News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by megaremote on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:12PM (#17864418)
> Why are companies promoting "pride"...telling workers to attend 'lgbt tolerance' meetings,etc... Wth!!!!

You ask this question, then answer it in your very next line. People don't respect everyone. They are intolerant.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by dang on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:27AM (#17865628)
That's much too shallow, generic, and flamebaity a tangent to lead anywhere other than a stupid ideological flamewar, which is what we got.

Ideological flamewars are stupid, even if the people contributing to them are smart. They're also repetitive, which makes them off topic here. So could you please not post like this again to HN?

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17864365 and marked it off-topic.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by badrabbit on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:22PM (#17864492)
Why is disrespecting or demeaning a coworker for any reason allowed? If I disrespect you because your haircut is unfashionable,would that be ok? If the meeting was about supporting neo-nazis ,would that not be saying the conmpany tolerates neo-nazis and does not welcome those who hate neo-nazism? Yet, you should respect your neo-nazi coworker,even if you were not told so.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by gameswithgo on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:27PM (#17864535)
It seems there are many valid reasons to disrespect a coworker, and being a neo-nazi is one of them.

You cannot hide a violent philosophy behind a shield of "it is my beliefs". None of us shall ever accept it. If it becomes the law that I must accept neo nazis, I still will not.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by badrabbit on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:31PM (#17864572)
No,they are your coworker. Period. They're not your friend. They are not promoting neo-nazi beliefs at work or direspecting other coworkers,what business of yours is their neo-nazi activity? Peace has a price.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by woodruffw on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:38PM (#17864618)
It's my business because, should they have it their way, I wouldn't be alive.

Asking people to be tolerant of ideologies that pose an existential threat is contradictory at best.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by smhost on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:57PM (#17864731)
The fact that this has to be explained at all shows just how much hacker news is overrun with fascist moral relativism. There's even a guy equating nazis with jews. What the fuck happened to you people?
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by austhrow743 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:53PM (#17865463)
People have cooperated with existential threats for economic gain for a very long time. Trade today, kill each other tomorrow. It's not contradictory at all.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by r00fus on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:27AM (#17865623)
And what kinds of societies and organizations so these dire situations blossom in? Crime organizations, autocratic regimes and slavery countries.

Sorry I don't want to work for or live in that kind of setting. I wouldn't want anyone to be forced to do so.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by woodruffw on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:13AM (#17865562)
This assumes that the software engineering market is so strapped for hires that it needs neo-Nazis. I don't buy that.

But more to the point: the contradiction isn't economic, it's linguistic. See the comment thread below.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by mc32 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:59PM (#17864743)
This is a difficult question. Communism has led to countless unjust senseless deaths. Many people alive would be dead in a traditionally communist regime. Should we make communism objectionable as a political ideology? (note: I am not saying naziism should not be objectionable, just that we have an equally deadly ideology that has some acceptance)

These things are fraught with complication.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by woodruffw on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:01PM (#17864758)
Communism, expressed as the kind that killed all those people, is objectionable. I object to it, and it seems like a broad segment of the population agrees.

However, that just isn't the same as what I'm describing. There is nothing analytical about communism that poses an existential threat to me. Neo-Nazism, on other other hand, is a priori incompatible with my existence.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by mc32 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:06PM (#17864806)
I do see this difference. However, in practice communism and faschism are pretty much two sides of the same coin. One has specific victims (though like communism, none stated, but there is always the out-group, I mean, you see Black African nazi sympathizers in Africa) communism also has an out-group: whether it be the owner-class or people who get in the way of their ideology.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by woodruffw on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:14PM (#17864869)
Sure, there's plenty of violence in the world. I am opposed to most forms of it.

But no, there is no equivocation here. One of these things (Neo-Nazism) is fundamentally incompatible, even just on the linguistic level, with my existence. The other (Communism) is undesirable and even reprehensible, but doesn't threaten the mode of discourse itself.

Put another way: proposing tolerance towards analytically intolerant ideas amounts to an "disagreement" between a linguistic claim and a claim about the language itself. I wrote about the danger of viewing these as normal "disagreements" about a week ago[1].

