News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by firasd on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:19PM (#17892513)
As an Indian I'm not sure I endorse all this as 'anti-colonialism'. This is a bunch of government bureaucrats who want e.g. data to be stored in the country so they can access personal info more easily...
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by Eridrus on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:55PM (#17892718)
Colonialism is a loaded word, but if you look at India trying to force cell phone companies to manufacture in India I think there is a clear desire to drive economic development through policy. I don't really blame them either, China offers a pretty compelling example of what state intervention in the market can do.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by firasd on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:25PM (#17892887)
Yeah. Many countries do that sort of thing, like the US imposing tariffs on car imports unless a some of the assembly is done domestically. I wouldn't necessarily endorse too much protectionism either—India has a clear example of the benefits of moving towards an open market after 1991. In fact the biggest Indian startup exit is Flipkart, bought by Walmart, which demonstrates the value of free flow of capital.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by redditmigrant on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:29PM (#17892915)
There is also the example of China which has policies that favor local companies and China has created dramatically more economic value for it's citizens than India's open market.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:47PM (#17893019)
Correlation isn’t causation. China could have done even better than it did if it was a more open market, and indeed it didn’t start growing rapidly until the government started getting out of the way in the 80s.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:32PM (#17893276)
England, France and the US have vested interests in China not growing, atleast a very powerful minority do. Opening markets when these foreign actors very recently attacked your population is basically suicide.

Open markets require a certain level of development. Post-Xi (and his anti-corruption measures), this will be possible.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by TheAceOfHearts on Saturday September 01, 2018 @04:32PM (#17893765)
> England, France and the US have vested interests in China not growing, atleast a very powerful minority do.

I'll admit I don't know much about China, but this seems like a very board statement. Could you expand on it a bit? What powerful minority are you thinking of? Aren't they already growing? I mean, China has pretty much taken over a ton of manufacturing.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by gerdesj on Saturday September 01, 2018 @06:18PM (#17894188)
You are responding to "IllogicalLogic" who whitters on about England, France and the US!

I'd get my fake news elsewhere:

* England is just one part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

* Germany's economy is rather bigger than either the UK or FR - why not mention them?

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @08:46PM (#17894766)
I generally use England interchangeably with Britian for Opium War related statements, because the main actors (and beneficiaries) at the end of the day were English, not Irish, not Australian, etc... down the list.

Germans werent huge Opium pushers at the time (compared to the English, French, and American). So score 1 for Germany, good decision on their part.

I would expect not having major part of your economy propped up by illcit trading has long term positive consequences, Germany is enjoying the fruits of that to some extent.

You can predict what people with ill-gotten gains do with their money (it's a different discussion but consider what corruption costs society/economy when looking at the 2nd and 3rd order effects of corrupt money).

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by mr_toad on Saturday September 01, 2018 @07:17PM (#17894416)
> Opening markets when these foreign actors very recently attacked your population is basically suicide.

Opening markets in Europe immediately afte WW2 were a major contributor to preventing another European war.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Paris_(1951)

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by Nomentatus on Saturday September 01, 2018 @09:15PM (#17894901)
Well, yeah, defeat utterly then open markets, that would work.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by antidesitter on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:47PM (#17893330)
> Opening markets when these foreign actors very recently attacked your population is basically suicide.

Do you have evidence to support this claim? You seem to be conflating these countries’ governments with their businesses.

Also, can you clarify what you mean by “attacked their population”?

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:08PM (#17893432)
>"Also, can you clarify what you mean by “attacked their >population”?"

The opium epedemic and wars drove the Chinese economy into the ground.

British invasion and colonization of India pushed one of the top trading nations and #1 GDP (China & India competed to maintain #1 status for 2000 years) in the world into the ground.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:26PM (#17893512)
The decline of the Qing dynasty drove the economy into the ground even before the British started opium there. China loves to blame foreigners for all of their problems, but a lot of it was self inflicted.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:39PM (#17893570)
Your timeline is a little off. The Qing dynasty decline was partly to blame but be sure that almost 1/4 of Chinese young adults under the age 25 being addicted to illegal opium (thanks to western traders) didn't help. If you think that wasn't a contributing factor, it is being ahistorical.

