News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by faitswulff on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:31PM (#17886892)
I found it interesting that the espionage is largely aimed at the private sector and not the government:

> About 70 percent of China’s overall espionage is aimed at the U.S. private sector, rather than the government, said Joshua Skule, the head of the FBI’s intelligence division, which is charged with countering foreign espionage in the United States.

> “They are conducting economic espionage at a rate that is unparalleled in our history,” he said.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by dfsegoat on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:49PM (#17887019)
Think of a scenario where certain government employees have accounts on some Private sector service: Maybe a Grindr or Tinder -- if they can work to obtain any sort of compromising information from those services - they can then use it to manipulate government employees ("Do what I say, or i'll out you")... In fact, pretty sure a Chinese co. recently obtained controlling interest of Grindr.

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/12/technology/grindr-sells-s...

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by JumpCrisscross on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:59PM (#17887109)
> Maybe a Grindr

Which is owned by a mainland Chinese firm [1].

[1] https://money.cnn.com/2016/01/12/technology/grindr-china-bei...

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by nostromo on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:12PM (#17887213)
We can inoculate ourselves to this threat by not caring about what politicians, government workers, and other people in general do in their private romantic lives.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by wlesieutre on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:31PM (#17888447)
"Do what I say or your wife finds out you're cheating on her" is still leverage even if the public doesn't care that you did it.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by bilbo0s on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:19PM (#17887733)
Just the reverse. Because a target can be compromised by what they do in their private lives, we, (meaning our intelligence people), have to care about what they are doing in their private lives.

I'd imagine that in the game of compromising targets, it doesn't really matter what the general public thinks of the target's behaviors or actions. The only thing that matters is that the target have a psychological profile consistent with wanting to keep their behavior or actions secret. As long as the target has the requisite characteristics with respect to ego, that target can probably be compromised if you can find something on them.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by GW150914 on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:36PM (#17888474)
Even if I buy your idea that human nature can change that way (and I don’t) you only tackled the ‘C’ in MICE. How do you solve Money, Ideology and Ego?
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by x3n0ph3n3 on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:29PM (#17887359)
Well, a think a spouse might justifiably care in the case of cheating.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by scottlegrand2 on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:09PM (#17887665)
At which point that's just the cycle of karma closing the loop, no?
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by 394549 on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:20PM (#17887742)
> At which point that's just the cycle of karma closing the loop, no?

You misunderstand. No one cares about Alice's personal life, karma, or happiness. All they care about is manipulating Alice and what a manipulated Alice might do. Alice's desire to hide her cheating from her spouse could lead Bob's trade secrets to getting stolen. Bob did nothing wrong here to have his "cycle of karma closing the loop."

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by scottlegrand2 on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:15PM (#17888349)
Never give Alice your passwords and always have a lock code on your cell phone. Anything else is a moral hazard in my opinion. Bob is complicit in this case IMO.

If my spouse were to attempt to extract data from my work laptop she would run smack-dab into my password. If on the other hand Bob has extracted highly confidential data onto a freely available machine, then Bob is not only complicit, Bob is culpable. Don't be Bob.

If we take this further and Bob's employer made it that easy to extract highly confidential data then they are their own worst enemy.

For example, if a foolish Google employee attempts to stalk an ex-partners confidential data from within Google, they will be terminated and escorted out of the building within 60 minutes. Be like Google here.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by 394549 on Tuesday September 04, 2018 @01:00PM (#17910614)
You misunderstand again. Bob isn't Alice's spouse, he's Alice's employer. Bob legitimately gave Alice access to confidential information in order to do her job. But, unknown to him (unless he intrusively investigated her personal life), Alice could be blackmailed into abusing that access because she cheated on her spouse.

Bob isn't "complicit" or "culpable" he's a victim.

