So, in the foreseeable future on the web, the devices are useful just for authentication.
I’m not sure if the restriction to authentication has substantially simplified the WebAuthn API. The restriction is caused by a speed optimization, not design simplification. If the actual payload was sent to the authenticator, rather than just its hash due to bandwidth limitations, then it seems like the API could be used for signing messages, not just authentication. I do agree that the user interfaces surrounding the APIs will be simpler due to the focus on authentication.
Hardware breaks.
Hardware is easily stolen.
Hardware-to-hardware interfaces require compatibility. You will probably respond, "but USB". To which I will say, "but BLE. but NFC. but data-over-audio ala square".
No security is perfect. When a hardware flaw is discovered, or comms technology changes, you have to buy new hardware.
If it does break or is stolen, how will you recover your account? This is not trivial.
https://krypt.co https://krypt.co/developers
It acts as a U2F token, but can also hold a private key for SSH authentication and/or git commit signing. On iOS, it can use the secure enclave.
Think of the hsm as just another key on your keychain. It has no ui other than a button,does not need charging and will remain in your pocket until needed. You don't want someone grabbing it off your hand while texting or making a call,that would mean they can access all your accounts.
http://www.hexview.com/~scl/neo/
https://www.avnet.com/shop/apac/products/nxp/a7005cghn1-t1ag...
A cheap smartphone without radio,screen,large battery with a custom os and a usb connection would be an even cheaper phone. The only things a personal hsm would add might be nfc and hardware rng. I'm surprised yubikey hasn't gotten cheaper even with companies like google using it.
The cost is probably much cheaper, but there is no reason for them to lower prices when there isn't really major (popular) competition.
I think once Google releases their key for general sale, Yubi will be forced to drop prices to compete.
- FIPS compliant RNG and key generation
- Hardware based key protection
- Secure (encrypted) on chip key (ECC, AES, SHA HMAC) and data storage
- Guaranteed Unique 72-bit Serial Number
- Boot validation
But that's not what people on this thread are asking for; they want it to do all the crypto stuff they do normally, with all the keys secured in hardware.
I'm a little out of my depth on this stuff; I've done chipset work but my part of those projects always starts with the C code. Maybe you can accomplish what you want with a cheap crypto IC. I'm really just pushing back on the idea that because you can build a smartphone out of a cheap ARM core, you can also build an HSM out of one.
You can put AES keys in the slots and have the IC perform operations with them.
> and you don't necessarily care if the whole package is secure against DPA, that part is a cheap way to get that.
Go get the NDA datasheet.
> (HSM out of ARM core alone)
We agree here.
Does the data sheet talk about hardware side channel mitigation?
USBArmory is around ~$100,I'm essentially talking about a mass produced user friendly version that cuts 40-60% of the cost due to mass production and slightly less extravagant hardware.
Imagine signing up to a site or service,all you need to do is allow it to generate a unique public/private key pair on your personal hsm. You would optionally associate a username with the public key,but that's it!
No need to enter name,address,phone,email,etc.., Unless required for the service. You won't even need a password(!!)
Lost the personal hsm? No worries,you wrote down a recovery key on paper and stored it next to your social security card and passport.
Here is my thing, simpler security is better security. I use a yubi everyday and it's nice but I also use TOTP and SMS every day. If I am using a hardware security device,why do I need any other form of authentication?
Why can't that same device be used for TLS client certificate storage for every site I visit,storing SSH private keys,trusted root CA store I can use with any device, message(email,signal,telegram,etc...) Encryption,message non-repudiation(think a twitter post or even this comment being signed by my hsm so I can't say 'the hackers did it'). You can use it for banking,voting,signing important documents online,etc...
You can already see how much work goes into adopting something like a yubikey. Why not make it a general purpose hsm that solves all these security problems.
You know what I like about this the most? Minimal user education required,just plug it in,click yes on the app's prompt and press the button on the hsm. Not only that,you can't phish or some other way social engineer the user to give up the private key. Users can keep it on their keychain or building access badge that would give physical attackers similar level of access(they can unlock your house keys and steal pii or get in the building with your badge and steal your laptop).
A user friendly usbarmory for the lay-person!