[1]: https://blog.yossarian.net/2018/08/20/Disagreement-Language-...

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by michaelmrose on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:52PM (#17864694)
You can't have peace with people who want to kill and oppress a significant portion of the population.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by yellowapple on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:34PM (#17864995)
Not with that attitude you can't.

Racists aren't (usually) racists for the fun of it. Racists are racists because they feel threatened by or lack sufficient exposure to / understanding of other races. If your goal is to cure racism, then making racists feel even more threatened is probably the least productive way of going about it.

Instead, the trick is to befriend them. Show them that there's nothing to fear. These people are more often than not just scared and confused; they're usually otherwise-decent people, and putting them at ease goes a long way toward letting them realize on their own that "hey, maybe my Jewish neighbors ain't so bad after all".

I know full well that the above is a lot easier said than done, but if you want a growling dog to stop growling at you, giving it treats is at least slightly more effective than yelling at it. On the former path, you might eventually tame the dog and get a friend out of the deal. On the latter path, it'll just growl louder and louder until it bites you.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ikeyany on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:16AM (#17865568)
No, the "trick" is not simply to befriend them. That is an incredibly simplistic and naive way to interpret hate, and it shows you haven't had to deal with racism strongly impacting your life. Not all bigotry is based in innocent misunderstanding. Sometimes it's intentionally strongly held convictions of derision and superiority.

The answer isn't to spew hate back at them, but it certainly isn't to make friends.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by yellowapple on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:11AM (#17866313)
In my experience, the vast majority of my racist family members and other acquaintances are such specifically because of a lack of understanding of and positive exposure to individuals of other races. Even the "strongly held convictions of derision and superiority" are more often than not compensation for a sense of fear rather than genuine belief in superiority.

I never said it was innocent misunderstanding, but it is still misunderstanding nonetheless, and it is still possible to at least start to correct this misunderstanding by alleviating the fear underlying it, thus making it easier for a racist individual to expose oneself to those "inferior" races and realize that they're just fellow human beings and not scary job-stealing world-order-establishing criminal boogeymen.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by UncleMeat on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:16AM (#17865576)
When has this ever worked at scale? All major social change to end oppression has been associated with large scale disruption and unrest.

How nice it must be to be in a group with power, where even if you are an unrepentant asshole and deny the humanity of others, those other people are obligated to be nice to you.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by yellowapple on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:59AM (#17866538)
It's not about obligation. It's about strategy and PR.

Re: whether or not it works at scale, it seems to have worked for Irish-Americans. It took awhile between the height of Irish immigration and the present day, but unlike in the 19th Century you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone unironically demanding Irish people to be deported or claiming Irish immigrants are stealing jobs. Similar deal for other previously-persecuted European immigrants and their descendants (Italians and Germans both come to mind). Asians are getting to that point, too; not really free of discrimination/prejudice, but even my most hatefully-racist acquaintances seem to at least tolerate their existence.

None of the above groups (to my knowledge) were all that socially disruptive (at least not intentionally); instead, they gradually integrated and blended with the existing demographics. Instead of Irish or German or Italian or English or French or Polish or Russian or what have you, we ended up with kind of a blended European demographic. I have a feeling Asians are on track to be part of that, too, and end up in a sort of blended "Eurasian" demographic. We ain't quite there yet, but I'd give it a couple decades before we are.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by tptacek on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:58PM (#17870245)
The word you're feeling around trying to find is "white".
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by detcader on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:59PM (#17870263)
Noel Ignatiev's "How the Irish Became White" is supposed to be a nice book on this subject
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by casiotone on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:41PM (#17865042)
> Instead, the trick is to befriend them. Show them that there's nothing to fear.

This doesn’t work[1]. Allowing parasitical ideology the space to express itself only emboldens it.

[1] All of recorded history

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by Izkata on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:29AM (#17865637)
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by casiotone on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:36PM (#17864603)
Pathetic. Their neo Nazi activity is my business because it’s infecting my community, it’s beating members of my community up and leaving them dying in the street. It’s making my community unsafe for people who have done nothing wrong. This capitulation of yours to dangerous, vicious belief systems is beneath contempt. We fight intolerance because it is never benign. It does not affect you but it affects others and you are willing to turn a blind eye and pretend everything is fine, because when YOU walk home, nobody is going to stomp your head into a curb.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by craigmcnamara on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:41PM (#17864635)
The price of peace has historically included kicking the shit out of Nazis and forcing them underground. Remember that thing they did that one time?
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by dang on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:28PM (#17870459)
Please don't bring the brutalist style of internet political battle onto this site. It's guaranteed to lead to the flaming shit we see below.

