News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by stirlo on Friday September 28, 2018 @09:58AM (#18093372)
It’s amazing to see the implications lay out first hand of a single manufacturing defect. Intel was the undisputed king until 10nm and now they are gasping for breath in the competitive environment. The stockholders must be extremely discounted that a single process change could remove such a massive competitive moat around their business
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by stcredzero on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:44PM (#18094798)
It’s amazing to see the implications lay out first hand of a single manufacturing defect.

Big tech is in the kind of business where the 3rd, 4th, or 5th item in the chain of Toyota's "Five Whys" can have such far reaching effects. In a way, this is nothing new. The auto industry has been in that kind of business for a very long time now. This is why Toyota's "Five Whys" exists.

I don't think the root of the problem here is technical, however. I suspect it's ultimately cultural. Didn't Andrew Grove say, "Only the paranoid survive?" How hard would it be to maintain a culture of paranoia at an industry leading company with huge margins? That's the kind of position that fosters overconfidence, not paranoia.

AMD's Epyc Master plan: (Or how AMD let Intel paint itself into a corner)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ucMQermB9wQ

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by mbell on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:20AM (#18093564)
> now they are gasping for breath in the competitive environment

That statement is beyond hyperbolic...

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by maccio92 on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:23AM (#18093579)
It's not, they've fallen all the way back to 22nm while AMD is at 7nm, while maintaining healthy production capabilities of current process nodes. And that's not even taking into account the fact that AMD architected an objectively better processor
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by alexhutcheson on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:27AM (#18093618)
The article is about chipsets[1], not processors. Intel is only falling back to 22nm for the chipset, which is a less performance-sensitive component than the processor. They are still making 14nm processors.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chipset

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by ZiiS on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:43AM (#18093765)
AMD (or rather TSMC) are not (yet) producing 7nm X86 processors for sale. Though you can buy 7nm ARM chips made by TSMC for Apple and Huawei.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:44AM (#18093771)
It'd seem they are doing that because they never moved CPUs to 10nm facilities, thus not freeing 14nm capacity for the chipsets and now they want to increase production of 14nm CPUs and they can only move chipsets to 22nm.

If the chipsets are simpler, less critical and easier to design than CPUs, shouldn't they start new processes with the least critical stuff?

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by bloomer on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:04AM (#18093939)
There is much less value in producing chipsets on the more advanced process line, which would basically waste the investment in the new process. Also depending on the issue it is likely to affect chipsets and cpus similarly so there may not even be a manufacturing advantage.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by monocasa on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:51AM (#18094377)
Typically the new process nodes are seen as a rapidly depreciating asset. You put the highest return on investment as quickly as you can.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @05:08PM (#18097077)
But won't you be able to deliver the high-value product sooner if you get early experience with the low-value one first?

You can design around unreliable processes by increasing redundancy and these simpler chips seem excellent as technology validation.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by monocasa on Friday September 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#18098223)
Not for the time frame generally seen until nowish which is a new process every 18 months. If you wait to smooth out your process you'll be left in the dust.

Also, easier on the RTL isn't really easier on the process. The digital guys and the process guys have very different constraints, so there's probably not even a benefit to having "simpler" chips on a newer process first.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Monday October 01, 2018 @07:35AM (#18111684)
Simpler chips also means smaller dies, which, for a new process also means better yield even at a higher defect rate. Not only chipsets could benefit from it, but also smaller processors such as the Atom lineup.

I assume a 10nm Quark X would be hard to see with the naked eye ;-)

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by monocasa on Monday October 01, 2018 @03:28PM (#18115961)
But the margins are already much lower on the smaller dies. Already something like a quark is next to free on the process level; the recurring cost is nearly all packaging and testing. Additionally there's some practical limits to how small you can make a chip since you still need the analog side of the io pins and their bond pads, and you can't shrink those very much.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by yborg on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:35AM (#18093692)
Intel is currently projecting full-year revenue for 2018 of $69.5 billion.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by adventured on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:01AM (#18093905)
Intel second quarter profit: $5 billion

AMD full-year 2017 revenue: $5.3 billion

You see, Intel is gasping for breath, drowning in the $18 billion of profit they'll generate this year. How they'll survive another year at this rate is anyone's guess.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by losteric on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:06AM (#18093956)
Gasping for breath != dead; Intel is stumbling here, AMD will start eating into those numbers unless Intel can regain their pace.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by tinus_hn on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:30AM (#18093646)
It doesn’t matter what AMD is building. The only thing that matters for Intel is how many products they ship because that’s where the money is made.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by ben_w on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:35AM (#18093695)
If Intel’s competitors are building better products than Intel, then Intel ships less products or has to charge less for their products. It matters what AMD produces.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by tinus_hn on Friday September 28, 2018 @06:47PM (#18097679)
In a free market that’s true. But it isn’t true. Guess what that means!
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:45AM (#18093777)
What's better for one person may not be better for all others.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by ben_w on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:23PM (#18094627)
In principle I agree with you.

