News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by toast0 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:25AM (#17846312)
Tieing 2fa directly to the phone is much better than tieing it to a phone number, until you don't control your phone. Then, how do you recover? You can't go down to the local Google (or whoever) kiosk, prove your identity, and get a new device added to 2fa, but you can get a new sim (downside, so can pretty much any carrier kiosk employee, or social engineer).

Also, phone numbers are pretty useful for contacting people, and most people have an address book with their friends and family and other important contacts. There's tremendous social value for people in those numbers continuing to work, to the extent possible. You're never going to be able to tell everyone who might want to know when your number changes, especially if you for a new number when yours was assigned to someone else.

Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by evfanknitram on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:38AM (#17846366)
> Then, how do you recover?

In case this is not a rethorical question: Using the backup codes or a copy of the barcode you printed.

Regardless of what method you use I assume you want a secure backup method.

> but you can get a new sim

Maybe easily if you are a private person and happen to lose the phone in your home country during opening hours. I tried this method once but the company just forwarded me to the internal helpdesk of the company I work for (this is a good thing, but previously they issued SIM cards to me). Got a sim like a week later.

Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by Aaargh20318 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:39AM (#17846375)
> how do you recover?

* By using the TOTP recovery codes (you did write them down, right ?)

* By using a TOTP client on another device (the client I use syncs it's (encrypted) database with all my iDevices)

* By restoring from a backup of your phone (you do have a backup, right ?)

Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by derwiki on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:41AM (#17846383)
Even if I do this, and most people reading this do this, I suspect there’s still a large number of people who don’t know they should be doing this (like older relatives).
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by TuringNYC on Sunday August 26, 2018 @02:13PM (#17847060)
I suspect the parent comment was being half sarcastic because almost no one actually does this (though those are the exact ways to solve the problem.)
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by brazzledazzle on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:49AM (#17846405)
The iCloud backup of my phone when restored to another phone didn’t bring over any of my authenticators. I don’t know if a physical backup would or not but it’s worth noting.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by Aaargh20318 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @05:03PM (#17847909)
They are tied to the phone, at least for Google Authenticator, if you do an iCloud backup. This is a security flag the app has set on the database file. If you do a local, encrypted backup the codes can be restored. Alternatively you can use a client like Authy that also allows you to sync them with your other devices (encrypted ofcourse).
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by 3pt14159 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:57AM (#17846439)
Yeah, if I hadn't been paranoid I would have lost $40k this way. Thankfully I'd kept my previous phone.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by drb91 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @01:10PM (#17846752)
Well, if that were not the case, your apple id would be the second factor to everything.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by brazzledazzle on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:33AM (#17850389)
You're right. I'm not criticizing, just noting it for anyone that might think the online backup would be sufficient after reading the comment I replied to.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by paulie_a on Sunday August 26, 2018 @04:32PM (#17847737)
And what happens when those backup codes don't work? You are now locked out of an account with 3000 dollars, and have to literally send a photo with your ID, and a note saying you need it reset. Google authenticaor should never be used for anything that matters.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by davchana on Sunday August 26, 2018 @01:49PM (#17846931)
You download or screenshot that QR Code while subscribing for 2fa with GA. Also keep the subscription key; & save both in a password database seperate from your usual password database.

2fa on phone totp is safe; SMS 2fa is less safe, prone to easy attacks. For phone somebody need to come n physically snatch your phone, get app lock password from you. For SMS, in few countries, not in India(in India either you need to prove that you own that existing SIM by getting a code there, or by seeing a customer service desk) a bit of social engineering & few answers from Facebook profile enables hackers to get a copy of SIM.

Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by madengr on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:30AM (#17846332)
Years ago, I had to physically show up at Verisign to get my domain changed. It was locked to an email address I no longer had. What a cluster that was.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by torstenvl on Sunday August 26, 2018 @02:30PM (#17847140)
That's exactly how it should work, though.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by kodablah on Sunday August 26, 2018 @02:54PM (#17847246)
In theory. In reality, people will sacrifice security for simplicity in these situations thereby financially incentivizing the opposite of "how it should work".
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by madengr on Sunday August 26, 2018 @03:15PM (#17847346)
The problem is that I live in KS and Verisign was in VA. I only went in person since I was visiting home. Went several weeks without a working domain.
Re:Phone Numbers Were Never Meant as ID. Now We’re All at Risk by jt2190 on Sunday August 26, 2018 @11:38AM (#17846364)
> Tieing 2fa directly to the phone is much better than tieing it to a phone number, until you don't control your phone.

This is worse. (edit: i.e. easier for the attacker since they don't need physical access to your device.) You still control your phone, but the attacker takes your phone number.