There are lots of other places on the web where you can practice this craft, but on HN we're trying to avoid the systemic effects it produces.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by sosense on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:54PM (#17864710)
Replace "Nazis" with "Jews" and see yourself for what you really are.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by dang on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:29PM (#17870468)
If you post ideological trolling like this again we will ban you.

Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and follow those rules when posting here.

[dead]
[dead]
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by casiotone on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @08:15AM (#17867608)
Oh no, your mind is clearly too far gone. I only want you to feel a deep shame.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by dang on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:30PM (#17870476)
If you post personal attacks like these again we will ban you.

Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and follow those rules when posting here.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by casiotone on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:05PM (#17871416)
Perhaps you could also put "Don't equate Nazis with the people they genocided" in there. I will not apologize nor will I stop attacking abhorrent people like this. It says a lot that my post is your priority and not the rest of the comments in this dumpster fire of a comment section.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by dang on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:17PM (#17871543)
It's not possible for us to read all the comments, which is what prioritizing them properly would require. Nor is it necessary, since other people breaking HN's rules doesn't authorize you to break them as well.

But if you look upthread you'll see that I was careful not to single you out, and if you read the thread as a whole you'll see that we put hours of effort into moderating it (though you'll need 'showdead' set to 'yes' in your profile, as well as to uncollapse a bunch of comments, to see a lot of it).

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by GW150914 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:46PM (#17865070)
The price of peace with these people was a world war. I’m not eager to see the price paid again, and I want to live where they want me dead. You can feel morally superior and hug a Nazi, I’ll stick with the more practical “Hetzjagd and Nazis.” I’m not interested in principle where people with no conscience or principles of their own are concerned, and I’m an adult who has standards in a world of standards. They’re not perfect, but they tend to get better with time and freedom to discuss them. “Kill the Jews/Blacks/Gays/etc” has been discussed extensively, then a war was fought. It’s over, the standard around Nazism is established as zero tolerance, and I for one am in favor of that. I’ll leave it to the paralytically anarchist/libertarian moral relativists to die on the hill of defending Nazis on principle.

In other words, my grandfather already paid the price for this peace in WWII, I’ll do my best to uphold it even in the face of the ideology which started that war.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by sidlls on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#17864558)
> If I disrespect you because your haircut is unfashionable,would that be ok?

No, that would be inappropriate. It would be equally inappropriate for someone to call a person who called out your inappropriate behavior disrespectful or intolerant. Similarly for your concern regarding neo-nazis.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by threeseed on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#17864552)
It’s not allowed.

But people can accidentally disrespect LGBT people eg. calling trans people by the incorrect gender.

And so to foster this workplace that you want as well it’s important for people to do things like tolerance training.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by lordCarbonFiber on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:27PM (#17864955)
I love how people get all up in arms about tolerance training. It's literally "hey these people are people too and here are ways to act so you don't inadvertartly contribute to an environment that might make them less productive workers". If your coworker is upset because they feel like they have to hide their significant other, their gender, etc at work everyone loses. This is in contrast to politics; you can decide to break from the GOP you can't decide to be less trans. The morons that equate the two are almost beyond hope.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:16PM (#17864450)
If an employee is harassing or demeaning their coworker based on their beliefs, that's enough grounds to fire an employee. Is there any evidence that promoting "pride" and "lgbt tolerance" makes employees treat each other well in cases where they otherwise wouldn't have?
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by austinheap on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:24PM (#17864511)
From Harvard Business Review:

"Results from our experiment involving 118 undergraduate students showed that taking the perspective of LGBT individuals or racial minorities — by writing a few sentences imagining the distinct challenges a marginalized minority might face — can improve pro-diversity attitudes and behavioral intentions toward these groups."

https://hbr.org/2017/07/two-types-of-diversity-training-that...