Unfortunately, your response doesn’t really deal with the point I made: not only does it apply equally to both companies, but also I cannot think of any economically significant use case where Intel will beat AMD while costing more ($ or watts) per gflop.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by loeg on Friday September 28, 2018 @01:34PM (#18095250)
Absolute single thread perf and/or memory latency still matter for many applications. AMD definitely wins on a $/gflop basis, especially at high core counts. But some applications are happy to trade absolute gflops for low latency and pay Intel out the nose for it.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @05:18PM (#18097143)
AMD wins on $/GFLOP for some applications, but not others. Their SIMD pipelines are half as wide as Intel's (even though they don't need to throttle as much as Intel when using them). They also got a kick out of the speculative execution attacks that hit Intel more (but that matters to cloud providers most, businesses less and doesn't matter at all for HPC users). You also need to consider what your compilers do and using the right optimizations for the specific architecture could make a huge difference.

It's a bit like x86 vs SPARC vs POWER vs ARM. Each has workloads that run better on them for the same amount of upfront and operational costs.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by loeg on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:30PM (#18098569)
Yeah, my statement was mostly aimed at high core count applications. It's definitely true that Intel remains more competitive in the low-core market segments. Extra boards and chasses add their own costs, though.

AMD is less than 50% the price at large core count models, relative to comparable to Intel, so even with half the SIMD pipeline they can still win on $/gflops there.

It isn't really the same as considering entirely different ISAs. The switching cost Intel -> AMD is far cheaper than switching Intel -> PPC. Sparc and ARM are not competitive at all.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by geezerjay on Friday September 28, 2018 @02:36PM (#18095837)
> But some applications are happy to trade absolute gflops for low latency and pay Intel out the nose for it.

Can you provide one example of where Intel products beat AMD's in latency in a way that prospective customers are willing to pay a premium for that performance delta?

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by loeg on Friday September 28, 2018 @04:36PM (#18096826)
My employer, for example, probably can't live with the single thread perf regression that the combination of reduced IPC and steeper remote memory latency causes. We would love to pay less for CPUs, but they aren't the dominant cost in our platform (TBs of flash costs $$$$$) so the savings is marginal. (I don't really want to name my employer here, though.)
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @05:27PM (#18097197)
Another case is memory. If your working dataset is, say, 24 TB, you want a machine that can have that much memory and you most likely have bigger problems than how much each of your 8 CPUs costs.

With that kind of problem, you may want to abandon x86 altogether.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by mmt on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:10PM (#18098510)
> With that kind of problem, you may want to abandon x86 altogether

At this end of the spectrum, that means abandoning commodity hardware, with everything it implies, not just a change in binary architecture, as it might for ARM vs. x86 in end user devices.

Recently, I looked up the max memory on IBM's system z, and it was only 32TB, but it looks like their Power Systems E980 can take 64TB. It appears that, like with their mainframe line, going that route means significant vendor lock-in, including proprietary memory modules.

It's certainly interesting that the current generation of high-end x86 CPUs took a step backwards from the last generation, in that that their max is 12TB and just catching back up to 24TB isn't expected to happen until next year.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by loeg on Saturday September 29, 2018 @01:52AM (#18098917)
Fortunately, we do not have that problem :-).
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Saturday September 29, 2018 @09:19AM (#18100163)
I'd be extremely happy to have that kind of problem.

For some reason, while I was in college, I got a complimentary subscription to a magazine called Supercomputing Review. It was one of the most interesting reads of that time.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:15AM (#18093514)
It looks like the 10nm process problems caught Intel very unprepared, which suggests bad news were not traveling as quickly and as far as they should. This is an issue with companies above a certain size.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by quantumhobbit on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:51AM (#18093831)
Bruce Webster calls this the Thermocline of Truth. Which I think is a great metaphor.

http://brucefwebster.com/2008/04/15/the-wetware-crisis-the-t...

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by blihp on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:23PM (#18094634)
The Pentium 4 problems over 15 years ago caught Intel very unprepared. The problems since have been increasingly less forgivable. 14nm wasn't exactly a smooth rollout either. The fact that Intel management decided that the physics problems they were encountering with increasing regularity could be countered by bold management proclamations suggests a hearing problem on their part rather than an issue of those further down the org chart communicating the issues far and wide.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by bloomer on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:10AM (#18093994)
It appears that the 10 nm problems caught Intel by surprise because they fell into the unknown category. I’m confused why you think that some communication issue follows from that. Intel has a multi year roadmap and long lead times so I don’t think they were unprepared for this. This is the exact response you would expect to a delay on the latest technology node.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by stcredzero on Friday September 28, 2018 @12:58PM (#18094914)
It appears that the 10 nm problems caught Intel by surprise because they fell into the unknown category.

Are you sure the problem couldn't be interpreted as, "We've set the die sizes too large?" Because that's how AMD is approaching it, and they're winning.

Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by barry0079 on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:26AM (#18093607)
Nobody wants to be frank with the people above them.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by Retric on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:36AM (#18093697)
Alternatively, people get to the top in part because they where lucky, which makes them more optimistic than they should be.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by bdamm on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:20AM (#18094097)
There’s another mechanism which is too much optimism. Everyone is susceptible, not just the folks at the top.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by rbanffy on Friday September 28, 2018 @10:45AM (#18093783)
That doesn't work out very well.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by pjc50 on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:26AM (#18094157)
Hardly a "single manufacturing defect", more the failure of an expected miracle to arrive. Getting the process shrink to work has always required a whole load of minor innovations to line up, and we were always wondering when Moore's Law would fail to deliver them on schedule. Now it seems to be happening.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by earenndil on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:48AM (#18094354)
Now? It started back in 2015.
Re:Intel Tock-Ticks Chipsets Back to 22nm by tedunangst on Friday September 28, 2018 @11:32AM (#18094204)
Stock down over negative 3% today.