US and Western Europe is facing this growing opioid issue today (during an economic decline), if we are not careful, we will see very clearly the effects (both socially and economically) of opioids poisoning the gene pool en masse.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday September 01, 2018 @04:00PM (#17893652)
That is like blaming the Mongolians for the fall of the Song Dynasty? Symptomatic of a dynasty in decline? Yes. Causal of that decline? No.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @04:17PM (#17893722)
So western power invading and enslaving China's major trading partners and drugging their population had 0 negative economic effect?

It seems the history books you have been exposed to detail a narrative that economic/trade flow history (narrative independent) does not recognize...

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday September 01, 2018 @06:44PM (#17894282)
No, it was symptomatic of a declining dynasty, it didn’t cause the decline in the first place. And even then, it wasn’t as comprehensive as you describe, the Japanese did way more damage to the Qing than the british did.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @09:49PM (#17895042)
Japan did alot of damage at the latter end of the Qing Dynasty too, yes (same time as peak opium epedemic/imports).

What followed a decade after was very telling though (I will skip the Boxer Rebellion but worth reading up on)....

Boxer Rebellion (somewhat Euro-centric perspective, but I will leave it to your objectivity, to see the otherside) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TFjHff-zaKY

In 1905, Roosevelt signed a secret treaty with the Japanese on his Imperial Cruise, allowing them to expand into Korea and the rest of Asia.

I don't blame you for not knowing this history, most US historians are/were unaware. Even congress was unaware of the treaty until the documents were released many many years later (post nobel peace prize being handed out).

It's a big part of why most Americans believed Pearl Harbor was potentially a precursor to a Japanese invasion attempt... When it was actually just a slap for breaking a 4 decade long secret treaty that greenlit Japanese expansion (USA renegged on this treaty during the 2nd Sino-Japanese war).

Imperial Cruise https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0AJ59vqzzg

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by reaperducer on Saturday September 01, 2018 @07:13PM (#17894397)
The opium epedemic and wars drove the Chinese economy into the ground.

You mean the ones from the 1800's? Seriously?

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Monday September 03, 2018 @10:31AM (#17902767)
You need a history lesson (most Americans do)

The Coming War on China (2016) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rTVwLNhojI

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:56PM (#17893375)
Trump is actively setting trade/economic policy considering 18-19th century history (economic history more specifically).

Remember the Opium Wars and the families it made rich (most famous, Coolidge (descendants of Thomas Jefferson), Roosevelts (through the Delano family), Forbes (John Kerry's family), etc.. in the US). On the otherside of the pond, in 1890 (peak opium crisis), 30% of Britain's GDP was illegal opium smuggling to China.

https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2017/3/30/opium-at-harvar...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell_%26_Company

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0AJ59vqzzg

The seperator between government and companies isn't as big as you think when this much multi-generational wealth and political power is invloved.

Kind of funny that many don't know their own history (Roman history is tough...going through 300 years of US history is trivially easy but most still don't).

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by mirimir on Saturday September 01, 2018 @08:37PM (#17894718)
Yes, there's lots of ugly in US history. It's been very effectively suppressed. Most Americans will think that you're some sort of conspiracy theorist :(

And by the way, US tobacco manufacturers also managed to addict most of Southeast Asia. I highly recommend Drugs and Rights by Douglas N. Husak (Rutgers, 1992).[0]

0) https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/drugs-and-rights/0C9669...

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @09:55PM (#17895068)
Economic history has less incentive to lie and it's hard to retroactively change 100 years of accounting/trade history to maintain a fake national narrative.

Remember in international trade, atleast 3 seperate entities end up with copies of every transaction (buyer/seller/shipper).

It's why I consider it more trustworthy...

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/business-history-rev...

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by mirimir on Saturday September 01, 2018 @10:18PM (#17895146)
Thanks. Great paper.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by redditmigrant on Saturday September 01, 2018 @11:47PM (#17895421)
If co-relation isnt causation then you can say the same about becoming an open market too right? Also, there is a difference between government ownership of enterprises, private but domestic ownership and foreign ownership. China has tried to ensure that important businesses are owned domestically.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by firasd on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:33PM (#17892941)
Fair enough, but China's main growth strategy was exporting manufactured goods. I'm not sure it is repeatable...
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by toomuchtodo on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:17PM (#17892840)
China requires non-Chinese auto manufacturers to buy Chinese batteries for their EVs, but Chinese auto manufacturers are free to buy superior Korean batteries for their vehicles. Make someone else bootstrap your industries. It's smart economic policy.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by baybal2 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:41PM (#17892976)
Lets take a look at your claim in details.