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:33PM (#17864587)
A small sample of students taking a survey isn't very convincing evidence.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by wwweston on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:44PM (#17864652)
It's certainly not total evidence, and I rather imagine there are limits to the effect if it exists at all.

But 118 students isn't that small of a sample (if I'm picking a methodological criticism, it'd be that it's a sample of college students rather than the general population).

And the exercise seems reasonably likely to provide some of the reported effect, and those effects fit with other studies that hold reading/writing fiction improves people's ability to model others better and some degree of empathy.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by mlevental on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:39PM (#17865028)
you asked if there was any evidence and then when evidence was given you dismissed it. do you know what the word "any" means? also this is argument in bad faith (asking for evidence and then discounting validity).
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:54PM (#17865131)
It's bad faith to ask for evidence, then when provided with bad evidence, to say that it's bad?

I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that diversity training does anything but shield companies from lawsuits to some extent.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by mlevental on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @09:50AM (#17868188)
>haven't found any compelling evidence

you really don't see how this is circular? how do you feel about this paraphrasing of climate change denial?

"I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that climate change is an anthropogenically driven process."

or this one of heliocentrism

"I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that the sun is at the center of the solar system."

or this one of

"I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that the earth is round."

you get my point? "compelling" is personal.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @10:35AM (#17868488)
You're comparing apples and oranges. What we know about our ball earth and heliocentrism are as close to solved science as it gets. I don't know much about climate change theory, but for the purposes of this conversation let's just say it's less settled than heliocentrism (we know and can predict patterns of the Earth's movement around the sun into the far future with great accuracy, but there is no such accuracy with prediction of climate change).

But you compare those to diversity training efficacy, which has no empirical evidence, and the controlled studies examining effects have conflicting results. This is just not an honest comparison at all. I dismissed your study because it literally doesn't tell me anything about the real world, not because I hand-waive anything that I don't agree with.

Would you change any of your own life habits based on how 100 college kids subjectively reported on their feelings? It's ridiculous to compare the amount of information that kind of study tells us to the astounding accuracy of how our heliocentric model of the solar system can and has predicted where and when solar eclipses will happen down to the minute.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by lordCarbonFiber on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:28PM (#17864961)
And yet you can't provide any counter evidence.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:36PM (#17865011)
The burden of proof for efficacy is on the ones dragging employees into mandatory meetings about non-work-related material.

But just for fun, here's another HBR article that shows that "the three most popular interventions make firms less diverse."

https://hbr.org/2016/07/why-diversity-programs-fail

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by badrabbit on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#17864551)
You shouldn't be tolerated or respectes as a result of your 'race' or 'sexuality'. Don't miss the forest for the trees.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by evil-olive on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:38PM (#17864617)
It's not black & white. There isn't just "acceptable behavior" and then "behavior so bad you should be fired on the spot for a first offense". There is a large grey area in between of behavior that might be inappropriate, depending on context, or that might be problematic but easy to correct by saying "here's why that's bad, don't do it again".

To think of it another way - you'll get fired for sexual harassment, but companies still give mandatory training about what exactly sexual harassment is and how to avoid it. Why should this be any different?

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:43PM (#17864646)
Companies give mandatory training for sexual harassment and diversity because it's either a legal requirement or a preemptive legal defense against lawsuits.
Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by gameswithgo on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#17864550)
>If an employee is harassing or demeaning their coworker based on their beliefs,

What does beliefs mean to you? Beliefs cast a very wide net. Is there no point at which a coworker should be cast out? Perhaps it is their religious belief that women should not be allowed to work. May such a person remain? Are we not to push back?

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by ericdykstra on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:39PM (#17864620)
If a religious man believes women should not be allowed to work, why would he join a company that hires women in the first place?

If he does, anyway, does it matter what he believes if he treats his coworkers (male and female) with respect anyway? If the belief doesn't manifest itself in negative actions, I don't really care what's going on in his head.

Re:Some Facebook Employees Unite to Challenge Its ‘Intoleran... by guipsp on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:31PM (#17864574)
It would certainly ward off some employees that don't agree with the values being promoted (a good thing!).