Re:We Spent $3.3M Buying Out Investors: Why and How We Did It
by delinka on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @06:12PM
(#17872531)
"...at the number they came up with..."
Maybe I've misread you here. Is this not a number the investors came up with?
As for the 9% interest rate, that starts sounding more like debt than ownership.
Re:We Spent $3.3M Buying Out Investors: Why and How We Did It
by tptacek on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @06:19PM
(#17872571)
Yes. That is the idea. As downside protection, Collaborative Fund's investment was to begin behaving as if it were debt (issuing interest, that is) after 5 years. I assume the expectation was that if Buffer maintained hypergrowth and reached the inevitable Series B, part of the series B negotiation would eliminate that downside protection clause. But they didn't; they charted a course that didn't involve an imminent second round, and so that protection clause was problematic.
Again: it would be really weird if companies could simply demand their equity back. The whole point of investing in a startup is that their equity will end up wildly more valuable --- not 40% more, but 10x more --- than the money put in.
Re:We Spent $3.3M Buying Out Investors: Why and How We Did It
by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @07:02PM
(#17872845)
Once the interest (aka "downside protection") kicks in, the shares effectively converted to debt, meaning the company was simply repaying a liability.
Re:We Spent $3.3M Buying Out Investors: Why and How We Did It
by tptacek on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @08:30PM
(#17873235)
Did I miss the part where they said that? The post suggests their counsel said it was a unique clause.
At any rate: they bought out their investors years before interest became due. It was a negotiated sale.
It would be pretty funny if the legal norm among startups was that they can acquire their own equity back from investors based on their 409A valuation.