs? I've never understood why they can't frankly.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by munk-a on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:33PM (#18116011)
Just to clarify, where in this thread was increasing it's budget discussed? The statement above pertains to current spending levels and it might be that the next dollar of budget put into the IRS yields $.90, but currently the IRS is assuring laws are obeyed while netting a gain to the US government. The only justification of cutting their balance (from a purely profit driven angle) is if the suspicion is that the first half of the budget to the IRS pays $2.40 per dollar and the second half pays $0 (or some similar less than dollar ratio), but this seems like a quite straight forward win.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by s73v3r_ on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:45PM (#18118470)
The article is about the IRS being dangerously underfunded.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by SamReidHughes on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:31PM (#18118619)
The thing is, even if you spend $1.00 to bring in $1.01, you're still bringing in money with 1% efficiency. If you didn't care about fairness and justice at all, that would be horrible economics.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by s73v3r_ on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:44PM (#18118462)
That danger does exist, but I do not believe what are anywhere near that point, given how dramatically underfunded they are.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by datavirtue on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @07:02AM (#18120414)
Cut the hyperbole, there is nothing dangerous about underfunding the IRS. Overfunding the military, that's another story.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by emodendroket on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @09:03AM (#18121145)
What's dangerous about it is massive budget shortfalls, not to mention unfairness, as taxes become optional for the very wealthy.

> The result is huge losses for the government. Business owners don’t pay $125 billion in taxes each year that they owe, according to I.R.S. estimates. That’s enough to fund the Departments of State, Energy and Homeland Security, with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration tossed in for good measure. Unlike wage earners who have their income separately reported to the I.R.S., business owners are often on the honor system.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by datavirtue on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @12:06PM (#18131630)
Wealthy will never pay tax. Owners do not pay tax, the people who buy thier products pay the taxes which are built into profit models. If it was a question of fairness everyone would be the owner. Governments should spend only what they can collect. They can't face budget shortfalls unless they are lending in the hopes that taxes flow as they are. States are still trying to recover from borrowing against tax revenue in the 90s.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by s73v3r_ on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @01:00PM (#18123478)
I'm not being hyperbolic. And if they are unable to do their jobs, that is quite dangerous, because then we will no longer have revenues to operate as a country.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by diminoten on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:17PM (#18115879)
The cost to citizenry aren't on the IRS's books so that's not relevant to them, and corruption also doesn't automatically follow increased funding.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by jonathankoren on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:14PM (#18118326)
You could say this about any law enforcement agency.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by neolefty on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:16PM (#18115877)
"abuse its power" — that sounds more like a talking point than constructive comment.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by creaghpatr on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:31PM (#18115989)
The IRS literally did admit to abusing its power in 2017 https://www.npr.org/2017/10/27/560308997/irs-apologizes-for-...
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by throwaway103281 on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:04PM (#18118280)
That seems surprisingly low to me. My dad used to be a tax officer in Germany and even in a bad year he'd bring in €10,000,000+. One year it was closer to half a billion. $1 -> $1.2 seems honestly barely worse the effort considering the cost on every company that gets audited, guilty or not.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by froindt on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @12:17AM (#18118755)
Was your dad working solo on everything he did? Did his collection numbers reflect teamwork?

You're comparing revenue on a per-producer basis to a much different number. There are support staff, programmers, benefits, buildings, etc. which all must be paid for too.

For what it's worth, this article from 2011 noting a 4:1 ROI. I'm not sure where 1.2 came from, but I was unable to find it after searching.

https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/irs-funding-cuts-c...

_ The Treasury estimates, for example, that every additional $1 invested in IRS tax enforcement beyond current levels would yield $4 in increased revenue

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by hugh-avherald on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @07:41AM (#18120591)
I think it's more like $12 for every $1. And contrary to a reply, it is the marginal rate, not the average rate.

https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/public-sector/our-insigh...