I think you're overconfident in simple security measures and have a poor understanding of human security threats.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by nyolfen on Friday August 31, 2018 @08:20PM (#17889385)
i read the example as alice being an employee of bob, not a spouse
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by jules on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:19PM (#17887736)
It is not karma if the country ends up paying, though.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by jfaioif3 on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:50PM (#17887533)
Now we will also get a few posts normalising cheating.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by mistermann on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:10PM (#17887676)
I don't think the general public can.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by Timmah on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:25PM (#17887769)
Hopefully the agencies have already thought of this, but it would be pretty easy to set up a honeypot with a veteran TS or higher clearance employee and tell him to set up fake accounts and see who comes knocking.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by sorokod on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:22PM (#17887290)
I think that in China, the separation between government and private business activities is quite fuzzy and the Chinese are ok with treating their intel resources in the same fuzzy manner.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by dqpb on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:14PM (#17887223)
China has a large enough population that they could literally assign a dedicated spy for every single American and still have a billion people left over.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by 394549 on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:39PM (#17886962)
> I found it interesting that the espionage is largely aimed at the private sector and not the government

It's not that surprising though. One of their main focuses seems to be acquiring technology to catch up and eventually surpass Western liberal democracies. See their "Made in China 2025" effort: https://www.cfr.org/blog/why-does-everyone-hate-made-china-2....

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by horsecaptin on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:13PM (#17888643)
China is not a market. It is a very large vendor and customer with many departments. This isn't good or evil, but it may be depending on who you are and what you're willing to stand for.

In a traditional market, the organizers set rules for vendors and customers. The same rules apply to anyone should they decide to become a vendor or customer, but organizers usually avoid becoming a vendor because of obvious conflicts of interest.

If you are a vendor then your customers in China are basically some subsidiary of the very large organization that is China. If you are a customer then you are basically buying from a subsidiary. Since you are dealing with subsidiaries, you have to understand that all the subsidiaries are encouraged to share information with each other to build a stronger China.

Building deeper relationships with a subsidiary means building deeper relations with the whole organization and that means satisfying deeper requirements (taxes, knowledge sharing, local factory, IP sharing, equity sharing). All this is normal if you are say, just two companies doing business with each other. But you aren't. You are a company doing business with an organization who you may be misunderstanding for a market.

Finally, theres the case where two companies merge and share all resources to become a stronger, better organization. Unlike many other countries, the Chinese identity is very much an ethnic and a lingual one. This means that if you are not Chinese, you will never be Chinese. If you aren't already Chinese, then the chances that you will be able to move to China should China become a prosperous society are slim to none.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by checkyoursudo on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:50PM (#17887534)
Seems reasonable that the Chinese feel like they have more to gain through economic espionage against the US than they do through political espionage.

I would guess there are countries against whom the Chinese would do the opposite, where economic espionage isn't worthwhile but compromising the government is.

The US, on the other hand, probably has more to gain through political espionage against the Chinese than through economic espionage.

All depends on what you think you need?

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by monocasa on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:59PM (#17887600)
> I would guess there are countries against whom the Chinese would do the opposite, where economic espionage isn't worthwhile but compromising the government is.

Yep, in Africa, and probably along their "New Silk Road".

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by marmot777 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:40AM (#17890596)
Isn't it sort of sad that they are stealing technology rather than making use of their own talents? Individuals don't feel good when they steal, so it must have some sort of effect on a society.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by checkyoursudo on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:42PM (#17893586)
Is it sad, as a society? I don't know.

For me, personally, yeah, it's very dishonorable to my worldview. I would prefer alliances and collaboration and the betterment of all people rather than protectionism and distrust and zero-sum attitudes and behaviors.

Hypothetically, what if their talents were indeed to steal stuff and get ahead by appropriating the work of others? Would it then be sad if they didn't put those talents to good use?

I have no idea if all people do or don't feel good when they steal, but I would have guessed that some people do in fact feel good when they steal. Perhaps the badness that the people-who-do-the-stealing-for-their-society feel is outweighed by the overall goodness that the rest of society feels because of their advancement in (stolen) technology and the economic and societal benefits that come with that?