Indeed, batteries are not included in list of components that can be imported duty free to bonded customs zones, as they don't qualify for being "electronic components."

But the situation is the same for all bulk commodities that have to be locally sourced. That is dictated by the initial purpose of free customs zones: give concessions on high value components, but for whatever Chinese industry was good at manufacturing back in nineties, give none.

The companies wanting to make EVs, are completely free to establish companies outside of free customs zones if they don't want to pay double duty.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by toomuchtodo on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:05PM (#17893133)
Were any of my claims not accurate?
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by baybal2 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:32PM (#17893536)
Foreign companies can go outside of free customs zones and pay duties as every other Chinese company. That's the point.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by thecleaner on Sunday September 02, 2018 @10:59AM (#17897205)
Theres a whole book about it that makes the claim that development is impossible without state intervention - how asia works. The anecdetoal evidence there is rather compelling.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by naiveai on Sunday September 02, 2018 @02:46AM (#17895940)
So compelling, with a dictator, closed-off information and all. So utterly compelling.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by danbolt on Saturday September 01, 2018 @10:37PM (#17895203)
I want to note that in Canada a lot of government data storage is required by law to be on Canadian soil. From what I understand this is to help mitigate a foreign actor from accessing your data (eg: a search warrant in the US could pull up photos of me from my Google Drive account).

I can’t speak for what it’s like in India though, and I can understand how having data locally can be an avenue for corruption like you say.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by cryptozeus on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:24PM (#17892553)
Yeh but isn’t that currently done by googles and Faceboos of the world ?
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by firasd on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:28PM (#17892574)
Right now if the government wants some information from Facebook they have to go through a whole process... if the info is duplicated on a server hosted by a subsidiary in India, we don't have strong protections where you can just send a questioning policeman away by saying, "get a warrant."

In my view this is not just an 'India' thing, I'm kinda skeptical of the general anti-tech panic that's been brewing over the last couple years. I think the status quo is pretty good and don't want a bunch of government regulators from the US, Europe, China, India etc to be getting all up in Google's business telling them how to run Youtube.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by eklavya on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:44PM (#17892667)
It’s like the whole prism thing never happened. Leave out US from all such discussions. They have everybody’s data.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by firasd on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:50PM (#17892693)
We know the NSA sucks up a ton of internet traffic but what I'm referring to under the umbrella of tech debates is, for example, the wide availability of encryption (so random traffic cops can't unlock your phone), which is an ongoing debate in the US and also mentioned in this article about India.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:06PM (#17893135)
So, we just default to all data being siphoned into the US so it has a monopoly on PII (personal identifiable information)...? Seriously, no way any asian country should trust foreign countries, that very recently invaded/enslaved them, with their data.

China, India, Russia, etc... all have domestic populations that need to flex their political muscle to achieve freedom in their respective countries, the west can't and won't save you unless there is big money involved (with that money will come foreign corruption)...

Protip: Solve your problems locally, and reap the economic benefit of building your own Indian/Chinese Google... it isn't rocket science and the exercise will be good for your people.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by wtmt on Monday September 03, 2018 @07:18AM (#17901884)
> In my view this is not just an 'India' thing, I'm kinda skeptical of the general anti-tech panic that's been brewing over the last couple years. I think the status quo is pretty good and don't want a bunch of government regulators from the US, Europe, China, India etc to be getting all up in Google's business telling them how to run Youtube.

Exactly.