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by sandworm101 on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:33PM (#18116009)
The same can be said about speeding tickets, that money spend on enforcement comes back. But tax collection isn't business. This is law enforcement, or at least enforcement of laws. We shouldn't judge it on its profitability. Like speed enforcement, it is something that has to be done not just for those who are caught, but to deter all the others who probably won't be caught.

There are evil implications should we judge the effectiveness of tax collectors purely on the basis of cost/gain. We don't want a situation where the IRS only ever goes after easy cases. The people who hide the most money have, by definition, the resources to hide it well. If you want the IRS to go after the big fish, they need the budget to do so. We don't want them resorting to drift-net tactics, only scooping up the easy/small fish.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by magduf on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:42PM (#18116090)
No, because then you end up squandering enormous resources on trying to make sure everyone is obeying the law, and your end result is far less desirable than if you had relaxed enforcement. What you're proposing is basically a police state; those never work out well in practice.

However, you have a good point about going after big fish, because those are the ones where the gov't is losing the most money, most likely. Some drift-net tactics are OK, where you use some random spot-checking to make sure the smaller fry aren't cheating badly and scare the rest of them into being honest, but don't expend a lot of resources on it because you won't get back the money you spend. But yes, I agree, going after the big fish should be the primary strategy, even if it is much more difficult.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by sandworm101 on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:49PM (#18116154)
>> What you're proposing is basically a police state

I take it you have never lived in a "police state". I have (middle east). Deterrence is how law works in a modern society. We cannot catch everyone and so must rely on a bit of fear. Fear of being caught it why we obey laws with which we disagree. I personally may think the speed limit on a road is ridiculously low. But that limit wasn't created by the police. I obey it because I don't want to pay a fine, not because I live in a police state. In a police state rules don't matter. I'd get the speeding ticket regardless of how fast or slow I was driving.

A real police state is one where the police both enforce and write the rules, where they are no longer under the control of legitimate government. The IRS is nowhere near that. It remains totally subservient to the elected government. Its budget comes from an external source. Allow it to self-fund and that leash is gone.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by SamReidHughes on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @12:13AM (#18118741)
> Deterrence is how law works in a modern society.

I think there's also a sense of fairness. I wouldn't like obeying a law if I knew everybody else is ignoring it and getting away with it. I'd be happier following it if I thought everybody else was. You wouldn't want to be the only bottlenose dolphin that didn't back-date your stock options.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by magduf on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:31PM (#18116561)
What I'm claiming is that excessive enforcement isn't worth the effects that come from it. The "bit of fear" you cite doesn't require extreme enforcement, only a certain amount, so that anyone breaking the rules knows they're gambling the odds and might get caught.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by Retric on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:55PM (#18118243)
When Evasion is ~40 times the IRS budget we are a long way from over enforcement. Not paying your taxes is stealing from the general public, that’s really not acceptable behavior.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by chrisweekly on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:56PM (#18118504)
Unless you're a corporation.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:34PM (#18118634)
What we're judging isn't whether we should do it because it's profitable, but how plausible claims are that we needed to cut the budget because "everyone is tightening their belts." A look at the numbers shows that explanation will not wash.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by thefounder on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:06PM (#18118296)
I think IRS's job is more to deter tax evasion not to make a profit.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:31PM (#18118620)
The point is that more enforcement deters tax evasion so effectively that it saves money, so there's no sound fiscal reason to cut the budget for tax enforcement. The entire point of slashing the budget is to make it easier to commit tax fraud.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by s73v3r_ on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:43PM (#18118458)
While that's true, if they're not enforcing the law, they can't deter tax evasion.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by YayamiOmate on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @05:28AM (#18120012)
I think you've committed oversimplification. If this relation was absolutely true then feed as much money as you can and get 20% profit. If it isn't then your point has no real basis.

This metric can be used only as the performance measurement not it's predictor.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:29PM (#18118609)
It seems like a no-brainer if you are not coming a position where your main ideology is that rich people shouldn't have to pay taxes.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by chrisbrandow on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @01:14AM (#18118984)
Yes. Unless your ideological commitments lead you to an opposite conclusion.