But 118 students isn't that small of a sample (if I'm picking a methodological criticism, it'd be that it's a sample of college students rather than the general population).
And the exercise seems reasonably likely to provide some of the reported effect, and those effects fit with other studies that hold reading/writing fiction improves people's ability to model others better and some degree of empathy.
I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that diversity training does anything but shield companies from lawsuits to some extent.
you really don't see how this is circular? how do you feel about this paraphrasing of climate change denial?
"I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that climate change is an anthropogenically driven process."
or this one of heliocentrism
"I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that the sun is at the center of the solar system."
or this one of
"I've read a good amount of the literature on this subject, and haven't found any compelling evidence that the earth is round."
you get my point? "compelling" is personal.
But you compare those to diversity training efficacy, which has no empirical evidence, and the controlled studies examining effects have conflicting results. This is just not an honest comparison at all. I dismissed your study because it literally doesn't tell me anything about the real world, not because I hand-waive anything that I don't agree with.
Would you change any of your own life habits based on how 100 college kids subjectively reported on their feelings? It's ridiculous to compare the amount of information that kind of study tells us to the astounding accuracy of how our heliocentric model of the solar system can and has predicted where and when solar eclipses will happen down to the minute.
But just for fun, here's another HBR article that shows that "the three most popular interventions make firms less diverse."