And I'd also rather we have end-to-end encryption being commonly available so that no options, except perhaps normal cellular telephony, can be trivially tapped by governments.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by cryptozeus on Sunday September 02, 2018 @01:23PM (#17897740)
Sure because fb, google knows how to protect your data ..eh ! I agree with your general view point but no one side is right here. Solution is complicated
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by xae342 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:42PM (#17892657)
I know Russia and Indonesia have laws for this reason you mention too.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by stevemoonto on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:41PM (#17892643)
it is about economy. India missed the opportunity to make money compare to China where there are lots of home grown company by forcing outside not to penetrate their market
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by hourislate on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:06PM (#17892776)
They exported their best talent to innovate for other countries. The only way they can capture some of the wealth these innovations create is to force manufacturers to do it in country.

Strange that they see no value in creating and more in manufacturing.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by lotsofpulp on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:29PM (#17892914)
They see the value, everyone does. They're just not able to execute because it's a country made up of a dozen little countries that all want their share and more.

To do the kind of manufacturing and industrialization China did in the time it did, you need a top down organization that does whatever is needed without having to waste time with people's "rights".

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:10PM (#17893157)
True, people in the west expect every country is ready for free markets and freedom of speech from the get go...nope.

Requires a certain level of development before freedom should be introduced. Especially post colonization, where colonial corruption agents are not fully removed from power in the systems in place.

[dead]
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by dang on Monday September 03, 2018 @02:29AM (#17900769)
This crosses into nationalistic flamewar, which is what we don't want on Hacker News. Please don't foment flames here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @08:35PM (#17894707)
In modern competitive markets, regaining economic dominance (without the sword) will take time, yes.

Can't actively attack people for 150 years+ (Chinese, see Imperial Cruise, Secret Japan Treaty of 1905) and expect them to, through peaceful means, dig themselves out in less than the time the attack was sustained.

I'm sure many in the west are ready to move on but usually the criminal doesnt decide when it's time to move on, the victim does.

Hence the usefulness in avoiding criminality.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by reaperducer on Saturday September 01, 2018 @09:35PM (#17894990)
Germany, Japan, and every other country that's been on the losing end of a fight would probably disagree.

Heck, Britain burned down America's White House, and they became best friends and important trading partners again in just a few years.

I think it's time to move on and stop blaming other countries for China's problems.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @11:20PM (#17895358)
None of the countries you mention sustained a multi-century attack by foreign powers... most endured less than a decade of attacks due to either being an ally/ or racially similar (lets not forget how racist we Europeans were, gladly many have reformed).

Also China is passing/will pass USA (and the world) in most important economic metrics this decade. So, some of your wishes are actively being answered in reality.

USA shouldn't blame itself for being passed though, can't hold down a multi-millenia spanning superpower for long, the Chinese people are resilient (and they have a lot of proof of work). Just hope Trump doesn't destroy what could be a great peaceful freindship between nations.

[dead]
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by hungryhobo on Sunday September 02, 2018 @06:49AM (#17896505)
Wow seriously? By what metrics?
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by IllogicalLogic on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:07PM (#17893141)
India hasn't missed anything, India rising is just beginning. Training abroad and repatraiting talent is quite common sense in the grand scheme of things.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by Marly32 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:58PM (#17893385)
Except no Indian is going to go back given the opportunity to stay in US/UK/AUS etc.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by throwaway6789 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:28PM (#17893516)
I am from India. I just got my I140 (for green card) approved and got 3 year extension for my h1b that is valid till half of 2021. I am going back next month. I don't want to spent the next 50-150 years being an h1b slave.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by xaranke on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:25PM (#17893507)
That's not true, anecdotally I know people who did and if you search you can find many more examples.
Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by chimeracoder on Saturday September 01, 2018 @01:49PM (#17893035)
> As an Indian I'm not sure I endorse all this as 'anti-colonialism'. This is a bunch of government bureaucrats who want e.g. data to be stored in the country so they can access personal info more easily...

As someone who's also Indian, and also remembers Indian pre-colonial and colonial history, I'm entirely on board with taking active measures to ensure we don't repeat the past.

Yes, all governments have an incentive to spy on their citizens - just look at Australia or the US or the UK. But India has very legitimate reasons to oppose foreign control of its technological infrastructure. And unlike those other countries, India has also established a right to privacy.

Re:India Pushes Back Against Tech ‘Colonization’ by Internet... by throwaway6789 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:29PM (#17893522)
Same here. As another Indian who wants India to be self sustaining, its high time we start focusing on creating a organic growth environment for Indian companies.