News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by sandworm101 on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:33PM (#18116009)
The same can be said about speeding tickets, that money spend on enforcement comes back. But tax collection isn't business. This is law enforcement, or at least enforcement of laws. We shouldn't judge it on its profitability. Like speed enforcement, it is something that has to be done not just for those who are caught, but to deter all the others who probably won't be caught.

There are evil implications should we judge the effectiveness of tax collectors purely on the basis of cost/gain. We don't want a situation where the IRS only ever goes after easy cases. The people who hide the most money have, by definition, the resources to hide it well. If you want the IRS to go after the big fish, they need the budget to do so. We don't want them resorting to drift-net tactics, only scooping up the easy/small fish.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by magduf on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:42PM (#18116090)
No, because then you end up squandering enormous resources on trying to make sure everyone is obeying the law, and your end result is far less desirable than if you had relaxed enforcement. What you're proposing is basically a police state; those never work out well in practice.

However, you have a good point about going after big fish, because those are the ones where the gov't is losing the most money, most likely. Some drift-net tactics are OK, where you use some random spot-checking to make sure the smaller fry aren't cheating badly and scare the rest of them into being honest, but don't expend a lot of resources on it because you won't get back the money you spend. But yes, I agree, going after the big fish should be the primary strategy, even if it is much more difficult.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by sandworm101 on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:49PM (#18116154)
>> What you're proposing is basically a police state

I take it you have never lived in a "police state". I have (middle east). Deterrence is how law works in a modern society. We cannot catch everyone and so must rely on a bit of fear. Fear of being caught it why we obey laws with which we disagree. I personally may think the speed limit on a road is ridiculously low. But that limit wasn't created by the police. I obey it because I don't want to pay a fine, not because I live in a police state. In a police state rules don't matter. I'd get the speeding ticket regardless of how fast or slow I was driving.

A real police state is one where the police both enforce and write the rules, where they are no longer under the control of legitimate government. The IRS is nowhere near that. It remains totally subservient to the elected government. Its budget comes from an external source. Allow it to self-fund and that leash is gone.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by SamReidHughes on Tuesday October 02, 2018 @12:13AM (#18118741)
> Deterrence is how law works in a modern society.

I think there's also a sense of fairness. I wouldn't like obeying a law if I knew everybody else is ignoring it and getting away with it. I'd be happier following it if I thought everybody else was. You wouldn't want to be the only bottlenose dolphin that didn't back-date your stock options.

Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by magduf on Monday October 01, 2018 @04:31PM (#18116561)
What I'm claiming is that excessive enforcement isn't worth the effects that come from it. The "bit of fear" you cite doesn't require extreme enforcement, only a certain amount, so that anyone breaking the rules knows they're gambling the odds and might get caught.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by Retric on Monday October 01, 2018 @09:55PM (#18118243)
When Evasion is ~40 times the IRS budget we are a long way from over enforcement. Not paying your taxes is stealing from the general public, that’s really not acceptable behavior.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by chrisweekly on Monday October 01, 2018 @10:56PM (#18118504)
Unless you're a corporation.
Re:I.R.S. Tax Fraud Cases Plummet After Budget Cuts by emodendroket on Monday October 01, 2018 @11:34PM (#18118634)
What we're judging isn't whether we should do it because it's profitable, but how plausible claims are that we needed to cut the budget because "everyone is tightening their belts." A look at the numbers shows that explanation will not wash.