Only if the AI is going to work for sure.
There was a UK company, SpinVox, they were big 10 years ago, they did voice recognition of your phone calls and sent you a text. They raised huge, like 100M pounds. Granted not AI.
Turns out they were doing most of their transcription manually with hopes of going automated.
It was a huge blow up, it boiled to fraud.
This is close to Elizabeth Holmes territory kind of storyline.
So it's possible to do as you say, but there needs to be transparency.
Also, AI is an approach, not a market ... so I think they're going to end up like transistors or some other kind of thing, the knowledge will be embedded within companies, and not so many pure AI companies.
However you have to be honest to investors, which I assume they weren't and thus commited fraud.
On the other hand, I could definitely see this being used in mock-ups, just as you might populate some UI with "fake" data to illustrate proofs-of-concept. The transition between mock-up and working application might be fuzzy, and it's a lack of honesty/transparency in this transition that leads to murky territory like you say.
Hard to rise above the background "AI noise" of well-funded marketing.
And people are already fed up with all the AI marketing bullshit; "ebbing tide sinks all boats".
One way is to offer real-time results via APIs or demos, which cannot be faked with humans due to sheer latency / volume. Another is to be active in the ML community (open source etc) to build a reputation. But there the audience is different (technical), and may not overlap with the business case much.
This will pass when funding gets tight again and/or the economy enters a recession. A very sharp recession is actually good for the valley because it helps clean out the fakers; it's no different than the first cold snap in the winter helping clear away certain pests.
(One takeaway from this is that if one wants to found a startup, and one is not a fraud, it's actually better in almost every way to do so in the first part of a recession: lower salaries, less grass-is-greener attrition, lower real estate costs, etc.)
For the customers, they need to be sure that the company is actually capable of solving the problem they are claiming to solve (before signing some sort of long term contract that doesn't actually make the claims the sales people put forward.) The customer's evaluation, however is distinct from that of an investors.
It is the job of an investor to determine if the startup is actually capable of having reasonable odds of successfully pursuing whatever they are claiming to be doing. If an investor is not, then for an actual startup doing machine learning, probably this is not they type of investor you want.
During the ICO pump and dump cycle one thing stuck out to me - nearly all of the ICOs were being run by people without any cryptography experience. Most had little to no software development experience. I'd suggest investors take their first step in evaluating "AI" startups similarly.
I get that on a purely technical level, but really... who cares about the implementation? If a company is solving problems it really doesn't matter, and if they're solving it better using some mix of ML and human intervention... again; who cares?
Trying to create a startup that can't at least compete with the existing solutions isn't a very good business strategy in my opinion.
That's what academia is for. Research that is still too far away from being profitable but that has it's merits in the long run.
I also happened to know one of the people they later hired, and right up to that point they were seriously enraged by this company's deceptive nonsense. The company didn't describe his job quite in the way the investor did, but yeah, that's pretty much what the job was. The compensation was very good.
In a sense people with strong domain knowledge and experience could view these companies as basically a way to outsource the two hardest startup filter functions (finding product-market fit, establishing timing) while at the same time preserving their option to join as highly-compensated ICs and leads.
Except for keeping this secret. Than it's called lying.
One of the biggest shocks I had going from childhood to adulthood was the sudden flip between people telling you that you have to be honest and the people now telling you to stop being honest. And the people who had previously told you that you must be honest, they tell you "oh yes, that's work", when you go back to ask them what you should do given you are being instructed by the people who pay your wages that you now have to lie.
I regret my parents never taught me we're living in softly adversarial world. People are not going to kill you, but businesses are out to fleece you.
"The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made." - Groucho Marx
See also; the appointed Liars of the Zoon tribe of Terry Pratchett's Discworld.
And the apparent message from that debacle isn't; "be honest", rather it is; "being dishonest nets billions, try not to get caught though".
It is, as long as you have reason to assume that you will be ABLE to automate the tasks. For many of these tasks, there is NO reason to assume that.
My feeling with AI tasks is that either they work reasonably well after a short time or they will never work well. (At least not until the next AI revolution.)
If a company doesn't have a good enough AI system for their task after a couple of months of toying with it, I will be Very sceptical that they will ever have one.
Anything customer-facing and low-latency, like human language translation, image classification, or speech recognition doesn’t seem viable at even modest scale. Anything involving large amounts of data, like analyzing financial data or server logs, seems potentially doable though still unlikely.
In general, it seems like the main advantage of AI products today is either latency of output or size of input, both of which seem difficult to fake by using humans. If a customer has a small amount of input data and wants a small number of results that are indistinguishable from what a trained human would produce, surely they would have no misconceptions about the current state of AI, and would just hire the human to produce it.
Of course a company marketing an online service that sells AI-generated musical compositions could cheat by hiring experienced human composers. But if there’s any money in such a service at all, I expect the customers would want to be able to generate a huge number of compositions, something that humans would probably not be able to do at any appreciable scale. If the customer wanted a single composition that sounded like it was composed by an expert human, I’m pretty sure they would just hire the human.
One thing I certainly could believe is common is human sanity checks on AI output, but that doesn’t strike me as bad or dishonest unless the seller is specifically claiming (for some reason) that no humans are involved. I could also definitely believe that companies fake AI demos for potential investors or future customers.
What types of AI products would be best-suited for humans to be able to viably fake?
When simultaneous translation becomes a product, its makers will stop claiming they do AI, and start claiming "we used AI to create this."
This is only a problem when credulous and powerful investors (a dangerous combination) get caught up in the hype.
Delusional; if it's really hard to get it to work then it's really hard to get it to work; investors should not believe "if only we get the data"
>(B) the company can prove there's commercially significant demand for the user experience that they hope to be able to eventually do with some algorithms/AI technology, and thus can attract investor capital for making the thing actually work (potentially years later). In some cases, the human-powered product might actually be really good, and the economics might work in.
Delusional - if the economics work then everyone would be doing it, there's no money in it, the investors should only invest if they understand that rooms full of transcribers will be needed - with all the management, recruitment and security issues that brings.
This is what the last wave of voicemail transcription companies tried; they all went bust with scores of millions of loss. Be warned.
Not having sufficient data to train a machine learning algorithm is a legitimate concern. Statistical machine learning algorithms are very bad at generalising, so they need lots and lots of examples of every possible variation of a concept, in order to model the concept well.
That is why everyone's going gaga over "the new electricity" (by Andrew Ng's saying). So in some cases, yes, there are applications that are impossible to develop without "the data".
Human reading a 1GB logfile looking for key words/phrases is a lot more doable.
The actual approach is a perfectly reasonable business strategy, because (A) it's really hard to work on machine learning without a lot of data, and it's often hard to get that data without actual users using the product in roughly the way it's supposed to work, and (B) the company can prove there's commercially significant demand for the user experience that they hope to be able to eventually do with some algorithms/AI technology, and thus can attract investor capital for making the thing actually work (potentially years later). In some cases, the human-powered product might actually be really good, and the economics might work in.
But it really sucks that the general hype around AI has generated a whole category of "AI companies" that don't actually use any AI technology. The dishonesty is really poor (I have a friend who's actually a machine learning expert start a job at one of these companies, and only then discover that the company did not use machine learning and no technical plans to do in the next year and actually just wanted another web developer... which obviously resulted in my friend quitting).
That said, I expect the trend to continue as long as companies get lots of extra press and investor attention for claiming to be an AI company.