But, yes, in the end, I personally would rather not have some technology than to acquire it by means contrary to my values. I know an awful lot of people whom I believe, or even know, would either say the opposite or would be indifferent.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by robotbikes on Saturday September 01, 2018 @03:48PM (#17893609)
Or perhaps it isn't seen through the lens of intellectual property. It could seen as gaining knowledge that would allow one to build things they would otherwise not. From what I understand the Chinese culture treats IP very differently than the US. It isn't treated as being owned but people share documentation and the like with people they like. Westerners have a much more legalistic framework for how we treat our ideas. The notion that someone should be able to use the force of the government to prevent others from using their idea isn't necessarily a given but instead the result of certain traditions and institutions. I know the US corporations would like to push these ideas into being part of a binding framework of world trade but this primarily benefits the large corporations that have invested in research, accumulated patents and want to control the world so that they can profit.

A lot of the espionage is probably also about gaining knowledge about firms for the purpose of understanding their weaknesses and the lay of the land vs. simply figuring out their secret sauce. I remember reading this was a common practice for Russian intelligence agents who didn't trust the official numbers and so wanted to gain proprietary knowledge from industry insiders.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by marmot777 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @10:39PM (#17895208)
Yes, I agree it’s cultural norms and so on but stealing IP is stealing the product of a lot of hard work. Imagine if you had an idea stored in a document and someone just stole it. There’s a certain universality about theft being wrong at a gut level.

Also, much of this theft involves breaking into other peoples computers. It’s wilfull violation of someone else in multiple ways. Breaking into a computer is as low as robbing a liquor store and I suspect thst everyone, even the perpetrators, feels that at a vicersl level.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by monocasa on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:43PM (#17886986)
Why? That's the proven strategy to leapfrog yourself into a developed economy. It's what the US, Germany, and Japan all did.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by toast_coder on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:51PM (#17887035)
The US, Germany, and Japan are all technology leaders. None of those nations leapfrogged into a developed nation by copying others.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by yourbandsucks on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:13PM (#17887218)
Funny story, heavy industry in the US was started by a guy who, realizing the British would check his luggage for documents, memorized all the plans and ideas he stole.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Cabot_Lowell

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by Kagerjay on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:02PM (#17887623)
uh...

Japan was practically given a lot of American Technology right after WWII under Robert Demings. In fact, Toyota is partially the way it is today, thanks to the Ford Assembly Line, but they still paved there own means of success.

Germany arguably the same as well, around the same time frame. Can't recall the exact history of what US gave to Germany though, but it was most likely part of the Marshall Plan.

US is copying a lot of methodologies and philosophies from Japan. Any deriative of the Toyota way is in many management philosophies, from scrum, agile development, etc. Germany, much technology is still being shared between both our countries today. Japan is copying a lot of software innovations from America, and vice versa.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by vvanders on Friday August 31, 2018 @03:56PM (#17888245)
Yeah, This American Life had a great podcast about the NUMMI[1] plant that covers this in great depth. Pretty fascinating stuff.

[1] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/561/nummi-2015

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by monocasa on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:13PM (#17887219)
In addition to what others have said, the Merchandise Marks of Act 1887 was passed in Britain to require all foreign made items to have a country of origin listed. This was mainly so that British consumers could see that something was a cheap German knockoff.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by g8oz on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:30PM (#17888442)
A counterexample: In WW1 German patents were declared invalid in the U.S. The U.S chemical industry basically then copied everything they could from them with the government's blessing.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by scarejunba on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:30PM (#17887362)
Can't wait for the 2060 version: "Unlike Brazil or India, China is a technology leader. It didn't copy others."
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by ISL on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:56PM (#17887078)
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by oh_sigh on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:24PM (#17887307)
Being familiar with a machine, and taking that knowledge elsewhere seems qualitatively different from wholesale copying of documents and blueprints.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by monocasa on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:29PM (#17887358)
> He learned of the American interest in developing similar machines, and he was also aware of British laws against exporting the designs. He therefore memorized as much as he could and departed for New York in 1789.

