Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by fsniper on Friday August 31, 2018 @03:29AM
(#17883625)
Isn't the title misleading? Article says there have been a vote, but the result was against removing him. Title leads you to believe that motion was accepted.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by mirimir on Friday August 31, 2018 @03:47AM
(#17883714)
Yes. Especially because ...
> More than 86 million shares voted against the proposal at a shareholder meeting in June, while fewer than 17 million voted in favor, Tesla said.
... and ...
> BlackRock funds are a top-10 Tesla stockholder, controlling nearly 6.5 million of Tesla’s 170 million shares, according to Thomson Reuters data based on public filings.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by mirimir on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:13AM
(#17883821)
OK. But why do we care how BlackRock voted? What makes them newsworthy, regarding Tesla or whatever? I could google it, but the article doesn't make it very clear.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by pvg on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:22AM
(#17883852)
It's a big shareholder voting for one of those somewhat-off-the-beaten-path proposals that often get zero support from big shareholders. That's about it. It's a pretty basic newswire service report. Does it belong on HN? Probably not. I voted for it not being on the front page!
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by mirimir on Friday August 31, 2018 @06:32AM
(#17884398)
Thanks. I could have googled that, I know. But I was rather expecting the article to make some argument. It did quote BlackRock about standing for "shareholder value", whatever that is. But I was wondering whether it was just a catfight, or stock manipulation, or whether BlackRock was standing for something fundamental.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by pvg on Monday September 03, 2018 @06:48AM
(#17901763)
It was 'BlackRock voted to replace Tesla's Musk with independent chairman' when it was posted, it's still that now. What do you think a non-Blackrock-involving headline would have been?
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by dragonwriter on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:18AM
(#17883839)
No, “A voted to Y” where A is a voter (or a subset of all voters) means “A cast its vote in support of position Y”, and doesn't say anything about the outcome of the vote.
This is syntactically identical, though disambiguated by semantic context, from the same structure where A identifies the electorate rather than one or more voters that do not make up the whole of the electorate. In that case, “A votes to Y means that the electorate named held a vote in which Y was the winning alternative.”
As this was a Tesla shareholder vote, “Blackrock voted to...” is an example of the first usage, while “Tesla shareholders voted to...” would be an example of the second.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by brobdingnagians on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:17AM
(#17883835)
Ambiguity of English language to logic in translation. `Congress voted to X` means that X is planned to be done. `I voted for X as President` does not mean that X is planning to be President.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by rdl on Saturday September 01, 2018 @12:38AM
(#17890234)
Fuck BlackRock. Aside from their weird anti-2A politics (maybe driven by their fund managers, maybe driven by LPs), now they are trying to kill Tesla?
(Driving Musk out as chairman might not itself cause serious problems, but it could also be a prelude to replacing him, which would be the end of Tesla.). It is pretty telling that their vote was at variance to most of the other institutions.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by TangoTrotFox on Friday August 31, 2018 @04:24AM
(#17883861)
I was going to say this headline seems geared to mislead. But really it's the existence of the article itself.
Apparently there was a recent vote about replacing Musk as chairman. The vote was overwhelmingly defeated with more than 83% voting to keep Musk. Instead of running an article on this Reuters seemingly chose to run an article highlighting a seemingly random minority holder voting for the replacement, with the result mentioned as a numeric aside. This feels like Spin.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by dagw on Friday August 31, 2018 @05:23AM
(#17884103)
BlackRock is far from a "seemingly random minority holder". They are the largest asset manager in world, with by all accounts has more assets under management than the 10 biggest sovereign wealth funds combined.
Re:BlackRock voted for proposal to replace Tesla’s Musk with...
by cmmartin on Friday August 31, 2018 @01:21PM
(#17887276)
Seriously misleading headline. They didn't vote to replace him at all. They voted to add another executive (A COO). He would have remained CEO. Also, the vote failed.
> More than 86 million shares voted against the proposal at a shareholder meeting in June, while fewer than 17 million voted in favor, Tesla said.
... and ...
> BlackRock funds are a top-10 Tesla stockholder, controlling nearly 6.5 million of Tesla’s 170 million shares, according to Thomson Reuters data based on public filings.
So who cares how BlackRock voted?
> Yes. Especially because...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BlackRock
I think a lot of people would consider how BlackRock voted to be newsworthy and follow their lead based on their size and expertise.
Additionally, it's clear the vote went the other way, because otherwise the headline would have been very different.
This is syntactically identical, though disambiguated by semantic context, from the same structure where A identifies the electorate rather than one or more voters that do not make up the whole of the electorate. In that case, “A votes to Y means that the electorate named held a vote in which Y was the winning alternative.”
As this was a Tesla shareholder vote, “Blackrock voted to...” is an example of the first usage, while “Tesla shareholders voted to...” would be an example of the second.
(Driving Musk out as chairman might not itself cause serious problems, but it could also be a prelude to replacing him, which would be the end of Tesla.). It is pretty telling that their vote was at variance to most of the other institutions.
Apparently there was a recent vote about replacing Musk as chairman. The vote was overwhelmingly defeated with more than 83% voting to keep Musk. Instead of running an article on this Reuters seemingly chose to run an article highlighting a seemingly random minority holder voting for the replacement, with the result mentioned as a numeric aside. This feels like Spin.