Meanwhile, if the investor didn't want to sell at the number they came up with, they could presumably just say "no".
You are, yes, probably being too cynical here.
I wouldn't imagine that's the case. Especially if the investor came up with the number and agreed to it in a legally binding contract. It'd be an uphill battle in court to get around that. (yeah, you still need the funds to defend your company...)
Also, my anecdata says that most corporations have in their corporate bylaws (or whatever the right document is) the provision that they can forcibly recall shares at any time (presumably for current fair market value/409A valuation.)
It would be pretty funny if the legal norm among startups was that they can acquire their own equity back from investors based on their 409A valuation.
Maybe I've misread you here. Is this not a number the investors came up with?
As for the 9% interest rate, that starts sounding more like debt than ownership.
Again: it would be really weird if companies could simply demand their equity back. The whole point of investing in a startup is that their equity will end up wildly more valuable --- not 40% more, but 10x more --- than the money put in.
At any rate: they bought out their investors years before interest became due. It was a negotiated sale.
I guarantee you this has annoyed you more than a few times as a user of their products.
In a market where VC style multi billion dollar exists just isn't going to happen, trying to force it is just going to ruin everything good about your product and company.
And VCs would rather see you ruin it, with a tiny chance of succeeding, than see you have a successful small/medium sized company.
Employees obviously I can't know but the article includes him telling investors there might not be an exit.
Every time I've told myself that, I later found out that I wasn't.
Under capitalism, the world always presents itself as better than it is.
I read the fluff around core values, but my first thought is that Joel would rather not risk his personal fortune by growing the company further. Better to ride the 25% margin as long as possible, giving himself enough liquidity to retire wealthy, than take a chance on growth.
Maybe I'm too cynical, but I admit I'd be tempted to do the same thing.