Textile mills at the time were the modern day equivalent of semiconductor foundries. I dare you to try something like that today and see what happens to you.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by oh_sigh on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:23PM (#17888395)
You're allowed to walk away from a job and retain the knowledge you learned in that job.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by monocasa on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:40PM (#17888495)
Not when "he was also aware of British laws against exporting the designs".

And semiconductor technology is generally considered a national secret.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by vkou on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:34PM (#17888466)
Not if what you know is a trade secret, that you have signed an NDA on.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by scarejunba on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:31PM (#17887373)
This is really nothing different from Anthony Lewandowski and friends.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by oh_sigh on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:24PM (#17888402)
It would be more like if Uber hired levandowski and he didn't (allegedly) walk away with gigabytes of info and only walked with what was in his own head
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by scarejunba on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:24PM (#17888700)
Things have changed since then. It's the same data. Your means of recording it has just changed.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by msie on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:44PM (#17887488)
Really? I remembered when the Americans accused the Japanese of copying.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by vkou on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:37PM (#17887828)
This is patently false. Industrial espionage, or just plain-old gifts (To keep the commies out) kickstarted the manufacturing economies of all three of those countries.

Of course, once you become a manufacturing leader, you want to pull the ladder up from under you, in the form of strong IP laws.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:19PM (#17887732)
The US and Japan most certainly did industrialize by copying from Europe. Ignoring IP whenever it was inconvenient.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by iooi on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:58PM (#17887097)
Ah yeah, I remember reading about that in my American History textbook! We started the industrial revolution right after we signed the declaration of independence, it was the British who copied us.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by marmot777 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:41AM (#17890599)
There's a difference between copying and outright theft.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by ProAm on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:53PM (#17887058)
It would be humorous if they recruited employees of startups, the philosophy of moving fast and break things along with spends as much money as possible as fast as you can will have China using sub-par software and bankrupt within months, countries can't pivot and looking for exit through acquisition would be nigh impossible!
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by scarejunba on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:27PM (#17888710)
What's an anti-startup dude even doing on HN? Makes no sense.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by WJW on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:39PM (#17887839)
Some people would argue that this has already happened.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by aurailious on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:09PM (#17887668)
Because private sector is incredibly easy to steal from. At least the government actually cares about it.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:15PM (#17887698)
> At least the government actually cares about it.

Unless you're OPM and you can't be bothered to follow NSA guidelines. Or you're the military and think having sensitive documents on a loosely secured SharePoint server is a great idea.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by marmot777 on Saturday September 01, 2018 @02:38AM (#17890583)
Econ theft seems to be their main goal. It's a shame they they feel they have to lower themslves to stealing secrets when they have their own capabilities that they should have enough confidence in to not have to steal.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by monksy on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:33PM (#17886908)
They do target the government workers as well. (Well I guess I should say other people do) People target those on linked in who have listed security clearances.
Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by ptero on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:44PM (#17886991)
> People target those on linked in who have listed security clearances.

Maybe, but I think they have a much better source: I suspect OPM data taken has been sold and lent out so they do not need to trust linked in; they can go directly to the source ( https://www.opm.gov/cybersecurity/cybersecurity-incidents/ ). I wonder if it also contains "concerns" that can indicate weak points for recruiting for a true one-stop shopping?

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by 394549 on Friday August 31, 2018 @12:51PM (#17887037)
> I wonder if it also contains "concerns" that can indicate weak points for recruiting for a true one-stop shopping?

It does. IIRC, it contained security clearance investigation files, so they could probably identify people who had issues but just squeaked by the process.

But that's not the only use. The OPM data could be used for counterintelligence, to identify US agents in the field.

Re:Chief U.S. spy catcher says China using LinkedIn to recru... by weliketocode on Friday August 31, 2018 @02:01PM (#17887612)
Interesting talking point, but they must be lumping a number of companies with government contracts into the private sector as well.

Still, curious to see some sort of hierarchy around motivations/emphasis for:

- top secret private info (defense or otherwise)

- regular private sector info

- public sector info related to government contracts

- public sector info related to IP or tech

- public or private sector info on important people